Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by spacelizard on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:05PM
(#6395128)
Not really. GPLv3 will prevent hardware manufacturers from locking down their devices if they intend to ship Ubuntu Mobile. This is a good thing for users of those devices. I can't defend Canonical's support of proprietary drivers, especially on these devices that are known to be used for such pervasive spying, but at least a non-hardware-locked device allows for workarounds (i.e. deployment of your own free drivers).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by wmf on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:48PM
(#6395454)
GPLv3 will prevent hardware manufacturers from locking down their devices if they intend to ship Ubuntu Mobile.
Actually the opposite; Canonical will sell phone vendors a non-GPL version of Mir so that they can lock down their phones.
Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by ldng on Monday September 16, 2013 @04:23PM
(#6395646)
Hence the copyright assignment required for any contribution to Canonical's projects, to ease the double licensing.
But for now, it's only speculation. Time will tell.
Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by mhall119 on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:56AM
(#6397653)
It's not copyright assignment, it's just a broader license grant than what the GPL allows.
Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by tga_d on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:16PM
(#6395191)
I'm sorry, but must be missing something. How does a GPLv3 display server prevent locking down the hardware? Afaik, the anti-TiVoization stuff only applies to the software that's GPLv3, not the stack it's running on.
Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by dkuntz2 on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:16PM
(#6396531)
Some argue that if it makes calls to a GPL application, it's a derivative work, which means it must also be GPL.
This means that if one part of the stack is GPL, everything higher must also be GPL.
Re:Intel rejection of Ubuntu’s Mir patch forces Canonical to...
by eltondegeneres on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:54PM
(#6397141)
Can you point me towards some people arguing this? It's patently false. If it were true, every single application on your typical GNU/Linux box would also be GPL.