Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ...
by mistercow on Monday August 26, 2013 @01:22PM
(#6278403)
>Since you have transparency, you can make each frame transparent, and lay them on top of each other; which allows more efficient temporal compression.
There is simply no way that you are going to achieve more efficient compression with that crude technique than with the algorithms used by modern video codecs.
I also think that losslessness is probably relatively low concern with an animation.
The transparency thing is important, although that is achievable with video as well. WebM is apparently going to support it directly one of these days, but the cross-browser way is to store the alpha channel in a separate half of the frame and combine them using an off-screen canvas. (Edit: see this demo: http://jakearchibald.com/scratch/alphavid/)
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ...
by malandrew on Monday August 26, 2013 @02:51PM
(#6279084)
Not having audio is also an advantage since it means that "paused by default" isn't desirable by most users.
I want all video on sites to never autoplay solely because of sound.
Re:Apngasm Wants To Promote Animated PNGs As An Alternative ...
by mistercow on Monday August 26, 2013 @09:32PM
(#6280931)
Do any browsers offer that option from the GUI? It seems unlikely to be common. It also seems like an easy fix for browser developers to allow you to exclude from that rule any video that has no audio track.
While much more efficient in the long run, a video codec loses out for short animations when you consider the above points.