(https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4825751)
(https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4826367)
Here's another newspaper article about the scam. (http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2012/may/23/credit-card-user...)
EDIT: cultural note - we don't[1] pay to receive a phone call, even with cell phones. Perhaps that makes a difference?
[1] Well, with normal accounts that is. Obviously free-phone 0800 numbers etc are different.
If you think way back, before dtmf/touch-tone phones, when you dialed a number, the line clicked. You press one, the line clicks once. For zero, 10 clicks. This is backwards compatible all the way to rotary phones.
Those clicks are the line being closed and re-opened in rapid succession. You dialled by 'hanging up' repeatedly. So the line can't close the moment you hang up - there's a grace period while it waits for the next click. If the initiating party does't hang up, they emulate this grace period until the exchange times out.
Ever see the "flash" key in a phone? Add a few milisseconds to that and a modern phone system should hangup.
If I remember the story correctly, this resulted in some debate followed by a law change, such that now if the called party hangs up, you have only a few seconds before the connection is broken.
I don't know how it went for the husband though...
In a proper telecom setup, if the hang-up time is longer than the flash time (a few hundred milliseconds) then the call should end - period. This allows you to hang up properly while allowing for call waiting features and the like.
As long as I tell my friend "I'm going to call up, pretend you are whoever I ask for", then when I call up and say "hello is Mr X there?" it's irrelevant whether I just dialed my friend, or whether he was sat on the line waiting for me to fake dial.
The person being duped provides a name and a number.
You leave your line open with a friend. Then you dial the new number, which doesn't work because the line is open, but it appears to work, fooling the person being duped.
Dialing the new number is a required part of the illusion so the person you are duping believes you are calling the person they provided the info for.
If you just dial your friends number and don't use the fake number... and they see you doing that... then that's stupid and your friends would have to be exceedingly trashed to fall for what is essentially you just dialing a friends number and talking to them.
What I don't understand is how the scammers got his landline number?
This is a really elaborate scam, btw. The few times my cc# has been stolen, some dude just makes a card and uses at someplace like a hardware store and buys $1500 worth of tools before the bank frauds it out. In, out, no contact with me, just a sprint.
Maybe to add a little bit of diversity:
At least in Germany, I don't recall this ever working.
It also meant you would accidentally DoS someone by failing to hang up correctly if you initated the call - the pre-mobile equivalent of someone phoning you from the inside of their pocket...
I didn't remember anything about the conversation, only that I got up from bed with a pounding headache and thought no more of it. A few days later my godmother phoned me up:
"Do you remember what you did a few days ago?"
"I think I phoned you up?"
It turns out that while she was talking at length I had passed out from the booze. She had spoken for some time and then I hadn't replied. After some time, finding the call strange, she hung up and picked up, only to find the sound of silence; my room in which I had passed out. This was unfortunate as she had quite a few phone calls to make and she was effectively blocked from doing so. Presumably at some point I came back to some kind of consciousness that was capable of putting the receiver down and staggering to bed, but not capable of remembering. Thankfully I was forgiven and suffered only the punishment of wry disapproval.
So yes - as a young man I accidentally DoS'ed my Godmother because of stupidity and Stella Artois.
Can someone explain this? This seems like a pretty glaring and obvious issue that I'm sure I would have experienced before. Is he saying that if he hangs up the phone and picks it up again and the person at the other end doesn't hang up, then the conversation isn't over?