News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by baddox on Friday August 02, 2013 @08:46PM (#6150551)
The thing is, they literally would not have to change a single thing after releasing the source code. They could refrain from looking at a single pull request. But perhaps their fear is that community additions may lead to a variously forked ecosystem which could dilute the "Dwarf Fortress" name thus dilute their grand vision.
Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by shazow on Friday August 02, 2013 @08:56PM (#6150580)
Indeed. They have a captive audience right now which donates on average more than $4,000/mo for the work of Tarn and Zach.

Take the +12 month release cycles, there will surely be more active open source forks than what the Adams' can compete with, resulting not only in loss of their revenue stream but also loss of control of their vision. Perhaps this would be an altruistic benefit to the community, but probably a solid loss for the creators unless they're willing and succeed in diving in and leading the community of contributors as a whole.

Very risky.

Also from another interview, Tarn spoke about how he sees Dwarf Fortress as his life's work. This is the masterpiece that he would spend the rest of his life perfecting. Imagine a master painter like Picasso working on a piece for nearly a decade, being asked to let the community contribute to it so that it will be completed sooner.

Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by crazypyro on Saturday August 03, 2013 @12:10AM (#6151078)
Exactly, we should understand the fact that open sourcing is not always compatiable with a work of art. (Games are art now, right?)
Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by eslaught on Friday August 02, 2013 @11:56PM (#6151045)
Sure, but look at what happened to Arc. There was excitement in the beginning, but since pg wasn't really taking patches (except bug fixes), the community forked the project and started working cool stuff on their own. Eventually, pg released new versions, which never incorporated the community fork's changes, so bit rot crept in, and people gradually lost interest and drifted away from the project. The project isn't dead exactly (is Lisp ever really dead?), but it isn't the hub of activity it was at the beginning.

I don't think dilution is main threat here. I think turning Dwarf Fortress into a viable open source community takes effort, and just letting the code into the wild won't necessarily accomplish much.

Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by pavel_lishin on Friday August 02, 2013 @10:09PM (#6150766)
If someone forked Dwarf Fortress and changed the key bindings to a sane default, I would switch to Midget Mountain or Little People Palace or whatever in a heart beat.
Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by axus on Saturday August 03, 2013 @08:10AM (#6151881)
Someone tried making their own clone, with a better interface and gameplay in the direction they wanted it to go. It's hard to replicate the amount of effort that has gone into DF.

http://www.goblincamp.com/

Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by AJ007 on Saturday August 03, 2013 @12:25PM (#6152510)
There are a lot of "clones", but these are essentially DF lite. They mimic the basic gameplay of digging under ground and building some sort of fort. Read through the past 3 months of updates ( http://www.bay12games.com/dwarves/ ) and you will see how ludicrously complex & detailed the game has become. You can't explain some of these things in a feature checklist, but rather with paragraphs.
Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by jamii on Saturday August 03, 2013 @09:06AM (#6151982)
Gnomoria seems to be coming along:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E75mL6R42i0

Re:Dwarf Fortress in 2013 by axus on Saturday August 03, 2013 @01:09PM (#6152615)
Lots of updates, but it's not open source as far as I can tell.