News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by jpwagner on Friday May 15, 2009 @04:19PM (#611269)
Wolfram|Alpha is focused on academic use-cases (for now), not searching for your own name or an online newspaper/blog.

It is purposely NOT Google.

Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by jkincaid on Friday May 15, 2009 @04:34PM (#611299)
Even with academic queries it's very hit or miss. When you get something that returns relevant results it's a Eureka! moment, and you'll be impressed. But then you try a similar query and get zilch.

I suspect academics will try their queries on Wolfram first and turn to Google if that doesn't work. But after seeing too many "no results found" messages, they might just skip the Wolfram step entirely. Google might not have the fancy graphs, but it almost always returns some kind of relevant data.

Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by asciilifeform on Friday May 15, 2009 @04:33PM (#611298)
> Wolfram|Alpha is focused on academic use-cases

I have, so far, found it nearly useless academically. (Computational biology, to be specific.) Perhaps it will improve with time.

Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by jerf on Friday May 15, 2009 @07:21PM (#611550)
Honest curiousity: What computational-biology question would you ask Wolfram|Alpha that you would expect a better answer to, vs. either Google, conventional journal search, or asking your own local computing resources? (In particular the questions that I know enough to ask, such as they are, would seem to be more suited to local resources.)

(In fact, I'd open that question up to any other similar discipline.)

Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by asciilifeform on Saturday May 16, 2009 @03:04PM (#612463)
Try getting any but the most widely used protein sequences out of it.
Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by henning on Friday May 15, 2009 @04:27PM (#611284)
I agree, trying to out-Google Google is a bad idea.
Re:Putting Wolfram Alpha To The Test: Not Super-Impressed (B... by paul9290 on Friday May 15, 2009 @08:51PM (#611643)
It looks like the launch of this is going better then Cuil and most people seem to understand that they should give it a chance(time) to mature into something extremely useful! It looks very promising!

Google began in 1997 or 98. I heard of it in 2000 but did not start using it til 2002/2003.