News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by ddebernardy on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:30AM (#6493999)
I think you're barking up the wrong tree... And that it has the potential to blow up in Firefox's face.

Remember what happened to html5 video. Everyone but Firefox was pragmatic, and implemented h.264 -- primarily, but not only for hardware acceleration reasons. Years later, Webkit-based browsers are ubiquitous, and Mozilla is developing a phone OS nobody will care about, in a desperate effort to become relevant again.

Imo, Mozilla ought to spare itself another embarrassment by being the only guys in the room with the contrarian opinion. Take the issue to the W3C directly -- or for that matter vote for your local pirate party. HN and other tech news venues might be the correct places to recruit support, but you ultimately want to lobby your case directly.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by Udo on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:38AM (#6494030)
What drove me to Chrome at the time was the resource hunger and the inferior UI of Firefox, not the video thing. If DRM is the consensus, Mozilla should (and probably for technical reasons must) have the contrarian opinion. It would be enough to make me switch back, actually.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by PhasmaFelis on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:43AM (#6494043)
I like Chrome. I think it's a better browser than Firefox. Having to switch back, after several years settling into Chrome's extensions and configurations, would really piss me off. But I'll do it if Chrome implements this bullshit and Firefox doesn't.

Wonder if I've still got tabs saved from the last time I seriously used Firefox, years ago. Probably not...

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by babby on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:09AM (#6494115)
I use both browsers regularly, but Firefox out of preference. It amazes me at how under performing chrome has become over the years. Font rendering, for one. The fact that they STILL don't have DirectWrite font rendering on Windows, something that has been with IE and FF since FF 3.6, amazes me.

Good luck trying to get a webfont to render the same (or look any good) in Chrome as it does in IE and FF on Winderps. The sheer fact that it isn't IE for once...

The font thing, while somewhat recent in usage, should have been in Chrome ages ago. Not going to bother getting into Chromes other more critical flaws as I feel like these threads devolve into this kind of shit too easily.

Just sucks that Chrome has gone from this cool browser that actually is progressive, to some kind of Ad-friendly extension of Google that just qualifies as "better than IE!".

Methinks you should jump on FF, it's better, and not because it may not support some arbitrary HTMl5 spec that we wont see for half a decade.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by fafner on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:43AM (#6494368)
It seems many Chrome users have last used FF 3.6 and still compare Chrome to that. Meanwhile Chrome has gotten slow and annoying. The old "boiling frog" anecdote comes to mind.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by bluecalm on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:39AM (#6494638)
Yep. I remember Chrome was blasting fast when I switched to it when it appeared. I switched back to FF few months ago and I like it better, especially on Android.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chris_mahan on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:18PM (#6497356)
I went back to firefox and could not be happier.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by lelandbatey on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:36AM (#6494348)
Indeed, with firebug for debuging and firefox sync, ever single feature I liked in Chrome is done as well or better in FF. Add the bonus that it performs faster and is leaner on memory, and I dropped Chrome some time ago.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by jaredmcateer on Friday October 04, 2013 @08:17AM (#6494872)
Does Firebug pretty print minified JavaScript now?
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by asimpletune on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:11AM (#6495787)
Yes
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by jaredmcateer on Sunday October 06, 2013 @09:59AM (#6504103)
If there is I couldn't find the option
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by OWaz on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:31AM (#6494337)
The thing about Chrome is that while the font rendering is horrible the dev tools are super awesome. At work I end up using FF for reading text and Chrome for inspecting/debugging.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by cenhyperion on Friday October 04, 2013 @09:20AM (#6495145)
One of my main reasons for using FF is firebug. That said, chrome's dev tools are wonderful and I'll often use both in tandem.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chris_wot on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:26AM (#6494474)
What's your opinion of Firefox's new developer tools?
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chrismonsanto on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:38AM (#6494507)
Firebug is much better.

- Tools like YSlow and PageSpeed require Firebug.

- You can't disable the browser cache from FF devtools, which really sucks when you are trying to debug a broken redirect.

- When inspecting an element in FF devtools, :before and :after CSS properties will not be shown. I wasted many hours debugging a CSS refactor because of this (imagine going up the DOM, comparing computed CSS properties until you reach the root). Both Firebug and Chrome devtools will show :before and :after properties.

I think Firebug and the Chrome devtools are comparable in quality.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by trycatch on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:22AM (#6494603)
> When inspecting an element in FF devtools, :before and :after CSS properties will not be shown.

It was fixed recently. https://hacks.mozilla.org/2013/09/new-features-in-the-firefo...

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by cromwellian on Friday October 04, 2013 @10:30AM (#6495547)
Can you even debug a web worker with Firebug? How about SourceMap support? The times when I've had to switch to FF devtools have been pretty painful. The profiling and tracing tools in chrome also seem lightyears better.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by madeofpalk on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:17AM (#6494592)
> Chrome devtools will show :before and :after properties.

And on that, I was plesently surprised to see Chrome will now display :before and :after psuedo elements in the DOM structure

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by frederickf on Saturday October 05, 2013 @08:11PM (#6502564)
The responsive design view is very handy. It switches the size of the view port without changing the size of the whole window. I still use firebug most of the time, but there are some issues with firebug you have to be careful of. See this post for an example http://perfectionkills.com/understanding-delete/#firebug_con...
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by barrkel on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:11AM (#6495783)
The profiler is nice, a lot better than Chrome IMO.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by ensignavenger on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:33PM (#6498460)
I would switch back to FireFox if I could figure out how to remove the titlebar so that my tabs properly lined up with the top of my screen. (Running under Linux Mint Cinnamon).
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by alipang on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:54AM (#6494539)
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by toyg on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:06AM (#6494564)
Chrome already implements it [1], it's in your browser right now.

I personally use Safari, but if Mozilla supports this pledge, I'll move back.

[1] https://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/list?can=1&q=EME&c...

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chris_wot on Friday October 04, 2013 @07:05AM (#6494683)
It's a draft that's still changing. How are they supporting a moving target?
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by zobzu on Friday October 04, 2013 @07:27AM (#6494714)
update every 6 weeks
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chris_wot on Friday October 04, 2013 @07:27AM (#6494717)
How many CDMs have they created? Genuinely interested.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by toyg on Friday October 04, 2013 @07:42AM (#6494758)
http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=275788

"Part 2 will incorporate the EME API with the Widevine CDM and is slated for a later release (M31)"

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chris_wot on Friday October 04, 2013 @07:54AM (#6494797)
OK, and what does the Widevine CDM entail? Does it run on all operating systems?
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by mzs on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:02PM (#6497259)
I just went here:

https://tools.google.com/dlpage/widevine

Seems only Window and Mac for desktop, maybe it's only in Chrome for Linux on ia32 and ia64?

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by chris_wot on Friday October 04, 2013 @08:11AM (#6494854)
It appears it runs on Linux and Windows, but not on ARM devices.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by thaumasiotes on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:27AM (#6494172)
I switched from firefox to chrome because of firefox's chronic memory leaks, and decided to live without extensions. Now I've switched back because firefox won't attempt to load tabs until you actually focus them.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by nine_k on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:07AM (#6494111)
Bookmark all tabs, exit one browser, open another, import the bookmarks. Mozilla and Chrome can import each other's bookmarks.

BTW I switched to Firefox on my laptop since it seems to be much less resource-hungry than Chrome. Not painful.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by fafner on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:45AM (#6494377)
Give FF a try again. It has vastly improved since FF 3.6.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by PhasmaFelis on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:45PM (#6498515)
Yeah, sounds like this is a good time to do that.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by aragot on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:14AM (#6494291)
+1, switched to Chrome with regret, because of Ff's bloating UI in 3-3.6 and its accompanying slowness.

-1 to the logic of switching "if they implement drm": If your drmized content isn't available in FF, you'll have all incentives to come back. Unfortunately.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by cabalamat on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:33AM (#6494493)
> -1 to the logic of switching "if they implement drm": If your drmized content isn't available in FF, you'll have all incentives to come back.

No I won't. I'll either find an uncrippled version of the content -- for example on TPB -- or I simply won't look at it.

DRM is a perversion of the WWW, and Berners-Lee is wrong to allow his invention to be sullied in this way. The web has been successful because it consists of open standards which means anyone can build on it. Just as tcp/ip is an open standard and Berners-Lee didn't need anyone's permission to build http and html. Take away that openness, and you'll be destroying something very valuable.

If the MAFIAA don't like the open web and want a locked-down system, let them build their own. I'm sure it'll be every bit as successful as Windows RT or the Ford Edsel were.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by untog on Friday October 04, 2013 @09:59AM (#6495371)
I think aragot was using 'you' to mean 'the user'. While you may be motivated to find uncrippled versions of the content, you can rest assured that the vast majority of users will not, and will just switch browser.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by cabalamat on Friday October 04, 2013 @12:56PM (#6496486)
You're probably right, although having said that I know lots of people who don't have an IT background who use BitTorrent because it is less hassle than DRM.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by devcpp on Friday October 04, 2013 @10:17AM (#6495479)
Please consider switching back to FF, at least for the same reasons, if not for all the other ones (FOSS, no backdoors and so on). If you want the same look as Chrome, try the UX nightlies. Butter smooth too. Best browser ever.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by jotm on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:57AM (#6494084)
Does it finally have good flash and JS blockers? Regardless, i hate the tab system and address bar search in Chrome, wish it was like Firefox's, then I'd switch because it's faster...
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by mkr-hn on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:20AM (#6494598)
I switched back to Firefox when Chrome's performance slid to the point where it was unusable after a day. I forgot what it was like to have middle click work correctly.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by Fuxy on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:44AM (#6494376)
I'm probably the only guy here that never switched to Chrome. I wasn't impressed by it's lack of functionality when it launched and didn't think giving up functionality i use for speed was a good idea.

Then Firefox became faster and now i got the best of both worlds though Chrome did grow over that time and now they have everything I would need but I have no reason to switch.

I really hope Firefox puts its foot down and refuses to implement DRM I mean it's an open source browser this should be unacceptable.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by gglitch on Friday October 04, 2013 @10:03AM (#6495396)
I also never switched, for ideological reasons. I've been hooked by the Mozilla Foundation's consistent messaging on freedom.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by themstheones on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:35AM (#6495942)
The only thing they ever did wrong in firefox was removing <blink>. It was in the Book of Mozilla; you can't contradict that.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:08AM (#6494425)
I switched back to Firefox from Chrome a few months ago (I still use Chrome for Gmail) because I found that the resource consumption issue has been turned on its head.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by liljimmytables on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:55AM (#6494544)
This has been my experience too. Also the search bar is fantastic in Firefox.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:25AM (#6494610)
True. Tab switching with % <search term> is extremely convenient.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by bad_user on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:23AM (#6494467)
> Remember what happened to html5 video

What did happen exactly? The desktop is still not playing Html5 video, Flash is still used. I still can't go fully with Html5 on YouTube.

On Android mobile phones, Firefox had a rough time not because of Html5 video, but because they were slow to develop a usable version. The first versions I tried were very unstable and ate too much memory compared to the stock browser. But you know, it's evolving and on Android right now I think it's better than Chrome, minus one or two annoyances. Plus, they took the pragmatic approach, as they fall-back on the operating system's support for H.264 - remember open-source projects cannot bundle H.264 by themselves. Chrome is not open-source, while Chromium is and Chromium does not come with H.264 (although you can make it work on Ubuntu at least by installing the necessary code packages).

How is Html5 video related in any way with Firefox's marketshare?

> Years later, Webkit-based browsers are ubiquitous, and Mozilla is developing a phone OS nobody will care about

You're probably speaking about mobile web browsers. People here forget how big the desktop is and it's not going anywhere. And the WebKit browsers you're talking about are incompatible with each other. As for Firefox OS - personally I care about it, because it's tackling a market that has been ignored by both iOS and Android and because it leads the way to new Web APIs. So there you have it - you can't say that nobody cares about it, when clearly I do.

> Mozilla ought to spare itself another embarrassment by being the only guys in the room with the contrarian opinion

Maybe you should spare yourself the embarrassment of not recognizing that Mozilla made the web better precisely because of its contrarian opinion.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by hexley on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:00AM (#6494551)
Doesn't VLC, MPlayer etc bundle h264? How can you say they aren't open source?
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by pgeorgi on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:49AM (#6494655)
VLC even ships with everything to "crack" DVDs. Those tools are flying under the radar, but Firefox probably won't (with two direct competitors being part of MPEG-LA).

Firefox makes money (through the search engine integration at least), VLC et al do not.

It might also help that VLC is a french project. Laws and patents are sufficiently different that it takes effort to build a case, while for US cases the MPEG-LA + members have probably a template on file where they only have to fill in the victim.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by devcpp on Friday October 04, 2013 @10:27AM (#6495529)
Fun fact: back in 2005, France had a law proposal to ban all free software and VLC was under threat. http://www.fsffrance.org/news/article2005-11-25.en.html
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by icebraining on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:50AM (#6494658)
They are, but redistributing them in certain jurisdictions may be illegal, which prevents many from actually exercising the rights the license grants them. For example, until not long ago, Debian would disable those codecs in their ffmpeg package.

Firefox can't afford to play fast-and-loose with patent liability.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by buster on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:30AM (#6494178)
Actually Mozilla did the right thing and theora and webm are as widely available in browsers (by count). The only two companies that blocked free codecs are the companies part of the MPEG-LA! Which means the get money from h264 content. It still sucks very much that the W3C did not force a codec in the standard, the current situation is awful!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML5_video

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by gsnedders on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:09PM (#6497298)
How does the W3C force a codec in the standard? Apple and Microsoft had outright stated that if the standard said one MUST support Ogg/Theora/Vorbis they would simply chose to violate the standard.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by buster on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:34PM (#6497782)
I dont unerstand. So the right way to form a standard is to follow the biggest corporation and implement their formats rather then create fair chances for everyone, is that it?
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by gsnedders on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:37PM (#6498190)
Nobody follows standards the W3C publish just because the W3C publish them. Indeed, if they have a good reason (or sometimes not so good reason) not to, they won't.

Publishing a standard that says "the user agent MUST support Ogg/Theora/Vorbis" doesn't change anything until you motivate the company that implementing that standard is more important than anything else. And as long as IE, Safari, and Chrome all supported H.264 (etc.) anyway, most web developers would just use H.264 thus giving MS, Apple, and Google no (external) motivation in terms of site-compatibility to support Ogg/Theora/Vorbis, and if the market (i.e., browser users) don't care about it — they won't add support.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by garfor_nrvnsqr on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:39AM (#6494033)
Considering mozilla is basically the last bastion of freedom in the world of major web browsers, I sincerely hope they ignore your advice
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by devx on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:21AM (#6494151)
Are you saying Firefox lost users because they refused to support h.264? That's bull. If they did lose users it was for completely different reasons. I remember being very disappointed with them for choosing h.264 in the end, but even more disappointed with Google for not making VP8 the default codec in Youtube, to have Mozilla's back (with fallback to Flash).

So what if MPAA goes to Mozilla next and tells them to adopt whatever auto-DMCA/censorship schemes they come up with next. Is Mozilla supposed to just accept it because "all the others are doing it"? I sure hope they wouldn't.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by darklajid on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:50AM (#6494529)

  Webkit-based browsers are ubiquitous
Are they? All the corporate guys I know that jumped on Chrome jumped to (..) IE10 now.

Everyone else still uses Firefox around me and wonders why someone would ever install a browser from an advertisement company.

Have you used Firefox on Android? I've to admit that running Aurora is kind of hardcore (daily updates..?), but - wow. It's not just a really good browser, it's beautiful on top of that.

I'm really looking forward to see devices with that OS nobody will care about - because all alternatives suck or died (WebOS was promising, so was Maemo/Meego. I'm also interested in sailfishOS).

Your whole comment is weird. Your claims make no sense from this point and I have to disagree with literally every single line you wrote here.

My hope is that FF/Mozilla _will_ pledge not to implement any of these idiotic ideas.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by untog on Friday October 04, 2013 @09:17AM (#6495128)
Webkit browsers are ubiquitous - they're on almost every smartphone sold these days, for a start.

Everyone else still uses Firefox around me and wonders why someone would ever install a browser from an advertisement company.

I have no idea who you have around you, but that is a very minority opinion. Chrome's usage keeps going up and Firefox usage goes down.

I've used Firefox on Android (including Aurora) and it's fine. I don't see what makes it better than Chrome.

Though I don't think your whole comment is "weird", I think that we both have different experiences.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by darklajid on Friday October 04, 2013 @09:57AM (#6495360)
I was mostly talking about the desktop, other people already commented on the 'forced' Webkit market share on mobile devices.

Firefox around me: From technical people to guys that use mostly Excel, everyone here uses FF (apart from the IE10+ guys at work). Heck, I learned about some of these strange 'take FF, compile it for amd64 and call it "optimized"' FF derived browsers through people that .. are average not-into-computers-really joes.

The only people that DO install Chrome around here (I know, I know, nothing but anecdotes to back this) are elderly family members that click that annoying huge 'You should really download our browser, it's teh best thing ever' button on Google - and get back to launch IE again the next day, because they didn't understand the whole thing, really.

I don't want to take Chrome away from anyone, I just dislike the 'Meh, FF OS is useless anyway, their browser is becoming obsolete and they just meddle with politics' dismissal in the original comment. A 'desperate effort to become relevant again'? Why (and in what world) would they be irrelevant in the first place?

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by criley2 on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:52AM (#6496065)
Anecdote: Literally no one in my office uses Firefox except when we need to copy paste a numbered list from a wikipage, and for some reason Firefox copy paste retains the numbering where nothing else does.

Everyone uses Chrome here, and we're not a fancy new tech company or anything, we're a pretty conservative shop that's been around twice as long as many HNers have been alive.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by code_duck on Saturday October 05, 2013 @11:00PM (#6502921)
Who are these nontechnical users who see Google as a ad company? I would think people who don't know about chrome would first think of google search, gmail, maps, google apps, google news, Android, Glass, and so forth.

WebKit powers the highest percentage of browsers, more than any other rendering engine. Not saying these stats are authoritative, but they are typical and similar to my own sites: http://www.w3counter.com/globalstats.php

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by comex on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:46AM (#6494233)
It might blow up in Firefox's face, a long time from now.

For now, there isn't even any standard for how the decryption algorithms should be implemented as plugins, so it's hard to see how Mozilla could implement it in the first place, let alone be pressured into implementing it.

Also, H.264 was already dominant on the web when the video tag was introduced, it was far better than Theora, it's slightly better than V8, and as you mention, it has hardware acceleration - all strong reasons for people to use it regardless of their opinion on patents. EME's support is mostly limited to a small number of companies that want to use it and doesn't seem inevitable at all. The situations are very different.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by mercurial on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:08AM (#6494282)
> Encrypted Media Extensions (EME) form the basis for a whole bunch of silliness, from proposals to prevent us viewing JavaScript source, to not being able to view text because of a font specification.

That's what you're backing. It may sound odd, but I imagine a large number of folks on HN disagree with you.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by ZeroGravitas on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:41AM (#6494363)
The vast, overwhelming majority of video watched since then has been H.264 via Flash (since it was more "pragmatic" to do so), so I struggle to see how that would have affected Mozilla in any major way. If flash had adopted VP8, (like they said they would) then things might have been very different.

And if your talking about mobile browsers, smartphones are dominated by two platforms, each owned by the corporate parents of two webkit-based browsers, one of whom doesn't allow you to install other browsers at all.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by caiusdurling on Friday October 04, 2013 @04:53AM (#6494394)
> one of whom doesn't allow you to install other browsers at all.

Nitpick, you can install other browsers on iOS. Don't think you can make them the default handler for URLs from other apps however, but most apps still ship their own web view inside the app making that a mostly moot point in my experience.

Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by ZeroGravitas on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:06AM (#6494563)
Yes, that's an issue too but what I specifically meant by that was mainly that you can install wrappers round the provided Webkit, but not, for example, Mozilla's gecko, Opera's presto, or Google's Blink browser engine or even your own spin on Webkit. So saying that Webkit is ubiquitous isn't saying as much about webkit's inherent quality or Mozilla's mistakes as it would if there was a free choice in the matter.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by ChikkaChiChi on Friday October 04, 2013 @09:22AM (#6495157)
Nitpick the nitpick, you can install applications on iOS that are forced to use the not-as-up-to-date-as-Mobile-Safari WebUIView. They are not allowed to roll their own engine.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by shmerl on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:05AM (#6494105)
Mozilla should refuse adding any of this junk into the browser.
Re:Mozilla bug 923590: Pledge never to implement HTML5 DRM by austinheap on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:48AM (#6494059)
Mozilla had one great strength.