News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by simias on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:39AM (#6276932)
Isn't it a bit late for that? I feel the modern alternative to gifs is simply embedded video.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by keeperofdakeys on Monday August 26, 2013 @10:11AM (#6277125)
Besides the whole video codec debacle, APNG has many advantages for the web (which are shared with gif). Since you have transparency, you can make each frame transparent, and lay them on top of each other; which allows more efficient temporal compression. You could also used an indexed palette, to save a lot of space (but not be limited to 256 colours per frame). Then you also get proper lossless compression, which is important for logos when scaling.

While much more efficient in the long run, a video codec loses out for short animations when you consider the above points.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by mistercow on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:22PM (#6278403)
>Since you have transparency, you can make each frame transparent, and lay them on top of each other; which allows more efficient temporal compression.

There is simply no way that you are going to achieve more efficient compression with that crude technique than with the algorithms used by modern video codecs.

I also think that losslessness is probably relatively low concern with an animation.

The transparency thing is important, although that is achievable with video as well. WebM is apparently going to support it directly one of these days, but the cross-browser way is to store the alpha channel in a separate half of the frame and combine them using an off-screen canvas. (Edit: see this demo: http://jakearchibald.com/scratch/alphavid/)

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by malandrew on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:51PM (#6279084)
Not having audio is also an advantage since it means that "paused by default" isn't desirable by most users.

I want all video on sites to never autoplay solely because of sound.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by mistercow on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:32PM (#6280931)
Do any browsers offer that option from the GUI? It seems unlikely to be common. It also seems like an easy fix for browser developers to allow you to exclude from that rule any video that has no audio track.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by noselasd on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:59AM (#6277046)
There's probably too many places where embedding a full blown video isn't practical - at least not in existing products. Avatars, emoticons, simple GUI elements (I'm thinking e.g. of a "copy file" dialog) and similar.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by simias on Monday August 26, 2013 @10:18AM (#6277176)
But isn't gif sufficient for that? apng is obviously technically superior, but gif is already supported everywhere. It's one of those cases where "perfect is the enemy of good" IMHO.

Don't forget that we now have javascript, CSS animations, canvas and webgl in addition to good old gifs to deal with animated features. Do we really need apng on top of that?

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by chr1 on Monday August 26, 2013 @12:47PM (#6278160)
With GIF one have to create multiple versions of the same image for different backgrounds. APNG works nicely on any background.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by Pxtl on Monday August 26, 2013 @10:14AM (#6277148)
Refinement of video embedding would still be ideal in my opinion. Isn't APNG lossless? Something lossy but low-resource (an older compression format, in other words) embedded as the full file (instead of streaming) would be deal - like dumping a little MP2 in place of a GIF.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by mistercow on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:26PM (#6278437)
Can you elaborate on why it's impractical? I understand that at a gut level you have the concept of "full blown video", but I'm not sure instinct is faithful to reality.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by randyrand on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:38PM (#6279388)
Not a proper answer - but h.264 has one clear goal, good compression ratios at good quality. Performance is secondary and as such h.264 is pretty expensive. This makes it a little silly for small assets where filesize is not a concern.

Little emoticon stuff makes more sense with GIF which are very inefficient with filesize but with very very little performance overhead.

This is just 'my gut' like you have said. A proper analysis of the performance of h.264/GIF vs resolution would be nice though.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by mistercow on Monday August 26, 2013 @04:42PM (#6279800)
I expect that the performance issues with small assets are probably minor (and smart phones have hardware acceleration for it). H.264 is expensive to encode, but the decoding cost is much lower, and is also adjustable at the cost of the compression ratio. If you want transparency, then the workaround you currently have to do with going through an off-screen canvas is another story for performance.

I can think of one other hypothetical problem, although it would need testing to confirm: block sizes. h.264 works with block sizes that are a multiple of 4, and AFAIK codecs often perform sub-optimally with input that cuts off mid-block. For large videos that doesn't matter much, since you don't usually focus on the edge of a video, but for a small asset, it might be a problem. Someone with more knowledge of h.264 might be able to correct me on this.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by zanny on Monday August 26, 2013 @12:01PM (#6277886)
With the <video> tag, you can hide the controls, autoplay, and loop. I don't see the issue.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by meemoo on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:36PM (#6278522)
The alpha channel in PNG/APNG is nice.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by jdiez17 on Monday August 26, 2013 @12:35PM (#6278082)
I tend to agree with you, but apparently people _really_ like GIFs, irrationally. I built a service[1] that converts GIF files to HTML5 video (h264 MP4 + OGV) and people reacted very violently, arguing that "it's not a GIF". It makes me kind of sad, but oh well. It even has a simple embedding mechanism[2].

[1] https://mediacru.sh [2] https://mediacru.sh/docs

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by dmaz on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:46PM (#6279037)
Excellent! I had this same idea in 2011, kudos on the execution! The size difference between animated GIF and actual video codecs is vast and the idea seemed obvious. I made a quick mashup with ffmpeg+Django (I'd use Go/MongoDB for web instead of Django these days.)

HTML5 video wasn't uniformly supported across browsers (and remember Google announced Chrome would drop h.264 around that time) and I didn't get positive responses on the idea. Maybe with more tools to support HTML5 video in animated GIF use cases and educational tools showing the difference in loading times and encoding algorithms this idea could take hold.

Also the WebP engineers have developed an animated WebP format which I disagree with but could be a step toward breaking GIF's monopoly on short animations.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by jdiez17 on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:14PM (#6279234)
>HTML5 video wasn't uniformly supported across browsers

It's still the case, IMHO. For example, mobile devices are a lost battle, in my experience, when it comes to HTML5 video (with autoplay and without controls). So MC ends up serving the straight up GIF to them.

I hope animated WebP becomes a thing but I have my doubts. I'm not sure whether the three major browsers will support it to an extent that it's actually sensible to use animated webp.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by KaoruAoiShiho on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:42PM (#6278570)
Well you can't embed videos on forums, tumblr, 2ch, etc. So it's harmful to convert to video for most people.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by jdiez17 on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:15PM (#6279248)
It'd be nice if that would change, though. Some forum software allows you to embed video from YouTube and friends, so it wouldn't be too much of a leap to embed short video clips using the mechanism described in the MediaCrush docs. I think it's an elegant solution.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by moheeb on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:04PM (#6278731)
This is like converting ASCII art to a .jpg. Sure it looks exactly the same, but the history of the format is gone.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by jdiez17 on Monday August 26, 2013 @03:16PM (#6279260)
The point is not that it looks the same (although it does). The point is that videos load much, much faster than gifs. I've seen gifs converted to videos, with the video loading 30 times faster than the gif.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by russellsprouts on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:53PM (#6281003)
There is a definite difference. The .gif has a dithered appearance, while the video is blocky.

A good animated picture format could be similar in size to video, while maintaining the advantages of a gif.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by pohl on Monday August 26, 2013 @05:30PM (#6280049)
I bet you are absolutely right that it's too late to get adoption, and I'm relieved to think so.

Here's an example of an increasingly-popular idiom on the web where embedded video doesn't quite do as good a job as animated GIFs.

I'm sorry for sharing this, but it is both timely (it's about some music award event yesterday evening) and relevant:

http://www.buzzfeed.com/lyapalater/the-weirdest-and-craziest...

If anything, though, this makes a case for not creating yet another tool for this kind of expression.

Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ... by Grue3 on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:51PM (#6278634)
Absolutely not. None of video codecs can reproduce PNG quality/compression.