Re:Two envelopes problem
by olalonde on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:16PM
(#6387454)
There is additional information in the Monty Hall problem: the host never opens the door with a car. In the two envelope's problem, the "host" merely restates the question no matter which envelope was chosen.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Folks, it's an analogy. An analogy compares two different things... trust me, I know they're different and I know in which ways.
All I was saying is common sense doesn't get you far in the Monty Hall problem. It really doesn't:
>[Vos Savant] received thousands of letters from her readers; 92% of the general public, 65% of universities, and many with PhDs, were against her answer.
Thus, it's kind of silly to say we're wasting time by going past a common sense analysis of something. It's also revisionist to say common sense does help you solve Monty Hall.
Sorry for misunderstanding you. I guess I lacked a bit of common sense...
Re:Two envelopes problem
by thatthatis on Sunday September 15, 2013 @12:19AM
(#6388099)
The montey hall problem can be restated in a way that makes it amenable to common sense. Door A or (Door B and Door C).
Or, restate the problem with 100 doors.
I'm not sure every problem like this one can be reduced to a common sense analog, but I'm suspect of problems that can't be.