News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:11PM (#6261139)
Yes yes, everything that's happening now has happened before with other technologies. Except this time:

1. it's in a runtime that is in more machines than any other in history.

2. can be loaded instantaneously with no installation procedures.

3. and no plugins

4. On almost any platform, linux, mac, windows, ios, android, windows phone, blackberry, palm, chrome OS, even game consoles. Including the nintendo DS!

5. is broadly accessible to people with various kinds of disabilities

6. doesn't require a team of 20 engineers taking 4 years to build. (which other tech has achieved, and arguably much better, but not combined with the other things above)

7. Works on miniature computer machines small enough to fit in your pocket, and can download your app wirelessly. From the air. in your pocket. FROM FUCKING OUTER SPACE

(incidentally, did HN skip out on the whole ordered list notation of markdown?)

edit; To add a couple more points:

* SEARCH ENGINES can automatically index your shit.

* We have these things called hyperlinks which allow automatic, ubiquitous and pervasive interoperation everywhere.

I see a common pattern on HN where whenever the topic of javascript comes up, all you see is pages and pages of wretching about how AWFUL it is, and how you could do X in Y language Z years ago already. That's not the hacker spirit. A hacker looks at what's out there, and what's possible, shuts up, and builds something awesome with it. (and then wretches about how awful it was)

In fact, the WORSE the underlying technology used to build something awesome, the more proud the hacker is that they achieved it. Where's that spirit?

Sure it's not as nice to program in as your favourite language or environment, but it's come a long damn way. would you give it a minute?

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by reeses on Friday August 23, 2013 @01:39AM (#6261902)
I fink u freeky and I like you a lot.

There's the stuff we wish we could have done 50 years ago but couldn't. There's the stuff we could have done 50 years ago but only one person could do it by making a $1m multi-user computer not so multi-user. Then there's the stuff we didn't even know about. They're all awesome.

Yes, Javascript has genital warts, but I don't have to care. I can write sorta-lisp, which means I can layer my own stuff on top, and it magically works. I mean, emscripten!

The things that I miss, like automatic image-based persistence, are coming back anyway, and they'll be fast, probably open source, and can be integrated in a hazy, drunken, weekend.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by luikore on Friday August 23, 2013 @01:17AM (#6261852)
Absolutely not. These statements are boring because everyone knows there are javascript everywhere on the internet. But so what? We should pay more attention to GOOD languages rather than popular languages. It's not javascript a great language but the people made the products great people. They could do even better if javascript is not so popular.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:06AM (#6262128)
What about javascript's popularity, exactly, is stopping you from making something great? Use whatever hipster language you want, I say. The only question is how are you going to get people to look at what you make if you can't put it on the internet?
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by luikore on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:07AM (#6262450)
Internet runs fine without JS, just like Hacker News... But yes, I should not spend time arguing something which doesn't worth it and go back make some real things.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by CmonDev on Friday August 23, 2013 @06:04AM (#6262569)
Thank god for mobile native apps! Bless Steam store! Bless Chrome store! Bless Windows 8 Store!
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by marshray on Friday August 23, 2013 @02:10AM (#6261970)
The only great languages are the ones used to say great things.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by luikore on Friday August 23, 2013 @04:56AM (#6262412)
There are great things in other languages and they are not so hyped like in the JS world. JS is more like a language used to say average (or below) things.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by williamcotton on Thursday August 22, 2013 @11:47PM (#6261597)
This post is great. The argument that followed was an unfortunate case of miscommunication on both side, oops!

JavaScript has many similarities to BASIC!

At one point, yes, points 1-5 were definitely true. Thank you for reminding me! Don't forget about BASIC!

Here's just a few of really big differences:

1.) BASIC didn't have a DOM. 2.) BASIC didn't have network abilities. 3.) BASIC didn't have advanced language features. 4.) BASIC wasn't didn't load and execute from a simple network request.

BASIC was SUPER important to the command line PC-era, just as JavaScript is really important to the cloud-era.

Microsoft and BASIC... Google and JavaScript...

Because JavaScript is attached to the DOM, and the DOM, aka, web pages, are SO crazy successful at delivering, presenting, archiving and navigating media, it really adds a level of longevity to the language that BASIC could only have dreamed of.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by k3n on Friday August 23, 2013 @12:31AM (#6261729)
> 2.) BASIC didn't have network abilities.

Are you sure about that? My C64 w/300 baud modem was able to hit BBS's...

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @12:34AM (#6261737)
The c64 did, but could you download a basic program from the bbs and run it in place without stopping the modem software? Could that BASIC program then proceed to, in place download more content to view, from same, or any other BBS? We're talking about BASIC here :)

Now, if you wanted to move forward a few years then the Amiga could do those things using some proprietary graphical modem software and a bespoke graphics/interaction language whose name totally escapes me at the moment. It wasn't BASIC.

But, you know, you needed an Amiga to use it, and almost nobody had one.

..( a google search later and )..

oh hey, here it is

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skypix

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by pjmlp on Friday August 23, 2013 @03:30AM (#6262206)
> But, you know, you needed an Amiga to use it, and almost nobody had one.

At least in Europe, I can assure most people that could buy computers mostly had an Amiga or Atari ST at home during the 16bit days.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:42AM (#6262523)
Did you ever use skypix?
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by pjmlp on Friday August 23, 2013 @07:54AM (#6262902)
No, in my circle of friends no one had modems.

Our main interests were games and demoscene related (assembly programming and pro-tracker).

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by k3n on Friday August 23, 2013 @07:48PM (#6266880)
You're really jumping the shark with your arguments.

I'm only pointing out that the c64 had networking capabilities -- because he said it didn't.

You're being exceedingly defensive and argumentative in this thread.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @10:02PM (#6267262)
He said BASIC didn't have networking capabilities. And well, that's true. c64 is a computer. BASIC is a language. they are two vastly different things.

and no, YOU'RE being extra argumentative in this thread.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:15PM (#6261153)
Surely 1-5 applied to Basic. Why not VB6?
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:16PM (#6261155)
no they didn't. (what alternate universe did you arrive from?) And /not VB6/ because microsoft lost that battle. And not java, because sun lost that battle. And not flash, because adobe lost that battle, and not unity, because they haven't, and won't win that battle, for the same reasons all the others lost.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:35PM (#6261221)
Well, first of all you edited your list, so it's 1, 2, 3, 5, 6. Which of those don't apply to Basic, and why not?
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:37PM (#6261231)
1. it's in a runtime that is in more machines than any other in history.

No. Never has, never will be. It's just a plainly obvious fact, no explanation needed.

2. can be loaded instantaneously with no installation procedures.

No. see above.

3. and no plugins

No. see above.

5. is broadly accessible to people with various kinds of disabilities

No. What makes you even barely think this even slightly applies?

6. doesn't require a team of 20 engineers taking 4 years to build. (which other tech has achieved, and arguably much better, but not combined with the other things above)

I'll give you that one, but not without a windows machine, and a multi-thousand dollar piece of proprietary software.

I'll admit I am not sure whether you mean BASIC or VISUAL BASIC. But none of these points apply to either, 6 even less.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:39PM (#6261237)
Are you familiar with early Apple and Microsoft products? I mean Basic. 5 we can strike, the interface was text-only. 1 was true at the time Basic was released, and that's why "it's different this time" is not relevant there.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:42PM (#6261245)
So it was text only. That makes it accessible how, exactly? Can you cite specific examples of supporting technology for this?

1. was true at the time Basic was released, but so what? it has none of the "features" that we're actually talking about, and is less powerful than even javascript version 1. By the time visual basic had our beloved features, 1. was no longer true.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:43PM (#6261248)
I said we can strike 5. That means I agree with you about 5.

Your argument is "it's different this time" because of reasons 1-7. I'm claiming 1,2,3,6 are not different when compared to Basic, at the time Basic was released.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:51PM (#6261269)
My argument is incredulity that you'd make such assertions that are baldly false, and don't apply to the actual reality that we live in. "Visual Basic" and "Basic" are not the same technology, and you can't simply merge them to get more points.

1. was true of BASIC for a brief time in the 80's, but was never true of VB

2. Not applicable to Basic (you had to type basic programs in by hand from a book, not exactly instant), not true of VB

3. Not applicable to Basic. What does "plugin" even mean there? You still have to type it in by hand. Not true of VB

5 was true of neither as you've conceded.

6 was true of visual basic, but never true of basic- to the degree that we're talking about sophisticated GUI apps, not simplistic text based adventures or weather quizzes.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:14PM (#6261323)
Well, I said "Why not VB6?" because I don't know much about it. But I'm pretty sure about Basic. You presented a list of reasons why JS is superior, and many of those were true of Basic at the time it was popular.

2. You can load Basic programs instantaneously. They're interpreted, and the interpreter came with the operating system or even the computer's hardware. How is JS any more instantaneous? You didn't have to type in a whole Basic program every time you wanted to run one - I'm guessing this is the confusion here.

3. There were no plugins. That's all that claim 3 ever was. I don't know how typing in a program by hand is relevant at any rate. Surely every program has to be typed in by hand, unless you're doing visual programming.

6. I thought this was about Basic itself, which did not take a team of 20 engineers four years to develop. As for applications, at the time it was really simple to program in compared to something like C.

So it comes down to 4, 5, 7. These aren't true of Basic, but they don't necessarily make JS a winner:

4. Basic programs were portable to machines that had interpreters, and there were lots of them. But sure, it probably wasn't as portable as JS, as I don't know if you could run it on a mainframe. C is a very portable language though, and always has been, so why does this mean JS wins?

5. Improvements in accessibility compared to the 80's applies to all technology. How is the disability support in JS better than other languages?

7. Home computers were IN YOUR FUCKING HOUSE! at the time Basic was popular. But non-Basic programs ran on those computers too, just like non-JS programs run on your phone. Miniaturization benefits all languages.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:20PM (#6261337)
This argument is absurd. I can't help but feel that I've been majorly trolled here, so I give up. Have fun writing your next big app in BASIC. I'd love to see how far you get. It sounds like you could go far, since you have one of those fancy new computers with a DISK drive on it.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:30PM (#6261362)
I never said I thought Basic was a good language (for programming in today). I just said it has (had) many of the same features that you believe make JS a good language. Where Basic doesn't have the features of JS, those features are readily available in other languages, due to technology advances.

I'm not even saying that the features you listed are bad features, nor am I saying that JS is a bad language. I'm simply refuting your primary claim about JS superiority due to some list of features, and about how this is different than all the other times. All popular languages have their place, by definition, and JS is one of them.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:43PM (#6261401)
I SAID I GIVE UP. Do you want me to print you up a certificate from print shop pro and sign it for you now?
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Thursday August 22, 2013 @11:34PM (#6261556)
For what it's worth, I wasn't trolling, but I was arguing for the sake of it. Since I now get that you're pretty upset, I just wanted to say sorry about that.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @12:07AM (#6261660)
Not upset, but it's all very silly.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by reeses on Friday August 23, 2013 @01:05AM (#6261813)
3, dude, Beagle Bros.

And BASIC is just FORTRAN for people who couldn't program and didn't have a real computer or pubes.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by marrs on Friday August 23, 2013 @04:44AM (#6262379)
You make a post like that and then accuse foobarbazqux of being a troll. Nice.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @07:29AM (#6262826)
well then give me a link to your marvelous BASIC program that I can run without installing anything. (I use a macintosh computer)
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by foobarbazqux on Friday August 23, 2013 @11:23AM (#6264151)
Maybe you haven't been to Radio Shack in a long time, but the new hotness is the Apple IIe.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @10:29AM (#6263794)
WELL? I'm waiting! what cool thing did you make in BASIC?
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by kybernetyk on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:28AM (#6262492)
> A hacker looks at what's out there, and what's possible, shuts up, and builds something awesome with it.

Yeah, but a hacker also doesn't waste his precious life time with subpar and awful technologies (unless he's forced/paid to do so).

That's why in my free time I rather fire up emacs and hack away in Lisp instead of building JavaScript webapps.

Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by TheZenPsycho on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:40AM (#6262518)
a hacker wastes her precious life-time on whatever she damn well likes.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by CmonDev on Friday August 23, 2013 @06:05AM (#6262571)
Yeap, the only way of dealing with a subpar language full-time is doing something in a cool language on side.
Re:Javascript Frameworks Are Amazing and Nobody Is Happy by CmonDev on Friday August 23, 2013 @05:59AM (#6262560)
Using IE vs Chrome vs FireFox is similar to using plug-ins in a way, e.g. not all of them are using all the HTML5 features same way.