News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by tcoppi on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:20PM (#6492155)
Loss of almost $80 million on $316 million in revenue, and they're offering $1b... seems like they're asking for a lot when they have very little.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 7Figures2Commas on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:48PM (#6492360)
Salesforce is worth $30 billion and has no earnings. Amazon is worth $143 billion and has no earnings. Facebook, with a ~$120 market cap, is valued at more than 200 times earnings. Tesla's market cap is roughly a third of Ford's.

As long as the Fed is easing, fundamentals don't matter. The mispricing in equities is particularly pronounced in prominent technology companies, but there is clear excess throughout the market.

The name of the game is momentum. This game will end, and badly, but questioning the market and fighting the Fed has not been the path to profit so keep in mind that, right now, Twitter's bottom line is practically irrelevant.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 3am on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:00PM (#6492432)
Come on, don't lump those together.

* 75% of CRM's float is sold short, market clearly agrees with you * AMZN has big FCF numbers, 2012 being an anomaly because of the big fixed capex expenditures. They grow the business without regard to engineering their GAAP earnings, which is admirable, and means the EV/FCF is probably a big, though somewhat reasonable 25-50. * FB analysis requires a DCF because they're growing earnings so fast. They're only 40 x estimated 2014 earnings * TSLA is not the same business model as F or GM, though they all nominally sell cars. Look at the leverage around licensing revenue that ARMH or QCOM showed.

I haven't read Twitter's S-1 and can't comment on it (50 x revenue makes it feel closer to CRM than any of the others), but I generally agree with your opinion that equities are near a peak because it is literally impossible for fixed income to be less attractive as an alternative and the Fed is clearly letting us know it's closer to the end of QE than the beginning. (disclaimer: nobody should make investment decisions based on my advice, I'm not a professional and you could lose all your money if you do, etc)

EDIT: after perusing the S-1 the revenue growth rate is incredible, so it may end up more like FB (which has only surpassed it's ipo price in the last month or so...)

EDIT 2: Yahoo!'s short data was laughably wrong, CRM's percent of float sold short is 10%

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 7Figures2Commas on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:53PM (#6492709)
Salesforce, Amazon, Facebook and Tesla may all be great companies that deserve aggressive valuations based on any number of factors. But if you truly believe that you can determine what a reasonable premium is in a market that is so influenced by central bank action, I tip my hat to you because you're much smarter than many of the people who do this for a living.

> I generally agree with your opinion that equities are near a peak because it is literally impossible for fixed income to be less attractive as an alternative and the Fed is clearly letting us know it's closer to the end of QE than the beginning

Just to be clear: I didn't state any opinion as to whether we're close to a peak or not, and based on what we've seen in the past month, I wouldn't use the word "clearly" in any sentence referencing the Fed's plans to end QE. The Fed is between a rock and a hard place, and while I think certain scenarios are more likely than others, I'll just say this: the only thing that would surprise me is if there are no more surprises.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 3am on Thursday October 03, 2013 @08:08PM (#6492988)
Fair enough, I didn't mean to put words in your mouth.

But I'd be curious at what price you're be willing to pay for Twitter shares based on the filing.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 7Figures2Commas on Thursday October 03, 2013 @08:15PM (#6493008)
I don't ignore fundamentals, but for non-dividend paying issues, I trade primarily on technicals. As such, I have no interest in Twitter shares and almost certainly won't any time soon, if ever.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by lifeisstillgood on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:19PM (#6492802)
would you mind walking back through that and explaining the acronyms and the meanings. I can google things like FCF is Free cash flow, but understanding that? much harder
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by tvladeck on Thursday October 03, 2013 @08:59PM (#6493147)
Free Cash Flow, conceptually, is the total amount of cash you would have from the company's operations as a single owner of the company in a given year.

The importance of free cash flow lies in how capital investment (buying buildings, factories, or other companies, among other things) is treated.

When a company invests money, it doesn't count against the company's profit. It is just treated as one asset turning into another asset.

/BUT/, if a company is essentially /required/ to invest money in new capital to keep the business going (think capital intensive businesses like oil exploration), as an owner you have to budget that you'll need cash to invest in new things, reducing the amount that actually comes to you.

That hit doesn't show up in profit or revenue, but it does show up in free cash flow.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by lifeisstillgood on Saturday October 05, 2013 @02:49AM (#6499763)
thanks to all replies
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by lemma on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:58PM (#6492951)
A quick note (since I'm on my phone) until someone posts a better reply: ev/fcf is a financial ratio you can use to compare how much you are paying for various companies (idea being that similar companies should sell for roughly similar ratios). DCF takes all the cash a company will ever make and tells you how much you should pay for that now. Basically, there are a lot of ways to value a company and some methods are better suited for a given stage in a company's life than others (for example, many methods fall apart when a company has no earnings or has negative cash flows).
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 3am on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:58PM (#6492955)
Sorry, most of those are ticker symbols (AMZN, FB, CRM, TSLA, F, GM, ARMH, and QCOM).

Other than that, QE is quantitative easing; EV/FCF is enterprise value divided by free cash flow, which can be a useful ratio sometimes (company has a lot of cash/equivalents or lots of non-cash charges lowering earnings); and DCF is discounted cash flow, which the sibling comment explains well.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by yapcguy on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:37PM (#6492628)
> after perusing the S-1 the revenue growth rate is incredible

Well, one could also say that the growth rate of their cost base is incredible too.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by lkrubner on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:50PM (#6492923)
Regarding the Fed and the economy, that is very true. Paul Krugman recently did a column where he suggested that there was no good way for the USA economy to move forward:

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/09/26/trade-and-secula...

He first suggests that we have possibly become dependent on unsustainable bubbles:

"Leaving aside the large surplus just after World War II, we went from persistent small surpluses before 1980 to persistent large deficits after 1980. This meant that we needed more domestic demand, other things equal, to achieve full employment — and arguably that we needed a series of bubbles and rising leverage, which are no longer forthcoming."

then he suggests a possible way out:

"And you might therefore argue that we can avoid secular stagnation by letting low interest rates lead to a debased dollar (hi, Congressman Ryan!), more competitive U.S. manufacturing, and balanced trade."

but then he casts doubt on the possibility of there being any way out:

"Or maybe not, because who exactly is supposed to be on the receiving end of our improved balance?"

As he has suggested in a series of recent blog posts, we might be facing a very long era of stagnation.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by acchow on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:19PM (#6492533)
What's the mechanism for QE having a particularly acute affect on technology company valuations?
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by 3am on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:24PM (#6492562)
You can value an equity based on it's discounted future cash flow discounting by a risk-free rate (typically US 10 yr notes). QE is the Fed making large purchases of t notes on the open market to keep the rate low, in order to keep capital cheap (and ostensibly encourage investment). If they stop these purchases there is a widely held belief that the t note rates will increase, which will hurt the equity premium across all companies. You can play around with any number of free online DCF calculators to see how varying the risk free rate of return effects current valuations.

edit: I am addressing the general question, not ipo valuations.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by preempalver on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:59PM (#6492727)
Anybody who thinks that IPO pricing is done by DCF.....
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by timr on Friday October 04, 2013 @12:14AM (#6493678)
It isn't, but it's a convenient model that holds true on average.

What people actually do is say: "oh, crap...I can't make money in fixed-income securities. I guess I'll dump my retirement in stocks instead." This flood of money eventually makes its way to the riskiest stocks and props up high valuations.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by acchow on Friday October 04, 2013 @12:33AM (#6493724)
> This flood of money eventually makes its way to the riskiest stocks

Citation needed.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by timr on Friday October 04, 2013 @03:55AM (#6494253)
The same way it makes it to every other stock. People buy them, looking for returns.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by foobarqux on Friday October 04, 2013 @12:22AM (#6493695)
Do you happen to understand why QE isn't suppose to increase the money supply? My understanding is the treasuries are bought by increasing the balance of a commercial banks federal reserve account. Can't the banks draw on that account?
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by onebaddude on Friday October 04, 2013 @08:50AM (#6495006)
The amount of reserves in the system are fixed by the Fed. Reserves can be moved from bank to bank, but the total amount in the system remains the same.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by foobarqux on Friday October 04, 2013 @06:44PM (#6498509)
What did the government use to buy back treasuries and where did it come from?
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by onebaddude on Friday October 04, 2013 @08:58AM (#6495041)
>If they stop these purchases there is a widely held belief that the t note rates will increase

The only people calling for a crash when rates return from "historically low" to just plain old "low" are those that depend on these low rates.

It never ends well when you pile in at historical minima/maxima.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by onebaddude on Friday October 04, 2013 @08:52AM (#6495015)
>As long as the Fed is easing, fundamentals don't matter.

Can you point to a metric, besides the obviously flawed Cape-Shiller, that shows the stock market is anywhere near a point where fundamentals "don't matter"?

>This game will end, and badly

Will it? I think it's already ended well, preventing us from going into a deep depression.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by rbranson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:41PM (#6492891)
In general, valuation reflects anticipation of future potential, not present performance. This is what's called "investment."
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by joeblau on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:14PM (#6493187)
So this is a good idea, until the Fed decides that it's not a good idea.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by sologoub on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:50PM (#6492377)
Looking at their adjusted EBIDTA, it looks like they managed roughly the same amount in 2012 as in 1st half of 2013. That definitely shows that they are aggressively driving to profitability.

Top line revenue is not looking quite as impressive, but 2012 is shown at $317 million, where as H1 of 2013 is shown at $254 million. If you assume same revenue levels for H2 (no idea if that's a valid assumption), you are looking at $508 million for 2013 or a 60% growth in revenues.

Add to this the sentiment comments made by others about how mainstream twitter is, and you definitely have decent justifications for high-ish stock price.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by dm8 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:31PM (#6492248)
Looks like they are betting on potential. To be honest, Twitter is so mainstream that it is entirely new medium of news/discovery/conversation just like Radio/TV/Internet. I'm sure they will be extremely profitable company in the future.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by Touche on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:42PM (#6492321)
I doubt it. Twitter is fundamentally flawed in a way that I'm not sure is fixable. The fact is that the vast majority of people on Twitter get no feedback at all when they post something. This is a combination of 2 things:

1) Tweets disappear quickly from a user's timeline 2) Most people have few active followers

1 and 2 work against each other to form a negative feedback loop. The result is the vast majority of users use it passively to read celebrity tweets, nothing more.

Twitter must know this as their growth is already peaking and they're not making much money. Expect to see more drastic measures to try and turn what they already have into something profitable. They've peaked.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by jedc on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:48PM (#6492358)
Twitter can have value to people that post nothing. (This is the case for a number of my friends on Twitter.) And what you're describing has existed since Twitter was created as Twttr.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by Touche on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:15PM (#6492514)
Right, it has value, but that value is not going to go up, is my point. Twitter users don't become more engaged over time because only a small percentage of users can use it the way it is intended.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by foobarqux on Friday October 04, 2013 @12:24AM (#6493702)
Seems to me most of the value in Twitter is as a broadcast medium for established media entities.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by guelo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:42PM (#6492657)
500 million tweets a day means that users are getting some kind of positive reinforcement for posting, and that it's more than celebrities.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by yapcguy on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:50PM (#6492692)
How many are retweets rather than original tweets?

How many are spam?

How many are shady i.e. pay folk in the Philippines or Pakistan to send out tweets all day, to boost the numbers?

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by bolder88 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:51PM (#6492701)
500m tweets a day is nothing.

That's only 5,700 tweets a second.

An average IRC network for example does more than that.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by cscheid on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:14PM (#6492777)
The number your comparison is missing, and one that happens to be crucial to both business and technical differences, is that you should be looking at tweet impressions, not tweets.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by hboon on Friday October 04, 2013 @02:51AM (#6494072)
Also interesting is if impressions should be counting followers of the tweet author or only if the follower reads it.

Many users are following so many accounts that they can only read only a small subset of their timeline. I wonder if Twitter's apps and services also have to evolve substantially like Facebook's did to include more elaborate filtering and ranking options.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by austenallred on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:45PM (#6492337)
I agree with you regarding Twitter's monetization opportunity; they're barely scratching the surface of what's possible, hiring like crazy (most of the expense), etc.

What seems odd to me is that they're filing for IPO right now. Do they honestly expect public markets to buy their "but it's becoming ubiquitous" story? 2000 wasn't that long ago.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by dm8 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:53PM (#6492385)
Doing IPO means raising money from public markets. So with IPO money, they believe they can buy lot of companies, hire people and make it really profitable business.

FB/Google/LinkedIn didn't have to go public but they had to due to SEC regulations and/or their existing investors.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by MichaelGG on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:29PM (#6492592)
Haven't they already raised over a billion dollars have have over 1000 employees?
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by umsm on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:38PM (#6492303)
Exactly. It feels like they are not concentrating on their profitability yet.

When they do, I believe they will have a lot more income.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by yapcguy on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:41PM (#6492654)
Oh my god.

They're bleeding money.

If they don't IPO now, how much longer could they last for?

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by stormbrew on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:43PM (#6492328)
Their revenue growth is pretty solid, so there is clearly potential there. Doubled revenue between first half 2012 and first half 2013, 10x yearly since 2010.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by yapcguy on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:44PM (#6492665)
Past performance is not an indication of future... you know the rest.

They're also on track to almost double their from 2012 to 2013. Why don't people ever look at the costs? There's a reason why they are on track to lose over $100 million this year.

Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by dev_jim on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:10PM (#6493342)
Another lazy post voted to the top on HN that beats the same ole lack of profit drum in a rapidly growing company. Where's the comparison to Apple to really drive home the point?
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by peloton on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:46PM (#6492348)
That's usually a placeholder number. They're going to raise what they can and it will probably end up much higher than $1b in stock.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by hayksaakian on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:44PM (#6492334)
For only recently opening their ad platform, that's not too surprising.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by tcoppi on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:47PM (#6492355)
Maybe, but then what is the reason they think this is a good time for an IPO? It seems kind of desperate to my admittedly untrained eye, but it could also be brilliant.
Re:Twitter files S-1 with the SEC by hayksaakian on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:54PM (#6492390)
From my naive point of view, it seems like now is when they can make their most optimistic projections that could still be taken seriously.