News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by jacquesm on Thursday August 22, 2013 @04:12AM (#6255832)
The writer of this article, Lord Falconer used to be Secretary of State for Justice.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by RyanMcGreal on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:24AM (#6256247)
In both the US and UK, the authors of their respective anti-terror laws are now trying to distance themselves from the predictable consequences of the laws they passed, i.e. that governments tend to overreach and loosely-written legislation enables this.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by davidjgraph on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:38AM (#6256286)
I don't think that's fair. The author states in very specific terms, referencing both the document and various definitions, that there is no reasonable way in which Schedule 7 could have been legally used for this purpose.

At a more general level, your point is valid, but on this specific discussion, less so.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by RyanMcGreal on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:57AM (#6256336)
The British government has been abusing the Terrorism Act since it received Royal Assent, and critics have pointed out from the time it was introduced that it was susceptible to abuse.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by einhverfr on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:38AM (#6257020)
I think my favorite abuse was the use of anti-terrorism law by the UK to seize assets of Icelandic banks in the country during that country's banking collapse.

My comment (which I think I repeated here among other places) was, "maybe they are afraid of a second Viking age."

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by ataggart on Thursday August 22, 2013 @08:59AM (#6256799)
>there is no reasonable way in which Schedule 7 could have been legally used for this purpose.

And yet it was used, for neither "reasonable" nor "legally" have any objective meaning. Both are convenient fictions to allow otherwise objectionable acts to gain the imprimatur of legitimacy.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by selectstar on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:17AM (#6256059)
Surprising person to have written this...

"In his role as Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs, Lord Falconer sought to make it easier for government bodies to refuse to release documents under the Freedom of Information Act (2000), "

Source : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Falconer,_Baron_Falcone...

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by jacquesm on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:25AM (#6256086)
Mindblowing actually. Lord Falconer is the last person that I would have expected to come out on this side of the debate, I had to re-read the byline to make sure I got it right, that's how unexpected this is. Imagine Eric Holder speaking out on behalf of Snowden or something to that effect. Obviously he's not friend of May's but to pen a column on the issue and declaring this illegal in so many words is a very strong statement.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by nicholassmith on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:38AM (#6256133)
It's interesting, I'm not actually overly surprised Lord Falconer spoke out over this as whilst he's was repeatedly hammered over the fact that Section 7 was a clear affront to civil liberties he maintained a consistent line that it was for a very specific purpose. I imagine he's enjoying the opportunity to hoist the Conservatives and repeat his line of "we never made it for this".

Alternatively he might be angry that the overly broad legislation that he was involved with has been used an imperfect way and justified the criticism that it received. I lean a bit further toward getting one over on the Tories though.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by coopdog on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:18AM (#6256911)
If he was a part of 'overly broad legislation' that 'could be used inappropriately but shouldn't be', then he's an idiot, or naive.

Put specific cases in which the law is applicable into the law itself, and specifically exclude as many applications as you can see that it shouldn't be applied for.

Giving broad powers to police and trusting them, just like trusting any human with broad powers, is a recipe for disaster. But then again we all knew this, I'm glad it's been an eye opener for him.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by jacquesm on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:45AM (#6256152)
I remember the way he spoke during the Kelly affair and that stands out more than anything for me. Contrasted with that to speak out like this in the Guardian no less is completely out of character. He's as much a chip of the old block as there ever was and even though he no doubt doesn't mind grilling the Tories he is going far further than would be required for that.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by repsilat on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:23AM (#6256245)
I'm not so surprised. If this were a proper use of the law it would be a much stronger case for the Greenwald/Snowden side -- in that case it would be clear that the law should be changed.

If this was a misapplication of the law then all that's called for is a slap on the wrist for the people who detained Miranda and an official apology. They might get some extra oversight out of it, but that's a stretch. Probably just a few internal memos so future actions don't raise such a stink.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by gadders on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:47AM (#6256159)
Not really. Eric Holder is still in power. A better analogy would be if George Bush's Attorney General spoke for Snowden.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by jacquesm on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:48AM (#6256166)
You're right, that would be a better choice. Thanks!
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by easytiger on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:59AM (#6256346)
isn't this all irrelevant and too late?

The government doesn't comment on security matters. There is no recourse. End of discussion.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by vidarh on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:46AM (#6256157)
He's a barrister and QC, and his name is associated closely with this law.

He's very much the type that might take this type of abuse as a combination of personal affront and horrible insult to the legal system, as well as worry that abuse of this law will reflect badly on him.

And he's not exactly best buddies with Theresa May.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by nagrom on Thursday August 22, 2013 @07:08AM (#6256375)
This, I think, is an indicator that the elected officials (and their direct appointees) have diddly-squat to do with the governance of the country. The UK is governed almost entirely at the whim of the civil service, and I can imagine that something similar holds for all other countries.

Governing a country is a hard job and to expect ministers, whose briefs change every year or two, to do a good job is ridiculous. So they rely on the civil service, who have years of their careers based around governance over individual topics.

You can see this, for example, in the way that UK governments are almost always more authoritarian than oppositions. As soon as they become under the jurisdiction of the civil service, opinions change and the agenda of the previous 'government' is openly advanced regardless of what the new party said in opposition. Once you're actually in Whitehall, I could imagine that your world view changes as you become immersed in a very closed system. The current government came into power claiming to be wanting to repeal the liberty-removing legislation that the previous government imposed. And here they are a few years on, misusing that legislation, defending it and wanting to impose more of their 'own'.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by gadders on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:44AM (#6256150)
And is therefore an opposition politician, and free to play politics with the issue.
Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by weego on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:51AM (#6256172)
Unless the statement

However, it is also right that schedule 7 powers can only be used "for the purpose of determining" whether the detained person is a terrorist. The use of the power to detain and question someone who the examining officer knows is not a terrorist is plainly not for this purpose, so it would neither be within the spirit nor the letter of the law.

is factually incorrect I'm not sure the insinuation that this is less valuable because it is political point scoring is that valuable.

Re: The detention of David Miranda was an unlawful use of th... by gadders on Thursday August 22, 2013 @06:25AM (#6256250)
He's a lawyer and a politician. Do you not think he could argue the exact opposite if he was in power?