News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by saosebastiao on Saturday October 05, 2013 @11:41PM (#6503008)
Why not "drug it out of them"? If the disease is caused by a chemical imbalance, why not try to fix the chemical imbalance? Some people (myself included) are not functional without medication.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by wpietri on Sunday October 06, 2013 @12:03AM (#6503063)
Personally, I'm pretty skeptical that most of the people diagnosed with it have a disease. I think it's a perfectly normal human variation that just doesn't match well with our Industrial Age approach to education.

The way I think of it is like height. There's a normal range of tall and short. There are also diseases that make people unusually tall or short. But mere shortness doesn't prove disease. And just because short people have trouble reaching cabinets built for average people doesn't mean we must give short kids extra hormones to make them be average in height.

I think it's reasonable to say, "Hey, in the world we want to create, it's better if many or all people take drugs to shape behaviors so that they match the system they should fit into." Why I don't like is the medicalization of variation.

Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by com2kid on Sunday October 06, 2013 @01:17AM (#6503219)
People with ADHD have reduced brain growth in areas associated with executive control.

ADHD is very real. So is the 50%+ of untreated people with ADHD having substance abuse problems. So is the higher suicide rate. So is the reduced rate of high school and college graduation. So are the dramatically increased rates of depression. Then there is the incredibly high rate of co-morbidity of ADHD with other psychological disorders, most prominently Bipolar Disorder.

Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by wpietri on Sunday October 06, 2013 @10:20AM (#6504147)
Those are interesting facts, but I don't think they prove anything about existence of ADHD as an actual disease. Lower-than-average height is also correlated with many diseases but it isn't a disease on its own.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by com2kid on Monday October 07, 2013 @02:22AM (#6506744)
The portion of the brain associated with self control is smaller in people with a mental disorder that is characterized by a lack of self control.

Now obviously proving the entire causation thing here is pretty hard, but, if someone is missing their eyes, and that person is blind, there might just be a causative relationship happening.

To put it in perspective (http://www.medscape.org/viewarticle/549973), 32% of people with ADHD suffer from depression. 21% bipolar. That isn't some statistical oddity.

(The % is higher in the untreated population, no citation on hand right now sorry)

Over 50% of people with ADHD have substance abuse problems.

Imagine taking a population and saying "oh yeah half those people are alcoholics, but there is no strange underlying cause, nope, we should just let them be."[1]

ADHD isn't the popularized image of "little Johnny can't do his boring old homework that the mean teacher assigned", but rather "Jenny can't make herself go to sleep even though if she is late one more day for work she will be fired and have no money for food or rent."

ADHD is like having your entire sense of self control ripped away from you, no matter how much you want to do something, you cannot force yourself to do it. Pleading and begging doesn't work. Breaking down in tears over one's complete lack of ability to accomplish the simplest of tasks doesn't help any. The neurochemical responsible for self control quite literally isn't there.

[1] Well ignoring that America has basically done that for multiple cultures already...

Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by wpietri on Thursday October 10, 2013 @04:30PM (#6529861)
I'm not our society is structured such that in many common circumstances, greater linearity is beneficial. I'm also not denying that there could be relationships between size of brain regions and various physical characteristics. And I'm certainly not denying your experiences.

What I'm questioning is constructing this as a mental disorder.

That's distinct from, say, psychosis. 100k years ago, being totally delusional would have been harmful. But there's no reason to think that most people classified as ADHD would have been at any disadvantage.

Again, come back to the height analogy (which you haven't addressed so far). There are obvious advantages in our society to being taller, including greater career success. Many short people hate being short. Does that mean there's something wrong with short people, or that they should all be treated with drugs as soon as we can diagnose Tallness Deficit Disorder?

Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by com2kid on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:23AM (#6531962)
Actually below a minimum height, treatment options are given to parents to help their children grow taller. There is a well estab

I also feel that you are tending towards the naturalist fallacy here. Just because something is natural doesn't mean that it is good (or neutral). Mother nature doesn't care.

As for ADHD existing 100k years ago, a large percentage of ADHD cases are in children born to mother's who used drugs during pregnancy. (Obviously not all, but there is a very large %). One cannot discount at least some modern factors being responsible for some percentage of ADHD cases.

Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by saosebastiao on Sunday October 06, 2013 @12:22AM (#6503108)
I think it is perfectly reasonable to take that viewpoint. It certainly might be over-diagnosed. However, as with all neurological disorders, there is often quite a bit of mutability in the actual diagnosis; It isn't uncommon for people to be initially diagnosed with ADHD, only to be later diagnosed with something else. There are a lot of overlapping symptoms with other disorders, varying from OCD to Bi-Polar to Asperger.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by wpietri on Sunday October 06, 2013 @10:51AM (#6504231)
Sure. And that's a sign to me that we don't really understand what's going on yet.

Those are interesting to mention in this context. It's a commonplace among hackers that a little OCD or a little Asperger can be beneficial in some circumstances. Indeed, Temple Grandin, perhaps the world's best-known high-functioning autistic, recommends computer programming as a career for people like her. Among artists, the same is true about Bipolar (the book Touched with Fire is an interesting study of why and how that's true).

I think it's relevant that Asperger was a valid diagnosis for a few decades, but it no longer is. (As of DSM-5, people are just placed somewhere on a spectrum of autism.) That's a great sign that we still have a lot to learn.

I'm sure you get this, but I worry that others will misunderstand me, so let me be clear here: I'm not saying that any of these things aren't a problem for people in today's society.

With attention span, for example, high-end classroom-style education and many high-end jobs require a great deal of focus. But that doesn't imply that people with lower-than-average levels of focus are diseased. Indeed, more than half of Americans consume stimulants daily, and many workplaces provide their staff with free stimulants (coffee, Coke) so they can keep up. Many unarguably normal students consume ADHD meds as study aids. If stimulants improve performance for everybody, they can't be considered diagnostic for a problem.

My concern here isn't that people are choosing that. We're half-evolved monkeys; it's great that we can choose who we want to be. My concern is that we're taking natural human variation and medicalizing it mainly because our current educational system finds some of that variation inconvenient.

Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by ginko on Sunday October 06, 2013 @12:08AM (#6503079)
Because I don't believe it's a disease.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by nav1 on Sunday October 06, 2013 @12:35AM (#6503139)
Of course. Never mind all the evidence. What you believe is more important than any research could ever be.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by UK-AL on Sunday October 06, 2013 @01:07PM (#6504632)
What evidence says it disease? rather simply a normal difference.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by saosebastiao on Sunday October 06, 2013 @12:16AM (#6503094)
And yet, thousands of doctors do, and they prescribe medication to thousands of patients who also do, and for the most part, those medications work as expected.
Re:ADHD Pill Faces High Hurdle in Europe as Stigma Persists by UK-AL on Sunday October 06, 2013 @08:16AM (#6503845)
It's not a disease, its a different type of mind.