I don't agree with this. Mainly because "protecting people from harm" is not well defined. There are people who seem scared of their own shadow and see nearly everything as potential harm.
EDIT: Not to diminish/trivialize the seriousness of this particular situation, but I still cannot agree with the sentence I quoted as being generally acceptable. As in, I don't want to see a law with that exact sentence in it.
Women are being threatened with violence, rape and death. Even if these are not threats people intend to carry out, to those receiving them they are deeply distressing. The threats are meant to intimidate and silence. Why should anyone put up with that?
They shouldn't. Some comments are obviously unacceptable. That's easy. The problem is, as always, where do you draw the line?
It's the comments at the margins of "acceptability" that are the most difficult to deal with and where the arguments of censorship are sure to come from. "You know it when you see it" is not easy to apply.
Threats of unlawful violence. This isn't hard.
> It's the comments at the margins
The US legal system is pretty explicitly biased towards defendants in gray areas, and most marginal cases will never be prosecuted or be thrown out by the judge.
Those that make it through to trial will have a jury determine whether a comment is a threat beyond reasonable doubt, and then the trial judge and at least two appellate judges will have to agree that the jury's verdict was not unreasonable.
Depending on the precise posture of the case, there are tens of judges and an army of clerks beyond that who may see the case cross their desks and provide at least cursory review.
And US courts pay very, very close attention to criminal cases based on speech.
I'm sure Twitter, its users and the legal system are just dying to have marginal cases decided by the courts.
What you've described is the problem I was referring to. One person says one thing, another says something else. A third party has to make the decision on whether it's acceptable or not. That's cumbersome, not very clear cut, and leads to one disgruntled party or at least some controversy.
"Crap! Robin Hood airport is closed. You've got a week and a bit to get your shit together otherwise I'm blowing the airport sky high!!"
£385 and £600 costs.
The general idea is not worthless, but it's disconnected from reality.
The problem is that any system that could be used to prevent people from making rape threats on the Internet could and inevitably would be used to silence various forms of dissent. We have seen this sort of thing before:
http://www.niemanlab.org/2010/04/mark-fiore-can-win-a-pulitz...
Yes, Apple is the same as Walmart in laying the dead hand of censorship on popular culture with the aim of increasing its own profits, but in most cases, there is not a legal compulsion to do so.
Otherwise, you've invented a hypothetical problem leading to a hypothetical event.
I think content platforms like twitter do have a responsibility to make their spaces reasonably safe for their users. This means not allowing one user to make threats against another.
There's a difference between hoping bad something might happen to someone, and threatening to rape them, come round to their house and stab them or telling them you've planted a bomb on their car. Would you argue otherwise?
I would have been happier if it had been handled with an investigation and warning and not make it to prosecution, but as far as I'm concerned, the guy deserved some nontrivial inconvenience. I'm kind of ambivalent about the fact that the conviction was quashed.
He wasn't even sent to prison. He was fined. I don't think that's a wholly unreasonable way for society to say "don't do that".
Of course, free speech does allow a nutjob creationist to pervert science education in Texas, but that's another matter.
One of the louder and more influential friends of the woman behind the successful Twitter abuse reporting petition is a particularly charming radical feminist called Cathy Brennan. Brennan believes that trans women are really men attacking women's rights by masquerading as women, and deals with this by systematically outing and doxxing them - we're taking names, photos, addresses, jobs in some cases. She's been known to call the FBI on them and falsely label them as pedophiles (because all trans women are pedophiles in her eyes).
She doesn't consider this harassment. She does, however, consider anyone who objects to her or anyone else doing this - no matter how politely - to be a form of harassment. In addition, she has an organised group of allies with the same views who she gets to dogpile site owners, often successfully. (She's certainly managed to get Wordpress.com blogs reinstated that spectacularly violate the ToS and common decency reinstated, in one case by appealing to Matt Mullenweg directly.)
Naturally, she entirely supports the new Twitter abuse reporting functionality.
I'll be interested if you can come up with a better one. Complaining about edge-cases has its place but doesn't actually provide an answer.
Criticism is silenced by other laws, such as libel. Threats to rape women have nothing to do with it.
Shouldn't be in theory, but essentially everyone with any pull in the public debate seems to want Twitter to ban based on whether the user's opinions are politically correct. So, for example, they argue that telling someone to choke on their own vomit is abusive when their opponents do it to them but a vital part of activism that must be protected when they do it to someone they consider deserving.
There's also signficant debate over whether moderators can even enforce policies in a fair and unbiased way: http://storify.com/andustar/twitter-moderation To be honest, I've never seen it happen ever.
The behaviour's really not acceptable. But... do we really need the state involved to deal with some teenager who thinks they're funny?
All of those are currently illegal.
I'm not sure what Twitter should do - include an abuse button that sends reports to a Twitter team who then report people to the relevant police? Or who then collect evidence in case the police contact Twitter (with suitable legal documentation)?
People do go to jail in the UK for making stupid comments on the Internet.
Here's an English 'troll' who made threats against US schools: (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-22813326)
Being able to report illegal content seems like a reasonable request. Being able to report content that breaks the ToS / AUP seems like a reasonable request. Protecting the free speech rights of people who are saying unpopular (but not illegal nor ToS violating) things shouldn't be a barrier to protecting people from harm.
I guess they might want to have some kind of transparency report to show how much stuff gets taken down, how often, and what kind of thing it is.