Re:Why aren’t there any technologists on the NSA review panel?
by tptacek on Thursday August 29, 2013 @12:23PM
(#6296698)
My guess is that it's the third bullet, but that someone in the administration thought it might serve some PR purpose, or that the administration felt like convening such a panel without announcing it would indicate doubts about the program that don't really exist.
The reality, of course, is that hardly anyone knows who any of these people are.
Have you read much of Sunstein's stuff? What's the thing you found most problematic? Surely it isn't Nudge (a great book! but not particularly indicative of Sunstein's legal philosophy.)
It makes him problematic if you think that the panel has any purpose suitable to a public panel at all.
* If it is a PR effort, its problematic because Sunstein's known biases make it easy to discount his opinion when the underlying facts aren't reviewable.
* If it is a serious effort to get to the bottom of what is going on at the NSA, it is problematic because Sunstein's known biases make it unlikely that he will be interested in probing to deeply.
* If it is a private effort to reassure Obama about legality, that doesn't make sense for a public panel of this type at all, no matter what the composition is.