Also, my guess is that the flat base is there because that's what's cool these days. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing: for a lot of people, having something that looks modern and recent is pretty important too. Just that I'm worried about it, a little bit.
Bootstrap is great for having some underlying architecture but the visual styles should rarely be used. Keeping the original bootstrap style says a few things about you and your product: You're either lazy, poor at design, or don't care enough to hire a competent designer.
I don't know if it was designed by focus group or not, but a lot of work went into flat design. It helps to start with understanding the reasoning behind Microsoft's Metro design language [1][2], which is one of the originators of the flat trend.
In a nutshell, it's aimed primarily at touchscreen devices, but the principles that make it work there also happen to work on most other screens - remove all "chrome" (unnecessary shadows, 3D elements, etc) and focus on the content (strong typography, media, organized with whitespace).
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metro_%28design_language%29
[2]: http://www.microsoft.com/design/toolbox/tutorials/windows-ph...
And: Bootstrap is not intended to be used "as is" in every case. It's supposed to give you an quick start, something you can extend and customize as you see fit. It does a terrific job at that.
Having a good enough default means I can spend my time improving the product, rather than worrying about something that neither the customers nor I care much about as long as it's good enough. And stock bootstrap very much is - that's one of the things I love so much about it.
With the flat design stuff, now I'll have to think about it, look for different solutions like themes, or maybe just going for it and hoping it's not a problem, and generally spend time not making our ebook conversions better.
Ultimately, it's not that big a deal, and I'm still way better off than without bootstrap, but I do consider it somewhat of a regression.
There are none. Web design trends like flat design are fashion.
(Anecdotally) For someone non technical, change is usually bad when it comes to interfaces. I think that simple and "easy to understand" is a great direction and have tried using flat and "ios7 color&font weight differentiated buttons" in some recent projects. I have seen teething issues when moving towards UIs where the visual definition of a button does not include some "quasi-3d" aspect. Simply differentiating by text or background color makes a lot of users apprehensive about touching things, afraid they will produce an unexpected or unwanted result. I've seen them adapt rather quickly, but there has always been some 'what do I press?' stage. Not exactly test data, but the results have been pretty consistent.
EDIT: I should note that usually adding a stroke to just the bottom edge of a clickable button or a slight shadow/gradient usually helps. You can see this style in a lot of recent google products and I think it works really well (and I bet they tested it before deploying!). This method allows you to remove or tone down the shadows/gradients/textures from your navbars and other items without having them feel disconnected from your buttons.
There was a time that some believed removing the underline from links was nothing but a design led trend and a move in the wrong direction. People figured it out, adjusted, and no site missed a beat.
My site, www.liberwriter.com is squarely aimed at non-technical people who are not really on top of the latest trends. I could very easily envision them having a higher cognitive load trying to figure out what is a button and what isn't and so on.
What do testing and studies show about this?