News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by sp332 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @03:32PM (#6168670)
The big news: Once Ciavarella was convicted, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court tossed out 4,000 convictions issued by the judge. Will the kids or their families get any restitution for wrongful imprisonment?
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by rayiner on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @04:13PM (#6168863)
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:02PM (#6169142)
Are they immune from being sued? Is such an immunity definitely constitutional?
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by rayiner on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:16PM (#6169232)
The states have sovereign immunity (they can only be sued by the federal government, other states, or when they consent to be sued). State sovereign immunity dates to the common law, but was explicitly affirmed by the 11th amendment.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by HarryHirsch on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @06:18PM (#6169594)
Sovereign immunity ("the King can do no wrong") is a very strange doctrine. One would have thought that notion would have gone out of the window when they beheaded Charles I, but somehow it has a strong foothold in the US. In most civilized countries it does not.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by unperson123 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @07:43PM (#6169953)
In Alden vs Maine, this is argued pretty well in the majority opinion written by Anthony Kennedy.

"sometimes referred to the States’ immunity from suit as "Eleventh Amendment immunity[,]" [that] phrase is [a] convenient shorthand but something of a misnomer, [because] the sovereign immunity of the States neither derives from nor is limited by the terms of the Eleventh Amendment. Rather, as the Constitution's structure, and its history, and the authoritative interpretations by this Court make clear, the States’ immunity from suit is a fundamental aspect of the sovereignty which the States enjoyed before the ratification of the Constitution, and which they retain today (either literally or by virtue of their admission into the Union upon an equal footing with the other States) except as altered by the plan of the Convention or certain constitutional Amendments."

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by HarryHirsch on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @08:59PM (#6170208)
It's not convincing at all. That opinion states that the States enjoy immunity because it had been a long-standing practice going back to before they joined the union. It's a long-standing practice of many civilized nations that the nation itself does not enjoy immunity from prosecution. If what Judge Kennedy wrote (Alden vs Maine happened in 1999!) isn't a no-argument I wouldn't know what is.

Also this: the State of Pennsylvania has committed grave injustice against thousands of its citizens. If they cannot get justice done through the courts what are they supposed to do instead? Take recourse to Direct Action? That's not desirable in civilized society. You can't be your own judge and executioner.

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by gohrt on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @11:08AM (#6173321)
> You can't be your own judge and executioner.

This is what government IS! Executive, Legislative, and Judiciary.

States have some subservience to the Federal government, as well.

The question really is "should the judiciary have power over the executive in this case, or should the executive or legistlature decide what compensation is appropriate." It's still "government" either way.

And let us remember which branch of government was the original villain in this case!

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by true_religion on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @10:18PM (#6170429)
> It's a long-standing practice of many civilized nations that the nation itself does not enjoy immunity from prosecution.

Can you name any of these countries so we can do a fact-check?

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by discodave on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @09:34PM (#6170303)
Err, also applies in Australia, UK, other commonwealth countries as far as I know.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by MaysonL on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:55PM (#6169476)
Perhaps DOJ should consider suing Pennsylvania for civil rights violation?
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by at-fates-hands on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:14PM (#6169221)
I would assume lawyers would look at other remedies such as lost wages, emotional distress, and other factors to seek a civil trial to get proper compensation.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by PeterisP on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @04:12PM (#6175297)
Well, Pennsylvania has voters, and at least now thousands of them have both motivation and moral standing to push for such statutes.

One shouldn't think of laws as something that exists to be obeyed - laws are (or should be) the written down consensus of We the People about how we want our society to be, and any [lack of] such law can and should be fixed.

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by ojbyrne on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @04:38PM (#6168997)
"He was also forced to pay $1 million in restitution."

I'm not sure who else other than the families would get that.

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by unreal37 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:45PM (#6169407)
The IRS. He was convicted of wire fraud and tax fraud.[1]

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13judge.html?pagewanted...

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by ojbyrne on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @09:25PM (#6170278)
Honestly that's kind of disgusting. One arm of the "system" fucked people's lives up. But restitution goes to another arm of the same system.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by saraid216 on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @10:37PM (#6170486)
I like how the "system" is such a vague and amorphous concept that you had to put it in air quotes.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by gohrt on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @11:11AM (#6173331)
To be clear: he didn't steal from the victims, so it is impossible to pay them restitution. He doesn't have years of life to give to them.

He should pay punitive damages though.

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by glesica on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @04:52PM (#6169088)
So about $250 per family, that seems fair...
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by mistercow on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:03PM (#6169151)
Well this was a criminal case, it seems pretty likely that a very successful civil lawsuit will follow. That said, the idea that the monetary penalty is less than he actually made is just bizarre.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by jeltz on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @06:35PM (#6169656)
Actually the 1 million seems to just be the tax he should have paid on the income.

"The answers became a bit clearer on Thursday as the judge, Mark A. Ciavarella Jr., and a colleague, Michael T. Conahan, appeared in federal court in Scranton, Pa., to plead guilty to wire fraud and income tax fraud for taking more than $2.6 million in kickbacks to send teenagers to two privately run youth detention centers run by PA Child Care and a sister company, Western PA Child Care."

The prison sentence was the punishment of the wrongful imprisonments.

Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by glesica on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @11:12PM (#6170597)
What really blows my mind is that elsewhere on HN today there was an article about asset forfeiture and police forcing a couple to turn over about $6k that was found in their car without ever even arresting or charging them. So why exactly doesn't this judge have to forfeit the assets he acquired through these kickbacks?! It's an illustration of just how unfair and ineffective our legal system really is, especially in terms of its treatment of the poor and/or uneducated.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by jlgreco on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @05:53PM (#6169459)
Who will those families all sue though that will 1) let them, and 2) have enough money so that all of them get reasonable restitution?
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by e3pi on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @01:25AM (#6171034)
The state. Their AG, et al on down allowed this heinous act of gross miscarriage of justice. These innocent youngsters are scarred for life. Being a state conspiracy by the Rico Act these victimized youth could be awarded treble damages. Like the charge of espionage over ES' head with draconian punishment of life in prison, or the inflated charges on Aaron Swartz,arguably to send a message to future whistle blowers and `hackers', the state criminal justice system must live in fear of the punitive consequences of malpractice. Seems to be how everything gets decided today.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by protomyth on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @06:16PM (#6169587)
How about the prison owners?
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by jlgreco on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @06:33PM (#6169648)
True, though split among 4000 children I can't imagine that is going to go very far either.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by jeltz on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @06:38PM (#6169673)
I wonder if the prison and owners has enough money the pay for this.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by sliverstorm on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @06:05PM (#6169534)
Don't worry, they'll find someone with enough money to be worth suing. Anyone will do, guilty or not, so long as they have money.
Re:Judge to serve 28 years after making $2 million sending c... by samstave on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @04:47PM (#6169059)
Lawyers