Damned? The best possible thing that could happen for the NSA as well as everyone else who is affected, would be for the NSA to be pared back to its only legitimate function, military intelligence.
Other good things that should come out of this are:
Strong gov't whistleblower protections, so that future potential leakers will not need to flee. A real threat of whistleblowers may tend to moderate illegal activities conducted in secret. Abuses may still occur, but they should be fewer, and more likely to be reported if whistleblowers had security.
International treaties to protect the security of political dissidents, including securing the freedom to travel.
Real, credible oversight. Relying on Congress didn't work. Relying on the Judicial didn't work. Relying on the press didn't work. We need something better.
When describing the functions of government, legitimacy is irrelevant. Besides being immeasurable, it's typically defined by those with authority.
> would be for the NSA to be pared back to its only legitimate function, military intelligence.
Have you considered spying on Americans is military intelligence? Have you considered the military may see the public as a threat to national security that may have to be neutralized at a given moments notice? Surely defending our country from anarchy is a legitimate function of the military?
Fair enough. I hope it is obvious that it was me asserting my opinion.
>Have you considered spying on Americans is military intelligence?
Yes I have. It is a thorny issue. I can even name good reasons that Congress, high ranking gov't officials should be spied upon. I'm not sure those good reasons supersede the potentially disastrous consequences though. Without a doubt though, ubiquitous spying is not compatible with the stated principles of our gov't.
>Have you considered the military may see the public as a threat to national security that may have to be neutralized at a given moments notice?
Yes. There are probably high ranking military officers who believe that moment is now.
>Surely defending our country from anarchy is a legitimate function of the military?
It is most certainly not, at least not without specific constraints.
To emphasize this: I just spent most of the night reading about http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EKMS. It's really kind of fascinating how dependent US gov/mil communications security is on these guys. The foreign-spying stuff is pretty much ancillary.
Citation needed.
This is like saying that if Google China does something Google US has nothing to do with it, which clearly isn't the case.
If the Guardian US were independent of the Scott Trust then you'd have a point but as it is the Guardian is solidly UK based no matter where the subsidiaries reside. I'd imagine a story this big would be passed by the editorial board.
For the Guardian US that is Janine Gibson and Stuart Millar, both have previously been part of the UK portion of the Guardian.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mosaddegh
Because who cares about attacks on other countries, right?
So when we are told others hate our freedoms, I want to know specifically which ones those are.
If they say "religion" I don't count that as one as I am not religious. If they say "speech" I'd like to point to "free speech zones" and other direct limitations.
I can't think of anything that is truly 100% free.
But to stonewall the general public on legitimate requests like these will cause people to use their fantasy as to what those capabilities really are, and that will likely overshoot reality. In that case any information the NSA is likely interested in will go underground so far that they won't be able to get at it in time to prevent damage.
On the other hand if they come clean and it will turn out to be (much) worse than people expected (and there is a good chance of this) then they will likely be reigned in diminishing their capability.
So they are damned either way.
Stonewalling is likely an indication that there is much more hidden than we know about today, otherwise coming clean would actually make them look better.
The best thing for the NSA would be for this whole thing to go away, organizations like that only work when they can do so in comparative secrecy. As soon as the spotlight is aimed at them some of their effectiveness (and in the case of the NSA likely quite a bit of it) will evaporate.
Those pesky foreign media and their relentless releases. Funny how the Guardian is the best place to get information about a United States institution, how Russian dissidents would move to the US and how a US whistleblower is now living in Russia.
It seems our (the general public) best chance in getting some progress in these matters is to play out nation states against each other.
I have no idea where this is all going but I could do with less surveillance in the name of (the war on) terror and a more constructive approach to geopolitical affairs to replace the 'might makes right' policy that we have today.