If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, then its a duck. That's the best we can do for now, whether mice or men.
That doesn't sound particularly scientific. Sometimes a bit of precision with language is nice.
In short: just because their test activated a memory doesn't mean it created one
Until then, here's a website that'll let you experience a common memory error. (http://psych.hanover.edu/JavaTest/CLE/Cognition/Cognition/fa...)
There are probably more experiments you can do on yourself to induce a false memory.
Reminds me of "Tom" from 50 first dates. Thanks for the good laugh this afternoon.
Given our species long history of pushing back the boundaries of mysticism, fear and uncertainty, it would seem presumptuous to doubt that our own minds are somehow exempt from the rules of the natural world.
It's pretty clear there is a physical basis for cognition. Some extremely pedantic philosophers may not come to the same conclusion though. If you have any doubts, here's how you can find out: get a friend to beat your head in with a baseball bat (made with preferably something tough like steel or titanium).
I mean, it's not like mice can verbalize their experience. They don't use words to tell us how they "feel" about these memories on the inside.
And in the article, it states that no new memories were actually created. Only the nature of existing memories were augmented to be negative.
From the article:
So they took an existing memory of a location, and made the mice scared of the location. That's a lot different from the claim in the headline.