This is exactly right. This is a case of the government reviewing itself by packing the review board with insiders and sympathizers. Nobody who disagrees with the NSA's behavior has been selected for this panel.
Blogger Emptywheel has been following this much more closely than the general media:
Advocate of Secret Infiltration, Cass Sunstein, on Obama’s “Committee To Make Us Trust the Dragnet” [1]
The No-Technologist Technology Review Panel [2]
3 Tech Issues the Non-Technologist NSA Technical Committee Needs to Address [3]
[1] http://www.emptywheel.net/2013/08/22/advocate-of-secret-infi...
[2] http://www.emptywheel.net/2013/08/27/the-no-technologist-tec...
[3] http://www.emptywheel.net/2013/08/28/3-tech-issues-the-non-t...
Richard Clarke built his post-government career (after being the most senior counterterrorism official in the Clinton administration) as a critic of the way the "war on terror" had been prosecuted, and has been working on "cyberwar" subjects for over a decade.
I don't like Clarke much and I don't agree with everything Cass Sunstein proposes but your dismissive tone harms your argument.
Obama himself graduated magna cum laude with a masters degree in law from Harvard and then lectured on constitutional law for 12 years at the University of Chicago Law School. Expertise in constitutional law doesn't necessarily translate to skepticism here. The constitution is not a moral authority on privacy.
Richard Clarke
He wrote an interesting op-ed before he was named to this committee. It appears to be critical of the NSA's operation, but a closer reading suggests his problem is about the degree, he's fine with massive record keeping, he just wants it in the hands of the telcos.
http://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/worry-nsa-article-1.13697...
I'm not sure where "moral authority on privacy" enters the picture. The question is how the program comports with the Constitution and the American system of governance.
The idea that Cass Sunstein is a "yes man" for Obama is laughable. If anything, it's the other way around.
You will also find in the work of most constitutional scholars something to upset any message board anarcho-libertarian, because very few of them believe in the black-letter absolutism that anarcho-libertarians choose to evaluate the Constitution in. You think there's nothing in Tribe's record to argue with? He's a gun control supporter, for one. You think pundits wouldn't be calling him an "Obama yes-man"?
But I'm still not convinced that the panel is anywhere near independent given the rest of the crew such as Morell and Richard Clarke.
(I appreciate how gracious your comment was. Thank you.)
The problem is that Sunstein has gone on record (and written a book) supporting governmental overreach. You're hiring yes-men to do your "independent review".
An issue at hand is whether the group will merely be researching means by which the ends can be maintained, that they are yes-men for the activities, the same way Obama appears to be. It's reasonable to question whether they have the same master, that they aren't truly independent.
No, wait, that's angels -- people can't really be trusted that way. If they could, we wouldn't need this panel in the first place.
He is a person who has expressed views supportive of an extremely active role of government in covertly surveilling and infiltrating with the intent of moderating domestic political groups whose views are unwelcome to the government.
This clearly makes him a extremely problematic pick for a review board whose role (as overtly stated by the President) is to instill confidence that the NSA is not taking an actions that are excessive, unconstitutional, and illegal under statute law in terms of covert domestic surveillance, no matter how "famous" he is.
It makes him problematic if you think that the panel has any purpose suitable to a public panel at all.
* If it is a PR effort, its problematic because Sunstein's known biases make it easy to discount his opinion when the underlying facts aren't reviewable.
* If it is a serious effort to get to the bottom of what is going on at the NSA, it is problematic because Sunstein's known biases make it unlikely that he will be interested in probing to deeply.
* If it is a private effort to reassure Obama about legality, that doesn't make sense for a public panel of this type at all, no matter what the composition is.
The reality, of course, is that hardly anyone knows who any of these people are.
Have you read much of Sunstein's stuff? What's the thing you found most problematic? Surely it isn't Nudge (a great book! but not particularly indicative of Sunstein's legal philosophy.)
Way to go! Replying to the grand parent's (revelation's) solid argument by using vague statements. Just what does the most famous living constitutional law scholar even mean? Besides being meaningless statement like the most beautiful woman in the world it is also almost irrelevant - almost nonsensical - to the current discussion. Just because a person has had a successful career - particularly in politics, bureaucracy and fields like that - doesn't mean the person doesn't have an agenda and vested interest. In fact some would argue it is quite the opposite as - unlike some tech/hard science luminaries, for example - their success is likely correlated with their other - rather nefarious - traits than pure merit alone.
Your next paragraph about Richard Clarke is in similar vein.
There's no appeal to authority here. If the parent had actually made a strong argument, Thomas might have responded with an actual argument as well.
First, they wanted Clapper to do the independent review. [1] This is the man that openly lied to congress and remains scott-free to this day.
Next they picked Michael Morell. [2] This dude was the acting director for the CIA until March of this very year. Clearly he has the capacity to conduct an independent review of his NSA buddies.
Joining this luminary will be Cass Sunstein [3], author of such classics like "Democracy and the Problem of Free Speech", and the person who proposed the government should infiltrate what he deems "conspiracy theory groups":
However, our main policy idea is that government should engage in cognitive infiltration of the groups that produce conspiracy theories [4, page 14]
Supporting these brains is Richard Clarke, who built his personal career on pushing the "war on terror" after 9/11. He also recently added "cyberwar" to his extensive portfolio of things he has absolutely no clue of. His views on privacy protections and large scale surveillance are well known:
If given the proper authorization, the United States government could stop files in the process of being stolen from getting to the Chinese hackers. If government agencies were authorized to create a major program to grab stolen data leaving the country, they could drastically reduce today’s wholesale theft of American corporate secrets. [5]
(It doesn't take a genius to realize this is the proposal of a person that probably doesn't even have internet access.)
Of course, all of these people work in some capacity for the Obama administration. It didn't even occur to the government morons running this show that maybe, just maybe, they should not pick people with an obvious and direct conflict of interest. They don't even bother to give the impression of caring.
[1]: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130812/13512624147/presi...
[2]: http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2013/08/white-house-pic...
[3]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cass_Sunstein
[4]: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1084585
[5]: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/03/opinion/how-china-steals-o...