News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:23PM (#6386942)
>How were you supposed to know?

Not to get all philosophical over a story on poo coffee, but this is one of the downsides to free markets. They hide information on the conditions of production unless compelled to by regulation or consumer demand, neither of which typically happen without an awareness campaign (such as this exposé). All you see is marketing and a price.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by frogpelt on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:41PM (#6387942)
And not to reciprocate, but free markets are much more likely to be transparent than any other.

When a free market realizes consumers demand transparency, transparency becomes an option in the market. Not the only option, but one of the many.

How would that transparency work in a market that is absolutely controlled by regulation and government? Fine, until that government itself ceased to be transparent.

ASIDE: There are no absolutely controlled markets or absolutely free markets and never will be. Capitalism will always seep out around the edges and regulation will always be necessary.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Sunday September 15, 2013 @02:07AM (#6388245)
> free markets are much more likely to be transparent than any other.

That's wishful thinking contradicted by oodles of historical experience. Random example: the unregulated market for medicine in the U.S. prior to the 20th century.

The problem is consumers are not organized by default. Markets typically reflect individual preferences just fine, but individuals don't have the resources to fact-check propaganda, research and verify conditions of production, etc. This aspect of "consumer demand" requires collective organization to express effectively.

A buying group is one example. But these things take investments of their own to start up, which is why you mostly find them among business customers. One of the reasons the corporate group health insurance market is so much better than the individual one.

For the everyman, the government is a mechanism by which they can express collective demand. And it's why food and medicine safety, to pick one fundamental, has never been effectively secured for the general public absent government regulation.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dnautics on Sunday September 15, 2013 @04:45AM (#6388508)
you don't suppose the danger of the market for medicine in the US prior to the 20th century had anything to do with the fact that chemistry didn't exist as a discipline? Just what do you expect them to have regulated?

The free market is quite good at providing consumers information, but often only if the consumers demand it. For a few decades now, consumers have gradually become more ethical in their consumption choices, and the markets are reflecting that. It's a long road and there are certainly many, many places where things can be improved. By contrast, consider that there is a lot of demand for certain values, like transparency, honesty, not sexually harassing your underlings, in government, and exactly how responsive do you suppose it's been?

The faulty assumption is that government will somehow be 'the betters' of the general public. But every indication of the narcissistic type that gets elected, and the petty bureaucratic authoritarian that is unelected, suggests that those advancement in government may not necessarily select for those traits you want. Neither does capitalism (as it's structured today), but at least consumers have a direct option to opt-out of unethical things done with their money, which they do not for government.

To pick another "fundamental", why do you suppose lightbulbs don't explode, and various and sundry electrical equipment doesn't electrocute you in the US? It's because regulation is being done by a private, nonprofit entity (the underwriter's laboratories) which goes through and certifies equipment for consumption. A good example of the free market working quite well to ensure safety, beyond even what the consumer might expect, with far less government interference.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Sunday September 15, 2013 @06:00AM (#6388602)
> For a few decades now, consumers have gradually become more ethical in their consumption choices

Look at the history behind that. It came out of the 60s. Massive popular organization against the system. A gigantic non-market force that effected greater awareness of environmental destruction, the conditions of production and so forth.

Consumers didn't just wake up one day with new preferences. They rioted against the market system.

P.S. You forgot about OSHA federal electrical safety regulations.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dnautics on Sunday September 15, 2013 @12:54PM (#6389554)
OSHA is only for the workplace and dates to 1970. UL goes back to the turn of the previous century. I don't know for sure, but I'd bet most electrical standards for OSHA defer to the UL standard.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Sunday September 15, 2013 @01:56PM (#6389702)
OSHA just federalized it. Electrical safety has been regulated at the state and local level since practically the dawn of electricity.

Even the trade organization of electrical manufacturers disagrees with you. Quoting the National Electric Code, "the NEC takes on real significance when it is adopted into law by states and local jurisdictions."

Source: http://www.nema.org/Technical/FieldReps/Pages/National-Elect...

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dinkumthinkum on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:57PM (#6387973)
You're conflating things. You can have ab200% regulated market with total transparency either by regulators or the participating companies ...

I mean actual the implication that you get a transparent market from a free market because of "consumer demands" is sort of laughable when you consider that the free market on planet Earth does not contain perfect agents.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by Zuider on Sunday September 15, 2013 @03:16PM (#6389961)
>...when you consider that the free market on planet Earth does not contain perfect agents.

But the same imperfect agents, human beings, also constitute governments and bureaucracies. Markets are not a perfect institution, and it is very easy to point out flaws, but they have an observed tendency towards improvement, self ordering, and discovery of better resources that is lacking from government. Flaws in the market tend towards being corrected while flaws in government tend to become entrenched, obfuscated, and aggressively defended against any attempt to reveal and correct them.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by coldtea on Sunday September 15, 2013 @06:40PM (#6390606)
>And not to reciprocate, but free markets are much more likely to be transparent than any other. When a free market realizes consumers demand transparency, transparency becomes an option in the market. Not the only option, but one of the many.

One that rarely, if ever, happens. Because, for one customers are powerless against a whole industry, second the industry can lobby to buy regulations and fix the conditions so it won't have to be transparent and third the people are told and manipulated by the very corporations (and the media they control either directly or through advertising money) to not ask for transparency. Plus, the industry can sell "fake transparency" and none will be the wiser.

That kind of reaction for transparency can only work for a small time, against some niche or singled-out company -- and that's only until the media moves on, the public forgets, and the company makes some vague promises and alters arragements enough to confuse people that it made "changes". Like Nike sweatshops, Foxconn, etc.

The markets most likely to be transparent are those that are heavily regulated, with a vigilant population and where profit is not respected as the number one motivation behind business.

And those are not those commonly touted as "free markets", but markets in places like New Zealand, Sweden, etc.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by nikatwork on Sunday September 15, 2013 @08:55PM (#6390985)
I think the common ground in these "govt regulations" versus "free market" arguments is that both sides want to see transparency, encourage consumer choice and avoid monopolies; it's the means that's disagreed upon.

> second the industry can lobby to buy regulations and fix the conditions so it won't have to be transparent

This seems to be most of a problem in the US, where money has such a direct influence on government. This doesn't mean that all govt is bad; it means that corrupt govt is bad.

To use your New Zealand example, they have arguably the most advanced and representative democratic system in existence. I think this helps limit antisocial corporate pressure (aka corruption) on their government regulations.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by iacvlvs on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:02PM (#6387063)
There is no true free market in the world. One of the defining characteristics of a free market is perfect information. This is one of the downsides of market imperfections.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:30PM (#6387134)
Ergo, it is a downside of all unregulated markets.

I would avoid the term "imperfection" for something that is fundamental to markets. The information on conditions of production usually has to come from the seller and there is usually little incentive for them to provide it unless compelled to.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by iacvlvs on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:47PM (#6387366)
It is fundamental to all markets in the real world. It is also a defining trait of the platonic ideal of a free market, and one of the reasons why the platonic ideal absolute free market is unrealisable. Markets can be more or less free, but never entirely so. Regulation by non-market forces is one way that markets are made less free. Such regulation is often intended to counteract or offset other things that make the market in question less free.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by icebraining on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:07PM (#6387248)
Ergo, it is a downside of all unregulated markets.

Unregulated? Do regulated markets have perfect information?

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:39PM (#6387343)
Didn't say that. Poor information on the conditions and effects of production is fundamental to unregulated markets. Much like externalities, they are not mere "imperfections" or footnotes which is usually how they are presented in pro-free-market Econ 101 texts. They are fundamental; e.g. much of the environmental threat the planet faces can be contributed to externalities and poor info. Nevermind the poor animal-poop slaves.

Regulations and activism (such as this type of journalism) are some of the non-market forces that can compensate.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by hrjet on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:43PM (#6387946)
But regulations may lead to bribery and other workarounds.

Activism may be biased. It may also lead to long-winded debates, and ultimately, to polluted information. (Eg, global warming, GM crops, etc).

Ultimately, it doesn't matter if there is regulation or not, activism or not; there is no perfect information.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by malkia on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:21PM (#6388011)
You have most regulations around kid's toys, and I'm thankful for that!
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jes on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:45PM (#6387180)
Why do you think that a free market requires perfect information? Do you think the situation is the same for a democracy? Does it also require perfect information?

http://wichitaliberty.org/free-markets/myth-markets-depend-o...

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Saturday September 14, 2013 @09:13PM (#6387787)
The linked commentary argues for the abolition of medical licensing. I could probably rest my case right there.

We actually had a lengthy experiment with that earlier in America, pre-regulation. It's where the term "snake oil salesman" originated. The establishment of medical licensing led to a dramatic improvement in public health.

If there's one characteristic of deregulation advocates that you can count on, it's that they have a complete disregard for history.

As for democracy, many attempts have been utterly subverted by voter fraud -- e.g. myriad dictators that win >90% of the "vote" in their countries. It is only through strict regulation that we've come to trust the accuracy of our polls to the degree that we have in the U.S. Having said that, what passes for democracy here is still utterly dominated by money, in that the best-funded candidate usually wins. Again, regulation of money in politics would be one way to improve on that defect.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by gordonguthrie on Sunday September 15, 2013 @05:37AM (#6388565)
Elections in the US are very poorly regulated - political appointees are Election Officers, gerrymandering of political districts is wholesales and your election turnouts are very low by international standards. The best funded candidate wins because your political parties are very weak. One of the core reasons behind this is that in 1948 you nationalised your political parties. In no other country in the world is the internal 'elections' of a political party - the way you select your candidates/primaries - run by the state. In only 8 of the states (I think!) are candidates selected by members of the parties only. Membership has no meaning - which means parties have no meaning - no collective existence. This lets private money rule the day in all your parties. When I was selected as an SNP parliamentary candidate in Scotland I was forbidden to spend ANY MONEY on my selection campaign. Only paid members of the party can select a candidate - and the only way to get selected is to be known the members personally and to do the work.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by abalone on Sunday September 15, 2013 @06:11AM (#6388619)
I'm all for regulating money out of politics. But point of clarification (since we're being all parliamentary).. I was comparing the U.S. to countries with even weaker election controls.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jes on Sunday September 15, 2013 @12:00PM (#6389426)
Before resting your case regarding the licensing of individuals to practice medicine, would you please comment on whether individuals who write software used in medical devices should also be licensed?
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by ZeroGravitas on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:47PM (#6387365)
Your response and the URL of your link refer to free markets, and they by definition require perfect information. The info at your link talks about something else.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by makomk on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:52PM (#6387578)
In particular, perfect information is required in order for the free market to allocate resources efficiently; if obtaining information has a cost, there are all sorts of fun ways to abuse that in order to break competition and misallocate resources. You can see this in the US cellphone industry - by increasing the complexity of their plans, cellphone providers have made it more expensive to comparison shop, meaning that customers (rationally) go with the first option rather than the lowest-cost one.

You can also see this with some of the smaller-scale Ponzis and investment scams - so long as the amount of money each investor has invested is much smaller than the amount it'd cost to investigate the investment, it's not rational for them to do so. One of the recent US Ponzis, Perma-Pave, actually failed because they got greedy and took on a large investor with reason to investigate what had happened to their money.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jes on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:48PM (#6387567)
In this definition from Wikipedia, in the section on Microeconomics, it is claimed that perfect information is a physical impossibility.

Can you help me understand why free markets "by definition" require that which cannot exist?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_information

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by makomk on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:55PM (#6387592)
Oh, that's easy - free markets are an ideal that can't actually exist in the real world, in part because perfect information is impossible.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by contingencies on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:05PM (#6387884)
Much like democracy.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dragonwriter on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:13PM (#6388002)
> Can you help me understand why free markets "by definition" require that which cannot exist?

Because, like "perfect information", "free markets" are an abstract conceptual ideal.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by tikhonj on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:11PM (#6388000)
The same reason integrals require continuous functions, which also can't meaningfully exist: it's a mathematical model. Just because it can't possibly exist in the real world does not mean it's useless or even "wrong" per se.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dinkumthinkum on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:28PM (#6388025)
By George I think he's got it!
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dinkumthinkum on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:06PM (#6387989)
The link you posted is on shaky ground and is quite unrigorous. The whole "democracy" example is poorly thought out. and then oddly enough we have a "regulated" democracy in the form of representatives and checks and balances ... to just add insult to injury to your argument.

... and medical licensing ... really?

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by Zuider on Sunday September 15, 2013 @03:32PM (#6390023)
>One of the defining characteristics of a free market is perfect information.

'Perfect information' is an unrealistic assumption used in neoclassical models which treat knowledge as just another input, on a par with raw ore, pork bellies or gasoline. In the real world it just doesn't work like that.

The defining characteristic of the free market is that it is a creative process of discovery. It creates knowledge where none existed before. There can be no such thing in principle as 'perfect information'. Information tends to exist in the state of being inherently dispersed among the actors, often tacit to the point of being inexpressible. The market facilitates the use of such knowledge, and the the discovery of new knowledge.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by justinmk on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:25PM (#6387483)
> this is one of the downsides to free markets. They hide information on the conditions of production

This is such a meaningless mantra. The election process--which is supposed to "fix" the free market--also hides information, except there are many fewer opportunities for correction. A vote happens once every N years, whereas market corrections are (relatively) continuous.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by mistercow on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:54PM (#6387754)
If one potential solution to free market problems doesn't work, that doesn't mean that the problems don't exist, aren't free market problems, or don't matter.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by justinmk on Monday September 16, 2013 @04:56AM (#6392268)
I'm eager to hear an alternative to market forces that doesn't involve elections.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by snowwrestler on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:59PM (#6388076)
I don't think a regulation forced Tony Wild to post this story, or for it to be voted to the top spot on HN.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jgg on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:47PM (#6387736)
The alternative is a regulated market, where I trust a government entity, full of humans who are vulnerable to the same forces of corruption, incompetence and greed, to give me accurate information and not be bought and paid for by private entities and thus used by private entities to give them even more influence and power.

Also, in what context are we dealing with a free market here and how is it relevant?

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dinkumthinkum on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:09PM (#6387995)
And yet even with flaws, there is evidence to suggest regulations by those funny "humans" have made products significantly safer.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jgg on Sunday September 15, 2013 @12:32AM (#6388116)
I agree, barring the unnecessary adjectives.

My point was that all 'systems' are corrupted by humans, not just a free market. I was criticizing an absolutist, irrelevant statement about the nature of the "free market" on the story, and mostly, asking the person how it was relevant at all, since nothing we have today remotely resembles a free market.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by zizee on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:20AM (#6392025)
A market in which the consumer cannot get access to all information about the market is not a free market at all.

Information availability is a key part of the definition of a free market.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by radarsat1 on Monday September 16, 2013 @04:18AM (#6392164)
Not sure. How does this interact with the ideas of Trade Secrets and the patent system? The latter is to encourage dissemination of the former in exchange for temporary monopoly.

One would usually argue that the ability to keep trade secrets is the more "free" market, yet we have decided that there are long-term societal benefits to dissemination so we provide government protection of ideas. Since Libertarians would say that this protection represents some form of government intervention, I would say that the idea of secrets is fairly fundamental to the idealists' free market.

Of course, whether or not patents are a good idea is debatable, but that's another question. My point is that I don't agree that transparency is a fundamental aspect of the free market, I haven't heard that argument before and don't see how the free market even encourages it. Sure, people might request a certain amount of transparency, but no more transparency will be provided than that which is demanded by consumers -- and we have seen quite frequently that consumers are quite willing to be kept in the dark to a certain extent.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by zizee on Monday September 16, 2013 @05:19AM (#6392325)
I'm not trying to debate the merits of trade secrets and the patent system. I was simply making the point that if you have a market where consumers don't have access to perfect information, it is not a free market.

The term "Free Market" has a very specific definition. Information accessibility is a very important part of that definition.

It is very difficult for all the criteria to be met, so you will never find a perfectly free market outside textbooks.

People talk about "free markets" all the time, especially business lobbyists/PR. Usually they use the term "free market" to mean the government should get the hell out of their way, but they often don't really want a free market (especially if they are the incumbents).

They have effectively co-opted the term to help their narratives, confusing people in the process.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by contextual on Sunday September 15, 2013 @08:08AM (#6388819)
I think that's why animal testing is such a huge industry, killing 19.5 million animals in the US alone every year[1]. It's even claiming the lives of house pets[2]. We don't see all the animal suffering that goes on to make consumer products. It's kept hidden from view.

[1] http://www.statisticbrain.com/animal-testing-statistics/ [2] http://www.stolenpets.com/about.htm