The reason why he destroyed it now is so that he doesn't face obstruction of justice charges later. He realized they were coming, one way or another.
A lot of lawyers advise that the only and best time to destroy evidence is before it becomes evidence.
I wouldn't put it past the DOJ to conjure up claims that there are always investigations into every company at all times, so any destruction of property at any time could be construed as destruction of evidence.
Then again I'm a bit more paranoid than most.
They've done it in the past, to the auditing firm involved in the Enron scandal. They actually indicted and convicted them of destroying audit records according to their standard procedures prior to them being investigated by the SEC.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Andersen_LLP_v._United_S...
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by JakeStone on Friday August 09, 2013 @07:37AM
(#6184992)
Jayzus. That would be as close as possible to actual implementation of the concept of 'thoughtcrime'. Thanks for the shiver.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by icantthinkofone on Friday August 09, 2013 @07:53AM
(#6185053)
What I thought you said, at first read, was "That would be close to impossible..." which would be a more correct statement.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by binarymax on Friday August 09, 2013 @03:39AM
(#6184218)
I wonder if they destroyed it before it was part of an investigation? It may have been preemptive to avoid that scenario when the Feds eventually did come knocking on the door.
Edit - yes that looks to be the case. From their blog: We see the writing the wall, and we have decided that it is best for us to shut down Silent Mail now. We have not received subpoenas, warrants, security letters, or anything else by any government, and this is why we are acting now.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by Donny32 on Friday August 09, 2013 @05:58AM
(#6184685)
Although if they had received a FISA subpoena, isn't that what they would be obliged to say?
except for "that is why we are acting now" and the rest of the text, yes
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by filipmaertens on Friday August 09, 2013 @03:39AM
(#6184220)
What he did was equally an act of heroism (in face of Internet history) and stupidity (in face of his own life). Perhaps, he should just have wiped and destroyed the disks, and have it "seemed like a system crash at a bad timing" caused it :)
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by StavrosK on Friday August 09, 2013 @04:21AM
(#6184347)
Isn't it fucked up when someone suggests that someone's life might be at risk because of some data he had (and completely had the right to delete) and it doesn't sound utterly ridiculous?
This is now the world we live in.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by mhurron on Friday August 09, 2013 @07:45AM
(#6185023)
People 'suggest' the government is going to kill people all the time, it doesn't make it true. That is the world you live in. You do not live in a James Bond film.
This guy didn't risk his life. His livelihood perhaps, but not his life.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by StavrosK on Friday August 09, 2013 @07:52AM
(#6185047)
Snowden's life is probably in danger, and Manning isn't having a swell time, just for coming out and saying that the US is involved in unsavory activities. Sure, this isn't at that level, but it's not inconceivable any more.
This isn't a James Bond film. It's 1984.
he risked his life in in the way that he may be placed in jail for a while. I don't think anyone is suggesting that he may be killed over a destroyed server.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by SODaniel on Friday August 09, 2013 @10:01AM
(#6185671)
I would probably argue that being imprisoned for an undetermined time is fairly comparable to "losing your life" for most people.
Lying under oath (or even when questioned by the police) is rarely a great idea. Because even if they can't prove you did anything illegal, that can still use your lie to hang you.
Why would it be if there was no on going investigation that they were made aware of (officially)? I think they are smarter than that. This seems like a pre-emptive move.
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by return0 on Friday August 09, 2013 @04:41AM
(#6184413)
But they weren't being prosecuted, how is that obstruction? How would they prove that it was "evidence"?
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by Torkild on Friday August 09, 2013 @04:44AM
(#6184421)
You're asking this of a government with a growing record of retroactively rewriting laws in its own favour?
Re:Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
by eliasmacpherson on Friday August 09, 2013 @05:45AM
(#6184647)
Retroactive law for warrantless wiretapping, I am aware of. What other laws can you add to that list?
Perhaps, the secret laws in secret courts that you (we) are neither aware of now, nor ever will.
That guy has brass balls. It may very well be that this will be interpreted as obstruction of justice, there is a specific element in there about destroying evidence.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstruction_of_justice