I respectfully note the disagreement of several participants here have with me. They disagree with my disagreement with the interviewed expert's casual language about thoughtful agency by bacteria. Noting your statements that this is just everyday conversational usage, I stand by my objection to that fallacious manner of speaking. Most people in the English-speaking world think erroneously about biological evolution and especially about the implications of evolution for human medicine. I am not alone in thinking that popular thinking about biology needs to be improved by rejecting the idea of organismal agency in evolution,[2] although it is remarkably hard to find this kind of careful thinking by a Google search amid the flood of webpages that specifically assert a purpose or intention to evolution by natural selection. Ernst Mayr, mentioned in one reply to my first comment here, is indeed a rare example of a reliable author on that issue. Human beings have a cognitive bias of attributing agency to inanimate objects,[3] and the reactions to my first comment suggest how deep-seated that cognitive bias is.
The entire revised introduction to the thirtieth anniversary edition of Richard Dawkins's book The Selfish Gene[4] appears to be available for free online reading, and Dawkins writes explicitly about what level of analysis can be useful when pretending that genes have intentions and goals while thinking about problems in evolutionary theory. The University of California Berkeley website about evolution has a good page about antibiotics[5] that makes helpful medical practice and public policy suggestions with more cautious language.
There is a testable prediction here of course: either bacteria outrun human antibiotic development or they do not. I'm confident that more bacterial lineages will be wiped out before human medicine is seriously compromised by natural selection of bacteria that are resistant to most antibiotics used in human medicine. The precautionary principle suggests that we follow the quoted expert's policy recommendations, but meanwhile conduct research for a deeper understanding of the biochemistry of harmful microorganisms and their ecology.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5674781
[2] http://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2011/02/21/natural-s...
[3] http://cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/3951/is-there-a-co...
[4] http://books.google.com/books?id=koaD_Aod_V0C&printsec=front...
[5] http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/article/medicine_03
Two other comments at this level express the nub of the argument:
I'm slightly bugged by "desire" type language because it does actually cause problems in how laymen think about evolution. It's not uncommon to hear them make the mistake of thinking evolution will "think ahead". But the bigger problem I have with it is the "anything we do ... bacteria will eventually discover".
Some problems are just very difficult to evolve around, and it's hard to predict what they'll be even if you have a complete working knowledge of an organism's genome and biological workings. If the problem space doesn't contain a solution that can be climbed toward without sacrificing fitness in the short term, it is unlikely that it will ever be found by evolution.
Evolution is actually a really crappy optimization algorithm. The reason it has worked so well is not that it is so effective, but because it's the only game in town.
That is very well put, and deserves your upvote.
At what point do we start designing RNA with a delivery mechanism that attaches itself to a specific bacterial type and eliminates it?
A good question. It is an empirical question about the future, so it has no definite answer yet, but that is the general research direction to follow to get around the legitimate problem mentioned in the article kindly submitted here.
> Indeed, I am on record here on HN[1] saying that I'd like to see the United States follow the lead of the EU immediately in banning antibiotics used in human medicine (especially last-line antibiotics used for antibiotic-resistant human disease) from use on farms. That seems like a sensible way to segregate the ecosystems in which microorganisms develop antibiotic resistance by haphazard evolution through natural selection.
Exposure to one agent can make bacteria more resistant to other agents, even ones that are unrelated. This is surprising, but confirmed through experiments. Bacteria have ways of flushing out toxins that become up-regulated, and they become more resistant to toxins in general. Agriculture only uses a few antibiotics, ones that are cheap in bulk, nontoxic to livestock, and can be mixed with feed, but the ramifications could extend to other, more critical, antibiotics used in medicine.
> As we reach a deeper biochemical understanding of the basis of all life, we will eventually understand the differences, which are biochemical differences at bottom, between human beings and bacteria, between human beings and protists, between human beings and fungi (yes, there are some systematic differences between animals and fungi) and between human beings and all other harmful microorganisms.
I think you're underestimating what we already know. Current antibiotics are based on the differences between eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells, and we understand a lot about the underlying biochemistry and drug targets. Lack of fundamental knowledge isn't a primary issue.
> I'm confident that more bacterial lineages will be wiped out before human medicine is seriously compromised by natural selection of bacteria that are resistant to most antibiotics used in human medicine.
Here you're underestimating bacteria. Bacterial lineages don't really go extinct, because they have no well-defined boundaries. Bacteria are very different from eukaryotes and they pick up genes from the environment. See horizontal gene transfer.
This is one of those vicious problems, like cancer, that resists being solved not for lack of our best efforts, but in spite of them.
[1] http://www.perseusbooksgroup.com/dacapo/book_detail.jsp?isbn...
> "Agriculture only uses a few antibiotics, ones that are cheap in bulk, nontoxic to livestock, and can be mixed with feed..."
The reality is much worse. Factory meat producers will abuse any antibiotic if they are allowed, even the most powerful last-resort antibiotics. For example, many poultry producers were routinely mixing fluoroquinolones into their feed until very recently. The practice was outlawed in 2005, but there is good evidence that some poultry producers continue to do it in violation of the law:
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/04/120405131431.ht...
Incidentally, I think the intuitive idea that the last resort antibiotics are the most powerful ones is a bit of a misconception. The ones used as a last resort tend to be the more toxic ones and the ones that have to be given intravenously. The reason they still work is probably because they were used sparingly while there were better alternatives available. That delayed the development of resistance.
> There is a testable prediction here of course: either bacteria outrun human antibiotic development or they do not. I'm confident that more bacterial lineages will be wiped out before human medicine is seriously compromised by natural selection of bacteria that are resistant to most antibiotics used in human medicine.
Do a dumb test. Walk into your nearest hospital, I don't even want to know which it is. Ask how many patients are infected with mRSA. Collect your jaw from the floor when they give you an answer that's 15% if you're lucky, 60-70% if you're unlucky. We have lost the fight with bacteria. It's over. We aren't "about to" lose it, we lost it ~1 year ago, and medicine is fast losing the ability to treat bacterial disease. We lost the fight with viruses a decade ago. If you get infected with a deadly viral disease, like rabies, it's curtains. There's nothing any hospital can do for you except sedate you until you're dead.
We are in fact well on our way to transform hospitals into deathtraps.
> Evolution is actually a really crappy optimization algorithm. The reason it has worked so well is not that it is so effective, but because it's the only game in town.
First of all, the obvious advantage of evolution is it's running time, 3.5 billion years. Second you probably subscribe to the naive notion that evolution, in 3.5 billion years running time, somehow failed to realize that mutation + natural selection is very, very slow. It didn't. The algorithm that, today, controls evolution of pretty much any species works entirely different from what most textbooks teach you. There are very, very few species that evolve through mutation and selection. We evolve through copying of other's genes, simulation and symbiosis (yes, genes can simulate the effect other genes will have on them. Also, most "life" functions of a human body, like breathing, metabolism, ... are actually performed by symbiotic bacteria on our behalf. Human cells can't actually do it themselves).
Unfortunately, if you study how evolution actually works you'll realize what it means for resistant bacteria. Once a fully resistant bacterial strain evolves, a process that takes between decades and centuries, all other species of bacteria will quickly copy the resistance, in a matter of months to years. Which is exactly what we've seen happening.
You'll also quickly realize that no matter how well-intentioned your use of bacteriophages is, it is very, very likely to make things worse, not better.
http://www.cdc.gov/mrsa/statistics/ (Center for Disease Control)
And the numbers of infections were far lower than you're claiming here - rather than approximately 20,000 in 100,000 as claimed above, the numbers (in 2011) were 4.5 in 100,000.
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2013/09/16/us-hospital-mrsa-id... (Reuters quoting numbers from a JAMA / CDC study).
As for rabies, according to Wikipedia quoting Sherris Medical Microbiology (4th ed.),
"Treatment after exposure is highly successful in preventing the disease if administered promptly, in general within 10 days of infection."
There's more information here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies#Treatment (Wikipedia)
Hurray for these protocols, but that won't do all that we need. It won't be possible to scrub the whole world with poisons the way we have begun scrubbing hospital rooms. We need ways to stop infections that we can't prevent.
It's a very worrying situation.
Just that bit of factual nonsense leads me to believe you are speaking far out of your area of expertise.
That's not a big deal in the U.S. because rabies is quite rare, but in the developing world it's still a thing.
Ceol may also be referring to the incubation time for rabies usually being more than a week - if you've just been infected with it and you present at day 7, then a prophylaxis will be administered.
Rabies infection is very survivable if caught before symptoms start to show up. We have a post-infection vaccine that can be used during the incubation period. We've had a vaccine for over a hundred years, and it works very well. In fact, the original rabies vaccine was the second vaccine ever developed, after smallpox.
What's lethal is symptomatic rabies -- but even that is not 100% lethal. There have actually been a few (under a dozen) documented cases of human survival after symptomatic rabies. Look up the Milwaukee Protocol.
Problem is, the treatment lies within the realm of heroic medicine, works less than 10% of the time, and requires a long period of physical therapy afterwards. The cost easily goes into the seven figures. And we don't even know if the treatment works. Survival might simply be the luck of the genetic draw.
So, $10 million to save the life of one patient with symptomatic rabies, vs. $2000 for the vaccine. So you can see why the treatment protocol emphasizes post-infection vaccination.
As for whether or not I used the right term, I'd actually suggest that "infection" is kind of a fussy term to begin with. But I also never used it in my post, so I'm curious as to how I could have used it wrongly.
I stated that after the treatment window closes for PEP, we're in the realm of very difficult treatments that are really only workable in the developed world. I don't see anywhere that your post and mine are contradictory.
Secondly, what on earth do you mean when you say we lost the fight against viruses a decade ago'?
We have only got better at treating viruses; we had almost no treatment for viruses a decade ago and we have some treatments now; for example we are now much better at treating chronic hepatitis c infection which is a leading cause of liver failure and cancer; we have good HIV drugs which can lead to long term management without significant comorbidities (although many of the pieces were in place a decade ago), and your illustrated case, rabies, has long been a problem child like many significant viral illnesses that are discovered close to the end of their course, has caused so much pathology by tr time they present that the course is terminal.
But there have only been a handful of cases of fulminant rabies in the developed world in the last decade, so it's hardly a thing that we are getting experience in treating.
We do not have any drug against any retrovirus (ie. a family of viruses) to which viruses do not show at least partial resistance.
As for the AIDS case, prevention of AIDS has pretty much failed in Africa and the middle east, as well as in significant parts of Asia. It is a matter of a decade or so until ~80% of those populations are HIV positive and the rest of the world will follow in the next few decades. All currently know anti-AIDS drugs will cease being effective in 5 years or less, and the rate of adaptation that the virus exhibits is still accelerating (we wouldn't be able to keep up with the current rate, so sadly, that doesn't even matter).
This is of course assuming we don't have another pandemic like the Spanish flue. We have had several near-pandemic panics in the past decade and all incidents have one thing in common : we failed spectacularly at containment. If, for example, bird flue had been ~6% more infectious than it was, it would have killed ~20% of the world's population (at least), and would have reaped >90% of it's death toll before a vaccine would become available. Absolutely nothing would have stopped it. Bird flue itself was only one of 5 incidents that could have exploded into a pandemic. The big message of these incidents: yes, they stopped, hurray. Sadly it wasn't us who stopped it (but rather small flaws in the virus' design).
- The prevention of HIV in developing countries is hampered not by the ineffectiveness of drugs, but the expense and difficulty administering them. HIV in the developed world is, in many cases, now essentially a chronic disease. Indeed, it is the use of HAART drugs to prevent transmission in discordant couples that is providing a glimmer of hope for reducing the burden of HIV without a vaccine.
- While serious, prevalence of HIV is nowhere near 80%. Also, increasing prevalence is a function of disease duration, so better treatments will, mathematically, cause prevalence to rise.
- I'd contest rather strongly that we failed spectacularly at containment for several recent outbreaks.
- Antiviral drugs are not our only means of fighting viruses. If "Anti-X drugs" were the solution, we'd have eliminated many bacterial diseases - we haven't. The key to fighting viruses is vaccination, and we've wiped two viruses off the face of the earth, and are largely facing political/social problems, rather than scientific ones, with adding two more to that tally.
What? We never had effective antivirals. We have a few useful drugs (oseltamivir, protease inhibitors, etc) for particular viruses, but there has never been a point in human history when rabies was a treatable disease. The Milwaukee protocol, which is the only effective[1] non-vaccine treatment for rabies, isn't even drug-based!
You may of course be confused. The major antiviral used in replications of the Giese case, amantadine, was also an anti-flu drug, resistance to which is now widespread in influenza (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amantadine#Veterinary_misuse ). However, I do not believe amantadine resistance has ever been described in rabies, which in any case is usually treated with vaccination -- the challenge is to get the immune system to respond to the virus before the host dies! Giese herself was treated with both amantadine and ribavirin. In any case, your claim is confusing at best, misleading at worst.
[1]: controversial, see http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/712839_7
Breathing? Where are the bacteria in the gas-exchange process? And 'metabolism' is a catch-all term that refers to so many different chemical reactions, plenty of which are conducted within the human cells themselves.
This, for instance:
"If you get infected with a deadly viral disease, like rabies, it's curtains. There's nothing any hospital can do for you except sedate you until you're dead."
The very low rabies incidence and near zero fatalities of rabies in the developed world actually show that it's a very winnable fight. The issue is, we have to show up to said fight. In the developing world, we're not always good at that.
The fight we have not yet one is the fight against poverty. Not many wealthy people die of rabies.
AIDS which was once fatal, is no longer, provided you can afford the treatment.
Its very common in a lot of of places in the world to ask for euthanasia in case of such diseases.
Compared to a chronic, wasting disease that will take years of opportunistic infections before you die, that's damned good.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (the same organization that employs the expert quoted in the article submitted to open this thread) reports that "Although MRSA is still a major patient threat, a CDC published in the Journal of the American Medical Association Internal Medicine showed that invasive (life-threatening) MRSA infections in healthcare settings are declining. Invasive MRSA infections that began in hospitals declined 54% between 2005 and 2011, with 30,800 fewer severe MRS infections. In addition, the study showed 9,000 fewer deaths in hospital patients in 2005 versus 2011."[1] So there are responses already in place that are gaining on antibiotic-resistant bacteria in hospital settings in the United States.
I care about the spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria. I am gravely concerned about the medical and public-health practices in India that have resulted in a massive increase in patients infected there with multiple-antibiotic-resistant tuberculosis.[2] I am 100 percent behind the idea that antibiotics have to be used cautiously and responsibly, and meanwhile we have to keep researching other means of infection control besides antibiotics.
You wrote,
We evolve through copying of other's genes, simulation and symbiosis (yes, genes can simulate the effect other genes will have on them.
Do you really mean "we" there? Are you saying that this mechanism in any way makes it impossible for human beings to eradicate harmful microorganisms? How? Please connect the dots to back up your conclusion that
Once a fully resistant bacterial strain evolves, a process that takes between decades and centuries, all other species of bacteria will quickly copy the resistance, in a matter of months to years
because the "all" there and the time scale you talk about both appear to be exaggerations, especially in light of the progress that has already occurred in limiting MRSA infections in the United States.
[1] http://www.cdc.gov/mrsa/healthcare/index.html
[2] http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230344420...
http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2013-06-23/news...
This is the important point that people forget. Bacteria are experiencing an extremely accelerated time course and can evolve and exchange advantageous mutations very quickly. We have only had antibiotics for 100 years, which is 3-4 generations of man, but billions of generations of bacteria!
The fact that lines of bacteria go extinct does nothing to disprove the fact that bacteria are developing resistance to antibiotics. Is it possible that there are antibiotics out there that can stop the newly-resistant bacteria? Of course. But it's getting harder and harder to find newer and more-powerful antibiotics.
A promising alternative appears to be bacteriophages.
From Wikipedia's Bacteriophage page: "Medical trials were carried out, but a basic lack of understanding of phages made these invalid".
I seriously hope alternatives like bacteriophages are being revisited and reconsidered within the medical community, as it's obvious that conventional antibiotics are increasingly becoming less effective each year.
The early days of 'phage therapy' were pretty bad - because we really didn't understand what was going on, the "purified" phage solutions still had bits of bacterial cell membranes and the like in them, including endotoxins. People died.
But phages were still being looked at for most of the antibiotic period, especially in countries without quite such widespread access to antibiotics. The Soviet Union had a very active program in Georgia, which was ongoing before the trouble there a few years back, I don't know the status of it now.
It's a promising avenue, and there's some decisive advantages phages have over antibiotics. But it's also quite hard, and right now we lack a generalizable form of phage therapy - it tends to be a bespoke solution to specific intractable cases. But the incentives might increase as antibiotics become less and less effective.
For awhile I wanted to work on phage research before I realized wet-lab Biology was not my forte.
Several phages even encode for bacterial virulence factors such as exotoxins (stx, diphteria toxin).
Fortunately, we are much better equipped in the molecular biology department to do research.
With phages you'd need a large library to counter different bacteria, you'd have to successfully identify the bacteria which is causing the problem which may require culturing. If you wanted to maintain phage effectiveness in a heavily selected environment you'd also need to design phage "reactors" where the phages can be continually evolved against current bacterial populations.
There was a whole club that met regularly around phages. Much of it was popularized by Delbruck. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phage_group
In fact, a bacteriophage may or may not be the most promising vector, but a bacteriophage engineered to attack pneumonia or specific infections would be the work of a sighted watchmaker, not dissimilar from ideas of targeted radiation or chemotherapy that are moving forward in the area of cancer treatment. I recall an experiment (not that this is my area of expertise at all) in the recent past that was attempting to use magnetized medicine along with some sort of electrode insertion, I believe, to coerce medicine to specific areas of the body.
Understanding comes from truth, not casual simplifying lies.
On the contrary, we eliminated smallpox which was one of the most devastating diseases in history so this fatalism is basically disproved. More depressingly, we've also made extinct thousands of species who have not evolved to resist us.
Smallpox was not eliminated with antibiotics, and nor was polio. Both are viruses, and both were eliminated with vaccines.
So what if a species goes extinct? That doesn't mean it can't evolve, only that it didn't adapt quickly enough.
No it isn't, it's misleading.
> It's like saying "Water wants to flow to the lowest point of a room"
Equally unnecessarily misleading. Water doesn't want anything, and before you claim people understand that let me tell you, they don't. It's a common belief that water has memory, there's an entire industry based on the concept and people fall for it. Walk into any grocery store and there are shelves of very expensive little bottles of water (homeopathy) being sold as cures for all kinds of things, it's disgusting.
> or "The arrow wants to follow the path of least air resistance"
Also unnecessarily misleading. Such talk may be fine among experts who "get" that's it's not accurate, but when talking to general public one should speak accurately, not loosely and "hope" they get it because the reality is many if not most don't and take what you say quite literally.
Bacteria don't 'want' anything in a purely technical sense. But they will eventually develop/are developing resistance to antibiotics anyway. You seem to be stuck in debating about the right sentences to describe that.
That should be least of our worries.
Humans aren't computers.
To some extent, but it is also impossible to do so perfectly.
> Semantics matter.
Semantic agreement is limited to the actual parties to the communication, and by location, place, time, and social context. You wouldn't explain something to a 5 year old the way you would a 25 year old and the same basic problems occur when you cross cultural or temporal boundaries.
When linguists discuss language, they usually start by pointing out that human language is defined by usage, not by prescriptions regarding definitions or grammar. This is a critical difference between natural languages and computer languages. Computer languages rigidly conform to specifications. Natural languages only approximate the rules we use to describe them.
So I think you are expecting too much from human communications.
That being said, I have no problem with the statement that bacteria want to survive. They most certainly have mechanisms that are engaged actively in order to increase chances of survival. Horizontal gene transfer (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horizontal_gene_transfer) allows bacteria to evolve in means other than traditional reproduction.
To add to my pedantic argument, it's not a conscious desire of theirs, but I'd argue that the basic things that humans do to survive (eat, drink, sleep, and have sex) are not conscious desires either. I'd argue that sexual reproduction is a mechanism that directly represents the biological success of greater genetic diversity and sharing of genes between organisms. We desire sex, and we desire sex with the best genetic candidates, and it's all a biological process encoded into our DNA that represents our desire for survival, so in that sense, bacteria desire survival as well.
And what does desire even mean? Does desire require consciousness and the ability to choose? It's a horribly imprecise term if you stare too long at it, so what I'm saying is that I don't think it's useful to pick on the doctor for his choice of words in this case.
Anyway, you have great points otherwise, but that first paragraph is not a point worth tripping over.
Some problems are just very difficult to evolve around, and it's hard to predict what they'll be even if you have a complete working knowledge of an organism's genome and biological workings. If the problem space doesn't contain a solution that can be climbed toward without sacrificing fitness in the short term, it is unlikely that it will ever be found by evolution.
Evolution is actually a really crappy optimization algorithm. The reason it has worked so well is not that it is so effective, but because it's the only game in town. It took evolution billions of years to make machines that can run 60 miles per hour. It took humans a few thousand years to create machines that run about 12 times that fast.
Bacteria work on a faster time scale than animals in terms of evolution, but five orders of magnitude? Somehow, I think we'll win in the long run.
This is a stunning visual - thank you. I see a multi-dimensional space of possible organism "configurations". Each dimension is a set of related alleles, spaced by the amount of energy it would take to shift from one to the other, i.e. the likelihood of switching that allele independently. Angles between dimensions indicate correlation, or more fundamentally the cost of holding similarly positioned alleles simultaneously. Each organism is a point in that space with a species being a cloud.
When one shines a "light", i.e. an antibiotic, on the space it lights up with warmer colours signifying configurations which take less energy for the organism to survive as (are more favourable) and cooler colours denoting deadlier configurations.
Thus, antibiotics become a game of chess. Humans try to box the organism into coolly coloured regions. That way, the amount of energy it would take to "tunnel" through the wall would be high. The organism, on the other hand, is trying to find warm "tunnels" by which to escape regions which are being boxed in. Advantage to the organism is it can build new dimensions.
However, it's one that doesn't need an agency to implement it. It just happens. A lot. Especially in the case of bacteria. You have a slow, crappy algorithm, but it's constantly running relentlessly in parallel in many trillions of instances. It doesn't need human attention. It doesn't need investment. It doesn't need society to be aware of its importance.
On the other hand, progress in antibiotics needs all of the above. If one of those things flags a bit, bacteria gain the upper hand. This is the problem.
It took evolution billions of years to make machines that could make machines that run about 700 miles per hours.
You come off as being dismissive of the power and beauty of evolution, although I don't think that's your intent. Evolution assembled the most complex system known to exist, starting from a handful of molecules, without any "thought" or "reasoning." The entire concept/illusion of life and consciousness was fabricated out of simple natural elements and physical processes. Amazing. Sure, once all of that has been put in place, it's trivial to expand upon. I'm sure you agree, I just like to take any opportunity to point this out. :)
If I come across as cynical about this, it's a response to the way evolution as a process has been fetishized by people who don't understand it. People look at the application of evolutionary algorithms to solving difficult problems and conclude that evolution is smarter than humans. But evolution's power really comes from its dumbness. It works without understanding the problem, and so it can be used to solve problems we don't understand very well. But when we learn how to model a problem intelligently, we're generally able to crush the results of evolution.
It's a recurring pattern. SAT, the NP-complete problem, is at first glance a ridiculously simple task, yet solving it means being able to solve all other problems. When designing a language or a machine, it is very very simple to accidentally make it Turing compatible, the barrier is just so low, despite the reward being.. everything.
There may have been a lot more complexity early on than that statement assumes. Static systems, after all, pretty much by definition can't evolve (and this is why a reductionistic assessment of evolution as biochemistry doesn't work).
The beauty behind evolution is the same beauty behind Feynman integrals in quantum physics. You take the integral over all possible paths and something is likely to work. Many paths will end or cancel eachother out.
It's like open source software.
What's really huge and what no is really a limit and perception of our brains, no?
For a evolutionary process that has started at the earliest stars after the Big Bang. Those species are currently so powerful, that we are very likely to them the same as bacteria are to us. Might as well perceive that to be a very reasonably efficient process.
One imagines a future in which we have a dwindling supply of biodiversity to 'sacrifice' in order to keep ourselves safe from bacterial onslaught.
Not unlike oil -- millions of years to produce, but destroyed in a few generations of exponential human growth.
It might make sense to speak of an antibiotic peak, like we speak of peak oil. I wonder if you could draw the same kind of curve.
This is the stuff of the Nobel prizes of yore, and it is the mechanistic basis for how antibiotics kill bacteria and not humans. Penicillins destroy the cell wall as it is remodeled (humans don't have a cell wall); lincosamides block protein synthesis at the ribosome (humans have a different ribosomal structure); amphotericin binds ergosterol and forms ion channels in fungal membranes (humans lack ergosterol).
As we continue to explore biochemistry, we will continue to understand (and perhaps even discover) new antimicrobials, though I suspect most of the future advances will come from large-scale screens of discovered or synthesized compounds without taking much biology into account until secondary stages (to increase potency or reduce toxicity).
[2] is a good book to get a perspective on antibiotic resistance.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horizontal_gene_transfer [2] http://www.perseusbooksgroup.com/dacapo/book_detail.jsp?isbn...
In his book 'Toward a New Philosophy of Biology" there is a chapter on this very topic - how teleonomy has pervaded almost all of Biological science and how teleological statements, which are just plain incorrect, are the major way in which Biological processes are explained. I think this has only increased in severity and effect as we have consolidated our systems level view of the world and I've often been in awe of the general ignorance toward fundamental principals such as this.
My own personal take on the situation?
I think it is a very dangerous and ignorant thing for our species to continue with it's genetic hegemony of our ecosystems, creating vast evolutionary plateaus where the slightest advantage can run amok and adapt into something that could wipe out entire species. There is _probably_ enough genetic diversity in humans to avoid this, but I doubt so amongst our crops and livestock.
But I share your optimism/pragmatism in that I feel our human ingenuity will overcome, and if so then the prizes are great indeed. From new drug delivery systems and entirely new ways of treating illnesses, to a more mature approach to our interactions with the biological inheritance we have here on Earth 1.0 - I would like to see our crops and livestock diversified, farming practices overhauled to focus on the long term and most importantly more serious study devoted to analysing and utilising the solutions evolution has put in front of us for the taking.
Not only are these things (IMHO) essential to the prolonged survival of our species, they are also achievable. The organic farming movement took only a generation to go from grass roots to industry standard (and I know there is all sorts of controversy surrounding it but the point is that the industry IS open to disruption), here in the UK there is a debate simmering under the surface of the popular media that could end in more wild deer providing venison for the pot, Canadian geese too, and everyone knows of the whole insect protein debate, and the practical applications of bio-tech and nano-tech are only getting more interesting as the fields begin to find their feet.
Bacteria may be blind and and random in their micro-level behavior. But the speed at which they replicate is multiple orders of magnitude faster than the speed at which we can test and iterate new defenses.
It's a race of blindingly fast random iterations VS top-down snail-paced logical defense. If human's are to win, I think they will need to bump up the defensive iteration time an order of magnitude or so.
However, right now the first part is happening and the second part isn't, so until medical science and technology advance sufficiently far -- if indeed they ever do, and specifically if they ever do before a devastating plague hits -- we're in trouble.
Recall the very mechanism that makes bacteria resistant over time: an antibiotic is deployed over a population of bacteria that have largely the same genotype but there are lots of mutations thrown in because they divide so fast. If any of the bacteria are resistant to the antibiotic, they survive and create a new population, again with largely the same genotype with lots of mutations thrown in, but this new population is entirely resistant to that antibiotic.
Now you've probably been visualizing a human body or a petri dish when I talk about "a population of bacteria", but consider the entire Earth. You'll never deploy an antibiotic across all the nooks and crannies of the entire Earth, and even if you were to, you'd just get an ~evenly spread population of bacteria, resistant to that antibiotic.
I guess you could _try_, if you were a supervillain or something.
We're giving bacteria (which reproduce rapidly and mutate quickly) the perfect natural science lab to mutate and select for antibiotic resistance. There are 10^14 bacterial cells in the human body vs only 10^13 human cells [1]. Their reproductive cycle is over one million times faster than ours.
We're creating the perfect conditions for rapid evolution of these organisms. This system is executed by billions of billions of bacteria continuously and we're trying to combat that evolution with a few thousand humans in labs.
It seems to me that the take-away here is we need better engineering of our own solutions and we need to find a way stop enabling this rapid evolution of bacteria.
Bacteria are not fully understood and there are things such as Quorum Sensing which implies some method to the chaos.
While they might not desire anything, they do definitely seek out things.
When you say this, aren't you are making precisely the same mistake you claim the expert was making?! I am sure Dr Arjun knows very well that evolutionary goals are local and specific to the circumstance a creature finds itself in.
>The intelligence that the hominid lineage has evolved gives human beings advantages that bacteria will never possess.
:-) how anthropomorphic! Intelligence may not be a survival trait as you seem to assume. We simply don't know that. Btw, bacteria has been a lot longer on this planet than primates. We are way out of our depth when it comes to understanding how they work (I am simply paraphrasing a friend's statement, he is doing fundamental research on biochemical pathways)
The organism of the bacterium doesn't have desire the way humans do, but the idea of a virus or manifestation of bacteria can have a figurative desire to evolve and grow.
E.g. it does not help if a bacteria can survive a soap if it is still physically flushed away.
We also have a massive escalation ladder for external detergents beyond basic soaps that include a near infinite number of substances of increasing brutality than our arsenal of antibiotics. Essentially anything that will not harm us much with relatively limited exposure, yet will physically disrupt small organism. We can wash our hands in bleach. Or various acids. Or any of numerous agents that are massively disruptive on biological organisms through basic chemistry or even by being physically abrasive.
We don't even particularly need to care if we kill off a fairly substantial number of our own skin cells in the process.
If we had the same arsenal available for fighting bacteria internally as what we can safely apply externally, we'd be in a fantastic position.
(http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/7/2/70-0225_article.htm)
> Skin hygiene, particularly of the hands, is a primary mechanism for reducing contact and fecal-oral transmission of infectious agents. Widespread use of antimicrobial products has prompted concern about emergence of resistance to antiseptics and damage to the skin barrier associated with frequent washing. This article reviews evidence for the relationship between skin hygiene and infection, the effects of washing on skin integrity, and recommendations for skin care practices.
The thing with anti-bacterial soaps is not that the use of the soap is bad. The problem is the anti-bacterial part. It puts amounts of a broad spectrum antibiotic into the environment (be it your hands, your countertop, or the water system) in concentrations that aren't enough to do much, but are enough to put a little bit of selective pressure on the organisms and promote resistance.
It's also not particularly effective - soap and water, through a combination of both mechanical action and how soap disrupts cell membranes, works swimmingly. So there's a cost, and no benefit.
The answer to 'why isn't there a resistance to soap' is that soap, as a chemical, is absurd overkill. It's hellish on lipids of all sorts (tough on grease...and lipid cell membranes), and there's nothing to evolve a resistance to. Not expressing a particular protein, or expressing an enzyme that does a number on an antibiotic compound is effective - to evolve a resistance to soap, you'd somehow have to develop an entirely new type of compound to build cell membranes out of.
And while evolution is rather magnificent, that's asking a little much.
Thinking about this more, I suspect there already has been some selection in this direction, but that it has little to no public health impact, as this defense is not useful in places where infections are typically a problem. Indeed, our body is teeming with bacteria (mainly in the guy) that are in fact beneficial, and they've presumably managed some resistance to shear stress and extreme chemical environments (e.g. high acid).
I dated a heatlh care professional for a while who was pretty adament that it was causing detrimental effects in the same manner as antibacterial soap.
So I don't know if I'd want it gone from toothpaste, but I'd like to see it gone from the many products where its useless or nearly useless, but included so someone can put 'Antibacterial' on the label.
Like soap. Soap is already antibacterial.
But the gap from a bacteria to something that can withstand the physical barrage of a thorough wash is huge in comparison to the relatively tiny changes to overcome some antibiotics. E.g. an antibiotic might disrupt a single process of the bacteria that is beneficial (for them) but that have a multitude of similar alternatives that are different enough for the antibiotic to fail. Compare that to even just being able to strongly enough attach to the skin to not be flushed away by sheer force from a wash.
There are many reasons that tends to be given for being careful about stronger measures: 1) it is not necessary. It's a matter of being cautious - by using the least effective means that is effective enough, we exert the minimum pressure necessary, leaving us with a larger arsenal of (to us) gentle alternatives to step up to. 2) the stronger methods, the more we kill off beneficial or neutral bacteria too, and by doing so we may make conditions better for bacteria that are nasty for us if we happen to pick them up. 3) we reduce our immune systems exposure to relatively harmless amounts of bacteria and some believe this may be sufficient to actually reduce our overall immune defence.
As DanBC pointed out in response to one of my other comments, there's also the issue of physical damage. While we can bring the heavy artillery and effectively kill anything that lives on our skin, we can as collateral damage cause damage to our skin that creates additional places to hide - effectively a worse variation of washing away good/neutral baceteria - not only may we be removing the competition, but we may be opening cracks and folds that'll be excellent hiding places.
The black death bubonic plague killed around a hundred million people, almost half of Europe's population. World war 2 got close to that number of deaths, but the black plague bacterium remains the most efficient killer of humanity on record.
Something that terrible sometimes has to be personified, just to make it comprehensible.
You are taking this too literally. But in any case just because bacteria aren't intelligent doesn't mean their behavior is purposeless. Evolution acts as an optimization process. It's not too far from the truth to ascribe it "desires".
On the frontline episode this was from talked about how pharmaceutical companies have all stopped investing in new antibiotics. It might be possible to make better ones but I don't know how much research is actually going on at the moment.
I'm kind of skeptical. We are fighting against millions of years of evolution. The drugs we have we only got by copying things evolution already found, and they became resistant in mere decades, an extremely short time from an evolutionary perspective. Any simple way of killing bacteria would probably already have been developed by evolution. Likewise pathogens have spent millions of years evolving to defeat everything thrown in their way, and they continue to do so.
We are joining into this ancient arms race as entirely new players.
Consider 'fly by wire' as an analogy. There was great emotion (and still is) around taking the pilot of an aircraft out of direct control of that aircraft. First required by dynamically unstable aircraft (the F-117) this is now a standard feature on large passenger aircraft. The problems are still the same though, one bad line of code (or perhaps a few bad lines) and the plane flies into the ground killing everyone.
Similarly with engineered RNA. We actually do this a lot these days (very interesting bio hacking going on) and with DNA printers you can pretty much design your own bug, print it out, load it into a waiting husk of an E. Coli bacterium and boom, new bug.) Understanding isn't quite there yet but it will be. And knowing the risks of a particular DNA pattern will be just as understandable as a knowing the risks of a piece of flight software.
[1] http://www.3ders.org/articles/20130324-synthesizing-dna-time...
(I think your analogy hides the potential impact of a mutating virus. Fly by wire only puts air travel at risk.)
I.e. they act as if they are selfish.
Blame this way of phrasing it on the limits of language.
Yes, it's inaccurate, but it is what often happens when you want to get across the message and can live with a bit of inaccuracy at the expense of message reach.
I'm not sure I understand your point though, beyond "with more knowledge we will get better at this." What is the timeline? Is there any current research that may lead to this breakthrough, whereby we no longer have to borrow evolved tools from other life forms and can actually develop a precise and resistance-immune treatment?
I personally think there is much potential in Phages in the future. It has already show to be one of the ways to go fighting resistant bacteria.
Examples: controlled release polymers, iPS cells, neurogenetics.
"Someone saying a thing cannot be done is liable to be interrupted by some damn fool doing it."
consider what they have: vast numbers and the ability to evolve much more quickly than we can develop new antibiotics
scary stuff
cf. "Information wants to be free."
Current antiobiotics are themselves mostly derived from "natural" chemicals emitted by microorganisms so that those microorganisms survive natural selection to go on reproducing in a world full of bacteria. Many of the early antiobiotics, for example penicillin, are derived from mycotoxins produced by fungi. Human medicine can use chemicals from fungi for protection against bacteria because human beings and all animals are more closely related to fungi than either fungi or animals are related to bacteria,[1] so fungi have a biochemical similarity to animals that makes it likely (although not certain) that a mycotoxin that is lethal to bacteria will be relatively harmless to human beings.
And this is the way forward to developing new antibiotics. As we reach a deeper biochemical understanding of the basis of all life, we will eventually understand the differences, which are biochemical differences at bottom, between human beings and bacteria, between human beings and protists, between human beings and fungi (yes, there are some systematic differences between animals and fungi) and between human beings and all other harmful microorganisms. Only human beings have science labs and clinical research studies to come up with new defenses against the thoughtless, largely immobile threats from other living things. We can form hypotheses, test those hypotheses rigorously, and perhaps make some lineages of harmful microorganisms as extinct in the wild as the smallpox virus and rinderpest virus now are. The intelligence that the hominid lineage has evolved gives human beings advantages that bacteria will never possess.
[1] http://ucjeps.berkeley.edu/DeepGreen/NYTimes.html
http://www.nytimes.com/1993/04/16/us/animals-and-fungi-evolu...