News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by 27182818284 on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:37PM (#622408)
Should be able to vote without going to a separate sub-page.

Also, it is kinda boring and just too much of a word blur for my tastes.

It kinda has also already been done in a way by sites like http://www.googlefight.com/

Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by alexsolo on Friday May 22, 2009 @04:16PM (#622644)
Yes, I agree.

What I would do is I would make sure that all the "or"s on the page line up. Then, I would change each line from being one link to being 2 links, so that the "this" and "that" are both links; clicking on one of them would result in voting for it.

Once you vote, you can turn off the voting for that line (via js).

Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by kbrower on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:06PM (#622445)
Voting from the listing pages is a great idea
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by catone on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:42PM (#622419)
I get an Internal Server error on any link I click.

But to be honest, I probably wouldn't have even bothered trying to click if I hadn't visited the page with the specific intent of giving the app a try to review it for you. It's just way too much text, with no real rhyme or reason for why it's presented the way it is, and no real incentive to do anything but close the browser. I agree with mediaman as well: voting should be possible without need to click through -- think of another incentive to get people to click through (like commenting/debating the merits of the head to head).

Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by mahmud on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:09PM (#622451)
nice first web app. you will be contending with the myriad of "hot or not" type clones that largely cater to the unmonetizable idling office worker or bored-to-tears slacker.

cheers!

Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by dmix on Friday May 22, 2009 @03:47PM (#622610)
Jytes been doing this for a few years: http://jyte.com/
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by intregus on Friday May 22, 2009 @04:10PM (#622636)
This reminds me a bit of http://you-vs-me.com
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by ironkeith on Friday May 22, 2009 @04:11PM (#622638)
... but not as good.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by jerryji on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:13PM (#622996)
And mine -- http://collectivesys.com

It might not be instantly obvious that comparison can be done, so here's one example -- http://collectivesys.com/item/compare/KSrJ1hb2c9wx%3BvLgQgEe...

Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by jack7890 on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:28PM (#622486)
It currently lets you choose between "turd" and "poo". Might want to add something to flag submissions.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by amalcon on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:00PM (#622436)
500 Internal Server Error when I try to vote either way on anything. It does not appear to count the vote.

I am not accepting cookies (except from explicitly allowed sites); this might be related. If so, the resulting behavior should be something other than 500'ing.

Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by kbrower on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:05PM (#622443)
Nice catch. thanks
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by ruchi on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:59PM (#622534)
There is a typo. Separated is spelled wrong next to "Add Categories" button.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by mediaman on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:33PM (#622394)
It would be nice to be able to vote without clicking on a specific category.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by aristus on Friday May 22, 2009 @03:13PM (#622555)
Randomize the left and rightness of the choices, and make the "or" centered (make it a 3-column table). Otherwise you will have heavy right-hand bias in the voting.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by deutronium on Friday May 22, 2009 @03:54PM (#622622)
It seems to me to be a little difficult to see whether 'a' or 'b' is winning, with the vote number in grey. Maybe the text size could increase with votes.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by jcromartie on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:39PM (#622513)
I am addicted already! Great simple concept. Others' ideas about the plainness and being able to vote without going to the sub-page are spot-on though.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by mynameishere on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:44PM (#622521)
Can anyone explain the point of this?
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by sp332 on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:51PM (#622527)
Nope, there is no point. But I like it anyways!
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by bombarolo on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:47PM (#622425)
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by johns on Friday May 22, 2009 @05:01PM (#622715)
Don't show vote totals before people vote if you want honest votes.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp: This or That by lr on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:34PM (#622500)
Slap tipjoy on it, i'll give it a tip!