News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by EdwardDiego on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @12:23AM (#6596859)
When I was trying to get into the developer game (I'm self-taught with no degree so couldn't follow the normal progression) the biggest market in my hometown was (and still is) for .NET developers.

So, I joined a .NET user group, I installed VS, I started learning.

Problem was, MS was churning out the "next great thing" faster than I could learn the last great thing. While I was getting my head around WinForms, WPF came out. I started using WPF, then Silverlight arrived, which was like WPF, just a subset of it, and therefore different enough to be problematic.

But that wasn't too bad. It was the 'blessed' data layer stuff that threw me. When I started it was DataSets etc. Then it was LINQ-to-SQL, then it was very much not LINQ-to-SQL, but instead was Entity Framework.

As a newbie who was trying to make myself marketable, it felt like a bit of a hamster wheel, but then through the user group, I met .NET pros who felt exactly the same way.

And at the end of the day, the greatest irony was that when I finally broke into the market, it was a Java-based developer role on the basis of my JavaScript. So all my years of frantically spinning the .NET wheel was for naught.

I still do love F# though.

In hindsight, the thing that strikes me about .NET development is that most businesses using it really want the whole stack to be from one provider whom they trust - and as a result, third party alternatives never really get a look-in if an MS or MS blessed technology such as JSON.net (http://james.newtonking.com/json) can do the same job.

That is a massive sweeping generalisation of course, and only applicable to the limits of my experience in a small city in a small country.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by ern on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @04:32AM (#6597603)
It was the 'blessed' data layer stuff that threw me. When I started it was DataSets etc. Then it was LINQ-to-SQL, then it was very much not LINQ-to-SQL, but instead was Entity Framework.

As a newbie who was trying to make myself marketable, it felt like a bit of a hamster wheel, but then through the user group, I met .NET pros who felt exactly the same way.

Most .NET developers learn what they need to know for the project at hand. A year ago, I worked on a fairly cutting-edge EF Code-First n-tier project, with knockout.js on the front end, using ASP.NET MVC web API. I am currently extending a crufty ASP.NET 2.0 webforms app.

Adaptability is an important skill for developers. Also, each iteration of the Microsoft data access stack feels like an improvement over the earlier ones, so it's not an unbearable burden to learn it.

And at the end of the day, the greatest irony was that when I finally broke into the market, it was a Java-based developer role on the basis of my JavaScript. So all my years of frantically spinning the .NET wheel was for naught.

Hiring someone for a Java job, based on their JavaScript knowledge is fairly unconventional (to put it politely). Are you certain that the general programming knowledge you acquired through "spinning the wheel" wasn't a factor?

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by EdwardDiego on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @05:14PM (#6601765)
> Are you certain that the general programming knowledge you acquired through "spinning the wheel" wasn't a factor?

I never stopped (and never do stop) learning as much as I could, and I apologise if I gave the impression I was only learning .NET stuff. I was primarily coding in Python, but got into JS to write stealth code to automate a horrendously manual part of my day job in a government contact centre.

To clarify for you on the hire, I was hired for the JS, but expected to learn Java pretty quickly.

> Adaptability is an important skill for developers.

For sure.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by petit_robert on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @04:31AM (#6597598)
>Problem was, MS was churning out the "next great thing" >faster than I could learn the last great thing.

Same here. I design databases, and MS kept bringing new data access methods every three years; I never could wrap my head around the ADO/DAO difference, but that did not matter for long because both were replaced by .Net

I sincerely wondered if this was not a deliberate tactic by Microsoft : while developpers are busy learning their newest "next great thing", they can't invest time in anything else.

Meanwhile I learned how to use an OSS lamp stack and have been happily using it for the last 10 years. Very stable and reliable, I could not be happier.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by xradionut on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @08:25AM (#6598272)
"I sincerely wondered if this was not a deliberate tactic by Microsoft : while developers are busy learning their newest "next great thing", they can't invest time in anything else."

Bingo!

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by im3w1l on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @08:56AM (#6598377)
On what grounds do you confirm his speculation?
Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by xradionut on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:51PM (#6600403)
Occam's razor.

Either Microsoft is incompetent or promoting/retirement of APIs is more profitable.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by im3w1l on Thursday October 24, 2013 @07:01AM (#6604497)
A, in my opinion, simpler explanation is that they change their product to try to make it better.
Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by petit_robert on Thursday October 24, 2013 @04:10PM (#6607633)
>A, in my opinion

mmmh... I thought about this too.

However, MS is anything but stupid marketing wise, I find. So I dismissed incompetence.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by EdwardDiego on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @08:36PM (#6602738)
> Meanwhile I learned how to use an OSS lamp stack and have been happily using it for the last 10 years. Very stable and reliable, I could not be happier.

I find that Java's biggest problem (stability/stagnation depending on who you ask) is also the JVM development ecosystem's benefit. There's not one body driving adoption of technologies by deciding what's supported and what's not, so technology choice is less dictated by economic imperatives.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by petit_robert on Thursday October 24, 2013 @04:27PM (#6607721)
Not sure what you mean exactly, but in any case I know nothing about Java; my LAMP stack is :

Linux, Apache, Mod_perl, Postgresql

All very pleasant to work with (1) and stable; mod_perl has a rather steep learning curve, but worth it for web work. Very powerful _and_ low cost.

( 1 : if you like Perl, obviously )

[Edit] asterik in note caused weird formatting; replaced with 1

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by pjmlp on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @01:43AM (#6597119)
I guess you also suffered from being a newbie into a myriad of technologies.

WPF and Silverlight share almost the XAML stack with little differences. One just needs to know those differences.

LINQ-to-SQL and Entity Framework are usually used together and also share common concepts.

Other vendors also keep changing their stacks, it is the job of a developer to keep up with changes and learn to quickly pick up what is relevant for a given project.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by Spearchucker on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @05:26AM (#6597742)
It's an interesting area. I've worked with Microsoft tools and technologies since 1986, right through to today. LINQ and the Entity Framework are two technologies I avoid because they push me into a design paradigm that doesn't work for me. Try encrypting an object before saving it to a database. And then try saving that object to SQL Server and a service end point, using the same data access layer. Try loading 500k records using LINQ on a netbook.

Sure, on Windows Phone I'm forced to use LINQ, and I've written some really crazy code to hide it from my app, but at least my app is fast.

Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by skriticos2 on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:23AM (#6597400)
I like the Unix / OpenGL way where you start with a sensible thing and then extend it, keeping the underlying architecture somewhat consistent.
Re:Ask HN: Why the Microsoft hate? by pjmlp on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:51AM (#6597466)
Have you ever done portable UNIX development across commercial UNIX systems?

Consistency leaves a lot to be desired as well.