Re:NSA Codebreaking: I Am The Other
by anigbrowl on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:59PM
(#6343912)
I wouldn't rely on Wikipedia's summary when you can consult the original document that summary is based on. As for the 4th amendment, there are national security exceptions to the 4th amendment that derive from other parts of the constitution, which exceptions have been upheld by courts. Providing for the common defense is also part of the government's constitutional remit.
This does not seem to permit going after ordinary criminals such as drug dealers, and it does not seem to permit indiscriminate gathering of all internet communications (since there would be no probable cause for the vast majority of these communications).
I'm specifically not talking about that non-national security contexts. Everything I've heard about the relationship between the NSA and the DEA seems like a massive ethical and legal fail.
As has been discussed before, internet communications almost certainly do not meet the definition of 'papers' per the 4th amendment, especially if those communications are not point-to-point but go through third party providers like webmail providers. Arguably they should be, but my understanding of the alw (especially Smith v. Maryland) is that they're not.
This does not seem to permit going after ordinary criminals such as drug dealers, and it does not seem to permit indiscriminate gathering of all internet communications (since there would be no probable cause for the vast majority of these communications).
I'm specifically not talking about that non-national security contexts. Everything I've heard about the relationship between the NSA and the DEA seems like a massive ethical and legal fail.
As has been discussed before, internet communications almost certainly do not meet the definition of 'papers' per the 4th amendment, especially if those communications are not point-to-point but go through third party providers like webmail providers. Arguably they should be, but my understanding of the alw (especially Smith v. Maryland) is that they're not.