It's 2013. Why would you be that?
You like paying money for some blood-line family to sit and have the good life?
It's also quite nice having someone connected with government that has been around longer than one or two political terms and thus has a wealth of experience to draw from and can an act in a way that's above short term popularism. If you ask even the most die hard anti-monarchists in the UK, I believe most of them would agree that the Queen has done a very good job. They're more concerned with her offspring and what happens when she dies.
Edit: forgot to mention too that the Queen, Charles, Harry, William, Kate and other immediate family members spend an enormous amount of their time directly involved in charity work.
What we get from monarchy is an ever expanding line of spongers and hangers on who we're expected to support.
Someone will no doubt be along in a minute to say we don't support them financially as they are the crown and generate wealth that way but I'd argue that was all stolen from the common man anyway (plus there's lots of hidden costs such as policing and security that don't come out of the royal budget)
The French had it right with Louis XVI.
We need a non-political president like the Irish, German and Israeli's have.
There was only ever one Shakespeare. There have been hundreds of royal families- the British one is notable because it still exists today. Take that away and they're just one of many, and tourists would be far, far less interested.
Then what do we promote? The Lake District?
http://www.arc-trust.org/about/
http://www.rspcareptilerescue.co.uk/
http://www.herpconstrust.org.uk/
(sorry thinly veiled joke about the Royals and Alex Jones)
(no I don't believe any of it but it's funny)
This is exactly one of the reasons I approve of them. Again, no bias, no selfish PR reason, they can just help out.
I knew it was some sort of joke, didn't realize it was about Icke. Oh, lizards!!!! Of course. I really should have seen that!!! Oh well.
Even so, I wanted to , er, "approve" of royals supporting other wise neglected charities.
I've been living in the US for the last five years and have come to appreciate the Royal Family more than when I was in the UK- their apolitical nature means that they are more internationally appreciated than most other world figures.
That's why it's just "sit".
Same for the charity work -- that's just what idle rich people do to pass their time, drink champagne and see each other over expensive food.
I don't see why. Making those trips is likely not very relaxing- just because it doesn't involve hard manual labour doesn't mean that constantly moving from city to city and politely gladhanding hundreds of people in a day isn't work.
But you're right, nothing good comes out of charity work, it's all just a bunch of rich people eating caviar. Glad your exhaustive investigation into the topic was successful.
Oh, I did investigated it exhaustively, and yes, nothing comes out of charity work.
It's just a way for people to feel good and situations to perpetuate.
The only work that matters and improves things is doing structural improvents and proving infrastructure.
Charity just make people dependent.
Not to mention that, in say Africa, it is estimated (by charity workers themselves) that the vast majority of charity money go to official's pockets.
Honestly, I don't believe you investigated anything beyond reading some bias newspaper. I also think you confuse small local charities and massive charitable attempts to solve world wide poverty. Two very different things. But if you investigated, you would know that, right?
No. A council is the way to go.
Besides, the councilors set the policy that council are supposed to follow. If the council is rubbish, its the fault of the councilors. That is supposed to be the point of electing them, or booting them.
It's not that they're crap, but they're powerless due to the contracted out power they have had to accept due to the budgetary constraints that the government have forced on them. They can deal with individual issues fine but there are problems bringing in full scale accountability when you have to shift 99% of work onto other people.
You've probably experienced the subcontrators, not the councilors who due to the low budget are crap.
Next time you get an issue, call your local councilor - you might be surprised!
Next, if the monarch asked something of the country as a whole, most people would take their word for it, because there would be no political motive or bias. If a PM did so, it becomes partisan and a debate. We had Blair take us to war twice on his say so. As such, most of the country opposed it and saw it was willy waving or macho-ness, or sucking up to the Americans, and so on. Had the Queen believed in it and come out and said something like, "Look, Im sorry, but with 60 odd years of experience, we have no choice", I think the country would have backed her, if only reluctantly. But the Brits would have thought, "bloody hell, she speaks, and well, OK". And that would be because of the huge constitutional risk doing so would have caused.
Finally, we could in the UK vote in something like a Nazi party. We could then take to the streets and have a violent revolution and kill the nazi's. After all that, the Monarch would still be there as a shield of stability for both us internally, an as an external sort of front. Having won our revolution, Queenie would still be there, and ask the winner, "Ok, now what?"
I prefer all this to every other presidential system, most notable the insane US presidential race. I don't want out head of state to be in that cesspit. I like that it just sits there, all nice and stable.
I care not for all the pomp and ceremony. I hate all the silly gossip. I dont think they need so many homes and hangers on. All that can be up for grabs, no problem. But at it core, I personally, prefer our monarch to any other alternative.
Sorry, but I do not believe that a vote is a universally good thing. Mostly, yes. But not an absolute. Here in the UK I firmly relive we have the two almost perfectly balanced. Democracy can do anything it likes, under a safe shield of our monarchy. If it ever got real nasty and extreme, the monarch can shut it down. We would have a crisis in that case, but we would not go Nazi, or something. I believe that externally other countries and cultures can see we are a thriving powerful democracy, but we also have depth and stability supplied by our monarch head of state.
UK! UK! UK! :)
Actually no. That is total rubbish since about 1915.
Em, you can have an elected President (like France IIRC). No reason to have some arbitrary blood-line human.
>and that they cannot be as corrupted as an elected or appointed person
If history is anything to go by, they can be even more corrupt and corrupted.
Nero was a monarch.
Recently I've come to think that elected is not better than something completely arbitrary (blood), and may even be worse.
At least which an arbitrary decision you might get a nice person, with elections you never seem to
Not need to feed and clothe and have huge palaces for a whole range of parasites.
The British system of government is far less costly than that of the US.
The Disraeli quote is to the point: the "representational" part of representational government is thorny, and pretty much ensures that a ruling clique is put in place whose interests do not mirror that of the electorate very well.
The constitution of representational democracies always put in place a watchdog over the powers of parliament: in the US, it is the legal system. In Turkey, it is the army. In the UK, it is the monarchy. Many people seem to think that law courts are an obviously superior guarantor of democracy than monarchies, few are able to argue the point well.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhyYgnhhKFw&list=SPqs5ohhass...