News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by spdy on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:17AM (#6481591)
Am i the only one who does not like "touch" on a desktop/laptop. It is not the revolutionary input method that makes everything magical. I want to think in boxes (desktops) not a fluid streams of desktop space.

We need something else for the desktop.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by freehunter on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:35AM (#6482009)
You seriously come to HN asking if you're the only one who doesn't like Windows 8's interface? I know this isn't your first post, so you're basically just posting a popular opinion phrased as a question in an attempt to reap karma.

Welcome to 2011. Your complaints are now fresh and new again.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by arethuza on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:21AM (#6481602)
It is even less appropriate on a server OS - I have no idea what they were thinking making Windows Server 2012 use the same touch oriented start menu replacement nightmare....

[Having to use a demo VM that has 2012 installed at the moment and I'm finding it incredibly annoying].

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by Freaky on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:38AM (#6481664)
Been using 8 for about a year and have no problem with the start screen without a touch interface - the workflow is pretty much identical to 7: Press the Windows key and type part of the name of what you want, with the bonus that it's significantly faster at giving results.

If you do end up having to select something in the menu, you now have more space to see what's available and modifying the layout to match your usage is a lot more accessible.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by gabemart on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:57AM (#6481706)
> Been using 8 for about a year and have no problem with the start screen without a touch interface - the workflow is pretty much identical to 7: Press the Windows key and type part of the name of what you want, with the bonus that it's significantly faster at giving results.

A full-screen menu appearing on top of whatever I am working on completely breaks my flow. It's immensely distracting to me. As a result, I literally never use it. Instead I use Launchy [1] which is well behaved and keeps within the confines of a very small dialogue box.

That doesn't completely fix Windows 8, though - there's still a bunch of touch-orientated stuff that there's no native way to deactivate.

[1] http://www.launchy.net/

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by lttlrck on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:28AM (#6481801)
I find Gnome 3 suffers the same issue. When I'm searching I know what I'm looking for 99% of the time, it's just a glorified accelerator combo, I don't need a full screen full of distractions.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by Freaky on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:31AM (#6481996)
I tend not to be launching much stuff when I'm working - editors, browsers, VMs etc are already open. Plus I have three monitors, and tend to have it opening on the smallest so it doesn't get in the way.

I do think Microsoft should have made it optional - it's obvious this is what people wanted, and it's not like it would have cost them much in development/support. Still, at least there's now a huge bunch of third party software to replace/augment it, most with far greater configurability than the original Start menu.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by philliphaydon on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:37AM (#6482624)
I thought, wow, awesome, an Alfred alternative to windows.

- Install

- Type in visualstud... I get CALCULATOR...

- Uninstall...

Launchy has absolutely NOTHING on Windows 8 Key + typing.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by TeddyLondon on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:37AM (#6481832)
Totally agree, I have been using 8 / 8.1 since it's release and really don't miss the start menu, I am forced to use xp quite often and cannot stand it, the amount of times I bring up the start menu up and type to bring up an app and the start menu just does nothing just makes me cry.

I have seen some people put the windows 7 style start menu on win 8 - it just doesn't make sense to me, the world moves on, things change, learn to adapt and life is so much sweeter!

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by arethuza on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:44AM (#6481676)
"you now have more space to see what's available"

Actually, you don't - on the server I am using there is an (otherwise excellent) Microsoft product installed that prefixes all of it's menu items with the same name so all you see is a number of items with the same logo and "Really long product name...." and to find out which one is which you have to hover the mouse over them, which rather defeats the purpose of the whole exercise.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by Freaky on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:38AM (#6482023)
So rename them like you would if you would in any previous version. %APPDATA%\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu, rename to heart's content. Or right click the tile, Open file location and rename.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by sesqu on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:51AM (#6482068)
It's funny how many times I've read the same reply to criticisms of Windows 8: "Despite appearances, you can still do X".

I wonder how many options will go the way of the shutdown button in Windows 9 - that is, moved entirely.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by gizzlon on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:43AM (#6481674)
yeah, but that's not how I use 7. I click the "pinned" icon in the taskbar. (It's not as fast as a keyboard short-cut, but it's good enough.)
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by Freaky on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:49AM (#6481689)
So then what's the problem? That works exactly as it did before.

And the first ten do have keyboard shortcuts - Win-0 to Win-9.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by gizzlon on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:56AM (#6482089)
oh, ok.. I thought you had to go through the "start screen" for some applications.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by gebe on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:49AM (#6481687)
You can still do that though.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by hug on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:14AM (#6481761)
I imagine what they were thinking is "maybe people shouldn't be logging on to individual servers in order to manage them."

I manage a number of 2012 VMs, and actually log onto them via RDP very rarely.

You should use RSAT on a workstation, or perhaps Powershell and Enter-PSSession (alias: etsn) in order to manage your machines. If you're a masochist you could even use winrs.exe from inside cmd.exe.

I can't think of much you can do with those two tools that you can't do otherwise, unless it involves [random third-party software]. Even with third party software, I don't see a reason people should be logging on to servers often enough that the start screen should be an appreciable problem -- especially since the start screen is likely to have an immediately obvious and clickable 100px*100px "tile" to get to the software you need to.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by LoneWolf on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:24AM (#6481615)
Now imagine having to manage servers everyday with that interface (yep I have to do it)
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by josteink on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:01AM (#6481726)
I guess it's a good excuse as any to finally learn powershell.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by LoneWolf on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:12AM (#6481755)
Indeed it is
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by ericcumbee on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:11AM (#6482460)
I think the Idea is that you wont use the GUI much on server instances. I am working through a Sharepoint MCSE right now. and the Server config and admin, your encouraged to use the Server Manager tool on another computer or the command line. Ideally on most installs the Full GUI is not installed. MS considers it best practice to use the Core install if at all possible. Followed by the Min Gui, and then if necessary the Full GUI.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by arethuza on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:24AM (#6482540)
"I think the Idea is that you wont use the GUI much on server instances"

Yes - but this one is a completely standalone demo VM from Microsoft with a pile of different products installed - so logging in directly and using the Screen Eating Menu From Hell is difficult to avoid.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by josteink on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:31AM (#6487617)
Having to use a demo VM that has 2012 installed at the moment and I'm finding it incredibly annoying

While Metro/Modern/Whatever is incredible annoying in itself when not on a tablet, having it (which depends on screen-corners) running in a VM which is typically window'ed brings the madness to new dimension.

For minimum frustration, I recommend fullscreen.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by sixothree on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:52AM (#6482069)
Start8 is $5.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by eksith on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:22AM (#6481605)
You're definitely not the only one.

Honestly, I feel like it's a break in my momentum and flow of creativity (that really sounds pretentious, but it's true) to move my hands from keyboard to screen. It's not like keyboard and mouse where both forms of input are on the horizontal plane.

I rather liked the idea behind the Nintendo DS where inputs are available on both the horizontal and (semi) vertical plane. If a touchpad can be made sufficiently intuitive and comfortable enough to serve as both keyboard, touchpad and display screen, I'm in.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by jpswade on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:50AM (#6481692)
Touch really lends itself to interfacing with objects.

Using a mouse, in particular is a little bit foreign to our natural instincts.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by frou_dh on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:57AM (#6481707)
We're already squarely in unnatural territory as soon as an LCD screen is involved.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by anonymous on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:41AM (#6482033)
And where in the entire body of everyday natural instinctively useful objects, are things that respond to and are manipulated by caressing them precisely with just the tips of your fingers? Well, sex obviously, but having sex with a large square piece of glass isn't at all enjoyable.

Kind of explains the popularity of thinkpads' nipple mouse, though.

Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by RivieraKid on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:33AM (#6481817)
Exactly this kind of pseudoscientific reasoning is behind the bad UI decisions in Win 8 and Gnome 3.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by FridayWithJohn on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:26AM (#6481621)
Agreed! Thankfully there is something else. Ubuntu baby!
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by eksith on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @06:29AM (#6481628)
Unity is no better IMO. It feels like another counter-intuitive and ultimately awkward (for me) interface. Which is why I'm right now on Linux Mint which ironically has the most "Windows 7-like" post-Win7 UI.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by RivieraKid on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:37AM (#6481829)
Pretty much, it's another example of the "reinvent the desktop" trend, that is horribly misguided.
Re:Unnoficial design concept for Windows 9 by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @11:23AM (#6482940)
This concept looks as if Canonical designed Windows, quite frankly.

If anything, it does borrow elements from the Android interface and modern DEs like Cinnamon.

I'll just stick to my window manager. There's something charming about their raw simplicity compared to the overt modern "glossy minimalist" interfaces of today.