News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by jrockway on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:04AM (#656042)
It's just begging for the political and commercial powers that be to stamp down on the web with a great, big boot.

No, this is the end of the ad-supported internet.

Politics doesn't matter; the (US) government cannot legally censor anything, they've tried, it's been declared unconstitutional. Companies don't care what they're hosting, as long as they are getting rich. If they could legally make millions of dollars a year hosting child porn, they would. (They have no objection to polluting the environment or forcing workers to work in unsafe conditions, directly resulting in many deaths every day. Showing videos on the Internet is child's play compared to that.)

However, it's the advertisers who will get upset, and then pull out. "Our product associated with porn being shown to children? Bye." With no advertising revenue, the web (as we know it) cannot exist. That means either censorship (too hard; "information wants to be free"), or actually paying money for content.

FWIW, this is not unheard of. The big Japanese video sharing site, NicoNico Douga, requires everyone to pay. Even though it's not free, it's more popular than Youtube.

In the end, the advertisers lose, and I think that's a good thing. I hate advertising.

Media corporations have already started demanding more control over the "distribution channel" that is the Internet.

They're demanding, but nobody cares about their demands. I know people whine about Hulu's restrictions, but I've never even visited Hulu and I still get all my TV online. It's called Usenet. You open your news reader, browse to alt.binaries.multimedia.tv-shows, or whatever, and download away. In 10 minutes, I have whatever show I want, in HD, with no restrictions. "Censorship is considered damage, and the Internet routes around it."

The whole "let's punish file-sharers" thing has also backfired. Even governments with very weak personal protections (France, the UK) have struck down the disconnection laws. The Pirate Party has 17% of the vote in Sweeden (and large numbers in other EU countries, I think). Organizations in the US are suing the RIAA for its lawsuit intimidation campaign.

The tide is shifting, and it's not towards the media industry's interests.

Basically, now is not time for the media companies to demand anything. Nobody cares what they think. If creating content isn't profitable anymore, they should go into some other business and stop bothering everyone else.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by eli on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:41AM (#656058)
The First Amendment right to free speech is not absolute. Sure, the Supreme Court has usually rejected prior restraint, but try writing a book about how to make crystal meth and let me know how it turns out.

And there's certainly no absolute right to anonymous speech....

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by jrockway on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:54AM (#656065)
try writing a book about how to make crystal meth and let me know how it turns out.

I can't think of any reason that this might be illegal. The research you need to do to write a good book may be illegal, however. You can always do that in a different country, though.

And there's certainly no absolute right to anonymous speech....

The courts disagree. See, http://www.eff.org/cases/doe-v-cahill for example. (http://www.groklaw.net/articlebasic.php?story=20051007151046... is a more in-depth analysis.)

Finally, "anonymity is a shield from the tyranny of the majority ... It thus exemplifies the purpose behind the Bill of Rights, and of the First Amendment in particular: to protect unpopular individuals from retaliation -- and their ideas from suppression -- at the hand of an intolerant society."

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by riffic on Saturday June 13, 2009 @08:23AM (#656083)
the authors of the federalist papers might beg to differ
Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by thomaslee on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:31AM (#656051)
"They're demanding, but nobody cares about their demands."

Except politicians whose morals and wants stretch in proportion to the contributions they receive.

"Basically, now is not time for the media companies to demand anything."

That's not the point I'm trying to make. The point is that this sort of "vandalism" is going to change the whole landscape, everything you just described.

Perhaps now is not the time for media companies to demand anything -- but if you take the freedom of today's Internet for granted, sooner or later this sort of behaviour is going to come back and bite us all on the ass. It could progress such that if censorship fails, they could always go down the China route and use plain old-fashioned fear.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by axod on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:10AM (#656045)
Perhaps you mean "Advertising on UGC websites". And in that case, it's far more likely sites will just come up with better moderation tools to detect questionable content.

Online advertising is crucial for the survival of the internet. I kinda like the fact most sites are free to visit. You can hate it all you like, but without it, most of the internet wouldn't exist. I hate people who hate advertising :/ It's irrational. It's like saying you hate 'money', 'commerce' or even 'information'

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by jrockway on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:32AM (#656052)
I will define "hating advertising" as "liking the lack of advertising better".

Fortunately, this is a decision I am free to make for myself. I can fast-forward through advertisements on television and block them on the Internet.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by axod on Saturday June 13, 2009 @09:06AM (#656102)
meh. I find them really useful. Perhaps it's a hippy anti-consumerism thing I just don't understand?
Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by sho on Saturday June 13, 2009 @07:56AM (#656066)
"Online advertising is crucial for the survival of the internet."

Which internet? There was plenty of internet before ads became common. Without ads some other structure would arise. It might change a bit but the internet is here to stay.

"I hate people who hate advertising :/ It's irrational."

I don't see anything irrational about disliking insidious, manipulative marketing messages being shoved in your face whereever you look. In fact I find it completely rational, what are you talking about? I am guessing that you rely on advertising for your income, but surely you can see the other perspective.

And saying that you "hate" people who hate advertising is pretty disturbing.

update: corrected misquote

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by jrockway on Saturday June 13, 2009 @08:07AM (#656073)
Which internet? There was plenty of internet before ads became common.

I agree. I have never found ads worth the trouble. I am no designer, but I cannot bear to look at ads on my own site, even if I could be making money. I would rather ensure that my readers have a peaceful and pristine experience learning from my writing than make a few cents off of them. I think I would even prefer a paywall to advertising. (And indeed, I have written a book that you have to pay for. Although it is on P2P sites, and I certainly won't be suing you if you download and read it. Give me money if you want to, otherwise, don't worry about it.)

And saying that you "hate" people who dislike advertising is pretty disturbing.

It's axod. He is hates everyone and everything, unless Apple makes it.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by axod on Saturday June 13, 2009 @09:09AM (#656106)
I love lots of things :) A free internet is one of those things.

I don't understand hate of advertising though. Are you anti-christmas presents also? Do you hate blockbuster movies? Hate disney? Hate consumerism? Maybe there's some 'hippiness' going on I just don't get.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by jrockway on Saturday June 13, 2009 @10:46AM (#656165)
I don't understand hate of advertising though.

It's boring to see the same thing over and over again. If I got a new ad every time, maybe I wouldn't block them.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by sho on Saturday June 13, 2009 @09:29AM (#656117)
You're not replying to me, but I want to respond anyway. I hate advertising for two main reasons:

1. It is mostly ugly and aesthetically displeasing. I care about how things look and take steps to seek out and appreciate things I like looking at (eg art, OSX) and avoid things I don't (advertising, Windows)

2. I recognise the human brain is a flawed machine and susceptible to clever manipulation, even when the person knows he is being manipulated. Thus, I avoid any contact with known-manipulative forms of messaging whereever possible - this includes most forms of advertising. I have no such aversion to, say, movie trailers (I generally love them) or local business catalogues, etc, since they are informational only and do not try to manipulate me. By the way, if you think you're immune to this manipulation, you are 1. in the vast majority of people and 2. provably wrong.

And I do dislike excessive consumerism, especially around christmastime, and credit advertising for spurring it on - but whatever, people can do what they want.

You always mentioning this "free, advertising-supported internet" but that is a simplistic view, IMO. The price of "free" is that you are expected to view, absorb, and presumably act on, commercial messaging. There is no immediate monetary charge, no, but there certainly is a cost.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by axod on Saturday June 13, 2009 @10:19AM (#656144)
Well, agree to disagree.

Advertising is there to tell me about products and services I didn't know about. I find that useful, and so do most people. Advertising (when done well) can be funny, witty, clever, artistic, etc. Sure, you get a few ugly adverts, just as with anything else.

I'm guessing it's mainly a "I haven't owned a TV for years/I hate consumerism/Anti-mainstream" type thing at work here...

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by samson on Saturday June 13, 2009 @09:16AM (#656113)
From my point of view the internet needs advertising, because if there wasn't Companies like Google orYahoo wouldn't have been able to take on Microsoft with subscription based services.
Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by sho on Saturday June 13, 2009 @09:09AM (#656105)
" I am no designer, but I cannot bear to look at ads on my own site, even if I could be making money. I would rather ensure that my readers have a peaceful and pristine experience learning from my writing than make a few cents off of them."

I wholeheartedly agree. Not only do I not touch ads in any business activities, I do not place ads on any of my personal sites either. I pay for them, then, out of my own pocket - to the tune of about $250/m. I would have thought putting my money where my mouth is like that would ward off claims of being a "freeloader" but apparently not.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by lucumo on Saturday June 13, 2009 @08:10AM (#656077)
> And saying that you "hate" people who dislike advertising is pretty disturbing.

"hate" advertising. Let's not misquote.

> I don't see anything irrational about disliking insidious, manipulative marketing messages being shoved in your face whereever you look.

It does seem a bit irrational to expect everything for free. The other option is payment. In discussion threads there are a lot of people that say "I'll gladly pay for no advertising", but real life so far has not given me reason to believe that that group is actually of a relevant size.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by sho on Saturday June 13, 2009 @08:17AM (#656082)
"Let's not misquote."

Sorry. Corrected.

"It does seem a bit irrational to expect everything for free"

Who said anything about "expecting everything for free"? I pay for a lot of things. I'd pay to access my favourite content if it was required.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by lucumo on Saturday June 13, 2009 @08:40AM (#656094)
> Sorry. Corrected.

Thanks.

Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by axod on Saturday June 13, 2009 @11:09AM (#656187)
OK, without ads, show me the business model for google, facebook, youtube, etc.
Re:4Chan Flooding YouTube with Childrens' Clips Containing Porn by jrockway on Saturday June 13, 2009 @11:44AM (#656215)
Maybe there isn't one?