We sometimes fall in love with our methods because that is what _we_ are good at, not what is necessarily the best course of action.
Again, I am not discounting the importance of improving technical measures, I am just cautioning against losing the sight of the forest for a tree.
I repeat, This is a political fight!
Edit - Added explanation.
When all email is getting stored in plaintext on NSA computers, it's going to be hard to get the government to give up all that juicy data. Reduce the value of the data they're getting, and it's easier to reach a point where the political heat just isn't worth it to them.
At the same time, the political effort helps prevent new laws that make the technical solutions more difficult. And it helps encourage people to actually use our fancy technical solutions. If ever there were a time when we can get people on board with using crypto, it's now.
Now that I say that, it sounds even more naive than I previously thought. All bets are probably off.
You can't let yourselves lose a power war by wasting all your time losing tactical battles. It's a tragedy if we all spend any time trying to protect our LOLs and OMGs to-from each other. If you are working on means for tracking behavior and extracting value (monetary, political, etc.) you are doing something less good than you could be.
Don't get caught by rope-a-dope when you could just cut funding for all this. We don't need protection from 20 terrorists who can kill 3,000 people. We can deal with them together. Somehow (fear, greed, stupidity?) we've lost our collective front. We need a 'We' now.
When Bush and some war-nat-resource-industry profiteers stack the deck, it's awful, but expected. At least the actions are rational. At this point, it's pretty obvious (not that it hasn't been for 50+ years) that we have a problem. The organizations at the heart of this are willing to act outside the spirit, if not the letter, of US law. The political factions riding power act outside the spirit, if not the letter, of our law and founding documents.
Our government is not behaving towards the world or our own citizens in the way that inspired generations to come here to build a better life for themselves.
The baby boomers frittered everything away. Lazy asses. Now, it's time to make amends. It's time to FORK THE USs REPO!!!
Yes, political pressure. But what if that doesn't work?
Anyways... No, you don't work within the system. You can't move fast enough to grassroots the elimination of funding for CIA and NSA and ancillary groups within military and war contractors. Any amount of traction will fail since there would be an asymmetrical and tactical-heavy process. You will lose against the financial and political interests of the ruling class. If the financial and political ruling class sees such a crowning jewel get it, they will FTFO and see it as a portent for things closer to their own power. The intelligence groups are the necessary brain to the necessary brawn that keeps the geopolitics in line with their bottom line.
The chasm between rich and poor is getting so far in the US that this is the beginning... you can't trust the poor. There's too many of them!
Same reasons why the UK would want a powerful pf filter implemented by a Chinese corporation at every single one of their ISPs. It's not to block dirty pictures, it's to shut off everything during social unrest. If they just wanted to block porno they could do simple DNS censorship, but they dropped in serious filter controls.
Currently my country is looking into regulating all wi-fi APs. They already have a kill switch for phones and ISPs, now they want to make sure you can't even make an adhoc or mesh network for social unrest. Of course it isn't to kill communications, it's to prevent crime because some criminals broadcast MITM networks inside cafes, so we need sweeping regulations to stop them.
Personally, I don't care whom is in office or how ostensibly benign they portray themselves to be during campaign cycles. Governments are large, uncoordinated, stupid animals capable of arbitrarily ruining people's lives when it's politically convenient.
PHK is wrong; You don't leave your doors unlocked because the mayor seems nice.
But it's true that with absolute government power where they can justify anything, and with so many partner countries willing to play along with them - encryption won't get you very far, no matter how good it is and where you are in the world. They'll find a way to put a backdoor into the systems somehow with or without the service provider's knowledge.
MOSAIC.
My political view is this: both the right to communicate and the privacy of communications need to be treated as a fundamental human rights, just as freedom of speech is currently treated.
Then there are subjective measures. Breaching these rights may be warranted in certain specific situations (just as free speech is), but the current processes don't seem to go far enough to protect us. Even freedom of speech seems to have been curtailed too far in recent years. We need to have the political will to push back on this. But this can only happen if, first, we add freedom of communications and privacy of communications to our list of fundamental human rights.
"oh maybe we should organize a union" or maybe "the NHS model is a good idea"
Any changes need to apply universally and not just to the government.
Freedom of speech != speech without consequence.
By that argument the Weiße Rose in ww2 Germany had free speech but they still got beheaded for it.
the UNHC defination is "Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers."
Note the "without interference"!
Governments throwing you in jail, intimidating you, or out right killing you all disrupt your right to free speech.
An employer exercising his free speech by firing you in no way prohibits your free speech. You can still tell everyone you want that you should form a union. No one is interfering to keep you from doing so.
Please tell me you don't actually equate those two scenarios.
consequences != interferences
Another example is the Chinese allowed protestors against the Olympics in special zones - they of course arrested them after - that is not free speech.
Possibly you ought to update the constitution in line with the Universal Declaration Of Human Rights like most of the first world countrys have.
Most people don't know that in some jobs it takes half a year or an entire year of salary to train someone new to their new job until they start being productive to the company.
It is also something employers do not love to do, firing people is hard emotionally. Most of them are not sociopaths.
How do I know? I had been and I am "employer" myself.
Let's take a few things off the table first. Voting is out for obvious reasons. Same goes for holding up signs in an approved free speech area. The occupy protests were a bit more effective at least in raising awareness but didn't upset the system much. Violence is a no for me personally on ethical grounds and also because history has shown violent revolution to achieve nothing but swap one form of tyranny for another.
What has actually worked in the past? Some examples that come to mind are the fight for Indian independence, the US labor movement and the US civil rights movement. These were mostly non-violent movements that deeply disrupted the status quo and created somewhat lasting change. They offer lots of practical examples.
Basically, we need to organize and act in a way that makes it impossible for bully governments and corporations to transact business as usual. Until that happens, there is no leverage, no opening for change.
Here's an idea: let's start a tech workers union. Imagine what a large scale tech worker strike would do to the economy. Now imagine if we were to participate in a general strike with industrial workers.
It would be most advantageous to organize now, while we still have a privileged status within the system. Let's not rest on that status and accept it as the bribe it is.
Any takers?
| One of the tactical mistake is not to "name" people on the other side this asymmetric warfare against the world police states, and put the individuals in the spotlight. The of agencies and governments is abstract and non-tangible. Unlike the "Snowdens, Mannings, Greenwalds and Mirandas" they do not have fear, and hence accountability.
| At the end of the day, these agencies are made of people, who make decisions. While the aim should be to keep the 'agencies' under check, the general population resisting them need to target (and I do not mean attack their home or family members or something like that, I only mean to put the individuals under the spotlight) to "name and shame" the entity with feelings, family, emotions, weaknesses etc. under scrutiny. Just as the Snowdens and the greenwalds choices come with with the consequences, so should be the case for the british officials who chose to take a stand.
The ability of the government to warrantlessly look at it is a political flaw and should also be corrected, but that doesn't mean the technical flaws should also be corrected.
It uses SMTP to transmit SMIME messages signed with X.509. Public keys for recipients are discovered either via DNS (as a CERT record) or via LDAP. Those discovered certificates are only trusted if the two parties have previously exchanged a trust anchor.
Direct itself does not define how trust relationships are initiated (which is a problem with scalability). So infrastructure is being formed around the protocol - such as HISPs and Trust Communities. HISPs intend to operate similar to how email providers operate - by providing web portals and edge protocols. Trust Communities are intended to create bundles of trust anchors for companies that have passed as certain level of accreditation.
There are currently two fully functional open source Reference Implementations in Java and C#.
http://wiki.directproject.org/
http://wiki.directproject.org/Reference+Implementation+Workg...
We have a version of the java reference implementation up and running, so I can vouch for it. I have been thinking about it in context of the privacy atmosphere for quite a while now. On one hand I'm excited that such a technology could also be used for secure communication and on the other I'm worried that health records will be susceptible to the same coercion.
But a slightly altered system where private keys are not consolidated might be a huge improvement.
We need to encrypt all communications expensively. Make algorithms which can be tuned to be arbitrarily expensive, computation-wise. Tune them so that it takes as much time as we can bear to encrypt and decrypt an email. Seconds, ideally.
The goal is to make it so that some large fraction of our computational resources are taken up encrypting and decrypting communications. Say, 10 or 20%. For every day uses this will just show up as emails being slow to open, since most people's computers are idle most of the time. But if your goal is to intercept and process all communications, all of the time, you can't do it without having an absurd level of computational resources at your disposal, even if you have all of the secret keys. Ten or twenty Google's worth of data centers.
If this was done properly, it would kill (free) webmail search. It wouldn't prevent targeted snooping, except insomuch as normal encryption does, but it could make pervasive snooping too expensive to be feasible.
One estimate I found was that there 150 million iPhone 5's shipped in the first year, and each one was about 25 GFlops. If 1% of that CPU was spent encrypting & decrypting communications to and from the iPhones, that is about 37,500 TFlops, which is just over the Rmax listed for the top supercomputer, Tianhe-2. Some numbers for the cost of that supercomputer are around $100 million, but the estimated cost for the Xeon Phis alone could be as high as $250 million. Giving the defenders the advantage, let's round up to $1 billion.
So the NSA needs to spend $1 billion per year to counteract the top smartphone in the world. Their budget is estimated to be as high as $10 billion / year, so they could do it. But how much of the total pie are iPhone 5's? I think to be competitive we need to push the cost to the NSA up towards $30 or $100 billion per year. $1 billion is trivial, $10 billion Congress will swallow and move on. They still fund NASA to the tune of $16 billion, and no one in Congress even cares about NASA anymore. But $100 billion per year, then you're talking real money.
So what fraction of total personal computer sales are iPhone 5's? If they're 10%, we'll be hard-pressed to keep the NSA out of the game. If they're 1% of personal computer sales, I think we have a chance of keeping ahead of them.
Imagine what we could spend on an actual threat.
That's not to say we couldn't or wouldn't spend in excess of $100 billion per year on a boondoggle. We've done it before and we'll do it again. But I think $100 billion is the point at which money even becomes an issue. $1 or $10 billion and there's barely a point in trying.
Targeted individual surveillance will likely always be possible (not just because of encryption, but because of the 5$ wrench, trojans and so on). What we need is to make global, indiscriminate and realtime surveillance computationally unfeasible.
Three years from now, most commercially-sensitive, politically-embarrassing, or otherwise-newsworthy material, will likely be obsolete.
We're not winning the war on drugs, but there is no indication of giving up on it at the federal level. Law enforcement spending is not slowing down.
I was thinking more of the USSR. There didn't seem to be any amount of money we weren't willing to spend. Lives, yes, but not money.
Unless you are speaking in some kind of figurative sense where I'm missing the metaphor, this isn't really true. The few real wars of attrition where the US has been on the winning side (WWI comes to mind) it "won" by joining late when the other side (as well as its allies) had already suffered considerable attrition. But even in those circumstances, its record in wars of attrition isn't that great (the US portion of the extended colonial conflict in Indochina comes to mind.)
Imagine how much computing power the US fighter jet program's budget could buy.
There's only one successful way to fight this: change the culture and change the politics.
Technical approaches are fine for shielding you today. At the rate the police state is accelerating, it's very unlikely to shield you tomorrow, as they're going to outlaw the means of shielding. They will not allow an arms race, they'll use their legal powers to shut it down, and make you a criminal.
Not going to happen short of a mass global natural disaster or mass military takeover changing the stakes. There's too much power concentrated at the top and no good reason for the people there to surrender any of it. If the masses get too persistent, they will "cull" the masses through whatever means...
You'll need to make sure that those responsible to signing the updates are resistant to coercion. The best bet there is probably a moderately large number of somewhat anonymous signers. Have a large and diverse pool of signers and require every update to have some portion of the signers sign off on it before the releases are accepted. With any luck if doors start getting kicked in and signers start getting hit with wrenches, at least one of them will be able to warn the public.
And for 4 billion USD they could create their own foundry. And then costs begin to plummet once again.
The weird thing of course is that the work is completely 'useless'
If you want a technological solution to the problem, use lavabit... I understand they offer a secure, encrypted (and reasonably convenient and usable) email service.
Thus making my actual point, that technological solutions will not resolve the problem.
Fully decentralized, based on the idea behind bitcoin.
Personally, as long as the encryption was entirely done client-side with opensource tools, and done properly (i.e. not involving keys stored on the actual server), I wouldn't mind making my messages go through hostile servers. Of course the NSA might be able to dedicate enough resources to break them, but they wouldn't have enough to break everyone's messages at the same time. If global surveillance were only possible with a two/three-year timelapse, that'd be a good enough window in most cases.
You can receive a message whenever you're online. The encrypted message is broadcast to a lot of people, at least one of them should be online when you go online.
We need to reboot email. Encrypt everything, including metadata -- given current hardware, the client can easily bruteforce it from a list of known keys. Build some sort of easy key distribution tool (connecting via p2p, dns, whatever, just build a goddamn UI). Ask existing transports to relax their restrictions enough to let fully-encrypted mail through, and build some intelligent webmail interface for this (Mailpile, currently being kickstarted, is trying to do smt like that).
We've been dicking around with PGP since the 90s without making any real progress, we've traded security for convenience (GMail, Facebook), it's time somebody reverts the trend.