News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by cs702 on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:09PM (#6432957)
Fairfax Financial is run by Prem Watsa, a cautious, methodical, "value" investor who has compounded Fairfax's book value by nearly 23%/year over the past 27 years.[1] (Fairfax's stock price has gained 19%/year over the same three-decade period.) His approach and track record are similar to those of Warren Buffett earlier in his career -- i.e., not someone one should normally bet against.

If Fairfax is offering to pay $4.7 billion to acquire RIM, Mr. Watsa somehow must have convinced himself that the value of RIM's business exceeds $4.7 billion by a large margin.

However, to me Blackberry looks like a dying platform suffering from anti-network effects (that is, fewer and fewer people use it, so fewer and fewer people want or need to use it). I don't understand how he gets comfortable with that number.

--

[1] See page 8 of Fairfax's last annual letter to shareholders: http://www.fairfax.ca/files/Letter%20to%20Shareholders%20fro...

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by slykat on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:51PM (#6434060)
I'm a value investor myself and was seriously considering buying into this stock if it dipped any further. The thesis for investment is pretty darn clear at this point: Blackberry is trading at levels significantly below asset value and below the amount you'd get from tearing down the company

The balance sheet numbers per share: 1) +$13.50 - Net current assets (i.e liquid assets) 2) +$2.50 - Real estate holding (less liquid) 3) +$6.50 - Book value of IP 4) -$7.00 - TOTAL Liabilities

Meaning if you shut down the company you could realize a value of around $16 per share. Even if you discount current assets & IP since they might be over-valued in the books you can realistically get to a $11-$14 range for the value of the stock.

Essentially this means that any smart owner could realize a significant profit at $9/share just tearing down the company smartly (i.e. not a fire sale). As such, I expect Fairfax: 1) Maintain the businesses that are profitable TODAY 2) Shut down the unprofitable parts of the business that are destroying earnings (and thus slowly eating into asset value and the investment thesis) 3) Shop out ownership / licensing of the IP given it's significant value

I don't think this means that Fairfax is trying to turn around the company and restore Blackberry to its earlier glory; that would be a bit irresponsible and reckless for a value investor. Don't expect Blackberry to be the same company it was before, although I expect parts of business to continue.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by cs702 on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @09:20AM (#6437653)
slykat: I'm looking at asset liquidation value too, but my conclusions are different from yours. According to the June 1, 2014 financial statements[1]:

* Cash, short-term and long-term liquid investments, receivables, and assets held for sale totaled $6.0 billion. (I wouldn't dare put a dollar value on inventories, because their value declines at an accelerating pace, like a waterfall, due to the rapid pace of technological change.)

* Property plant & equipment (consisting mostly of land and buildings) totals $2.2 billion. Let's give them full credit for this figure.

* Total liabilities are $3.7 billion.

So, assuming you can liquidate the whole business quickly, the liquidation value of all tangible assets appears to be somewhere around $6.0 + $2.2 - $3.7 = $4.5 billion. However, the company is hemorrhaging money by the day and suffering from anti-network effects that can make revenues drop like a waterfall (instead of declining in a gentle slope), so this estimate may be optimistic. In a year, the figure could very well be down to $3.5 billion.

That leaves the value of intellectual property, carried on the books at $3.5 billion. Of that amount, $0.8 billion is the price paid for Blackberry's share of the Nortel patents[2]; the reminder consists primarily of all the Blackberry software they've developed in-house (that is, their proprietary OS and applications, built on top of QNX), which is valuable to third parties only to the extent they want to build a business around it. My (conservative) guess: this is worth a LOT less than $3.5 billion -- maybe ~$1 billion -- but I don't know for sure.[3]

At a proposed purchase price of $4.7 billion, the margin of safety looks very slim to me.

--

[1] http://ca.blackberry.com/content/dam/bbCompany/Desktop/Globa...

[2] See the "Intangible Assets, Net" notes in http://press.blackberry.com/content/dam/rim/press/PDF/Financ...

[3] For reference, QNX -- the jewel in Blackberry's software portfolio -- has been sold twice over the past decade. Harman International bought it for $138 million in 1994, and then sold it to RIM for $200 million in 2010. These figures are rounding errors compared to $4.7 billion. Source: http://blog.vdcresearch.com/embedded_sw/2010/04/update-2-rim...

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by slykat on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @08:03PM (#6441728)
Glad to see someone actually looked into the balance sheet before discussing valuation! To be fair I didn't do a detailed analysis into their books - I just skimmed over their balance sheet.

Nevertheless here's where I think we disagree:

* Inventory will have some liquidation value. Let's discount inventory by 75% which is pretty conservative; you will still get $200M here

* IP - Main disagreement for me is here. Most analysts who have pegged the IP at $2 - $3 bn. Let's put it at $2bn, the lower end of the spectrum [1][2]

6.2 + 2.2 - 3.7 + 2 = $6.7B (~40% above purchase price)

As we can see the main question is the value of the IP (and PPE to a lesser extent). I have absolutely no experience valuing patents, I'm not a patent lawyer, and definitely won't be evaluating their 9K+ patent applications. So unfortunately there's a pretty big unknown in the valuation.

Regardless we have a $4.7B - $6.7B range based on a very quick 15 minute analysis of their balance sheet with an upside of earnings of any profitable lines of business that can be operated independently (if they exist).

My guess is tha Prem Watsa, as former chairman of BBRY, has done a much more rigorous evaluation of their IP and found profitable business lines he wants to keep / spin-off to reach a comfortable margin of safety.

[1] http://money.cnn.com/2013/09/24/technology/enterprise/blackb...

[2] http://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2013/08/26/the-n...

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by cs702 on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @10:41AM (#6444840)
slykat: thank you.

The value of IP isn't the only question. We also seem to disagree on how quickly value is evaporating! Blackberry sales are bound to decline faster and faster, like a waterfall -- similar to what happened to Nokia's smartphones.

After the introduction of iOS and Android in 2007-2008, Nokia's quarterly smartphone unit sales barely budged... at first... but then dropped by two-thirds between Q1 2010 and Q1 2012![1]

Liquidating a company of Blackberry's size would take at least two years. Any estimate of liquidation value should take into account the possibility of quarterly unit sales dropping by two-thirds in the near future.

--

[1] http://www.dazeinfo.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/post-15.b...

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by turingbook on Monday September 23, 2013 @08:04PM (#6434970)
Interesting analysis. There is another analysis from Quartz: 0 for phone business, 1.2 billion for BBM and enterprise infrastructure, 2.8b cash, 1b for patent portfolio.

http://qz.com/127441/cheat-sheet-here-are-the-bits-of-blackb...

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by slykat on Monday September 23, 2013 @09:21PM (#6435265)
I'd like to caution that this analysis is incredibly flawed. Specifically it magically ignores the entire liabilities side of the balance sheet (when you buy a company you don't just inherit their cash balances but also their debts). This is the problem with most financial journalism; you shouldn't taking financial advice from someone who doesn't understand the income statement or balance sheet.

All I did was take the balance sheet and pull out intangible assets: https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ABBRY&fstype=ii&ei=.... I did NOT consider the value of earnings from any of the business (i.e. income sheet) as the investment thesis I made was for shutting down the business, and I don't want to divine profitability from each of the business lines.

They really need to require finance coursework in college so this kind of fake financial journalism gets stamped out.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by bproper on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @07:15AM (#6437161)
One of the attractive things about Blackberry is that they have no debt.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/blackberry...

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by slykat on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @08:06PM (#6441746)
Yes but they have $3.7 billion in liabilities that this article conveniently ignores.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by ams6110 on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:24PM (#6435746)
Blackberry is trading at levels significantly below asset value and below the amount you'd get from tearing down the company

FWIW, this is about where Apple was in 2000, at ~$12/share.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by sirkneeland on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:12PM (#6438775)
Yes, but despite being named after a fruit, BlackBerry is no Apple.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by JonFish85 on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:12PM (#6432993)
Take it private, do another, more aggressive round of layoffs and get down to a very core group. Then decide whether to chop it up and sell it off (patents alone are probably worth a good chunk of money). As far as I know, Blackberry has no debt, so that makes the math a bit easier.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by beat on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:35PM (#6433957)
As I put it elsewhere, there's not $4.7B of meat on the corpse. And that seems against the grain of a growth-oriented fund. That's the sort of thing that old-school junk bond funds would do to buy up and part out factories, inventory, and pension funds.

The only justifications I can think of for buying Blackberry are a: to rebuild them, b: to integrate their good tech into an existing system (a good play for an also-ran smart phone that wants more market share and is willing to gamble for Blackberry's old, loyal enterprise market), c: to deliberately put them out of business (a good play for a successful smart phone to either go after the vacuum created by their death, or prevent competitors from exercising plan B).

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by mathattack on Monday September 23, 2013 @05:45PM (#6434376)
Just extrapolating from http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=BBRY rather than digging in to financial statements: Blackberry has $10 billion in annual sales while losing $200 million.

Is it such a stretch to imagine a buyer killing R&D and investment, and marketing the carcass for enough years of free cash flow to get back the $4.7 billion?

Value investors aren't necessarily growth investors. The margin of error they look for can come from a cheap price.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by tomkarlo on Monday September 23, 2013 @07:25PM (#6434823)
Blackberry has rapidly declining sales (-50% in 2 years)... you'd have to hope to not just cut costs, but cut them faster (and repeatedly) to stay ahead of the current decline in sales. And you'd have to expect that decline to accelerate if you're cutting back on R&D (and probably facing general brain drain - why would a good mobile engineer keep working for a company in obvious wind-down? Nobody likes to work on an EOL platform.)
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by mathattack on Monday September 23, 2013 @07:43PM (#6434903)
In this environment you pay the folks keeping the lights on "just enough"
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by tomkarlo on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:45AM (#6436039)
That works if it's a factory. It doesn't work that well in a mobile device manufacturer. Anyone selling wireless devices is subject to ongoing changes in the regulatory environment, plus security threats. If they don't have a team better than what you get by paying "just enough", bitrot will set in within a year.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by mathattack on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @06:53AM (#6437087)
I'm sure it will. But the scenario in question is "How do you wind down the beast taking as much cash out as possible?"

It's similar to, "What if AOL just tried to milk the subscriptions instead of blowing all that money?"

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by tomkarlo on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @12:30AM (#6442643)
It's really, really not similar to AOL.

AOL has an ongoing cash flow from subscription payments. Those payments keep coming from customers until they either quit the service or die off.

Blackberry sells devices. They don't have significant recurring revenue streams - customers have to come back and re-up to a new device every 2-3 years, or they don't get any money. That means as soon as you're no longer offering a competitive product, the revenue stream can dry up very quickly. Especially if carriers and retailers decide you're no longer worth carrying.

Look at the 50% drop they've taken in the past two years. Even if that line just stays constant, you're talking about a decrease of 90% in 6 years total. It's rare than you can scale a tech business down 90% or more and still operate it in any reasonable fashion.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by beat on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:04AM (#6438324)
Blackberry just wrote off $900M in unsold devices. That's a much bigger loss.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by hbbio on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:13PM (#6432997)
This might be where his knowledge of the company comes from:

"On January 22, 2012, it was reported he was to be appointed to BlackBerry handset maker, Research In Motion Ltd. (RIM), board of directors in the company's largest ever corporate shakeup. Mr Watsa resigned in August 2013, but kept his investment in the company at the time."

Source Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prem_Watsa

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by goodcanadian on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:45PM (#6433274)
At the end of the last quarter, the company's book value was $9.4 billion. Even if you leave out intangibles (like patents, which everyone seems to agree is worth something), the value was $5.9 billion. I think the value proposition is easy to see. Heck, current assets minus all liabilities was $3.4 billion which means that they are valuing the patents and buildings at about $1.3 billion (perhaps a bit more if you factor in this quarter's losses). It might be better for shareholders to wind the company down, and pay out the cash as dividends.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by joonix on Monday September 23, 2013 @06:59PM (#6434725)
IP and buildings are already counted in assets so I'm not sure where you are getting that from.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by mathattack on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:05PM (#6433775)
Value investors don't share the founder's shame in riding the revenues of the installed base. Many software firms find home with private equity firms that are happy to cut R&D and Marketing, and live off of services revenue. I could see Blackberry going down this path.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by sireat on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @06:39AM (#6437037)
What has not been mentioned how curious the timing of this offer has been.

BBRY just did a massive writedown basically valuing all their newest phone inventory at $0. BBRY also changed the way they record sales so it looks like they have a bigger sales drop than they really did(they still had a very bad drop).

To have all these bad news and then for Watsa make what is effectively an insider bid for a company after participating in such negative news(resigning from the BBRY board a few weeks earlier does not count), smacks of something "unethical".

Why didn't he make a $12 bid a few days earlier? It is obvious Watsa knew the bad news and could make an informed bid.

A lot of regular investors are feeling extremely hurt by this. If I had invested in BBRY at say $10 hoping for a longer term turnaround, I would be upset as well.

To a regular investor it looks like the big boys not playing fair. Not that life is fair or anything.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by Zikes on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:49PM (#6433686)
Could the anti-network effect be addressed by targeting niche markets? A renewed focus on Enterprise, for example, or a marketing strategy that paints them as a "premium" consumer choice.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by smtddr on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:13PM (#6433816)
I definitely agree with this. With all these multi-featured & difficult to secure smartphones out there, we definitely have an untapped market in enterprise-secure smartphones in the same way box.com is the enterprise-version[1] of dropbox.com.

1. Note I'm avoiding the argument about what makes dropbox less secure than box.com. I have no idea, but somehow box.com is making money. The company I work for mandated box.com over dropbox citing "security concerns". Whatever the reason/mindset exists that concludes dropbox is less secure than https://www.box.com/enterprise/ , is the same mindset that would buy "enterprise-secure" smartphone over whatever trendy iOS/Android phone is available.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by Zikes on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:25PM (#6433896)
I can't get to box.com myself to see if it's any different, but I do know that dropbox has full access to files you store on their servers. That's an automatic red flag for a lot of companies.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by madeofpalk on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:11PM (#6435699)
Many companies go for Box because you can se per-folder permissions and creates groups of users for permissions.

These sorts of things are pretty mandatory for companies of reasonable size.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by crazytony on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:47PM (#6434032)
I don't know. Most non-tech execs I know would rather chew off their arm than give up their iphone.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by jrn on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:33PM (#6433175)
They have a lot of cash, no debt. Qnx finally has a beautifull gui. Still have contracts with chrysler group. Bunch of buildings, patents, and huge upside. If they can license Nokia maps, now that Nokia HW is out of the picture, bb10 will have satisfied my last complaint.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by rescripting on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:07PM (#6433435)
http://m.here.com does a great job in the BB10 browser, but I agree that Nokia maps in a native app would be a great addition.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by jpswade on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:51PM (#6433695)
I suspect Blackberry is a dying platform, but it's IP and licenses have value.

This seems like your textbook acquire, split and sell.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by mathattack on Monday September 23, 2013 @05:46PM (#6434382)
They may also be able to ride the machine down by underinvesting in R&D and marketing.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by outside1234 on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:57PM (#6434107)
Probably through patents. Sell those to highest bidding troll, then layoff to a very small core of the remaining interesting engineers with a brain and sell those to Google or Microsoft as an aquihire.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by dirkdk on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:32PM (#6433169)
Blackberry has $2.8 billion in cash in the bank, so price is $1.9 billion. Not bad for a huge set of patents
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by jonknee on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:58PM (#6433736)
Not really, that's accounts receivable. They also have $3.4 billion in liabilities.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by kcg on Monday September 23, 2013 @06:41PM (#6434643)
No, as of June 1 the company had $2.8B of cash, cash equivalents AND short-term investments (liquid securities). There's an additional $2.5B of accounts receivable on the balance sheet.

You are correct that BBRY has $3.4B of current liabilities.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by bsullivan01 on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:13PM (#6433467)
If they can stop the bleeding, which I suppose they will if their goal is to chop shop it. They'll fire another 30% and start shopping parts of BB
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by jsz0 on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:56PM (#6434101)
First step stop making $1B worth of devices no one wants to buy.
Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by cremnob on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:28PM (#6433131)
Fairfax first invested in RIM back in 2010 and they've been adding to that position ever since. Their 10% stake was purchased at an average price of $17. He's been in the red on this investment for a while. I think this purchase is more about trying to turn the company around and try to recoup whatever they can. What JonFish85 posted is probably what's going to happen here.

> Take it private, do another, more aggressive round of layoffs and get down to a very core group. Then decide whether to chop it up and sell it off (patents alone are probably worth a good chunk of money). As far as I know, Blackberry has no debt, so that makes the math a bit easier.

Watsa is a great investor with a solid track record, but I think this has been a mistake for him.

Re:Fairfax strikes $4.7-billion deal to buy BlackBerry by rorrr2 on Monday September 23, 2013 @04:15PM (#6433827)
As long as they can squeeze more than $4.7B out of RIM, it doesn't matter if it's a dying brand (which it is).