People loved Rapportive, people wanted Rapportive outside of GMail, Rapportive delivered.
> It's one of the most basic rules of growing a company that pursuing short-term gains (1-2 years) with dodgy maneuvers, directly translate into long-terms losses in the 10-fold numbers of the short term gains. This is not too hard to understand, is the executive team of Linkedin not intelligent enough to get that?
http://www.businessinsider.com/linkedin-stock-performance-20...
Amazingly you've managed to crap not only on the Intro team, not only on the Intro team and LinkedIn executives, but every single LinkedIn employee – please tell me more about how to build this great culture you champion.
LinkedIn is not a tech company, it is a bunch of business people who hired technologists to build a website.
Sure, lots of good tech has been open sourced by LinkedIn employees, but none of them sit in decision making capacities (or Intro would not exist). THAT is the culture problem.
As a fairly technical person, I think Intro is a fairly neat product. There's definitely some implementation issues that mean that I'm not going to use it (I don't really want a linkedin advert in all my outgoing email), but I'd imagine it'd be pretty useful for some people. I already trust one large corporation with my email despite the fact I know they don't have my best interests at heart. Adding another one wouldn't be a deal breaker.
Besides, even if they aren't in the positions of authority, technologists can still be culpable. I thought we already had enough examples in history of culpable people who were "simply following orders" to render such types of discussions moot.
That may or may not be true, but my basic position is that I want to do business with people who don't care whether dodgy practices will or will not make money in the short, medium, or long term, they have scruples that outweigh their venality.
Edit: to clarify, "these people" refers to the type of people the parent was complaining about, who use deception and dark patterns, not to all people working on growth in general. Making the distinction is what I'm arguing for.
Is the implementation that's shady/spammy? I don't see how Intro isn't useful for recruiters to instantly have the linkedin profile of the person their emailing available to them on their phone. That way it's a quick reference check.
The spammy part: They toss LinkedIn ads on your emails to other people after you hit send.
The ads bit is a bit shit though.
http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/13/ark-is-like-a-rapportive-mo...
So while Intro seems to have less friction, you have to give up privacy (HAH. Email and privacy always makes me laugh) to achieve it, which does suck.
Shame there wasn't a cooler way to try and handle it by only using headers or something, rather than MITM the whole damned email stack.
Ark is neat though. Out of curiosity, how do you handle double notifications? As in, I get a new email, now I've got a notification in Mail and Ark? Or does Ark replace Mail entirely?
They're just copying the people in the financial industry. And the people involved made very nice sums of money, so their intelligence was successfully used to their own personal benefit.
Maybe the stock runup has made it such that they think they're just squeezing the last few drops out of this before they fully cash out.
This is pure speculation of course, but I gather this scenario is a risk with any company that has a lot of hype and such employee exit paths.
The reason for that is probably also though that Linkedin is not a passion product. It's not that their employees/founders are super passionate about connecting employees to employers, they are passionate about it making money. It's a bit understandable though, it's not easy to have a really strong passion for Linkedin or its mission.
Sidebar: What the heck does "main growth hacker" even supposed to mean? It blows my mind when people start coming up with new names for what they do. "Senior sanitation engineer" etc.
I get spammed by all the social networks I've joined, and even by a few that I didn't join. I get mail from every newspaper or magazine I've ever subscribed to, and many that I never have. Condemning one business for doing this while praising another is just hypocrisy.
Facebook is regularly criticised, often fiercely, for their invasive privacy policies.
Intercepting email and inserting content is quantitatively different from sending bulk email. I think this programme is being criticised because it intercepts people's mail and inserts content - that's very different from receiving mail and leads to insecurity on several levels (they see your mail, sharing passwords, getting used to inserted content which can then be imitated for phishing).
Also people do criticise FB and Twitter here too, but the objection is not spamming.
"sharing passwords" isn't a problem with this scheme because it doesn't use your password. It creates a separate IMAP account and links it to your regular account via OAuth.
"I think this programme is being criticised because it intercepts people's mail and inserts content" -- really? A sample comment is "they are spammers." Nothing there about man-in-the-middle, nothing there about email interception. I don't think most of the people bashing LinkedIn here even understand how Rapportive/Intro works.
The particular CSS exploit shown here seems like one that can and will be fixed. Obviously, there are other ways to do phishing via email, including just sending an email that looks like someone else's mail (remember: postcard). A lot of mail services are starting to filter spammy or fake-looking mail, so that may help.
In a company with great culture, this kind of project would have been caught by the various stakeholders of this project and it would not have been released.
However, at Linkedin, the engineers and product managers having learned over the years that these kind of things are "fine" and can be looked over as long as the feature brings more engagement, more traffic --> more money, made this dodgy product slip through the cracks of Linkedin.
I don't know how many times Linkedin has been on hackernews for email spam, when will they finally get it?
I talked to the main growth hacker of Linkedin a while ago who does all the email marketing and asked him if it's not a bit dodgy what they are doing. He smirked and told me how much these strategies boost engagement at Linkedin and how much money they make.
This is not something to be proud of, it's like being proud of having stolen 10 kids a lollipop today. Everybody can steal lollipops, build a drug cartel or big company with dodgy maneuvers, because then it is not about how gifted they were, it's how deceitful.
That is just not impressive. However, it's insanely impressive to build a company without being dodgy, but just by making a great product that your users love.
It's one of the most basic rules of growing a company that pursuing short-term gains (1-2 years) with dodgy maneuvers, directly translate into long-terms losses in the 10-fold numbers of the short term gains.
This is not too hard to understand, is the executive team of Linkedin not intelligent enough to get that?