News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by ealexhudson on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:14AM (#6084189)
I upvoted this because I think it's an interesting experiment. Attempting to raise $1M+ every day for a month, though, I think is insanely ambitious. Asking people for $830 for a device that they won't get for a year is asking a lot, particularly since the specs aren't worlds away from current phones (two years time, and probably $500 would get you a device with those specs, unlocked).

Worse, I just don't even get the use case. If I have to dock it with stuff to make it work, that means I need some kind of installation. Spending more money just so I can carry my PC around instead of having at home on a desk - hm, really not sure about that. People who use their mobile as a primary device tend not to have any sort of desktop, and I don't really get the impression they miss it that much.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by dkokelley on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:53AM (#6084513)
I'm wondering if the ambitious goal of $32M is part of their strategy. Given that a higher goal is less likely to be met, I (and others who might consider backing) may be willing to adjust our risk function for the $600-800 such that we are more likely to back the project. Assuming that after 30 days only $20M is raised, then the outcome is as follows:

1: Nobody is actually charged for supporting the project

2: Other interested parties (phone manufacturers and carriers) will see that there is demand for a phone that doesn't even exist yet. These interested parties might consider reaching this market to differentiate from the current phone OS leaders.

3: Canonical still gets to see their OS in smartphones.

Maybe I'm reaching at straws. I do believe them when they say that manufacturing at scale is expensive.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by bryanlarsen on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:15PM (#6084655)
I would have backed based on this theory if it was a Kickstarter project. Kickstarter uses Amazon and doesn't charge until the end of the drive. Indiegogo uses Paypal, and charges immediately, giving a refund if the drive fails. While both of these differences aren't quite showstoppers, they're enough that I didn't pull the trigger on something that seems highly unlikely to succeed. I wouldn't mind paying $600 for this thing if it actually happened, but I would mind having $600 sitting around in my rarely used paypal account.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by dangoor on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:36PM (#6084809)
You could withdraw the $600...

I do appreciate you pointing this difference out though, because it does mean that folks will have $600 (or $830) tied up in this from day 1 and not from day 31.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by sirn on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @03:45AM (#6088704)
One possible problem with withdraw later is that you're subjected to 2.5% conversion fee if you're not withdraw to US bank account. In the end some international user will need to pay PayPal about $15 to get refund.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by jellicle on Monday July 22, 2013 @03:42PM (#6086039)
So let's say this campaign comes close but doesn't reach its goal. Someone is then on the hook for close to a million dollars in credit card charges. It doesn't appear to be the individual. But the FAQ is deeply unclear as to whether it is Indiegogo or Canonical who gets to pay these fees. Anyone know?
Re:Ubuntu Edge by sspiff on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:35PM (#6084799)
In my experience, refunds on PayPal go back to your credit card. Am I wrong about this?
Re:Ubuntu Edge by rlpb on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:03PM (#6084989)
From https://www.paypal.com/webapps/helpcenter/article/?articleID...:

"If you paid with your debit card or credit card, your payment is refunded to that card."

Re:Ubuntu Edge by bryanlarsen on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:19PM (#6085102)
I've had the opposite experience, which is why I'm bringing up this issue. However, my refund was processed as a payment to me rather than a refund, so it's quite possible that your experience is the more typical one.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by jlgaddis on Monday July 22, 2013 @10:16PM (#6087792)
If you use a credit or debit card, yes. PayPal, however, does everything possible to (get you to) use ACH transfer from your bank account instead. In that case, I believe that you would end up with $600/$850 sitting in your PayPal account and withdrawing can be a PITA in some cases.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by ealexhudson on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:01PM (#6084560)
Yeah, it's quite possible they realise how unlikely the target is, and it could just be a way of attempting to demonstrate the market (given $830 is likely at one end of the bell-curve, it's a potentially interesting data point).

I find it a bit baffling. I refuse to believe Canonical want to enter the hardware market, but maybe there is a Nexus-like role for this hardware in terms of getting the ODMs to up their game. But, as a way of testing the market, I don't understand it. The FirefoxOS approach is much more appropriate, tbh, and if anything they need volume (which is going to come from the lower end of the market) not quality.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by oblique63 on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:31PM (#6084767)
> I refuse to believe Canonical want to enter the hardware market

I don't know, from all the design hints Canonical's been dropping in the last few years, it seems like they really are trying to place themselves as direct competitors to apple, however naive/overambitious that may sound. So a play for hardware wouldn't surprise me that much. I think this stunt would make much less sense if it were purely to advance an android/firefox-style mobile os strategy.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by TheLegace on Monday July 22, 2013 @10:36PM (#6087864)
In the video Mark says that they're not making it for consumers and saying that they want other companies to do it and they will show them kind of thing.

It doesn't sound to inspiring in the long term though.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by oblique63 on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:25AM (#6089012)
> they want other companies to do it and they will show them

Isn't that what the iphone inadvertently did anyway though? If Edge succeeds, the logical consequence would be that other manufacturers would start to pay attention in one form or another, Canonical just seems to be upfront about the fact and is trying to presumably leverage it somehow.

Apple's strategy is based around ios exclusivity on a limited set of 'high-end' devices though, so it's hard to predict what exactly Canonical is planning for after the Edge succeeds/fails. I'm fairly certain Shuttleworth is heavily inspired by the Apple playbook, but their hints at android-like distribution are admittedly somewhat confusing. It's almost like they want to do both modes of attack, but I'm not sure how that would work (nor how competing directly against android would succeed either for that matter). Only time will tell.

Personally, I find the sheer fact that they're actually Open and trying something new to be quite inspiring on it's own. Long-term? That's anyone's guess, but I wouldn't exactly bet against them at this point, that's for sure.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by muyuu on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:40PM (#6085218)
I also thought Light Table was insanely over-ambitious for a 1-man software project and it got funded.

Maybe Ubuntu can pull this off.

If I had not very recently bought a high end smartphone I'd chip in. I might chip in anyway.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by achiang on Monday July 22, 2013 @02:06PM (#6085380)
Manufacturing is expensive.

The vast majority of the $32M goes simply to manufacturing. The remainder covers taxes, fees, shipping, certification, and returns.

It does not cover the cost of the development team's time.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by lsiebert on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:49PM (#6086689)
Money isn't static, and the interest isn't negligible.

Assuming you can get 1 % interest per month on the 32,000,000 before paying it out, that is still 320k. They can hold it for 2-3 months and pay their developers easily.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by Guvante on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:07PM (#6086779)
You can't get 1% interest risk free in a high-interest market, let alone the current one.

If you try really hard you can get 1% a year without taking on risk.

And you can't have any risk if you are going to be manufacturing phones with that money (sorry we don't have enough phones, we bet on Apple and their stock went down 20%).

Re:Ubuntu Edge by YokoZar on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:23PM (#6086860)
US Government Treasury bonds have a 3.5% annual interest rate. I'm pretty sure that buying them does not require trying hard.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by _delirium on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:59PM (#6087031)
The grandparent was talking about 1% per month, though. That would equate to (with compounding) a 12.5% annual interest rate, which no remotely safe financial instrument is paying.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by Guvante on Monday July 22, 2013 @08:14PM (#6087372)
What bond has that high of an interest rate? I am seeing 0.3% annual rates for US bonds right now. (And that is for 2 year bonds, not very good for 1-3 month lags)
Re:Ubuntu Edge by YokoZar on Monday July 22, 2013 @08:44PM (#6087465)
Even if you only need the money for a year, there is no reason you can't buy 30 year bonds and sell them later. Short term treasury bonds get a much lower price because they are dominated by buyers that are obligated to buy them for some reason (they've even had negative interest rates in the past).
Re:Ubuntu Edge by jussij on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @01:17AM (#6088365)
> there is no reason you can't buy 30 year bonds and sell them later.

Except, there are no guarantees the price you get on the sale of those bonds will be the same as the price you initially payed.

The possibilities are you might get your money back, you might make money or you might lose money on that sale.

Edit: In fact as can be seen by the graph below the yield on 30 Year T-Bonds is going up, indicating the price of the bond is falling (as the price moves inversly to the yield).

http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/bond/30_year

NOTE: See the 6m curve from link above

Re:Ubuntu Edge by effn on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @03:53AM (#6088733)
No, short term bonds get lower yield because they carry much less interest rate risk. There's no free lunch.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by YokoZar on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:39AM (#6089182)
That cannot explain a negative interest rate.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by _delirium on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @09:18AM (#6089795)
That's just an indication of their safety. Short-term U.S. Treasuries are being used as a safe bank account by a number of people with money to park who don't trust regular banks, and don't want to expose themselves to the interest-rate risk that long-term bonds bring. This raises demand and pushes down interest rates, sometimes even into the negative range.

If you're an American with, say, $75k to park, there's no reason to put it in a treasury at negative interest, of course: you can just put it in an FDIC-insured bank account. But if you're a Cypriot with $50m to park, buying treasuries looks attractive relative to Eurobonds or Cypriot banks, and continues to look attractive even if prices rise to the point where the interest rate is moderately negative.

But in neither case should you buy a 30-year bond for short-term cash parking, unless you are either hedged against the interest-rate risk, or willing to expose yourself to a bet on the direction interest rates will move. If they move the wrong way, your $100k might be worth $90k next year, which will completely wipe out your 3.5% interest and more.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by jussij on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @03:18AM (#6094870)
> That cannot explain a negative interest rate.

Those were not bonds, but rather Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS) which are tied to CPI.

The fixed payment on five-year TIPS, known as the real yield, has been pushed below zero because the rise in the CPI is greater than the yield on regular five-year U.S. notes

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-10-25/treasury-draws-nega...

Why they were negative is because they are tied to CPI and the CPI was higher than the interest on similar short term bonds.

So provided the CPI continues to rise, these TPS securities (which are tied to CPI) will end up paying more return than similar short term bonds.

In other words the market was betting the CPI would continue to rise while short term interest rates would remain low.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by effn on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @03:48AM (#6088715)
30-year bonds do, but they are not risk-free unless you hold them to maturity.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by nobodysfool on Monday July 22, 2013 @03:50PM (#6086073)
There aren't much in the way of specs here. The screen will likely be 1024x768 or similar, seeing as how they say that they are shooting for around 300ppi in a 4.5in screen. The battery technology that they say they want is unproven, produced only in sample quantities, and has issues with the electrolyte expanding to 4x it's size (which they say will be fixed via carbon nanotubes, the latest 'magic pixie dust'). I am pretty sure they will have an announcement later on saying that they had to switch battery technologies in order to source what they need. For $800 it's quite expensive. I imagine they could easily just buy a bunch Galaxy S4s and offer that with Ubuntu as an option... that way they wouldn't have to deal with certification and all that jazz. I'd be happy to be proven wrong, but seriously people need to think about this before just handing out their money. My bet is one year from now if you had given them your money, there will be better phones out that make this one seem like a joke. Compare what they are offering to the Galaxy S4, the S4 will definitely have a better screen, it's running at 1.9ghz (will 2.1 or whatever is the fastest make much of a difference? probably not). A better battery may be great, but the S4 has great battery life, which will last almost all day, good enough for most people. I'd be surprised if I don't see batteries explode on this device if they do manage to ship with the new technology (and expensive) battery. The ram may be the one reason to purchase the device, but it would be a lot less expensive just to ask any of the vendors on Alibaba to up the ram to 4gb (as long as you are ordering in large quantities).
Re:Ubuntu Edge by morsch on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:47PM (#6086677)
Here are the specs from the page -- were they added subsequently?

    Dual boot Ubuntu mobile OS and Android
    Fully integrated Ubuntu desktop PC when docked
    Fastest multi-core CPU, 4GB RAM, 128GB storage
    4.5in 1,280 x 720 HD sapphire crystal display
    8mp low-light rear camera, 2mp front camera
    Dual-LTE, dual-band 802.11n Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 4, NFC
    GPS, accelerometer, gyro, proximity sensor, compass, barometer
    Stereo speakers with HD audio, dual-mic recording, Active Noise Cancellation
    MHL connector, 3.5mm jack
    Silicon-anode Li-Ion battery
    64 x 9 x 124mm
Re:Ubuntu Edge by voltagex_ on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:37PM (#6088099)
I wonder which will happen first, Google supporting BT4/LE on the phones that already have this built-in, or Canonical getting a phone built from scratch and having BT LE support?
Re:Ubuntu Edge by devindotcom on Monday July 22, 2013 @03:59PM (#6086110)
300ppi at 4.5in would probably be 720p - that's what the First and M4/One mini have at 4.3 in for something like 330 ppi. That would be m y guess anyway.

I'm more concerned with the promise of 4GB ram and 128GB storage. That's going to be very expensive. The highest end phones today cost more and half half or less of that. (I know, things get cheaper, but this isn't orders of 20 million, it's orders of 20,000)

Re:Ubuntu Edge by nobodysfool on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @02:08PM (#6097911)
Not only the ram. The 'sapphire screen' and battery are probably going to be the most expensive pieces of the system. I don't think anyone is complaining that their gorilla glass screen is not durable enough. The highest end phones have less ram most likely because of battery life issues. That ram has to be refreshed, and more of it means more drain on the battery. Not to mention that in android phones, they try to fill up the ram as much as possible to avoid accessing the flash storage after booting since that also drains the battery. The consequence may be longer boot times, if Ubuntu does this also.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by Synaesthesia on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:19PM (#6093278)
128gb of flash storage is like $150 retail, probably less in bulk. 4gb RAM is not expensive, yeah it's integrated, but the reason why device manufacturers hold back is they're penny pinchers who are looking to maximise profit, and they're also running mobile OS'es that don't need 4gb.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by voltagex_ on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:32PM (#6088086)
Finally, a phone that beats the storage I had in my iRiver H340 (with the extremely expensive 80GB Toshiba mini hard drive)
Re:Ubuntu Edge by DocG on Monday July 22, 2013 @02:11PM (#6085417)
The first paragraph explains it.

let me quote: "In the car industry, Formula 1 provides a commercial testbed for cutting-edge technologies. The Ubuntu Edge project aims to do the same for the mobile phone industry -- to provide a low-volume, high-technology platform, crowdfunded by enthusiasts and mobile computing professionals. A pioneering project that accelerates the adoption of new technologies and drives them down into the mainstream."

It is not for you. If you want good phone, there are plenty out there to choose from.

formula 1 car is impossible to use in everyday life. It has really specific place where it excels. Edge is probably medicore phone and medicore pc, but it is probably really good at being both at the same time.

It is wrong approach to compare it to mobile users.

Edit: quote from comment section: "It's a premier, demonstration platform, not a mass market device." -achiang

Re:Ubuntu Edge by jfb on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:19PM (#6086841)
It's an interesting project (not for me, personally, but hey, let a hundred flowers bloom and all that), but I think that they're overestimating the state of phone hardware commoditization, if they expect that they can pick and choose parts and hit their spec targets in less than a year. That seems insanely ambitious to me.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by grey-area on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @04:44AM (#6088880)
They've reached around $3.2m in their first day, so they're on track, though probably donations will slow down from now on till it nears the end. The price is pretty high, and this is not a mass market device in its current form - it's an interesting strategy to target the high end. Perhaps they see Apple as floundering in years to come, and want to take that slice of the market and work down?

It's interesting that you talk about some kind of installation. Everyone with a desktop PC already has such an installation, and many people with laptops have one too - a screen and keyboard for when they're at home, and a laptop which plugs in there, or can be separated and used independently. Works for me.

So I imagine the target market here is people who use laptops with a screen at home and would be happy with even more convenience and a smaller device to carry around. This probably isn't a realistic convergence device as it is so ambitious, at present it's more dream than reality, but one day we might all work this way.

I find it more attractive to have a hard local store of my data than the alternative of trusting cloud providers with all my data and working from thin clients.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by mtgx on Monday July 22, 2013 @03:40PM (#6086021)
They should try to get some carriers to put some money on that. They could buy hundreds or thousands at a time, if they want more diversity in their offering.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by dubcanada on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:03PM (#6084991)
One of the reasons they went with IndieGoGo vs KickStarter is probably that they know they may not reach $32M. So they'll take what they can (IndieGogo gives you what you make, vs kickstarter that you need to make more then you request in order to get it) and do what they can.

As far as I am concerned they may have just typed in a random number in the millions as people like goals.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by kklimonda on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:07PM (#6085017)
It is a Fixed Funding project so if they don't gather the entire sum it won't get funded.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by mobbom on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:06PM (#6085008)
While this is possible with IndieGoGo, they selected to only receive funds if the project is fully funded. This is detailed under the "Contribute now" button.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by dubcanada on Monday July 22, 2013 @02:02PM (#6085357)
Hrm... you're right. I'm wondering why they would do that? Does it really take $32M to create a new phone for mass market?
Re:Ubuntu Edge by DocG on Monday July 22, 2013 @02:27PM (#6085542)
at least. And it is "one run only" phone.

This is for selling the whole production series.

It is only around 40 000 phones. Most phones sell at least in millions.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by lettergram on Monday July 22, 2013 @02:46PM (#6085688)
If 40,000 people are willing to fund the initial production going mainstream would be easy. I believe in the video they even said that if enough people were interested they could get more backing.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by DocG on Monday July 22, 2013 @03:42PM (#6086034)
I think video said if this thing succeeds, then there might be similar future projects. If not, there wont be next edge or similar projects.

"The Ubuntu Edge is an exclusive production run, available only through Indiegogo"

But there is no going mainstream, it is the whole point. This is not the mainstream pc/mobile. Good quote from comment section:

"It's a premier, demonstration platform, not a mass market device." -achiang

I think what they are doing is awesome and comparison with formula 1 is pretty spot on. They are trying to build mobile with new approach, build it as PC.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by seabrookmx on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:30PM (#6086587)
Except it's a horrible comparison, because an F1 car is orders of magnitude higher in performance than an everyday car. The Edge on the other hand, has a lower resolution screen than the Galaxy S4, a consumer device.

They claim the performance will be amazing, yet don't even specify which CPU/SoC they will be using (only claiming it will be a quad, also available in the Galaxy series).

128gb of storage? Big deal. My Galaxy S3 with a 64gb SD card has that much too.

Cool phone, and I love the smartphone/PC convergence they are striving for - but comparing it to the engineering marvel of an F1 car is a little outlandish.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by DocG on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:05PM (#6086766)
I do understand why you think this comparison is off, but

if Edge would have magnitudes of better performace(and I mean magnitudes) they would have to develop one for themselvs(meaning cpu/soc, they are already developing their soft). No crowdfunding will ever cover that. So it is choice between reality and dream.

Lower resolution was explained here:

"We also believe the race for ever higher resolution has become a distraction. Beyond 300ppi you’re adding overhead rather than improving display clarity. We think colour, brightness and dynamic range are now the edge of invention so we’ll choose a display for its balance of resolution, dynamic range and colour accuracy."

I think, and this is just an idea that: they can't announce unannounced cpu/soc or they or they don't know(that would be bad)

your s3 has 64gb sd. They are talking about onboard storage. At the moment biggest onboard is 64gb, there are around 8 highest end phones that have that. This is probably the easiest thing to up if memory prices and size goes down. First 128gb phones should come out around the same time when Edge. Then you will have 128gb onboard+whatever sd you buy extra.

Why am I protective over this thing? Because I am the one who they are making this thing for. I like playing with tech and I would see the benefit for using this portable computer. .. altough, at the moment it is out of my budget.

EDIT: This does not mean it is all perfect project. There are already some unanswered legitimate questions in comment section.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by ssafejava on Monday July 22, 2013 @08:53PM (#6087504)
I agree - and this is what dissuades me from buying one. While the industrial design is indeed cool I'm not convinced that faster phones won't be available at the time of launch; this product has a very significant number of engineering challenges ahead of it, not the least of which is software.

If there is a 2nd- or 3rd-gen Edge I will be very interested, but today's state-of-the-art ARM quad is not enough for the tasks I usually run on my laptop. If it can't replace my laptop, then contributing to this project is just throwing $600 (or $830!) sight-unseen into a development black hole that could be months late.

In these sorts of situations contributors are almost never reimbursed for delays. By the time this launches there will be yet another generation of Intel chips, ARM chips, and flagship Android/iPhone devices. It just doesn't make economic sense.

I appreciate what they are trying to do and I don't know if there's a better way. But it's quite a risk to shell out that much for a toy that may not really be that useful in this iteration.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by jfb on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:23PM (#6086859)
A little hyperbole never hurt anybody. But they are off by at least one order of magnitude in terms of cost if they're thinking of doing really new things with a mobile device.

Actually, upon reflection, the comparison to F1 is completely spurious. They're not talking about doing any new hardware development; instead, they're looking at slapping commodity hardware in a box. That's doomed.

Re:Ubuntu Edge by voltagex_ on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:35PM (#6088093)
Your S3 also can't load apps off that storage because of design decisions made by Google.
Re:Ubuntu Edge by yesplorer on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @02:34AM (#6088540)
The phone is not produced for mass market. I think he said that right at the beginning of the presentation and repeated it along the line