News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by _yields on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:19PM (#6265325)
> while selling it as the user's benefit

I disagree.

Facebook, Google, Microsoft have a walled garden, in-fact every company on earth thinks on how to keep customers from leaving.

The difference between Apple and others is that Apple products are far superior, i can't imagine myself using any Microsoft product if Apple provides it.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by eloisant on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:30PM (#6265410)
Well, no.

Google releases pretty much all of its products on iPhone. Apple doesn't releases anything on other platforms and when they do because they have no choice (iTunes on Windows), they do it poorly.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by deveac on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:55PM (#6265579)
Well, Google certainly builds walls for its garden. Looking at things like nuking Reader in favor of G+, nerfing its applications on iOS compared to Android (funny how quickly iOS got turn by turn Google Maps once Apple released its own map application), and even initiatives like Free Zone in developing nations that provide free internet only for checking G+, gmail, and sites opened directly from a Google search). Just look at the shenanigans Google is pulling right now with Microsoft and getting Youtube on mobile there.

All of these companies throw walls up for the sake of profits and strategic benefit. Different heights, different locations, some hard walls, some soft, -but they all build them.

The entire free Android operating systems itself is just vendor lock-in for Google, which is an advertising (not search) company.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by cromwellian on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:06PM (#6265649)
Actually, you're wrong, sometimes the iOS apps have features that Android doesn't have yet, for example, iOS Maps actually had the new Maps interface before Android. Also, Google has Google Takeout, which lets you leave Google and take everything with you.

Android is not vendor lock in, because Google isn't the vendor in this scenario, Samsung, Amazon, Sony, etc are. For example, Amazon doesn't include Google's services, and Samsung is clearly moving in the direction of pushing their own stuff in front of Google's.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by deveac on Friday August 23, 2013 @04:47PM (#6266163)
>Actually, you're wrong, sometimes the iOS apps have features that Android doesn't have yet...

I didn't say they didn't, nor did I even imply it. Understand that this doesn't change the fact that Google witheld app features from other OEMs and kept enhanced versions for its own partners for competitive reasons. Just because Apple did it too doesn't mean Google didn't (as I already pointed out).

>Android is not vendor lock in, because Google isn't the vendor in this scenario, Samsung, Amazon, Sony, etc are.

I was talking about walled gardens, and wasn't making an arbitrary distinction of "vendor" lock-in.

As I was saying though, from the standpoint of a walled garden, Android as a free operating system has been remarkably successful as a soft wall for Google, getting their advertisements on more handsets more quickly than any other method. Instead of risking consumers switching, they are eliminating competitors before consumers even get the option to switch. OEMs have been keen to adopt an OS that cost them next to nothing and played nice with branding and in house apps.

Clearly Amazon and Samsung modifying the OS is a concern of Google's, and they are combating this with native apps, web apps, and their own competitive offerings (hardware included).

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by cromwellian on Friday August 23, 2013 @06:50PM (#6266668)
What you're basically saying is that Google used open source to create a protective ecosystem that prevents other vendors from taking over with their own moats.

Chrome serves the same function. It ensures Google is not blocked by browser default search engine changing, it prevents other people's walls. But would you claim Chrome is "vendor lock in"?

Android is primarily a defense mechanism. If Apple and Microsoft together had nearly 100% of the market for the mobile web, they could change the default search engine to Bing and sink Google overnight.

Android if anything, preserves choice and prevents lock-in, because unlike iOS, it is an open OS, and vendors can always change the defaults.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by lostlogin on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:00PM (#6266224)
Apple is a hardware as software company. Google is an advertising company. Apple wants the dollars in your pocket, Google wants your eyes. Discussing things in terms of open, closed access to competitors platforms etc is missing the point of each company.
Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by inkandstick on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:25PM (#6265366)
> i can't imagine myself using any Microsoft product if Apple provides it.

I can say that you are in the minority, people use apple now because they are cool and with subsidies cheap. I see a larger amount of android phones now than I did 2 years ago when everyone and their mother had an iPhone and now the Android phones are starting to look cool with there gimmicks like the phone pausing video when you look away.

People bought iPads because they were a cheapish replacement for a computer and they were cool, I think Apple has everyone beat on the tablet market at the moment, while more people might know what a Galaxy S4 is they probably don't know the name of a Tablet that isn't iPad.

But for computers cheap Windows laptops still reign supreme.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by myko on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:31PM (#6265414)
> I think Apple has everyone beat on the tablet market at the moment

At 10" yes, but at the 7" range the Nexus 7 is really superior to me as a user - I don't know the sales numbers though, maybe the iPad Mini is doing better there too.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by mistercow on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:21PM (#6265739)
Are you really suggesting that Apple products are superior in every case? Are you going to tell me that Safari is superior to either Firefox or Chrome?
Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by Oletros on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:23PM (#6265351)
"The difference between Apple and others is that Apple products are far superior"

Really? How are superior?

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by _yields on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:41PM (#6265479)
I hope this is a joke, but..

Go a head, take OSX and Windows 7 and compare between them, see how much it takes Windows 7 to crash and tell you: "do you want to send us a report?".

The report should be sent automatically and analyzed by computers before it reaches humans.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by estel on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:24PM (#6265761)
I take it you don't use xcode then...?

But seriously, what are you demonstrating here by providing an anecdote? I've got some of my own: I use osx and windows 7/8 extensively every day, and (except xcode!) neither of them crashes with even the slightest degree of regularity: they're both great operating systems.

But of course, neither are evidence of any form to support the claim "x is better than y". Which is good, because it's a stupid debate anyway.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by TheLegace on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:54PM (#6265574)
As much as I hate to say it, your right.

As I type into my girlfriend's macbook, I feel ashamed, but at the same time I cannot get myself to buy a laptop because they all suck.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by larrik on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:24PM (#6265766)
Okay, XCode crashes on me about every hour of use or so on my Mac Mini (especially when I leave it and come back). None of my Windows 7 programs have crashed on me in over a month. Btw, once XCode crashes, Apple offers to let me send in a technical report.

*Sent from my Linux Mint machine.

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by lostlogin on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:04PM (#6266241)
In terms of consumer experience, XCodes performance is hardly relevant. Use iTunes as an example. That god awful abomination gives me rage like few other programs manage.
Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by Oletros on Friday August 23, 2013 @04:57PM (#6266213)
I'm writing this in my Macbook Air and I use Windows 7 and Windows 8.

I have not seen a OS crash since years. If you're talking about app crashing I see more less the same on both oses

Re:A Steve Jobs email exchange that captures Apple’s strategy by ernesth on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:02PM (#6265627)
> i can't imagine myself using any Microsoft product if Apple provides it.

Did you try microsoft mice?