It's very common in these kind of scenarios that either a) the same criticism / suggestions have been made regularly over a long time by people inside the company which have gone ignored, or b) the company has a culture in which that information never reaches the CEO, either out of fear or because of middle management layers.
In both those cases, the CEO is actually mismanaging the company and completely undermining the motivation and loyalty of his employees.
I've seen this happen time and time again. CEO's and managers don't accept internal criticism or suggestions, don't give their people the freedom to take action themselves, but some outsider swoops in with an impressive Powerpoint presentation (or dress) and suddenly they see the light.
It's the opposite of taking risks (you can blame the outsiders if it fails), it's actually cowardice.
Even if that's the case, I think sometimes this is what needs to happen that makes you realize the change/s that has to be done to be better. (be more transparent, fire some managers or key people, etc.)
Either way it's a very strong vote of no confidence in the existing staff by the CEO.
Unless there is a long story of trying to improve the app internally, it appears this CEO decided at the bar that his own staff wasn't good enough and needed to be replaced with external consultants without considering other root causes (including himself).
Executives that are easily persuaded by the sales pitches of external consultants and don't listen to their own people are a dime a dozen.
Not to mention the fact that whatever his answers are they are specific to his organization, what he sells and who he is surrounded by.
Once again, interesting questions but I'm not sure either way the answers matter that much. I don't think how he handled this particular case (noting though that you did want to know if he had done these things before) you can draw any clear conclusions.
Separately I wonder if the person who pitched him were not an attractive woman but say an unattractive woman or man what the results would have been and what would have happened. (That said I've had great results pitching people by email which is more or less a neutral.)
That is the lesson I am going to take away. Ideas matter, but if execution is the thing you can change, then embrace the people that tell you your execution sucks and have ideas.
[1] http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=neg
[2] http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/voices/2012/05/negging-lat...
Robert Cialdini, for example, is heavily cited as an influence within the PUA community. So calling a "neg" a "pickup technique" might not even be accurate. I imagine the idea of "lower the value of a high-value target to penetrate their shield" probably predates the term PUA by quite some time.
As a founder, I am always looking for that combination in my users.
The bonus was offering herself as the solution. I'll venture that his decision was made even before she finished the sentence.
(Or maybe you haven't, but they wouldn't hire you. That would have been an interesting interview. "So, Mr X, where do you see yourself in this business in five years time?" "In a prison cell nearby, looking out through the bars at the smoking ruins and laughing.")
When asking to work for a company, there is always the tension between the company needing one's input (in other words, their product really suck in some way) and the company willing and being able to act on the input. The OP's story flashed back the other stories of the designer that went to Google to bring some design expertise and just dropped the ball because it was an endless uphill battle.
[1] Of course, the other way round, if she's a freelance designer invited to award ceremonies and walks at CEOs pitching ideas to improve their companies, she'll eventually find work I think.
That could have killed the thing. "Logo, All the app and ratings" is not three things. Still, some alcohol may have been involved so this could have made sense at the time.
It was more probably the nerve and familiarity with the product that convinced him.
So yes he took a risk. This was one of many. If it didn't pay off, he could take others.
Let's not forget the CEO, who committed and risked resources on a hunch or instinct or who-knows-what.
If I had to pick one of the two to ask how they had the nerve to act and to learn from, I'd pick him. (Of course I'd prefer both and not to belittle her gumption and skills to back it up).
- What did he see to suggest risking those resources? ... To create a team of outsiders to work on the core app?
- How likely did he expect things to work out?
- How did he explain the expenditure of flying the others in to the CFO or whomever?
- Or did he make a unilateral decision without asking others?
- Did he just get lucky?
- Had he done things like this before and succeeded? Failed?
- Was he worried about making waves in his organization? Did he?
Plenty more questions pop up...