News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by tokenadult on Monday August 26, 2013 @12:02PM (#6277894)
"This io9 flashback previously ran in January 2012."

This note on the submitted article prompted me to look for earlier discussion of the Inca empire through the HN Search tool. This article appears not to have been submitted before, but we have had other discussions here about the Inca empire and its conquest by the Spanish.

The submitted article correctly notes that the history of the Inca empire is fragmentary because of a severe lack of written sources. Archeology is a poor substitute for history (relying on actual written records from the time studied) because it is hard to figure out what people were thinking. The rather rapid conquest of the Inca empire by a badly outnumbered group of Spanish explorers surely relied most on the epidemic diseases that the Spaniards inadvertently brought with them, but it appears to have relied as well on dissatisfaction with Inca rule on the part of many Inca subjects. People don't fight hard against invaders if their "home" rulers are dictators--World War II provides other examples of that principle. Maybe the greatest mystery of the Inca empire is that it lasted any length of time at all. The empire collapsed rapidly once a new, tiny group of potential rulers arrived. South America's Andean territories soon became viceroyalties of Spain, far away.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by Florin_Andrei on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:41PM (#6278559)
> Maybe the greatest mystery of the Inca empire is that it lasted any length of time at all. The empire collapsed rapidly once a new, tiny group of potential rulers arrived.

Any society would collapse like a house of cards if it wasn't in its prime, but was instead just a bunch of bewildered, shell-shocked survivors of a 90% die-off event triggered by new microbes. Pizarro was dealing with people who were basically living in a post-apocalyptic universe. The gods were angry and all that stuff.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by mercurial on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:15PM (#6278803)
> Basically the Russians weren't fighting to keep the Nazis from invading, but were focused on a counter-invasion.

The thesis of Icebreaker [1], a controversial history book by an ex-GRU officer, is that Stalin was planning an invasion of Germany right when Operation Barbarossa happened. However, his interpretation is disputed by most historians.

What is certain is that the Red Army was caught with its pants down and got a sound beating at the beginning. However, they did fight with tremendous tenacity (eg, at Stalingrad) later on, and eventually pushed back the Germans.

You'll also note that Germans and Japanese troops fought with particular determination even when it became clear that defeat was the only possible outcome. Contrast this with the dismal performance of French and British troops during the Battle of France.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by ekianjo on Monday August 26, 2013 @08:59PM (#6280830)
> Contrast this with the dismal performance of French and British troops during the Battle of France.

Contrast this with the millions of people who died in Germany and Japan because of that determination (or should I say their rulers' determination!), without avoiding the final outcome at all. The French government understood very fast they were completely behind and were going to lose and they did the right thing to avoid a massacre which would have prevented nothing.

And besides, in Germany and Japan people were forced into fighting until the end (even teenagers in Germany), it's not like it was the "nation in arms" or something. Nobody wants to lose their life on purpose.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by mercurial on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @02:44AM (#6281865)
> Contrast this with the millions of people who died in Germany and Japan because of that determination (or should I say their rulers' determination!), without avoiding the final outcome at all. The French government understood very fast they were completely behind and were going to lose and they did the right thing to avoid a massacre which would have prevented nothing.

I was more thinking in terms of low troop morale and lack of aggressivity of (in particular) French high command.

A contrario, German troops, although outclassed both on the Western and Eastern fronts by the end of the war, managed a fighting retreat in mostly good order, even mounting a daring counter-offensive in the Ardennes in 1944 which caught Allied troops flat-footed.

> And besides, in Germany and Japan people were forced into fighting until the end (even teenagers in Germany), it's not like it was the "nation in arms" or something. Nobody wants to lose their life on purpose.

You are thinking of the Volkssturm, which had a relatively minor impact on the war, and only existed for a few months. On the other hand, regular German units did not collapse and disintegrate under pressure, when they could simply have surrendered to the Allies (at least on the Western front). As for Japanese units, just read about the battle of Iwo Jima. I'm not aware that Japanese units on the island were more "forced to fight" than any other body of troops, but still fought almost to the last man, in spite of their poor physical condition.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by ekianjo on Tuesday August 27, 2013 @07:35AM (#6282802)
> I'm not aware that Japanese units on the island were more "forced to fight" than any other body of troops, but still fought almost to the last man, in spite of their poor physical condition.

They fought out of despair since they were told they would be tortured if they ever get caught (and most of them killed themselves instead of surrendering in the end). And it's not like they had anywhere to go at Iwo Jima. They were on an island.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by int_19h on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:46PM (#6280403)
> You'll also note that Germans and Japanese troops fought with particular determination even when it became clear that defeat was the only possible outcome.

I actually recall reading regarding Germans that there was a very peculiar distortion of perception there when even during late 1944 and early 1945, with Soviet armies literally at the door, a lot of people genuinely still believed that a victory (at that point defined as peace on non-debilitating terms) was highly likely - based on letters and other personal correspondence from that period, journals etc.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by ekianjo on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:02PM (#6280838)
I'm not so sure about that. When cities like Dresden were bombed day and night and destroyed to the ground, it'd be very hard to believe Victory or Peace is at hand. Maybe people living in Berlin had that perception, but I would be very surprised if that was a general sentiment in Germany.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by oarevalo on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:08PM (#6278309)
Actually, Pizarro took advantage that at the time of his arrival at Peru, the Inca's were in a somewhat state of civil war due to the two heirs (Huascar and Atahualpa) of the recently deceased Inca (Huayna Capac) fighting each other.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by s_baby on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:23PM (#6278413)
>People don't fight hard against invaders if their "home" rulers are dictators--World War II provides other examples of that principle.

You don't think the Russians fought hard?

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by freehunter on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:34PM (#6278502)
I assume I have a limited knowledge of WWII history on that front, but from what I was taught in history class, the biggest deterrent of the Nazi invasion of the USSR was the weather. What we learned was that the Russians were invading Germany more than the Germans could invade Russia. Basically the Russians weren't fighting to keep the Nazis from invading, but were focused on a counter-invasion.

I could very well be wrong, as I took WWII history in the US (which tends not to focus on European involvement in WWII).

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by int_19h on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:44PM (#6280401)
Weather helped somewhat to slow blitzkrieg down in 1941 (though it applies to both sides equally; Soviets were just better prepared), but it doesn't win wars. If you look at casualty figures, 2/3 of all Axis casualties in WW2 (this includes Japanese!) happened on the Eastern Front in Europe; and most of those weren't frostbite.

Soviets paid two for one in terms of casualties, though. But they could keep doing that for longer, and their industry could keep up as well (war production figures for Reich vs USSR are rather telling).

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by soperj on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:08PM (#6278750)
That sounds more like Napoleon's Russian excursion, than the Nazi one.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by mpyne on Monday August 26, 2013 @05:38PM (#6280093)
Well when I took WWII history in the U.S. it had no such inaccuracies, though it did tend to gloss over the Eastern Front in general.

Of course the schools I've been to have also stayed away from trying to teach creationism as biology so maybe it's different elsewhere in the U.S.

Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by tokenadult on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:43PM (#6278579)
I had Ukraine in mind as one outstanding example. For some parts of the territory Japan invaded, too, the local people thought at first that maybe the invaders would be better rulers than their previous rulers.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by jeltz on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:15PM (#6278804)
Ukraine had very recently suffered an artificial famine caused by Stalin so it had less to do with form of government and more to do with that genocide does not breed loyalty.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by asdfdsa1234 on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:09PM (#6278759)
Ukraine had just suffered a forced famine (Holodomor) that killed millions.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by soperj on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:06PM (#6278741)
Just wondering about this: "World War II provides other examples of that principle" care to elaborate on that?
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by asdfdsa1234 on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:12PM (#6278776)
Why do you call them "dictators" instead of "royalty?"
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by jeltz on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:27PM (#6278444)
What examples from WW2 do you have? I can see no pattern between countries ruled by dictators and not.
Re:The greatest mystery of the Inca Empire was its strange e... by int_19h on Monday August 26, 2013 @06:50PM (#6280419)
I think this was a reference to the fact that Soviet Union had extremely high (compared to average) rates of collaboration with the enemy among both civilian population on occupied territories, as well as and POWs.

Some keywords to look up: Hiwi, Russian Liberation Army, Lokot Republic, Ostlegionen.