If Norway can do it why can't Australia?
In fact, extremely heavy taxation will help with the "problem" of unions because with heavy taxation, the mining companies wouldn't have an incentive to penny-pinch on salaries. And with higher salaries, a greater amount of the mining wealth would be evenly distributed and enter the economy where a larger number of people can spend it. This is what happens in the North Sea. As a bonus, the unions will to a greater degree spend their efforts of safety measures instead of a game of tug-rope when it comes to salaries. The Norwegian model works.
Of course, you can't just tack on a 70+% tax regimen in retrospect without confiscating enormous shareholder value. So I think Australia is more or less screwed on this front. The best you could do would be to progressively tax new minesites. But of course this screws up the incentives unless it was done from the start.
The second difference is that Hawke and Keating didn't just drop it like a bombshell. They took their time to talk it through with the industry, over I think it was about 18 months of consultation and negotiation.
Disclaimer: I work at Rio Tinto.
There are controls put in to ensure safety (e.g. cabin sensors to detect signs of driver fatigue, in-vehicle monitoring, vehicle blackbox, etc.), but at the end of the day, it can only help so much.
Source: Brother in law was a foreman at a strip mine.
The OH&S benefits alone would have justified the project in the long term, and not parking the truck up justifies it in the short term - even without any existential threat from the unions.
As an aside, was there any threat of union activity? I haven't followed WA industrial relations in the last 5 years, but I though the operators have been too busy wallowing in cash to worry about pay.
I agree that there is more than one reason why Rio is doing this. But from a business perspective they are more vulnerable to production interruptions than BHP -- who aren't carrying such a heavy debt burden.
I am currently reading about the history of the North Sea subsea workers during the great petroleum expansion from 1960-2000, and the safety culture which followed from American drilling companies was just atrocious. Divers would be forced into lethal working conditions in situations where it was completely out of proportion to the importance of the work. 16-hour shifts under water, aggressive decompression tables which frequently led to both acute diving sickness and long-term delibitating injury, in addition to frequent accidents. (An "accident" under water usually means death). One time they sent down a guy who had been picked up from a pub three hours prior, who started the dive by puking in front of the whole crew. He died.
So tl;dr, giving unions the power to temporarily stop the work for safety concerns is vital if you want to make sure that the workers mostly get home safely.
If you improve safety by removing humans from dangerous situations, you reduce interruptions to operations. For a company at the scale of Rio, that's millions of dollars per day.
http://www.amazon.com/Gangster-Capitalism-United-Globalizati...
Rio is also automating their trains, and minesite operations (a kind of "flight tower" for a minesite) have all been done remote for years. It looks a lot like an NOC, actually.
Finding people to drive trucks for 100k+ is actually not that hard. You basically advertise a job: "drive trucks. Make big bucks" and people flock to it.
But getting 2 or 3 different people to drive the same truck in shifts, and accommodating them, and flying them in and out, and feeding them ... it adds up. To an overhead that could run past a million dollars per year, per truck. And if you have an idle truck, that's lost money.
But it's not even the money. Rio, like BHP Billiton, enjoys insane free cashflow right now.
It's about protecting production from union activity.
In the 80s the Western Australian mining industry was repeatedly crippled by huge fights between the mining giants and the unions, particularly the quite-militant CFMEU. A mix of legislative changes by a long-serving conservative government beginning in the mid 90s, plus generous individual contracts, broke the unions' grip on mining. And just in time for the mining boom.
In 2007 a Labor government was elected and dramatically tilted the legislative tables back in favour of the unions. Then the GFC struck with full force and it so happened that Rio had just prior to it borrowed heavily to buy assets at the top of the market. So any prolonged interruption to production would be death.
And so Rio have moved to make their mining operations as union-proof as possible. Automatic trucks is part of it. The ore trains too, parts of their port systems ... everything that can be made autonomous and/or remote is being made autonomous and remote.