News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by jnardiello on Monday September 09, 2013 @06:51AM (#6352655)
Frankly, TitStare was quite funny. In despite of being tits-related, i can't see how a woman could find it offensive (maybe because she has tits too? i can't see the correlation).

It's more about lonely developers staring at tits.

It's funny to see how the tech industry is passing thru its "feminist" age and just can't understand that THERE ARE differences between men and women, which doesn't mean anyhow that one is better than the other. They are just different. Liking tits is completely normal for a man, joking on it is too. Sexism is something different, a much bigger and subtle problem, against which (too often) women themselves do not react.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:38AM (#6352833)
Let me preface this by saying that I'm frustrated on a regular basis by the claim that everything is sexist, because labeling someone who isn't with that word can be just as harmful. Especially in the tech industry and gaming and geekery. Even more, I'm put off by the almost constant misuse of the word "misogyny". It is never used for what the word really means. It just sounds good, so people throw it around.

However, as thick headed and unapologetically thick-skinned I assert myself to be and expect others to be, I can absolutely see why women would have a problem with this in this particular environment.

Let me present a really shoddy analogy (but it's all I've got at the moment):

I am obese. I attend a tech conference full of professionals in my industry. Friends, colleagues, potential connections, people I admire. Someone then comes on stage and does a presentation about fat people. It's an app that focuses on how fat people are. For humor. And they attempt to make a lot of humor about it. And the audience around me is laughing.

Now, I'm super fat. I'm more than aware of that. I know that people around me are, too. I have a good sense of humor. I'm even happy to make myself the ass-end of a joke about my weight. However, when I am in a huge room full of people laughing at a presentation making light of people like me, I suddenly feel incredibly awkward, self-aware, embarrassed, and like I'm not wanted there. Maybe that I don't even belong there. So, I stop going. I stop supporting. I stop participating.

It's all about context and having a little tact. These guys used pretty poor judgement. I don't think they should be strung up or driven out of town for it. They should just be an example of how people with no ill-intentions can end up making other people really uncomfortable and how that is something you need to be sensitive to when acting in any professionally related capacity.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by lifebeyondfife on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:06AM (#6352709)
You need to learn that what is considered (possibly socially) acceptable behaviour amongst your friends, is not necessarily acceptable in the workplace.

If you want a definition of the workplace, it includes hacker meetups, youtube videos, presentations etc. where people of all social groups come together to discuss or create code. I have a very twisted sense of humour that many would find offensive. At work though I keep that side of myself under wraps, not out of a sense of fear but of respect.

The bottom line is this: by collectively changing our behaviour to be less offensive (from the point of view of gender, sexuality, race, religion etc.) then people from those groups feel more safe and secure in that environment. If women truly felt comfortable to enter into the currently male dominated tech industry we get a bigger talent pool to choose from - the competition and skillset increases. Now re-read that sentence substituting 'women' and 'male dominated' with any minority/majority pairing and we start to see how much bigger we can make the number of available programmers.

It may seem dull to have a workplace that's so sterile and inoffensively humourless, but it's work, not a bar.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by marvin on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:38AM (#6353041)
You've made a good utilitarian argument for why the biased gender views in tech should be abolished. I think this will convince some people. But it's worth mentioning that making other people comfortable around you is something that is worth it on its own merits.

Refusing to bother with making other people comfortable unless there is a benefit, which some hacker types tend to do, is really a sociopathic personality trait.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:41AM (#6352855)
In short, there is nothing wrong with the comedy of, say, Chris Rock, but it would probably not be a good fit for a professional working environment. Even if outside of that working environment every single person there would be laughing along with his vulgar set.

What these guys did can be both a poor choice and not wrong.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by brodo on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:37AM (#6352831)
I don't want to spend 8 hours a day in a sterile humorless environment where everyone is scared to say something wrong on the off chance that someone might get offended. Moreover the old work/free time duality is dying. People work form home and do non-work stuff at work.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by lifebeyondfife on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:03AM (#6352928)
I totally understand this (and jnardiello and pstack's points too). As a counterpoint, I also know of at least one female dev who would think nothing of discussing an app like the one above and joining in the laughs.

I suppose the problem is, do we need to vet everyone for sharing the same humour and standards of acceptability as us? If we're joining the same football team or going to a comedy club and some beers, I wouldn't particularly enjoy hanging out with someone as dull/safe as I am at work. But is it ok to say to a woman, "We'd love to welcome you onboard so long as you don't mind the dick jokes constantly flying around the office."? (Whether explicitly or implicitly, I don't think it is ok).

If we really want to solve the clique-problem in tech, we need to either change the boundaries of acceptable humour and behaviour. No-one wants to spend 8 hours a day in a "sterile humorless environment". I know I had the most fun coding in my early 20s in an office where 90% of us were just out of university and male.

There are going to be more tradeoffs towards inclusiveness as we go forward. Even it reduces the fun sometimes, I think it's the right thing to do.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by jnardiello on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:11AM (#6352730)
And i do totally agree with you on this. Both presentations were pointless, stupid, superficial and idiotic.

Still, the point here is not about sexism, but about (as you mentioned) idiots being on stage presenting something they had to keep for themselves or for their local meetups.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:12AM (#6352734)
It is about sexism.

Tell me that this is not sexist?

https://mobile.twitter.com/HateYouCards/status/3767351904348...

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:50AM (#6352875)
Sexism is the assertion that one sex is inferior to the other, usually because of or alongside assertion of stereotypes of that gender.

Misogyny is the hatred of women.

Neither word really has anything to do with being attracted to the sexuality of the other gender. Neither word really has anything to do with simply being unkind, mean, or insensitive. Unfortunately, we often seem to throw these labels on people (labels which stick and aren't too dissimilar from calling someone a racist or homophobe) when they're not really relevant. Having a poster of a sexualized woman or buying videogames with attractive women on the poster or laughing at a joke about the other gender or saying a particular person of the other gender is an idiot are -- while unkind and inconsiderate -- not generally matters of discrimination, superiority, or "hate".

Frankly, I feel we do a disservice to the value of these words in describing actual sexism and actual (but rare) misogyny by throwing them at everything under the sun that makes someone a little uncomfortable or is anything short of respectful. Of course, even suggesting that we should be more careful of our use of these words, I am now probably both of them.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:10AM (#6352950)
You do not have a fully defined view of sexism there. One other part of sexism is sexual objectification, which reduces the person or whole gender to an instrument of sexual pleasure, without any view of the person's dignity or humanity.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:27AM (#6353272)
I just don't share the black-and-white view of the world that you may.

Objectification can be a component of sexism, but in and of itself is not sexist. It is a natural part of human existence demonstrated by both genders on a regular basis in a variety of ways. It is even the entire foundation of initial human attraction. It is not inherently wrong.

Men and women dance at strip clubs. They objectify the customers and the customers objectify the strippers. Hell, my butcher is an object that gives me steak for money and that is all we know of each other. That's okay. You are not obligated to regard everyone as a whole all the time.

We need to stop asserting that every interaction with each person (real or fictional, in person or entertainment) requires a holistic appreciation of every atom of their humanity.

If you objectify all human beings, you share a common trait of sociopaths. If the entirety of your view and interaction with the other gender is based on objectification, then you are probably sexist and have serious issues to deal with. If neither of these are the case, then you are probably a normal human being.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:57AM (#6353113)
Nobody was reduced to that though.

What fun would a pair of tits floating in the air be? I'd rather stare at tits that are attached to a whole woman.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:10AM (#6353192)
I have no idea what you are talking about.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:19AM (#6353236)
You said "One other part of sexism is sexual objectification, which reduces the person or whole gender to an instrument of sexual pleasure."

And I said that nobody was reduced to being just a sexual object.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:59AM (#6353459)
The screen literally just had tits. The whole point of the app was to look at tits. There was nothing else of a woman involved. They really did just take the "tits" part and exclude the rest!
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:04AM (#6353484)
Yeah, great argument. So if you hear a drum, you have no concept of a drummer?

No, you're right - men who see just a pair of tits think "that's all I need - nothing attached, just the tits pleaze, tyvm."

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:09AM (#6353513)
I'm not talking about every guy on the planet. But I think it's very clear that whoever made this app thought, "Know what? We should make an app that just has tits. Nothing else, just tits."

More to the point: the women are being used in a way that is completely determined by the user of the app, instead of being given any kind of consideration as people.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @12:56PM (#6354567)
Tits are part of people. I have tits. People have tits and I like people and I like their tits. Without people, there are no tits. How many different ways can I say this? I don't like tits that are disconnected from people. That's disgusting.

If I am staring at a woman's tits - I am certainly giving her whole person my consideration, even though my eyes can only look at one thing at a time. WTF would I do with just a pair of tits?

No, the reason I'm looking is that I probably want more.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @01:06PM (#6354635)
I am certainly giving her whole person my consideration

This app removes the women's ability to participate in the exchange at all. They have no control and are presented in a way that is completely in control of the user. When you remove her ability to decide how her body is being used, you are not considering her as a whole person. It's not about tits.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by verroq on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:20AM (#6352761)
Is it sexist to like tits?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:24AM (#6352781)
Having a sexuality is not sexist. Sexualising the workplace usually is, as it makes it unfriendly to others.

I appreciate that porn (hard, soft or just this smut) is a business too, but is that the business that techcrunch is in?

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:58AM (#6353116)
Entertainment is part of tech and tits as well as tit jokes are damn entertaining.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:05AM (#6353155)
> tits as well as tit jokes are damn entertaining.

For some only. That's the point.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:20AM (#6353239)
Guess what? Women find tit jokes funny too so don't even try and say that you know what the whole group of Women is thinking...

Fuck cencorship. The freedom to offend is more important.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:42AM (#6353357)
Nowhere did I say that I "know what the whole group of Women is thinking". It's a bit ironic that you precede that with "Women find tit jokes funny" which could be interpreted as you saying that you in fact do know.

But I do know for a fact that some women, in fact some people do not find them funny. Which is what I did say.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:44AM (#6353375)
So then what's your point?

Don't joke about anything that anybody could possibly get offended at?

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:51AM (#6353415)
That would be ideal, yes. But you could start with avoiding predictable offence to large percentage of people.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:56AM (#6353438)
Please prove to me that the majority of women or even a large portion are offended. Nobody has done that yet.

Furthermore, even if you could prove that - percentage has nothing to do with it. That is a completely arbitrary qualifier. Offending people is a birth given right. Get over it.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:59AM (#6353461)
Now you're just trolling. Given the response that occurred in the media and in general, I suggest that you prove the opposite.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:10AM (#6353519)
> Now you're just trolling.

What the fuck does that even mean?

> Given the response that occurred in the media and in general...

The media is your measuring stick? The same media that regularly objectifies women in your opinion? That's rich. You should probably go think about that some more.

You and all the whiners just like you are the ones complaining about tit jokes, so you prove it.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:17AM (#6353551)
> The same media that regularly objectifies women in your opinion?

In my opinion? Citation needed.

> You and all the whiners just like you

Sweeping generalisation.

So to be clear, you're saying that there's no fuss being made, and also it's being made by "whiners"?

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:26AM (#6353612)
Does "the media" regularly objectify women or not in your opinion or not?

Why not just tell me the truth instead of asking me to cite you on your own opinion?

(I just can't imagine that you think "the media" is any better than this titstare app. Have you watched TV before?)

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:32AM (#6353645)
Seeing as I never gave any opinion on the question of "Does "the media" regularly objectify women or not", it's irrelevant, despite you erroneously attributing that to me. It's a derailing tactic.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:37AM (#6353687)
I responded to your assertion that:

> Given the response that occurred in the media and in general...

So no, it's not a derailing tactic. And if you didn't notice, this thread is three pages to the right. There's nothing to derail.

When you're having a conversation in person, do you accuse them of being a Troll and derailing the conversation when they respond to your ridiculous assertions?

Give me a fucking break. This is like arguing with a three year old. OK fine, you can have the last word if it's so important to you. I've already torn apart every single point you think you've made, so fuck off.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:41AM (#6353720)
If someone repeatedly said things in person like "Give me a fucking break" and "fuck off" and being generally disrespectful, while asserting that "I've already torn apart every single point you think you've made" and regularly misreading what's being said and failing to address the substantial point then yes, I would call them immature.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:48AM (#6353759)
Respect is earned, not given.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @11:38AM (#6354081)
People on HN generally start off with a reasonable amount of respect from me - more so than Reddit or 4chan for instance. I've never seen anyone piss it away so rapidly before though.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:47PM (#6357554)
Not to mention, there were a lot of arguments he made about not being concerned about being offended, then he got offended and started getting abusive. Ironic.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:30AM (#6352808)
No. I like them quite a bit. But it is sexist to make an app to encourage men to ogle random women's breasts and submit photos while doing so, to an audience of men and women.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:51AM (#6352879)
No it isn't.

Presenting it was not an act of discrimination or hate. It was inconsiderate and possibly both crude and dumb.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:59AM (#6352911)
If its not sexist, then can you explain why it is inconsiderate?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:26AM (#6353265)
I understand that you're attempting to imply that showing consideration demonstrates an admittance of guilt. I'm afraid that's not a compelling argument.

It's inconsiderate, because it could potentially make some members of the audience uncomfortable or self-aware. This would not be a concern if you knew the comportment of your audience. Snoop Dogg doesn't present himself or his content the same way on David Letterman that he does at a concert.

Someone being uncomfortable with your content doesn't invalidate it nor does your taking their discomfort into consideration in either content or presentation.

It shows that you are a mature human being with empathy.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:33PM (#6357484)
Why did it make the audience members feel uncomfortable?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:32AM (#6353295)
It's inconsiderate because they got all the men thinking about tits at a mostly tit-less conference.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:06AM (#6353165)
It's not sexist to make an app to encourage men to ogle random women's breasts and submit photos while doing so, to an audience of men and women.

Men are doing it anyway and there's nothing wrong with that either.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:12AM (#6353208)
> It's not sexist to make an app to encourage men to ogle random women's breasts and submit photos while doing so, to an audience of men and women.

I think you will have to accept that many people hold a exactly opposite opinion on that point.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:17AM (#6353227)
Did I indicate anywhere that some people don't have the opposite, poorly formed opinion? I don't give a shit. If they try censorship, I say offend them even more until THEY accept that not everyone agrees with them.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:45AM (#6353383)
> Did I indicate anywhere that some people don't have the opposite, poorly formed opinion?

I think that we can agree that there are poorly formed opinions on display here.

> I say offend them even more until THEY accept that not everyone agrees with them.

Someone's throwing their toys around today.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:50AM (#6353401)
But can you agree that these people complaining about tit jokes are not accepting many other people's opinion that tit jokes are funny and that people should be free to joke about them if they wish?

> Someone's throwing their toys around today?

How so? By pointing out your illogical stance?

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:54AM (#6353426)
> But can you agree that these people complaining about tit jokes are not accepting many other people's opinion that tit jokes are funny and that people should be free to joke about them if they wish?

Hell no. This is standard derailing junk. It goes "my freedom to be an arsehole and drive people away is just as important as other people's desire to work in an arsehole-free environment." It's childish and inconsiderate.

> How so?

I leave it to you to work out what the petulant part of "I say offend them even more" is.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:01AM (#6353471)
> It's childish and inconsiderate.

That's your fucking opinion though.

> I leave it to you to work out..blah blah blah.

Oh gawd. What a fucking cop-out. Stop replying to me you chicken shit.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:14AM (#6353541)
I am capable of disagreeing without resorting to abusive and threatening behaviour. While trying to understand what the other person is saying. Skills that you could learn.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @06:54AM (#6352662)
Rubbish. It was about objectifying women. It had nothing to do with lonely developers. These were two boofhead Australians who sadly exist in my part of the world who used women's bodies as a joke so they could get a quick laugh.

There are too many "men" like this in Sydney. I use the word "men" loosely.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by fractalsea on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:15AM (#6352740)
And to me this sounds as racist as any casual sexism I hear in the workplace. Why did you need to re-iterate -- in a negative manner -- that they were Australians, and that this somehow explains their behaviour?

OK -- I wrote that before realising that you are also living in Australia (and I assume a male citizen), but I'm still not sure that makes it any better...

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:37AM (#6352828)
I didn't say all Australians are boofheads. I said some Australians are boofheads. And I never said it explains or condones their behaviour that they are Australians. Doesn't help stereotypes!

Yes, I am an Australian male :-)

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by jnardiello on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:03AM (#6352703)
Let me understand, anything sex-related which isn't expressed in scientific or moral terms has to burn in hell, right? Mainly because it is "objectifying" and insulting.

Sometimes having a good laugh is a lot smarter than creating a political situation out of nothing. I think this is the case.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:07AM (#6352711)
"Titstare" was designed to allow men stare at women's breasts. In other words, for one reason only: objectification of women and their body parts.

If you can't see that here, I'm not sure what else to say to you!

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by wsc981 on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:33AM (#6352814)
If there was a hypothetical "dickstare" app for woman (to objectify men and their body parts) I wouldn't make a big deal of it.

Seems to me a lot of woman do objectify men. For example when I'm browsing the Dutch Viva forums, there are plenty of topics on so called "fuck buddies". Male friends that are not relationship material but good enough for sex.

Some topics from the last few weeks are:

* Traineeship Suriname[1]: a topic about a Dutch girl that is going for a traineeship in Suriname and she has a certain fetish for black people and is mainly interested in having sex with said people.

* Do you have a fuck buddy[2]: an inquiry of which readers from the forums have a fuck buddy.

Another example could be some Coca-Cola commercials [3][4]. Do we feel (as men) offended by how these commercials objectify our gender?

[1]: http://forum.viva.nl/forum/Seks/Stage_Suriname/list_messages...

[2]: http://forum.viva.nl/forum/Seks/Fuckbuddy/list_messages/2030...

[3]: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l7AqpFcgTqQ

[4]: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6Sre-wpGHE

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:53AM (#6352888)
But this is not a talk at a conference, and it is also not supposed to be a joke. It's not comparable at all.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:55AM (#6352897)
Both genders objectify each other on a regular basis. There isn't even anything wrong with that (unless objectifying each other is the whole of your entire concept and interaction with the other gender).

The issue here is pretty clear cut. It wasn't appropriate for the setting in which it was presented. Nothing more. A stupid app, Cosmo magazine, pinup posters, physical attraction, and so on aren't really relevant and don't need to be inherently demonized.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:12AM (#6352959)
Yeah, there is something wrong with objectification. When you reduce someone to an impersonal object, with no regard to their dignity or personality, you dehumanise them. You can essentially do what you will with them.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:34AM (#6353311)
Guess what? People I don't know in a porn video performing sexual acts as their profession in order to sexually arouse people watching them are "impersonal objects". So are male and female models who exist as clothing-racks or make-up canvases. Musicians and actors exist to entertain and their dignity and personality are not relevant. My garbageman is a guy who exists to make my cans of trash go away.

Even you, as highly as you must regard every human interaction in your every moment of existence, surely deal with a great number of people on a regular basis who exist simply to perform a function that you benefit from.

As for "you can essentially do what you will with them"... I think that speaks more to you than anyone who enjoys porn, strippers, pinup posters, musicians, dancers, actors, or anyone else that they have no personal regard for. That statement is kind of like a religious person finding out that I'm an atheist and incredulously responding with "if you don't believe in god, how come you're not out raping and murdering people?!".

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:03PM (#6357620)
Sadly for me, I struggle with sexual objectification of women. If there was one aspect of my life I wish I cold change instantly, that would be it. I work on it daily.

However, when I deal with a garbageman, I treat him with respect because I know he's a human being doing his work. I don't see him as just a garbageman, though I interact with him with that primary purpose. But I can honestly never say I've ever considered my garbageman as only "someone who makes my garbage go away". This would allow me to be an arsehole to him while he is doing his job.

Lets say you see the garbageman fall over and break his leg. I'll bet you'd call an ambulance. Congratulations if this is the case, he is no longer just someone who takes away your garbage - you have not objectified him.

I never interact with clothes models, but then I don't look at the clothes model when I look at a catalog (not consciously anyway), mostly at the clothes. If I was to interact with them, then I would hope not to treat them as just an object.

When I watch a good movie, I interact with the character the actor plays - I don't objectify the actor in this case. I knowmthenactor is acting, and appreciate them for their personality and performance.

As for strippers and porn: I've never been to a stripshow in my life, and will never do so. I've had plenty of opportunities, but have always declined. Why? I don't want to objectify the strippers. And I don't want them objectifying me as the punter.

For porn: that's something I try to avoid at all costs. Not easy.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by laichzeit0 on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:29AM (#6352807)
What if, let's just make this hypothetical for a second, woman want men to stare at their breasts? Would you still have an issue?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:18AM (#6352979)
I think we would be better served if we stopped seeing everything as sexist or not sexist and determining that if a thing is not, then everyone should shut up and leave it alone.

Instead, let's dispense with the labels or making anyone out to be bad and simply think about our moms. There are countless things that are not sexist or wrong in any capacity, whatsoever. You still wouldn't feel comfortable doing them around your mom.

If it would feel awkward around your mom, then it might not be appropriate for a lot of wider audiences. Especially where we are potentially involving a professional capacity.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:56AM (#6352900)
This hypothetical is not useful. You don't have to take it as an arbitrary "axiom" for the argument; you could empirically measure some of the women who are offended by this talk.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by laichzeit0 on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:04AM (#6352931)
The reason why it's useful is because in your case (empirically measure) it becomes at best "relative". There may be cultures / societies where woman desire men to stare at their breasts. In this case his argument would mean naught.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:18AM (#6353230)
Maybe? My point is, empirically, we are not in that culture!

Edit: oh wait... You're saying that maybe the guys in the presentation are not reducing women to their physical bits, but actually treating them as human beings who like being treated this way? If so there is a simple way to disprove it: The women can't say "no". Since the women are not given any agency, they are not being treated as human beings but as mere objects with no control over how their bodies are used.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:16AM (#6352970)
Was the app presented in such a culture? Where are you going with this?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:40AM (#6352846)
Where you are going with this is so ridiculous I won't be responding, other than with this response!
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by laichzeit0 on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:48AM (#6352866)
It's not ridiculous at all. It's one of the fundamental assumptions you're making in all your arguments but unwilling to put down as an axiom.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:04AM (#6352934)
Fine, I'll respond then. If some women don't find it offensive, all I need to find are women who did find it offensive, belittling, discouraging or isolating.

Or some men who believed it was offensive, belittling, discouraging or isolating to women. Like myself and a bunch of others.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by laichzeit0 on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:18AM (#6352977)
Yes and what will you conclude from that? Some find it offensive, some do not. It's by no means universal and some kind of "necessary truth".
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by chris_wot on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:33AM (#6353022)
Many do find it offensive. As many find the word "nigger" racist, but some do not doesn't disprove that it is a racist term. So it is here.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @10:23AM (#6353591)
A word can't be racist. A word can be used by racists, but the word itself - no.

There is a whole spectrum out there. The word "nigger" is a term of endearment for many.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by sp332 on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:09AM (#6352721)
Specifically, it makes the women in the audience feel like they are only wanted for their tits and nothing else. It throws away the rest of the woman and says, we only need the tits.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by rfnslyr on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:20AM (#6352760)
The prank wasn't brought to light with the intention of offending women. It's a play on an activity with men, we look at boobs. Not everything involving sex is made with the objective of targeting someone, it's just a joke. If you fail to see it as such, that's your problem.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by marvin on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:13AM (#6352736)
Really? It's impossible for you to see how women at a tech conference could get the impression that they aren't valued for their ideas and skills when an app to look at tits gets a prominent spot?

I sometimes think that the persistent claims of sex discrimination in tech are a bit over-the-top, but in this instance it's quite obvious. This stunt was very poorly thought out.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by partoa on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:34AM (#6352818)
What does titstare have to do with not valuing women for anything other than their tits? Pardon me for asking.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by marvin on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:33AM (#6353019)
It's not about intent, it's about perception. Using or building a tit-staring app may or may not imply that the guy in question respects women less for their technical merits, or judges them on looks rather than skills.

The problem is that as a technical woman in the audience, you will be very likely to perceive such an initiative as something that detracts from your personal values (professional merit, technical skills). This is doubly true in the tech community, where women are a minority, and is separate from the question of whether technical guys actually disrespect women. This kind of initiative is bad regardless. I'm pretty sure, though, that you will find a correlation between tit-staring and actual discrimination. Women as a minority in technical communities already have a hard enough time coping with the pressure to perform "in spite of their gender", there is no point in making it tougher for them.

When we use words like "objectification" in the context of sex discrimination in tech, it's really just an abstraction over valuing women less than men regarding technical skills. A lot of smart people will consider this a weasel-word, but it has a foundation in actual social mechanisms.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by partoa on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:06AM (#6353166)
Put that way, it may make sense...My problem is that almost everyone is reacting as if the intention of that presentation was to demean or objectify women rather than make light of the fact that men do stare at tits. Still, I'd go for both men and women understanding each other over political correctness. Reason, this will eventually lead to men only events http://borderhouseblog.com/?p=5811.

I wouldn't go for making men uncomfortable around women any more than making women uncomfortable around men. The solution, I believe, lies somewhere in between men appreciating that some things are rude in certain contexts and women appreciating that men may make certain jokes without any ill intent. Also, in my experience, in offices that are balanced, gender wise, such jokes are not uncommon; it's a thing people do.

I just think that such arguments simply trivialise misogyny which actually exists http://www.policymic.com/articles/30922/adria-richards-why-a....

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by marvin on Monday September 09, 2013 @11:45AM (#6354128)
Yeah, I agree with these points, and I believe the last one is a big deal. The ideal would be a tech community where there is a suitable balance in all respects. It doesn't provide any benefit if a lot of people have to self-censor in the name of political correctness. When people claim that this is necessary, they are missing the point. This is a nuanced situation where it would be very easy to throw the baby out with the bathwater. The PyCon incident perfectly illustrated this.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:07AM (#6352713)
> i can't see how a woman could find it offensive

Irrelevant. If you want to know if women find it offensive, ask women. Stop dismissing things because you manage to fail to see them.

This is an area in which you should probably check your intuition with other people.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by yashg on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:10AM (#6352725)
//i can't see how a woman could find it offensive //

Feminism won't be required the day men understand why a woman would find it offensive. Imagine being a man in a room full of women in a society ruled over by women and all women are laughing at a penis stare app. Today you'd say "Oh I would find it funny too", but that's male privilege. We live in a male dominated society so you fail to see why women would not find a tit stare app funny.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by rational_me on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:24AM (#6352784)
It already happens.

Women laughing at a man having his penis cut off.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDjUjhexTQk&hd=1

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by icebraining on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:18AM (#6353231)
You forgot the "society ruled by women" part.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by rational_me on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:41PM (#6357071)
You mean the oppressed minority that constitutes over half of humans?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by icebraining on Monday September 09, 2013 @08:12PM (#6357178)
No, I mean the gender that has more than a thousands of deaths per year at the hands of their partners, and of which 20% is raped at least once in their adulthood.

Bit regardless of that, if you think a majority can`t be oppressed, I suggest you learn some history.

Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by drunken_thor on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:00AM (#6352693)
It's more about objectification of women it doesn't matter if it is lonely developers doing it. It is disrespectful. What are the women who attended this hackathon supposed to think. Do you think they would feel like they are valued for the ideas and knowledge they bring, or their tits?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by pstack on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:39AM (#6353331)
I have asserted that it's not so much that it in itself is disrespectful. It is disrespectful that they would not take into consideration that some of their audience may be made awkward by it (and a person can feel awkward about many things which are not necessarily bad in any way).
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by iMark on Monday September 09, 2013 @06:53AM (#6352659)
You're playing devil's advocate, right?
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by jnardiello on Monday September 09, 2013 @06:54AM (#6352664)
Not really. Just expressing a point of view.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @07:14AM (#6352739)
A devil's advocate expresses a point of view. Specifically, they express a point of view that they do not agree with.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by WayneDB on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:25AM (#6353258)
It's more than that. Playing devil's advocate means you're expressing the opposite point of view when you don't really hold that point of view, but you're doing it to prove a point.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 09, 2013 @09:50AM (#6353403)
Indeed. jnardiello was asked if that is what they were doing, or if they genuinely hold that view; and they haven't given a definitive answer.
Re:'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better by eli on Monday September 09, 2013 @05:12PM (#6356248)
This app has a high probability of making people in the audience uncomfortable on the basis of their gender. That is pretty much never cool.