News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by danielharan on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:26AM (#6391800)
Wow, so a person is brought into a country a 7. At 20, she still has no legal right to be there, and if caught, can be sent back to "her" country?

That's effed up.

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by nandemo on Monday September 16, 2013 @05:16AM (#6392320)
I think part of the reason is:

(a) Parents will immigrate with their kids knowing that they won't have legal residence status. I know some immigrants are escaping dire poverty or persecution, but not all. So I think parents have some responsibility here.

(b) Plus, the US is relatively lax in enforcing immigration laws. People do (a) and get work, send their kids to school, buy a house, etc. There's no way you could get away with that in (say) Japan.

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by tehwalrus on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:26AM (#6392038)
similar things for some Britons, mostly of Jamaican origin. If they arrived as children after some date in the 80s, they're in the country "legally", but they're not citizens. They're not allowed to get a passport, and if they leave the country there's no guarantee they'll be allowed back in.

Often, they don't realise this until they're ~20, whenever they first apply for a passport - and they have to go through a lengthy process of applying for citizenship, which can take up to 5 years (or longer, what was that backlog?) and still might not be successful. Which can kind of mess up your holiday plans.

(In fairness, they can at least get a job!)

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by coldtea on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:31AM (#6392508)
How about this: 300 million people are brought (illegally) to the country at 7.

At 20, should they have a legal right to be there?

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jacquesm on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:13AM (#6392636)
> At 20, should they have a legal right to be there?

Absolutely. After all, if 13 years is not enough to locate and deport them those people have a right to a continued existence in the place where they are now completely at home and integrated. Anything else would be inhuman.

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by coldtea on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:45AM (#6393178)
So deporting them (including being real hard on them) before those 13 years is OK, but suddenly 13 years (or 12 or 10) is some kind of limit after which they can impose themselves upon a sovereign country?

Especially since the fail to deport is not because of lack of want or try, but because of evading checks etc?

I'm all for granting asylum for legitimate cases in small numbers, but "came here because my country sucks" or multi-million people migration is not good if the local population doesn't want it.

Actually, with regard to results, it's not extremely different to an invansion and can even help to prepare one later on (such tactics of getting people to mass migrate to another country/region, have been historically used to disrupt population dynamics there and let a third party to have leverage on the original local populations, e.g by China in Tibet and numerous others, even back to the Roman empire).

Some of those things might not apply when talking about small percentages of immigrants or the US (who as a great power has little to fear seriously), but are legitimate concerns for smaller nations.

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jacquesm on Monday September 16, 2013 @10:05AM (#6393289)
I personally would put that limit a lot lower, more like 2 years or however long it could reasonably take to process an asylum request if you subscribe to this concept at all (which I really don't, I'm all for completely open borders or disbanding them altogether, it's the only way citizens of various countries get to vote with their feet).
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by coldtea on Monday September 16, 2013 @12:54PM (#6394245)
>it's the only way citizens of various countries get to vote with their feet

You're not supposed to "vote with your feet". That's called "fleeing" and those who do it are "cowards". You're supposed to fight and make your country better, including bringing down an oppresive regime etc. For ages, even women and children have fought for freedom and for making the world a better place, including risking their lives. Rosa Parks, for but one example, didn't "vote with their feet".

As for "completely open borders" that either happens when all the earth is a united country (where everybody can vote for the general leadership), or is just crazy talk when there are sovereign countries that are more and less powerful.

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jacquesm on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:58PM (#6394667)
If you call someone fleeing an oppressive regime a coward then you're more than likely not currently living in one and have even more likely never lived under one. Let me give you a history lesson, on the off chance that you'll prove me wrong. When you live under an oppressive regime the sum of the power stacked against the few that would do something about it is such that they have three choices: rise up and be cut down, shut up and comply or flee. If you feel like judging any of those that either comply or flee as being either cowards or worse then you forget that ordinary people typically just want to get on with their lives without interference from the authorities. Not everybody is in a position to risk all for an improved status quo, for instance. Those that do are to be commended, those that don't are not to be despised. That's all that I can impart to you from my (short) time of voluntary stay behind what was then called the Iron Curtain, but it is a lesson that stayed with me.

As for the crazy talk, I can definitely imagine a world where there are no border controls but where countries are still sovereign to greater or lesser extent. There are vast regions in the world where we have exactly that situation right now, I don't see why it couldn't apply to the rest of it. The current leader of North Korea might agree with you that this is crazy talk, but then again, that's exactly my opinion of him.

Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jedmeyers on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:45PM (#6394557)
From your comments I assume you are of a Native American origins right?
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jedmeyers on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:42PM (#6394538)
I know people who worked legally(!) in the US for 14 years, and paid taxes for this whole time - they do not even have a Green Card yet. And you are saying that illegal immigrants should get citizenship just because they have been here for 13 years.
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jacquesm on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:53PM (#6394617)
No, I think they should be given citizenship because they exhibit all the properties of citizens. The timespan doesn't have anything to do with it just that after such a long time any idea of deportation for whatever reason is totally ridiculous. Reality should never have to adapt to the paper world, but the paper world should adapt to reality.
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jedmeyers on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:56PM (#6394639)
If you say that once someone exhibit all properties of a citizen he should become one. My question to you is: at what point does one start exhibiting all properties of a citizen and how should Government verify that he does?
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by jacquesm on Monday September 16, 2013 @02:03PM (#6394704)
That's easy: as soon as the government thinks that someone ought to be taxed.
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by mason240 on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:07AM (#6393028)
Which is the same thing that would happen in Canada or any European country.
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by Kudzu_Bob on Monday September 16, 2013 @08:38AM (#6392932)
If a person is raised since age seven in a house his parents bought with money that they embezzled, and then at age thirty he inherits the house from them, must he give it up once the source of the family's ill-gotten gains is discovered by the authorities?
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by lmm on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:59AM (#6393249)
No? Are you saying that legally he would have to?
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by Kudzu_Bob on Monday September 16, 2013 @02:18PM (#6394804)
If I rob your girlfriend of a nice ring she's wearing so that I can give it to my girlfriend, does my girlfriend legally get to keep the ring once the crime becomes known, just because the theft took place years ago?
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by lmm on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:50PM (#6395462)
If we didn't file charges within thirty years, yes, IIRC.
Re:Immigrants lacking papers work legally – as their own bosses by Kudzu_Bob on Monday September 16, 2013 @04:07PM (#6395556)
The amount of time being discussed here is well under thirty years. In any event, property stolen during the Second World War is still being returned forcibly to its original owners.