News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by tedunangst on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @12:48PM (#6599902)
Clearly, everyone needs to stop washing their hands, or bacteria will develop soap immunity. And then what will we do?
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by vidarh on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:40PM (#6600322)
Killing bacteria is easy. The trick is killing bacteria without harming ourselves. Soaps can be massively more "brutal" in terms of the mechanisms that destroy bacteria than what antibiotics can, and so the evolutionary steps that would have to occur for resistance are vastly larger, and would mean changing them in many different directions.

E.g. it does not help if a bacteria can survive a soap if it is still physically flushed away.

We also have a massive escalation ladder for external detergents beyond basic soaps that include a near infinite number of substances of increasing brutality than our arsenal of antibiotics. Essentially anything that will not harm us much with relatively limited exposure, yet will physically disrupt small organism. We can wash our hands in bleach. Or various acids. Or any of numerous agents that are massively disruptive on biological organisms through basic chemistry or even by being physically abrasive.

We don't even particularly need to care if we kill off a fairly substantial number of our own skin cells in the process.

If we had the same arsenal available for fighting bacteria internally as what we can safely apply externally, we'd be in a fantastic position.

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by DanBC on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:46PM (#6600366)
I agree with you, but we need to be cautious with washing hands. The CDC have a nice document about "when is clean too clean?" which mentions the problems with people who have to clean their hand frequently. Damaged skin can harbour bacteria, and can make it harder to remove those bacteria.

(http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/7/2/70-0225_article.htm)

> Skin hygiene, particularly of the hands, is a primary mechanism for reducing contact and fecal-oral transmission of infectious agents. Widespread use of antimicrobial products has prompted concern about emergence of resistance to antiseptics and damage to the skin barrier associated with frequent washing. This article reviews evidence for the relationship between skin hygiene and infection, the effects of washing on skin integrity, and recommendations for skin care practices.

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by frakkingcylons on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:20PM (#6601031)
Thanks for linking that article. The most interesting takeaway from that personally was that an alcohol-based rinse (hand sanitizer) is effective against nearly all kinds of infectious agents except for Gram-positive bacteria (which have a lipid cell envelope), without the threat of the emergence of resistance.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by mtdewcmu on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:07PM (#6600910)
Handwashing with soap doesn't actually kill bacteria, it mechanically dislodges the oils and debris that bacteria are embedded in on your skin and rinses them down the drain. So bacteria have no defense.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by dsizzle on Thursday October 24, 2013 @01:30PM (#6606588)
The ability to burrow in between cells and to have more adhesive surfaces seem like two possible defenses bacteria already vary in and could evolve better. (Surely handwashing doesn't remove 100% of bacteria.) One reason this doesn't pose problems similar to antibiotic resistance is that this defense doesn't become a useful strategy inside the body, where infections are problematic for humans.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by dsizzle on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:55PM (#6600433)
You don't directly address the resistance question, but I think that issue comes down to the "escalation ladder", which you do bring up. You can increase the effective of handwashing (or ultraviolet or whatever) in a way that just isn't possible with antibiotics.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by ghaff on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:12PM (#6600094)
You've been voted down but there is actually a school of thought that excess use of antibacterials and generally going "overboard" (whatever that means exactly) with preventing children from being exposed to natural flora can potentially result in weakened immune systems. There's a lot of pseudo-science in these claims but that doesn't mean there's absolutely no truth to them. It would probably be hard to do a study though and it's not clear who would fund such a thing.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by dsizzle on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:49PM (#6600386)
Ignoring the snark (of the parent comment), I've often wondered why it was bad to use anti-bacterial soap (and antibiotics in general), but not regular soap, since both leave some amount of bacteria behind, which presumably have genetics making them more resistant to the pressure. I think part of the answer is that its just not possible to evolve resistance to any amount of soap and hand washing, unlike resistance to the targeted mechanisms of an antibacterial compound.
Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by Fomite on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:11PM (#6600947)
I'll take a stab at this - I'm an infectious disease epidemiologist that works on hospital infections mostly.

The thing with anti-bacterial soaps is not that the use of the soap is bad. The problem is the anti-bacterial part. It puts amounts of a broad spectrum antibiotic into the environment (be it your hands, your countertop, or the water system) in concentrations that aren't enough to do much, but are enough to put a little bit of selective pressure on the organisms and promote resistance.

It's also not particularly effective - soap and water, through a combination of both mechanical action and how soap disrupts cell membranes, works swimmingly. So there's a cost, and no benefit.

The answer to 'why isn't there a resistance to soap' is that soap, as a chemical, is absurd overkill. It's hellish on lipids of all sorts (tough on grease...and lipid cell membranes), and there's nothing to evolve a resistance to. Not expressing a particular protein, or expressing an enzyme that does a number on an antibiotic compound is effective - to evolve a resistance to soap, you'd somehow have to develop an entirely new type of compound to build cell membranes out of.

And while evolution is rather magnificent, that's asking a little much.

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by dsizzle on Thursday October 24, 2013 @01:40PM (#6606653)
Bacteria evolving to secrete a soap-resistant compound doesn't sound far-fetched at all. Such compounds clearly exist already (e.g. pigments that don't wash off).

Thinking about this more, I suspect there already has been some selection in this direction, but that it has little to no public health impact, as this defense is not useful in places where infections are typically a problem. Indeed, our body is teeming with bacteria (mainly in the guy) that are in fact beneficial, and they've presumably managed some resistance to shear stress and extreme chemical environments (e.g. high acid).

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by EvanKelly on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:44PM (#6601178)
How do you feel about Triclosan in toothpaste?

I dated a heatlh care professional for a while who was pretty adament that it was causing detrimental effects in the same manner as antibacterial soap.

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by Fomite on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:55PM (#6601241)
That one is...a little trickier. There is some evidence that it works for controlling bacterial growth leading to gingivitis - suggesting there may be some utility for it. But its ubiquity in consumer products makes me a little skittish.

So I don't know if I'd want it gone from toothpaste, but I'd like to see it gone from the many products where its useless or nearly useless, but included so someone can put 'Antibacterial' on the label.

Like soap. Soap is already antibacterial.

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by vidarh on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @02:13PM (#6600547)
It obviously is possible to evolve resistance to soap and hand washing: It doesn't kill us.

But the gap from a bacteria to something that can withstand the physical barrage of a thorough wash is huge in comparison to the relatively tiny changes to overcome some antibiotics. E.g. an antibiotic might disrupt a single process of the bacteria that is beneficial (for them) but that have a multitude of similar alternatives that are different enough for the antibiotic to fail. Compare that to even just being able to strongly enough attach to the skin to not be flushed away by sheer force from a wash.

There are many reasons that tends to be given for being careful about stronger measures: 1) it is not necessary. It's a matter of being cautious - by using the least effective means that is effective enough, we exert the minimum pressure necessary, leaving us with a larger arsenal of (to us) gentle alternatives to step up to. 2) the stronger methods, the more we kill off beneficial or neutral bacteria too, and by doing so we may make conditions better for bacteria that are nasty for us if we happen to pick them up. 3) we reduce our immune systems exposure to relatively harmless amounts of bacteria and some believe this may be sufficient to actually reduce our overall immune defence.

As DanBC pointed out in response to one of my other comments, there's also the issue of physical damage. While we can bring the heavy artillery and effectively kill anything that lives on our skin, we can as collateral damage cause damage to our skin that creates additional places to hide - effectively a worse variation of washing away good/neutral baceteria - not only may we be removing the competition, but we may be opening cracks and folds that'll be excellent hiding places.

Re:Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibioti... by architgupta on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:42PM (#6600336)
You could probably compare kids in the developing world versus kids in the developed world.