There's the famous Rails vulnerability due to YAML. Python needed to add 'yaml.safe_load'.
YAML is a little too rich. It's always one poorly thought out convenience feature away from disaster.
It has parsers for nearly every language, I wrote one for js: http://npmjs.org/package/tomljs
I think parsers for JSON and Yaml, INI etc should be designed in such a way as to make it impossible to assign anything like an object, class, function, etc. Numbers, strings, and collections of numbers and strings... that's all you should get (though obviously "string" is frought with peril.) Anything more is unnecessarily complex.
The way to have avoided the issue would have been for JSON to have a grammar that broke eval(). But one could argue the ability to pass JSON into eval() to get JavaScript is one of the reasons JSON became popular to begin with.
YAML is easy to type, even with the whitespace. So is INI. And as verbose as XML is, it's easier, ime, to type than JSON. Of those four, JSON is the hardest to write by hand; certainly it's the one I make most mistakes with, to extent I have a particular technique for writing it out (prefixing the commas). As a result JSON as a config file format is tedious, verbose, and error prone; its sweet spot is a machine interchange format that a human can debug/read if needed.
Rails RCE, sup
But I do like the Rails convention of using YAML format and have adopted that in my own code as much as possible.
--- !ruby/hash:ActionDispatch::Routing::RouteSet::NamedRouteCollection
'foo; eval(eval(puts '=== hello there'.inspect);': !ruby/object:OpenStruct
table:
:defaults: {}
Allowing people to run arbitrary code on rails servers.[0] http://rubysource.com/anatomy-of-an-exploit-an-in-depth-look...
But for over the wire communication, JSON makes more sense than YAML, not only because parsing unsafe YAML from an untrusted client could cause exploits like you mentioned, but also because YAML is dependent on indentation and line breaks, and therefore makes communication with the client side much more awkward than just sending JSON to the client or receiving JSON from it.
Also, many of the security holes in YAML come from its use as a serialization format which can represent native classes. I wish the YAML parsers had more explicit support for simple data schemas which would reduce the security risk and be sufficient for most configuration files.
Adding easy syntax highlighting is my next step to address this problem.
For -configuration- you want a simpler format; INI is worth considering, as is http://p3rl.org/JSONY which is ingy's implementation of a vision we thrashed out for a more sysadmin-friendly config format.
+1 re YAML
Even with indentation problems, the time saved in not typing curly brackets, extra quotation marks, and commas, and the time saved in not having to visually parse these when reading YAML more than makes up for the occasional data structure bug caused by bad indentation.
JSON works great for on the fly communication with frontends that are running JavaScript, or for communication between JavaScript processes like Node.js servers. But for configuration files and other things that need comments YAML is many times better, both for it's clean, Markdown reminiscent structure, and its native comment support.
Node.js has a great module called js-yaml (https://github.com/nodeca/js-yaml) which automatically registers handlers for .yml and .yaml files, allowing you to require them in your Node.js code just like you can with JSON files.
It also comes with a YAML parser for the browser side of things, so if you want you could even communicate YAML directly from the server to the client side, although frankly I don't see much advantage to sending YAML over the wire instead of JSON. (And as others have mentioned below untrusted YAML sources could insert malicious objects in YAML, so I wouldn't recommend this technique.)
You can even use YAML for your package.json in a Node program: (https://npmjs.org/package/npm-yaml)