Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by pvnick on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:31PM
(#6049732)
Nobody on the internet is NSA-free as they're siphoning photons off the fiber optic cables. I choose to give my support to those fighting tooth and nail against the surveillance, and right now the evidence points towards Yahoo doing that better than most.
Plus they got a glittery gold star from the EFF!
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by rfctr on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:53PM
(#6049791)
> right now the evidence points towards Yahoo doing that better than most
I see your point. Still, Yahoo may be just the first to win the right to disclose. Similar decisions may follow towards Google and MS, for example, and -- oh horror -- HN.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by unimpressive on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:44AM
(#6050213)
HN is all public messages anyway. There's no private message feature. The only data they have to give is what you've upvoted and your email. (Though that former set of data might be interesting.)
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by pvnick on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:57PM
(#6049802)
I hope you're right, I may have to reconsider. But honestly I love a good comeback story and have been rooting for Yahoo since Mayer took over.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by mjolk on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @06:29AM
(#6050894)
E-mail comes with some expectation of privacy due to addressing and targeted communication. Hackernews is public content. Apples and oranges.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by rfctr on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:47AM
(#6051465)
Yes, on HN is it public (for example) that a user with a nickname "abcdefg" made some statement about cryptography in general and some government projects in particular.
What is not public is who is "abcdefg" in the real life? What is their IP, for instance, at time moment T?
Under some conditions NSA may be interested and request this information from HN.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by mjolk on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @09:17AM
(#6051632)
Sure, but it's a public forum. Only a naive person has any expectation of long-term anonymity.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by barbs on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:27AM
(#6050188)
Look at that giffy glitter!!
https://www.eff.org/sites/default/files/images_insert/sparkl...
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by crag on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:27PM
(#6049861)
I agree. Time to take a look at Yahoo and Firefox. Been years.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by kllrnohj on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @02:02AM
(#6050242)
> right now the evidence points towards Yahoo doing that better than most.
Evidence still points to Google quite solidly leading in this area. Yahoo has 1 gold star from the EFF, Google has considerably more.
Assuming you place any value in glittery gold stars from the EFF, that is.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by motters on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:28AM
(#6050559)
It's unclear whether Yahoo did fight tooth and nail. They were assimilated into PRISM on 3/12/2008 according to the leaked slide. Other companies (particularly Apple) took longer to undermine and presumably put up more of a fight.
Re:Yahoo wins motion to declassify court documents in PRISM ...
by scott_w on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:25AM
(#6051366)
Not necessarily. Remember that Apple is a hardware company first. They may simply have had nothing of interest to the NSA until more recently.
So... no. Yahoo is not a NSA-free land.