News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by anigbrowl on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:21PM (#6343196)
However, it is not within the NSA's authority to pursue criminal activity within the U.S. — they're only mandated to spy on communications between the U.S. and a foreign country, or entirely outside the U.S.

Completely untrue. The NSA is in the business of gathering national foreign intelligence, which includes intelligence on the signals activity of foreign persons within the US. Suppose we know there are two Belgian spies in New York, are you telling me the NSA isn't allowed to listen into their conversations? Of course they are. This notion that they're not supposed to listen to any calls that begin and end within the US is just absurd. Foreign intelligence doesn't just encompass other places, it encompasses persons from those places who may be acting within the US. I can't believe I have to explain this.

See http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/codification/execut... 1.12b

EDIT: It amuses me that people downvote posts with citations to primary sources. Have some more! Here's the definition of US persons (who the NSA is not supposed to spy on): http://www.nsa.gov/sigint/faqs.shtml#sigint4 per http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1801 which defines exactly who is a US person, an agent of a foreign power etc. basically, individuals who are citizens or hold green cards are US persons (also some associations and corporations, but you can read it yourself), any other individual is not regardless of whether they are in the US or not.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by csandreasen on Friday September 06, 2013 @10:26PM (#6343682)
No, they're not allowed to target foreigners inside the US. Spies inside the US fall under the jurisdiction of the FBI. See page of the leaked incidents report [1] on page 6 where it talks about the types of incidents, specifically:

"Roamers: Roaming incidents occur when valid foreign target selectors are active inside the U.S. Roamer incidents continue to constitute the largest category of collection incidents across E.O. 12333 and FAA authorities. Roamer incidents are largely unpreventable, even with good target awareness and traffic review, since target travel activities are often unannounced and not easily predicted."

[1] http://www.documentcloud.org/documents/758651-1qcy12-violati...

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by anigbrowl on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:45PM (#6343876)
What you're quoting is an operational manual. Executive orders are law, until such time as the legislature or judiciary sees fit to restrain the executive branch. They most certainly are allowed to target foreigners; whether they hand their data over to the FBI for the arrest process is beside the point.
Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by csandreasen on Saturday September 07, 2013 @01:20AM (#6344060)
What I'm quoting is not an operations manual, it's the executive summary of the 1st quarter 2012 intelligence oversight report from NSA's internal oversight and compliance section. According to that document, NSA considers it a violation of both EO 12333 and the FISA Amendment Act to target foreigners on US soil.

I should have cited a link to EO 12333 [1] in my previous comment; the section that indicates that the FBI has the lead in domestic counterintelligence is section 2.3 (b). I'll admit it's not the most clearly worded, but it does go out of its way to single out the FBI:

"Collection within the United States of foreign intelligence not otherwise obtainable shall be undertaken by the FBI or, when significant foreign intelligence is sought, by other authorized agencies of the Intelligence Community, provided that no foreign intelligence collection by such agencies may be undertaken for the purpose of acquiring information concerning the domestic activities of United States persons"

The section on the NSA responsibilities (section 1.12(b)) speaks primarily to collecting signals intelligence for foreign intelligence purposes in support of the Department of Defense; it doesn't mention anything about counterintelligence. The FBI is singled out again in 1.14(a) as having the responsibility to conduct domestic counterintelligence. Other parts of the DoD have the responsibity to work with the FBI on matters of domestic counterintelligence (1.12(d)).

[1] http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/codification/execut...

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by anigbrowl on Saturday September 07, 2013 @01:57PM (#6345838)
Thanks for the clarification. I misread your post above and thought this was based on one of the Snowden Powerpoint slides. However, I think part of the confusion here is over the US persons term.

As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, that term refers to citizens and green card holders, plus associations/corporations made up largely of those two groups. A tourist or someone on a temporary visa, for example, is not a US person. therefore, any activities they engage in are by definition those of a forieng person. I stand by my argument that 'foreign/domestic' is a function of the people involved and the scope of their activities, not of geography.

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by greenyoda on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:24PM (#6343565)
According to Wikipedia:

"NSA's domestic surveillance activities are limited by the requirements imposed by the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution; however, these protections do not apply to non-U.S. persons located outside of U.S. borders, so the NSA's foreign surveillance efforts are subject to far fewer limitations under U.S. law."[1]

As you mentioned in another one of your comments, the Fourth Amendment applies in the U.S. even to people who are not U.S. Persons. So this would seem to imply that warrantless eavesdropping on people's communications within the U.S. by the NSA is not permissible.

Also, regarding FISA:

"In sum, a significant purpose of the electronic surveillance must be to obtain intelligence in the United States on foreign powers (such as enemy agents or spies) or individuals connected to international terrorist groups. To use FISA, the government must show probable cause that the “target of the surveillance is a foreign power or agent of a foreign power."[2]

This does not seem to permit going after ordinary criminals such as drug dealers, and it does not seem to permit indiscriminate gathering of all internet communications (since there would be no probable cause for the vast majority of these communications).

"Suppose we know there are two Belgian spies in New York, are you telling me the NSA isn't allowed to listen into their conversations?"

Sure they are, if they go to the FISA court and get a warrant.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nsa#Domestic_activity

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveilla...

Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other by anigbrowl on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:59PM (#6343912)
I wouldn't rely on Wikipedia's summary when you can consult the original document that summary is based on. As for the 4th amendment, there are national security exceptions to the 4th amendment that derive from other parts of the constitution, which exceptions have been upheld by courts. Providing for the common defense is also part of the government's constitutional remit.

This does not seem to permit going after ordinary criminals such as drug dealers, and it does not seem to permit indiscriminate gathering of all internet communications (since there would be no probable cause for the vast majority of these communications).

I'm specifically not talking about that non-national security contexts. Everything I've heard about the relationship between the NSA and the DEA seems like a massive ethical and legal fail.

As has been discussed before, internet communications almost certainly do not meet the definition of 'papers' per the 4th amendment, especially if those communications are not point-to-point but go through third party providers like webmail providers. Arguably they should be, but my understanding of the alw (especially Smith v. Maryland) is that they're not.