Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by regal on Saturday August 03, 2013 @07:49AM
(#6151833)
She said: "While I'm pleased they're listening, it's taken Twitter a week to come up with this.
"Twitter's 'report abuse' button on the iPhone application goes through to the old reporting form. What we're looking for is an overhaul of the system which sits behind the button.
"The current process is lengthy, complicated and impossible to use if you're under sustained attack like I have been.
"Right now, all the emphasis is on the victim, often under intense pressure, to report rather than for Twitter to track down the perpetrator and stop them."
-----------------
Two thoughts:
One, the expectations here for the turnaround time for Twitter to add new functionality to its system seem to be somewhat unrealistic.
Two, perhaps Twitter wants users reporting abuse to fill out a form (perhaps they could make it shorter if it's overly lengthy) as a filter to make sure only real abuse cases are filed, as opposed to, say, a system where anyone who doesn't like a Tweet clicks an abuse button, and that Tweet is immediately censored, or one in which Twitter hires a team of 50 outsourcers to manually sort through tens of thousands of daily abuse claims.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by gabemart on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:42AM
(#6152037)
>a system where anyone who doesn't like a Tweet clicks an abuse button, and that Tweet is immediately censored
A la "Flag for spam" on youtube comments. I would hesitantly estimate that perhaps 1% of comments which appear with a "This has been flagged as spam" warning are actually spam.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by 6d0debc071 on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:51AM
(#6152055)
If people didn't want services on free services, then the people who were using them to make money would be up the creek. Adding 'customer' in front of that concept doesn't change the underlying relationship.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by brador on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:24AM
(#6152146)
Human customer service doesn't scale well. The number of false flags Twitter will get on this report button is non trivial. Most people are assholes when they get power, and that report button is power. It will be used by some to remove people they don't like from Twitter. We've seen the same on other services (youtube), and we'll see it here.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by scholia on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:49AM
(#6152221)
We have computers that block spam, remove content from Google's index, drive cars and win at Jeopardy. They could certainly remove a lot of abuse, and that would be worth doing.
I'm not convinced it would result in wrongly removing a lot of people, since there is some form of karma in the number of followers and the number of lists someone is on.
Of course, it would be nice to have some recourse to an independent appeal if something goes wrong. However, Google manages without one (1), and its decisions can have devastating personal and financial consequences. That's not the case with Twitter, where there is no real barrier to creating accounts. Including spam accounts.
(1) Unless you happen to be buddies with someone at Google.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by 6d0debc071 on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:09PM
(#6154130)
> Human customer service doesn't scale well.
Mmm, well, there you're changing your argument on me ^_^;
Okay, let's talk about that instead. Problems: False positives, (from whose perspective?) low staff to customer ratio.
Potential solutions:
Recruit volunteer staff
Pros: More staff.
Cons: Some of them are going to be evil.
Let users report people they don't want to hear from (as you point out, this is how it will work)
Pros: Reduces staff tasks
Cons: Again, might be used for evil
So, essentially what we seem to be looking at with the above problems is a trust issue. If you give people binary access to total power, even on a probabilistic basis as per the report function, then it's going to be abuse.
Potential solutions:
Give people more limited forms of power than banning and not banning.
Pros: - varies
Cons: Less deterrents?
How might we do that?
Potential solutions: Let people ban others from their accounts.
Pros: No longer have to worry about people who just don't like someone banning them.
Cons: Loses a lot of the social deterrent effect, people who joke about rape probably don't care about continuing to talk to the person they're attacking anyway.
Cons: Doesn't let you network with people who are likely to share your values, so you'll get exposed to attacks anyway.
(This seems to be the current state of affairs - I don't really use twitter so I don't know, but suggestions on pages seem to imply it.)
If we solve the second problem there, the first one becomes less of an issue. At this point it starts to look like a networking and evidence problem. If we have ban groups - that you can join or unjoin as you please, to make abuse less likely, and have each individual user's decisions absolutely override any group level decision for their account.
Okay, what are the potential problems with that?
How would you vote?
If someone's banned from one person's account gets banned from all of them, then as the group increases the power of any individual within that group will increase.
Require more than one person to make a decision to get rid of someone?
How do we stop groups of thugs just voting to shut someone up?
Choose a representative sample? Say by forwarding the reported post to three people within the group and having them all sign off on it.
Downside is you duplicate work - upside is you reduce the potential for them all to be evil - and if the group itself is evil then it's not a group that people would want to be part of anyway.
How do you keep trolls out? If the group consistently votes against your reports, then your reports stop being received?
==========================
I don't know, admittedly this isn't my area and this is like ten minutes thought. But it doesn't seem to me like an absolutely unsolvable problem as much as it seems a bit tricky.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by brador on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:50AM
(#6159039)
The situation for Twitter is messy no matter what they do. A report link also opens them up to a tiny liability of 'I reported it and you did nothing', so they'll likely default to leaning on ban first ask questions later. Again, just like Youtube has. Messy, but interesting to follow what they do.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by Dewie on Saturday August 03, 2013 @11:26AM
(#6152352)
One possible solution might be to only let people that have registered with their real name report abuse easily, and they can report anyone (real name or not). These are the people who people can easily track down, so death threats are much more frightening to receive for these people. They will probably abuse the report function less since they feel like they are interacting in an open public space with their real identity, and I guess they might be easier to ban from the service if they abuse it.
The problem would be to find out who is actually registering with real names, but I think Facebook have done this for a while now. It shouldn't be a problem for people that are a bit famous, and with the lopsided amount of people on Twitter that are followed compared to the whole userbase, I guess it might mostly be decently famous people that would have the want or need to register with their real names.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by stfu on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:54AM
(#6152065)
I absolutely dislike this development. It seems beyond my understanding why Twitter is becoming the judge over which value systems around the world are the right ones to enforce and which ones are the wrong ones.
If they want to play that whole culture sensitivity game, they also need to censor all negative statements against religious figures - because there is certainly some nation, somewhere in the world, which has laws against that.
It seems to me absolutely unacceptable why Twitter is bowing to free-speech censorship of one country (U.K.) and not of another (let's say all the Arabic Nations).
Either you subscribe to the rigorous interpretation of free speech in the U.S. or you have to respect each Nation's individual understanding of free speech. Otherwise this is pure cultural imperialism.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by yummyfajitas on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:20AM
(#6152132)
What's wrong with cultural imperialism? Some cultures just suck, and cultural relativism is nonsense.
"This burning of widows is your custom; prepare the funeral pile. But my nation has also a custom. When men burn women alive we hang them, and confiscate all their property. My carpenters shall therefore erect gibbets on which to hang all concerned when the widow is consumed. Let us all act according to national customs."
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by marvin on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:53AM
(#6152238)
Cultural imperialism is wrong when you can't be absolutely, unequivocally certain that your own culture is in the right. Which means that most of the time, cultural imperialism is bad. I don't know how much you've been travelling, but every place you'll visit you will see that there are big and small differences. Most of these will be weird to you, and some will be offensive. This is true even for very similar cultures, like for instance those of Australia and the United States. It becomes pretty obvious that it's usually impossible to be right in the scientific sense, when it comes to customs and cultural norms.
I think we can safely say that witch-burning, widow-burning, genital mutilation (might there be an interesting observation about a popular US custom here?) and torture are all bad enough to warrant a bit of pressure. But outside of human rights violations, or maybe things that most cultures would agree is bad, these questions become fuzzy enough that you'll be more likely to look like a jackass than do any good. Try to imagine how cultural imperialism would look to you if, for instance, India was the global superpower and not the United States.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by DanBC on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:42AM
(#6151935)
I don;t know if there's a cultural difference, but people in the UK are generally okay with preventing people making threats to rape, kill, or bomb women.
All of those are currently illegal.
I'm not sure what Twitter should do - include an abuse button that sends reports to a Twitter team who then report people to the relevant police? Or who then collect evidence in case the police contact Twitter (with suitable legal documentation)?
People do go to jail in the UK for making stupid comments on the Internet.
Being able to report illegal content seems like a reasonable request. Being able to report content that breaks the ToS / AUP seems like a reasonable request. Protecting the free speech rights of people who are saying unpopular (but not illegal nor ToS violating) things shouldn't be a barrier to protecting people from harm.
I guess they might want to have some kind of transparency report to show how much stuff gets taken down, how often, and what kind of thing it is.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by smtddr on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:02AM
(#6151971)
> Protecting the free speech rights of people who are saying unpopular (but not illegal nor ToS violating) things shouldn't be a barrier to protecting people from harm.
I don't agree with this. Mainly because "protecting people from harm" is not well defined. There are people who seem scared of their own shadow and see nearly everything as potential harm.
EDIT: Not to diminish/trivialize the seriousness of this particular situation, but I still cannot agree with the sentence I quoted as being generally acceptable. As in, I don't want to see a law with that exact sentence in it.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by nemof on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:07AM
(#6151985)
This seems kind of facile.
Women are being threatened with violence, rape and death. Even if these are not threats people intend to carry out, to those receiving them they are deeply distressing. The threats are meant to intimidate and silence. Why should anyone put up with that?
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by onebaddude on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:40AM
(#6152034)
>Why should anyone put up with that?
They shouldn't. Some comments are obviously unacceptable. That's easy. The problem is, as always, where do you draw the line?
It's the comments at the margins of "acceptability" that are the most difficult to deal with and where the arguments of censorship are sure to come from. "You know it when you see it" is not easy to apply.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by nknighthb on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:39AM
(#6152183)
> The problem is, as always, where do you draw the line?
Threats of unlawful violence. This isn't hard.
> It's the comments at the margins
The US legal system is pretty explicitly biased towards defendants in gray areas, and most marginal cases will never be prosecuted or be thrown out by the judge.
Those that make it through to trial will have a jury determine whether a comment is a threat beyond reasonable doubt, and then the trial judge and at least two appellate judges will have to agree that the jury's verdict was not unreasonable.
Depending on the precise posture of the case, there are tens of judges and an army of clerks beyond that who may see the case cross their desks and provide at least cursory review.
And US courts pay very, very close attention to criminal cases based on speech.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by onebaddude on Saturday August 03, 2013 @07:24PM
(#6153803)
>The US legal system is pretty explicitly biased towards defendants in gray areas
I'm sure Twitter, its users and the legal system are just dying to have marginal cases decided by the courts.
What you've described is the problem I was referring to. One person says one thing, another says something else. A third party has to make the decision on whether it's acceptable or not. That's cumbersome, not very clear cut, and leads to one disgruntled party or at least some controversy.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by nknighthb on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:39PM
(#6154029)
No third party has to make a decision for Twitter to decide something is unacceptable on its platform, and I would hope Twitter would be much stricter with people who make threats than courts.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by RodericDay on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:24AM
(#6152014)
I agree. It always sounds a bit phony when people bring up the "freedom of speech" defense, as in "if we relinquish our right to use slurs, we won't be able to topple authoritarian tyrannical governments".
The general idea is not worthless, but it's disconnected from reality.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by betterunix on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:56AM
(#6152070)
It is not about toppling authoritarian governments. The right to speak freely is important for any democratic system to function. People have to be able to voice their complaints and criticisms.
The problem is that any system that could be used to prevent people from making rape threats on the Internet could and inevitably would be used to silence various forms of dissent. We have seen this sort of thing before:
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by scholia on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:36AM
(#6152181)
Your example has nothing to do with the law, and dissent wasn't being silenced. It was entirely down to Apple, which has made a commercial decision not to distribute certain types of material. This doesn't prevent the same material being distributed by other means.
Yes, Apple is the same as Walmart in laying the dead hand of censorship on popular culture with the aim of increasing its own profits, but in most cases, there is not a legal compulsion to do so.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by stfu on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:11AM
(#6152112)
I hope you come with a big van when you take in all the "i hope you die" commentators on YouTube. Policing the internet of all distressing talk is just a ridiculous idea.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by nemof on Saturday August 03, 2013 @12:54PM
(#6152585)
strangely I wasn't suggesting all of the internet should be patrolled, why would you conflate my statement with that?
I think content platforms like twitter do have a responsibility to make their spaces reasonably safe for their users. This means not allowing one user to make threats against another.
There's a difference between hoping bad something might happen to someone, and threatening to rape them, come round to their house and stab them or telling them you've planted a bomb on their car. Would you argue otherwise?
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by stfu on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:44AM
(#6152202)
Well, you might think so. But in Britain you might need to go all the way to the High Court to establish the notion that things are not always meant the way they are written: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-19009344
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by nknighthb on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:57AM
(#6152250)
I actually have very little problem with that case. I think the tweet read plainly as a threat and an incredibly stupid thing to say.
I would have been happier if it had been handled with an investigation and warning and not make it to prosecution, but as far as I'm concerned, the guy deserved some nontrivial inconvenience. I'm kind of ambivalent about the fact that the conviction was quashed.
He wasn't even sent to prison. He was fined. I don't think that's a wholly unreasonable way for society to say "don't do that".
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by alan_cx on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:58AM
(#6151959)
Free speech in the UK is under massive threat. But no one really cares. Much like the US reaction to the NSA thing. People think it wont have and effect on them, so they just ignore it. People who do care about free speech, and privacy, are subtly marginalized as radicals, which is presented as being a step or two away from being a terrorist or pervert.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by scholia on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:25AM
(#6152016)
Free speech does not include the right to threaten rape or violence, or to harass women. That is the case both online an offline. Try saying something like this in a loud voice in a pub and see how you get on:
https://twitter.com/femfreq/status/363160225873805312
Of course, free speech does allow a nutjob creationist to pervert science education in Texas, but that's another matter.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by makomk on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:34AM
(#6152173)
Define "harassing", and "women" too for that matter.
One of the louder and more influential friends of the woman behind the successful Twitter abuse reporting petition is a particularly charming radical feminist called Cathy Brennan. Brennan believes that trans women are really men attacking women's rights by masquerading as women, and deals with this by systematically outing and doxxing them - we're taking names, photos, addresses, jobs in some cases. She's been known to call the FBI on them and falsely label them as pedophiles (because all trans women are pedophiles in her eyes).
She doesn't consider this harassment. She does, however, consider anyone who objects to her or anyone else doing this - no matter how politely - to be a form of harassment. In addition, she has an organised group of allies with the same views who she gets to dogpile site owners, often successfully. (She's certainly managed to get Wordpress.com blogs reinstated that spectacularly violate the ToS and common decency reinstated, in one case by appealing to Matt Mullenweg directly.)
Naturally, she entirely supports the new Twitter abuse reporting functionality.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by scholia on Saturday August 03, 2013 @11:00AM
(#6152265)
The abuse of women on Twitter is vicious and very common. Much of it is also illegal. There's no excuse for ignoring it, and the abuse button looks like the best available answer for roughly 400 million users.
I'll be interested if you can come up with a better one. Complaining about edge-cases has its place but doesn't actually provide an answer.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by betterunix on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:49AM
(#6152050)
The problem here is that any system that is used to fight threats of rape or violence will inevitably be used to silence political dissent, criticisms of corporations, etc. The existence of trolls is the price of free speech on the Internet.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by scholia on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:22AM
(#6152143)
And the evidence for that is... where exactly? There's plenty of criticism of corporations and governments, as long as you're not threatening them with violence.
Criticism is silenced by other laws, such as libel. Threats to rape women have nothing to do with it.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by makomk on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:21AM
(#6152009)
Protecting the free speech rights of people who are saying unpopular (but not illegal nor ToS violating) things shouldn't be a barrier to protecting people from harm.
Shouldn't be in theory, but essentially everyone with any pull in the public debate seems to want Twitter to ban based on whether the user's opinions are politically correct. So, for example, they argue that telling someone to choke on their own vomit is abusive when their opponents do it to them but a vital part of activism that must be protected when they do it to someone they consider deserving.
There's also signficant debate over whether moderators can even enforce policies in a fair and unbiased way: http://storify.com/andustar/twitter-moderation To be honest, I've never seen it happen ever.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by teamonkey on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:35AM
(#6152029)
There's a right to free speech in the US but nothing to say it has to exist on any particular platform. This is no different from banning people on forums (except for the unscalable moderation problems, of course).
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by 6d0debc071 on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:01AM
(#6152080)
You get rape threats if you go on Xbox live and the like too. People seem to have mostly dealt with this sort of thing by banning the user from the service.
The behaviour's really not acceptable. But... do we really need the state involved to deal with some teenager who thinks they're funny?
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by osfp on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:17AM
(#6151893)
This is the death of twitter, it will become just another propaganda machine. People who like propaganda machine will continue to use twitter, people who don't like propaganda machine will use other microblogging tools instead of twitter.
That's awful and obviously shouldn't be allowed. On the other hand, given how serious rape threats are, you would presumably agree that anyone who used those rape threats to pressure for censorship of political viewpoints they disagreed with was trivialising rape and should be called out for doing so?
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by makomk on Saturday August 03, 2013 @10:19AM
(#6152128)
No. It is, so far as I know, possible for Twitter to intervene against rape threats without also engaging in censorship of undesirable political viewpoints.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by alan_cx on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:01AM
(#6151966)
Interesting that lower down the comment is referred to as a joke. However, things said that are clearly jokes, can result in arrest and prosecution, then jail.
Re:Twitter boss 'sorry' to abused women
by ronaldx on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:56AM
(#6151958)
> This is the death of twitter
Quite possibly the opposite:
If this leads to a requirement for microblogging tools to manage their content, Twitter has the most resources to throw at the problem. This allows them to protect their position as the largest incumbent.
"Twitter's 'report abuse' button on the iPhone application goes through to the old reporting form. What we're looking for is an overhaul of the system which sits behind the button.
"The current process is lengthy, complicated and impossible to use if you're under sustained attack like I have been.
"Right now, all the emphasis is on the victim, often under intense pressure, to report rather than for Twitter to track down the perpetrator and stop them."
-----------------
Two thoughts:
One, the expectations here for the turnaround time for Twitter to add new functionality to its system seem to be somewhat unrealistic.
Two, perhaps Twitter wants users reporting abuse to fill out a form (perhaps they could make it shorter if it's overly lengthy) as a filter to make sure only real abuse cases are filed, as opposed to, say, a system where anyone who doesn't like a Tweet clicks an abuse button, and that Tweet is immediately censored, or one in which Twitter hires a team of 50 outsourcers to manually sort through tens of thousands of daily abuse claims.
A la "Flag for spam" on youtube comments. I would hesitantly estimate that perhaps 1% of comments which appear with a "This has been flagged as spam" warning are actually spam.
I'm not convinced it would result in wrongly removing a lot of people, since there is some form of karma in the number of followers and the number of lists someone is on.
Of course, it would be nice to have some recourse to an independent appeal if something goes wrong. However, Google manages without one (1), and its decisions can have devastating personal and financial consequences. That's not the case with Twitter, where there is no real barrier to creating accounts. Including spam accounts.
(1) Unless you happen to be buddies with someone at Google.
Mmm, well, there you're changing your argument on me ^_^;
Okay, let's talk about that instead. Problems: False positives, (from whose perspective?) low staff to customer ratio.
Potential solutions:
Recruit volunteer staff
Pros: More staff. Cons: Some of them are going to be evil.
Let users report people they don't want to hear from (as you point out, this is how it will work)
Pros: Reduces staff tasks Cons: Again, might be used for evil
So, essentially what we seem to be looking at with the above problems is a trust issue. If you give people binary access to total power, even on a probabilistic basis as per the report function, then it's going to be abuse.
Potential solutions:
Give people more limited forms of power than banning and not banning.
Pros: - varies Cons: Less deterrents?
How might we do that?
Potential solutions: Let people ban others from their accounts.
Pros: No longer have to worry about people who just don't like someone banning them. Cons: Loses a lot of the social deterrent effect, people who joke about rape probably don't care about continuing to talk to the person they're attacking anyway. Cons: Doesn't let you network with people who are likely to share your values, so you'll get exposed to attacks anyway.
(This seems to be the current state of affairs - I don't really use twitter so I don't know, but suggestions on pages seem to imply it.)
If we solve the second problem there, the first one becomes less of an issue. At this point it starts to look like a networking and evidence problem. If we have ban groups - that you can join or unjoin as you please, to make abuse less likely, and have each individual user's decisions absolutely override any group level decision for their account.
Okay, what are the potential problems with that?
How would you vote?
If someone's banned from one person's account gets banned from all of them, then as the group increases the power of any individual within that group will increase.
Require more than one person to make a decision to get rid of someone?
How do we stop groups of thugs just voting to shut someone up?
Choose a representative sample? Say by forwarding the reported post to three people within the group and having them all sign off on it.
Downside is you duplicate work - upside is you reduce the potential for them all to be evil - and if the group itself is evil then it's not a group that people would want to be part of anyway.
How do you keep trolls out? If the group consistently votes against your reports, then your reports stop being received?
==========================
I don't know, admittedly this isn't my area and this is like ten minutes thought. But it doesn't seem to me like an absolutely unsolvable problem as much as it seems a bit tricky.
The problem would be to find out who is actually registering with real names, but I think Facebook have done this for a while now. It shouldn't be a problem for people that are a bit famous, and with the lopsided amount of people on Twitter that are followed compared to the whole userbase, I guess it might mostly be decently famous people that would have the want or need to register with their real names.
If they want to play that whole culture sensitivity game, they also need to censor all negative statements against religious figures - because there is certainly some nation, somewhere in the world, which has laws against that.
It seems to me absolutely unacceptable why Twitter is bowing to free-speech censorship of one country (U.K.) and not of another (let's say all the Arabic Nations).
Either you subscribe to the rigorous interpretation of free speech in the U.S. or you have to respect each Nation's individual understanding of free speech. Otherwise this is pure cultural imperialism.
"This burning of widows is your custom; prepare the funeral pile. But my nation has also a custom. When men burn women alive we hang them, and confiscate all their property. My carpenters shall therefore erect gibbets on which to hang all concerned when the widow is consumed. Let us all act according to national customs."
Charles Napier, British Commander of India
I think we can safely say that witch-burning, widow-burning, genital mutilation (might there be an interesting observation about a popular US custom here?) and torture are all bad enough to warrant a bit of pressure. But outside of human rights violations, or maybe things that most cultures would agree is bad, these questions become fuzzy enough that you'll be more likely to look like a jackass than do any good. Try to imagine how cultural imperialism would look to you if, for instance, India was the global superpower and not the United States.
http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html has some good observations about cognitive bias regarding social customs.
All of those are currently illegal.
I'm not sure what Twitter should do - include an abuse button that sends reports to a Twitter team who then report people to the relevant police? Or who then collect evidence in case the police contact Twitter (with suitable legal documentation)?
People do go to jail in the UK for making stupid comments on the Internet.
Here's an English 'troll' who made threats against US schools: (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-22813326)
Being able to report illegal content seems like a reasonable request. Being able to report content that breaks the ToS / AUP seems like a reasonable request. Protecting the free speech rights of people who are saying unpopular (but not illegal nor ToS violating) things shouldn't be a barrier to protecting people from harm.
I guess they might want to have some kind of transparency report to show how much stuff gets taken down, how often, and what kind of thing it is.
I don't agree with this. Mainly because "protecting people from harm" is not well defined. There are people who seem scared of their own shadow and see nearly everything as potential harm.
EDIT: Not to diminish/trivialize the seriousness of this particular situation, but I still cannot agree with the sentence I quoted as being generally acceptable. As in, I don't want to see a law with that exact sentence in it.
Women are being threatened with violence, rape and death. Even if these are not threats people intend to carry out, to those receiving them they are deeply distressing. The threats are meant to intimidate and silence. Why should anyone put up with that?
They shouldn't. Some comments are obviously unacceptable. That's easy. The problem is, as always, where do you draw the line?
It's the comments at the margins of "acceptability" that are the most difficult to deal with and where the arguments of censorship are sure to come from. "You know it when you see it" is not easy to apply.
Threats of unlawful violence. This isn't hard.
> It's the comments at the margins
The US legal system is pretty explicitly biased towards defendants in gray areas, and most marginal cases will never be prosecuted or be thrown out by the judge.
Those that make it through to trial will have a jury determine whether a comment is a threat beyond reasonable doubt, and then the trial judge and at least two appellate judges will have to agree that the jury's verdict was not unreasonable.
Depending on the precise posture of the case, there are tens of judges and an army of clerks beyond that who may see the case cross their desks and provide at least cursory review.
And US courts pay very, very close attention to criminal cases based on speech.
I'm sure Twitter, its users and the legal system are just dying to have marginal cases decided by the courts.
What you've described is the problem I was referring to. One person says one thing, another says something else. A third party has to make the decision on whether it's acceptable or not. That's cumbersome, not very clear cut, and leads to one disgruntled party or at least some controversy.
"Crap! Robin Hood airport is closed. You've got a week and a bit to get your shit together otherwise I'm blowing the airport sky high!!"
£385 and £600 costs.
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Joke_Trial)
The general idea is not worthless, but it's disconnected from reality.
The problem is that any system that could be used to prevent people from making rape threats on the Internet could and inevitably would be used to silence various forms of dissent. We have seen this sort of thing before:
http://www.niemanlab.org/2010/04/mark-fiore-can-win-a-pulitz...
Yes, Apple is the same as Walmart in laying the dead hand of censorship on popular culture with the aim of increasing its own profits, but in most cases, there is not a legal compulsion to do so.
Otherwise, you've invented a hypothetical problem leading to a hypothetical event.
I think content platforms like twitter do have a responsibility to make their spaces reasonably safe for their users. This means not allowing one user to make threats against another.
There's a difference between hoping bad something might happen to someone, and threatening to rape them, come round to their house and stab them or telling them you've planted a bomb on their car. Would you argue otherwise?
I would have been happier if it had been handled with an investigation and warning and not make it to prosecution, but as far as I'm concerned, the guy deserved some nontrivial inconvenience. I'm kind of ambivalent about the fact that the conviction was quashed.
He wasn't even sent to prison. He was fined. I don't think that's a wholly unreasonable way for society to say "don't do that".
Of course, free speech does allow a nutjob creationist to pervert science education in Texas, but that's another matter.
One of the louder and more influential friends of the woman behind the successful Twitter abuse reporting petition is a particularly charming radical feminist called Cathy Brennan. Brennan believes that trans women are really men attacking women's rights by masquerading as women, and deals with this by systematically outing and doxxing them - we're taking names, photos, addresses, jobs in some cases. She's been known to call the FBI on them and falsely label them as pedophiles (because all trans women are pedophiles in her eyes).
She doesn't consider this harassment. She does, however, consider anyone who objects to her or anyone else doing this - no matter how politely - to be a form of harassment. In addition, she has an organised group of allies with the same views who she gets to dogpile site owners, often successfully. (She's certainly managed to get Wordpress.com blogs reinstated that spectacularly violate the ToS and common decency reinstated, in one case by appealing to Matt Mullenweg directly.)
Naturally, she entirely supports the new Twitter abuse reporting functionality.
I'll be interested if you can come up with a better one. Complaining about edge-cases has its place but doesn't actually provide an answer.
Criticism is silenced by other laws, such as libel. Threats to rape women have nothing to do with it.
Shouldn't be in theory, but essentially everyone with any pull in the public debate seems to want Twitter to ban based on whether the user's opinions are politically correct. So, for example, they argue that telling someone to choke on their own vomit is abusive when their opponents do it to them but a vital part of activism that must be protected when they do it to someone they consider deserving.
There's also signficant debate over whether moderators can even enforce policies in a fair and unbiased way: http://storify.com/andustar/twitter-moderation To be honest, I've never seen it happen ever.
The behaviour's really not acceptable. But... do we really need the state involved to deal with some teenager who thinks they're funny?
That's awful and obviously shouldn't be allowed. On the other hand, given how serious rape threats are, you would presumably agree that anyone who used those rape threats to pressure for censorship of political viewpoints they disagreed with was trivialising rape and should be called out for doing so?
you're just playing cheap word games for politics.
http://www.wired.com/business/2010/04/apple-bans-satire/
Or maybe "just" this:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/06/29/texas-teen...
Weird.
Quite possibly the opposite:
If this leads to a requirement for microblogging tools to manage their content, Twitter has the most resources to throw at the problem. This allows them to protect their position as the largest incumbent.