News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by 3pt14159 on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:15AM (#6045643)
The reason I don't listen to women in tech presentations:

1. I'm basically not allowed to voice an opinion that isn't completely aligned with the feminist status quo (I believe in equality, fuck me right).

2. I'd rather learn how to build a better emberjs app. Or learn more about thorium.

3. Unlike the vast majority of problems, there are few concrete steps to be taken to correct the imbalances that do exist.

Edit:

I can't believe I had to self sensor, just to hit the post button.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by theorique on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:25AM (#6045694)
The reason I don't listen to women in tech presentations

I assume you mean "I don't listen to 'women in tech' presentations", rather than, "I don't listen to women, in tech presentations". The former is a political stance, the latter is excluding an entire sex for unknown reason, even if they are talking of emberjs or thorium.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by GhotiFish on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:43AM (#6045832)
Yah I read those two sentences as well.

A piece of advice from my father: If you have two ways to take something, take it the nice way.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by theorique on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:34AM (#6046205)
Good advice :)

I try to follow it in my life.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by prawks on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:51AM (#6045884)
I'll admit I side with the poster a bit, and I'd definitely agree with the former. The problem is that "women in tech" presentation don't try to fix the root-cause of the issue by giving "men in tech" any reason to believe women should be treated as equals. In my undergraduate studies we had an exceptional student who happened to be female. She gave enlightening and challenging technical presentations that engaged the audience. That's how it should be.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by needacig on Monday July 15, 2013 @07:10PM (#6049108)
> The problem is that "women in tech" presentation don't try to fix the root-cause of the issue by giving "men in tech" any reason to believe women should be treated as equals.

Why is your null hypothesis that women shouldn't be treated as equals?

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by reedlaw on Monday July 15, 2013 @08:19PM (#6049345)
I did't read it that way. By having separate presentations for women the implicit message is one of inequality. Why not just "tech" presentations where men and women are equally welcome?

The article, on the other hand, seems to be pushing more for indistinguishability rather than equality. E.g.: "That depressing statistic about there being only three female CEOs in the FTSE 100..." It is only depressing if you think men and women being created equal means that they should have a perfect 50/50 split representation across every endeavor.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by prawks on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:25AM (#6051365)
Correct. Women are equals, there's no reason for them not to be. But until people stop encouraging such a divide, I don't see anything changing.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by 3pt14159 on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:57PM (#6046818)
Obviously I don't mean that I don't listen to women.

I mean women-in-tech presentations.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:00AM (#6045965)
1. I'm basically not allowed to voice an opinion that isn't completely aligned with the feminist status quo (I believe in equality, fuck me right).

Many people not involved with feminist groups often think feminists think the same about everything. Which shows they know nothing about actual disagreements within feminists groups. Just look up transexual issues & feminism. That's a big source of disagreement right there.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by __--__ on Monday July 15, 2013 @04:04PM (#6048217)
"Not all feminists are like that" is an intellectually lazy argument. Of course not all feminists agree. That doesn't matter in the slightest when I have feminists (who I count as friends, no less) telling me that I have no right to have an opinion on gender equality because I'm a white middle class male. "Privilege" and "Patriarchy" is shaming language used by even the meekist feminist (and again, said by people who actually like me) to make me feel bad for being born the way I am - a white male who wants to make a comfortable living. Anytime I make a comment about this topic, the response I get is what I imagine women used to get in Victorian era england; "Aww, that's sweet, now sit down, shut up and let the women talk."

I don't oppress women. Women oppress me. And pointing that out makes me the asshole.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by gthrowaway on Monday July 15, 2013 @05:25PM (#6048639)
Of course "feminism" isn't a unified lockstep movement.

But is there a thing, let's call it "pop feminism", which is widespread enough and whose adherents share enough basic ideas and positions, that we can usefully predicate things of it? Absolutely. And, well, that's the problem.

For example, when I see people use terms like "patriarchy" in earnest, I tend to grimace a bit. Not because I think they're crazy radical idiots, but because I think they're dangerously behind the times. The concept of unilateral patriarchy (i.e., a system in which most/all advantages based on gender accrue to men while most/all disadvantages based on gender accrue to women) is something like thirty years out of date at this point. We know now that the enemy is gender essentialism, which rigid, constrained roles and systemic advantages/disadvantages emerge from. We also know now that it's not a unidirectional oppression -- the resulting roles have aspects which harm people of all genders, and give at least some advantages to people of all genders.

But for every one person who gets this there are a thousand, or more, who just read sites like Jezebel, or feminism-related tags on Tumblr/Facebook, and end up imbibing pop-feminism ideas that are woefully out of touch with what we now actually know about gender in our society. What's worse, those ideas tend to reinforce essentialist gender roles rather than seek to overturn them.

The wage gap, currently being argued in the usual stupid way in another front-page thread, is actually a wonderful example of this. Research has shown, time and again, that much of the gap results from women being assigned, by society as a whole, a "childbearer/caregiver" role. And the consequences are clear. Women are more likely to work part-time, women who work full-time work fewer hours and less overtime, women actively seek out "child-friendly" workplaces, women start out with relative earning parity but it falls off a cliff once they have or start thinking about having children, a whole raft of stuff that adds up really really quickly.

A real solution to this would be to throw out the essentialism and the notion that child-rearing is "women's work". A real solution would seek to push women out of automatically assuming that bearing and raising children is a vitally important life goal, and would seek to push men out of automatically assuming their role doesn't involve caring for kids. A real solution would question basic ideas about what a successful life looks like and throw out any and all assumptions about "I am of this gender, therefore I should desire that"

But pop feminism doesn't do any of that. Instead it assumes that being a woman is mostly identical with wanting to have children and be their primary caregiver. So pop-feminist articles focus on how to "have it all", how to "balance" raising two kids with working 80-hour weeks at a law firm or running your own business, and argue that the important thing is to provide things like on-site day-care and generous maternal-leave policies to ensure women can keep right on performing the same rigid role they've had imposed on them for centuries.

What's more, we know these policies really don't work. There are countries which have implemented them, and they still see drastic drop-offs of women's lifetime earnings post-childbirth. What those policies do really well is make it easier to slide back into that role of "raising children is what I'm really supposed to do with my life".

But rather than attack the real problem, and ask the real, really hard questions about gender roles and how to overturn them, most people who identify as "feminist" just forward and share and retweet the same old pop-feminism drivel. And if you believe there isn't a relatively large group of people who identify that way and do exactly that, with relative ideological unity in terms of underlying assumptions, then I just don't know what Internet you're spending time on.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:56AM (#6050647)
You're basically describing the patriarchy and modern feminism.

When people now use words like "patriarchy" now, they don't mean "all and any man opressing all women", they mean what you talk about, rigid gender roles. You post basically describes the patriarchy and how it's bad. The idea that women should so some work (e.g. nursing) and men shouldn't do some work (e.g. nursing), is patriarchy.

I can't find any FAQ on Jezebel (since I don't read it much), so I can't find their definition, but there are definitions on http://finallyfeminism101.wordpress.com, a Feminist 101 site.

Feminists recogise that patriarchy does affect men negatively. (e.g. reddit's SRS Fempire on just that: http://www.reddit.com/r/SRSDiscussion/comments/1a0bef/xpost_... )

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by gthrowaway on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @05:38PM (#6054913)
About the best way I can put this is via analogy.

Imagine a patient with appendicitis who goes to a doctor, and the doctor just hands over a prescription for pain medication and says "no worries, this will make you feel better right away".

The pain meds will make the patient feel better for a bit, but really they're just masking a symptom of the underlying disease, which is still there. And sooner or later that appendix must be treated or got rid of, or the patient's going to die.

The pop-feminism practised in places like SRS, Jezebel, Tumblr, etc. is the social-justice equivalent of giving the appendicitis patient pain meds. "Smashing the patriarchy" will still leave the underlying disease of which it's a symptom (essentialism and roles assigned on the basis of gender) untreated.

Of course, that's an oversimplification, since the popular conception of "patriarchy" is deeply flawed in other ways (it lacks the explanatory power to say anything more glib than a 101-style "of course it hurts you too, sweetie" to men who are also being harmed by the deeper disease of essentialism, to take one example).

But I've long since given up trying to get this through to most people on internet boards, which is why I now do it under throwaway accounts.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @05:06AM (#6056790)
The pop-feminism practised in places like SRS, Jezebel, Tumblr, etc. is the social-justice equivalent of giving the appendicitis patient pain meds. "Smashing the patriarchy" will still leave the underlying disease of which it's a symptom (essentialism and roles assigned on the basis of gender) untreated.

Now I'm confused. I'm an SRSer, and "the patriachy" is gender roles. "smashing the patriachy" means ending gender roles & essentialism.

* the popular conception of "patriarchy" is deeply flawed in other ways (it lacks the explanatory power to say anything more glib than a 101-style "of course it hurts you too, sweetie" to men who are also being harmed by the deeper disease of essentialism, to take one example).*

Here's a thread on SRS talking about how the patriachy hurts men: http://www.reddit.com/r/SRSDiscussion/comments/1a0bef/xpost_...

Believe me, us social justice/feminist/SRS people do have serious conversations about lots of things, including men.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by gthrowaway on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:01AM (#6058021)
Well.

Firstly, the fact that you continue to use and insist on an overladen (with decades' worth of baggage) term that obscures what you're talking about, rather than just say what you claim to mean, is not an encouraging sign to me.

Secondly, if SRS is really a place where "serious conversations", as you put it, take place, then they certainly were adept at hiding it from me back when I frequented. After a while, one gets rather tired of the LOL DILDZ and LOL MRAS and wants to actually accomplish some good. Perhaps it's now a better place, but given how toxic the culture was I very much doubt it.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by reedlaw on Monday July 15, 2013 @08:31PM (#6049382)
> A real solution would seek to push women out of automatically assuming that bearing and raising children is a vitally important life goal [...]

If bearing and raising children is not a vitally important life goal I don't know what is. The failure to do so would literally spell the end of civilization. Perhaps this view accounts for birth rates declining below sustainable levels in developed nations.

> [...] and would seek to push men out of automatically assuming their role doesn't involve caring for kids.

Of course no father should assume this.

But I feel this entire argument is pushing for indistinguishability more than equality. There will never be indistinguishability between men and women. Equality doesn't mean eliminating all differences.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by gthrowaway on Monday July 15, 2013 @09:31PM (#6049549)
Read the comment again.

Gender roles are pervasive, but are more obvious for women, who tend to get defined in terms of their wombs rather than any individual characteristics. Essentialists who hold traditional/conservative views don't really go much beyond that -- bearing and raising children is what women are for. Essentialists who hold progressive/liberal views try to hide this, but are still basically assuming that all women really want, deep-down inside, to be mothers above all other goals, so the discourse is all about how to do other things at the same time as that.

And that's a problem regardless of who's doing it or why. A developed civilization can remain viable without needing every woman to be a baby factory first and foremost, so why do we still push that attitude from basically all sides?

And although there probably always will be some life paths that are incompatible with having children, most of the ones that are incompatible today are not necessarily incompatible; they're only contingently incompatible as a consequence of how our society is structured (with its focus on career advancement and measuring one's worth in terms of titles and raw dollar values, and the resulting need to work insane hours). We could tear down all those assumptions, and have a society where everyone has the option of multiple ways to lead a fulfilling life, with raising children being one of those. But we don't do that, and even the popular incarnations of movements which claim to advocate for real equality of opportunity don't try.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:18AM (#6051333)
Gender roles can be very harmful for some men. Gay men (sorta). Effeminate or camp men. Men who crossdress etc.

We could tear down all those assumptions, and have a society where everyone has the option of multiple ways to lead a fulfilling life, with raising children being one of those.

Yep, that's what feminists are doing, smashing the patriarchy.

But we don't do that, and even the popular incarnations of movements which claim to advocate for real equality of opportunity don't try.

Feminism is doing this.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by papsosouid on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:04AM (#6045996)
That doesn't mean there isn't a significant amount of mythology that is widely agreed upon in feminist circles. If you expect insane conspiracy theory nonsense like "patriarchy" to actually be supported by evidence rather than accepted on faith, then you are not welcome in feminist discourse, plain and simple.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by icebraining on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:40AM (#6046255)
I'm rather confused by your post. I've never seen the patriarchy described as a "conspiracy", or a willful choice by men to control women, but has a social structure - perpetuated by certain social institutions - that ensure that men as a gender (not every individual, of course) maintain oppressive power over women.

Regardless of the existence of the patriarchy as a phenomena - and there are many critics of the theory, from the right and the left -, it makes no sense to dismiss it as a conspiracy theory.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:25PM (#6046551)
I've never seen the patriarchy described as a "conspiracy"

Anti-feminists would tend to view it as a conspiracy, or no longer existing ("women can vote, so it's all OK now, right?"). Sadly this sort of attitude/meme does exist....

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by papsosouid on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:45AM (#6046292)
>but has a social structure - perpetuated by certain social institutions - that ensure that men as a gender (not every individual, of course) maintain oppressive power over women.

What you described is a conspiracy. Of course feminists don't describe their own conspiracy theories as conspiracy theories, they want them to appear legitimate.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by wonderzombie on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:14PM (#6047456)
I disagree. This is necessary but not sufficient to describe a conspiracy. Conspiracies imply collusion, or some form of plan.

Patriarchy as it is commonly understood in feminist circles is more nuanced than your straw-man. It's bottom-up, not top-down. You'd have to stretch the definition of "conspiracy" awfully far to cover an emergent property of a set of principles and societal norms.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by king_jester on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:54AM (#6046347)
Conspiracy usually means a deliberate attempt of a group to do something rather than something that occurs for systemic or institutional reasons.

Ultimately patriarchy as a social force and concept is totally provable has statistical and philosophical evidence that shows it exists. Every basic women's studies or feminist book goes over this to some extent.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by papsosouid on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:01PM (#6046378)
Institutions do not form spontaneously, and the "systems" you refer to were also created by humans. The notion that men created systems and institutions which oppress women, but it is totally not a conspiracy because they did it by accident is not well represented in feminist academia.

>totally provable has statistical and philosophical evidence that shows it exists.

Except that alternative explanations are dismissed. If the "evidence" supports many possible conclusions, then it is not proof of a single specific conclusion like "patriarchy".

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by king_jester on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:10PM (#6046447)
> Institutions do not form spontaneously, and the "systems" you refer to were also created by humans. The notion that men created systems and institutions which oppress women, but it is totally not a conspiracy because they did it by accident is not well represented in feminist academia.

It seems like you are saying that is there is indeed a real conspiracy of institutions created and/or controlled by men, in which case I totally agree. We have well documented cases, historically and in the present, of institutions and systems that are dominated by men.

> Except that alternative explanations are dismissed. If the "evidence" supports many possible conclusions, then it is not proof of a single specific conclusion like "patriarchy".

I've yet to see convincing alternative explanations. All of the evidence points to existence of patriarchy as a social institution.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by papsosouid on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:35PM (#6046645)
>It seems like you are saying that is there is indeed a real conspiracy of institutions created and/or controlled by men, in which case I totally agree.

It seems like you are deliberately choosing to respond with non-sequiturs and strawmen because you don't want to have an honest conversation.

>I've yet to see convincing alternative explanations. All of the evidence points to existence of patriarchy as a social institution.

Just as creationists view all evidence as pointing to the existence of god. If you start with a conclusion, and twist everything to suit that end, you can't reasonably expect people who didn't start with the same bias to agree with your conclusions.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by jb17 on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:42AM (#6046271)
Do you really think societal structures that privilege men are a myth? Apart from being quite obvious to anyone who is not extremely biased, there are whole academic branches that study this. I'd say calling that "mythology" puts you into conspiracy theory territory.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by dyno12345 on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:02PM (#6047353)
Simply put, if you say that the patriarchy causes X and not Y and I say that the patriarchy causes Y and not X there is no way to resolve the disagreement.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by hacker789 on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:17PM (#6046495)
> Do you really think societal structures that privilege men are a myth?

Nope. And neither are the societal structures that privilege women.

Western women have always been among the safest, most privileged human beings on the planet. Predictably, and unfortunately, modern western feminists never compare the plight of the average man with the plight of the average woman when determining who wins the Oppression Olympics; instead, they look jealously toward men at the top of society and declare that because women aren't a part of that, they're more oppressed.

And sadly, it gets more ridiculous than that. I've seen people on this forum actually say, with similar words:

Institutionalized misandry cannot exist, because most people at the top of society are men. Women don't have the institutional power to oppress men. Any oppression men face is a result of The Patriarchy.

Ignoring the fact that oppression can come from outside of congress (university policies, for example), those people are defining patriarchy to simply mean "Oppressive policies written by people with penises, even if feminists support those policies".

And that's what makes it dogma.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by wonderzombie on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:23PM (#6047535)
Ignoring the fact that oppression can come from outside of congress (university policies, for example), those people are defining patriarchy to simply mean "Oppressive policies written by people with penises, even if feminists support those policies".

You are of course entitled to your opinion, but I think you'd be better served by engaging with a more nuanced and complex version of these views. What you describe here is caricature. And in all I think it says more about you than feminism.

A common refrain in feminist circles is that patriarchy hurts everyone. A good example is parental leave as it applies to men. Paternity leave in the US is absurdly bad, suggesting that we as a society do not value the time a father spends with his child. Along those lines, men are typically graded on a patronizingly terrible curve when it comes to childcare. And so on.

Note that these aren't just laws, but societal norms, especially the latter where people praise you for doing basic shit like picking up your kids from work or whatever. If you view patriarchy as an emergent property, then the idea that "laws written by men" are a sufficient description of the concept is just absurd. You could of course take the least coherent out of any group which espouses a belief and engage with that, but that's not an honest way to have a discussion.

So like I said maybe don't engage with the most ridiculous possible presentation of feminism.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by papsosouid on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:50AM (#6046321)
There have been "whole academic branches" that studied all sorts of nonsense and quackery. That doesn't validate modern feminist mythology any more than it validated phrenology. Rather than resort to weasel words, if you want to take an opposing position than take it. Show me this male created oppression machine.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:28PM (#6046580)
So, because some ideas are widely accepted in feminists theories (the patriarchy) must mean that there is nothing that feminists disagree about?!

That's like saying that because there is a significant amount of shared ideas in US politics (e.g.: "US Independence was a good thing"), that US politics is now some sort of group think where dissent is not allowed and everyone thinks the same!

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by papsosouid on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:31PM (#6046607)
>must mean that there is nothing that feminists disagree about?!

Nobody made that claim, that is my point. Responding to strawmen is not productive, respond to the actual conversation.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by epsylon on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:27AM (#6045714)
> 1. I'm basically not allowed to voice an opinion that isn't completely aligned with the feminist status quo (I believe in equality, fuck me right).

Yes, because there is actually a single, unified, globally agreed upon feminist status quo who tries to silence the voices of brave dissenters...

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by Zikes on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:20AM (#6046107)
There doesn't need to be a single, unified, globally agreed upon feminist status quo, because as soon as a dissenting opinion is voiced the extremist groups are the ones that speak the loudest and the rest of the feminist movement just stands back and watches.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by newnewnew on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:13PM (#6046463)
And they wield a ton of power. Ask the programmer that was fired for saying "dongle" within earshot of Adria Richards. Chances are your HR bureaucracy is radically feminist.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by robot_friend on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:46PM (#6046730)
More like radically covering-their-ass-ist. HR departments are paid to prevent potential lawsuits and it's cheaper/less risky to fire someone at the first hint of controversy than it is to face the chance of a lawsuit, no matter how small.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by newnewnew on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:59PM (#6046840)
If feminist complaints are acted upon by HR, and patriarchal complaints are not (if, in fact, they ever receive one), then you know on which side is HR.

Feminists see themselves as permanent underdogs, like the USA, but it just ain't true.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by epsylon on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:33AM (#6050579)
Adria Richards was also fired for that.

> Chances are your HR bureaucracy is radically feminist.

Ah, the good old feminist conspiracy. Do you really believe what you said ? I will stand by my words. There is no feminist conspiracy.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by theorique on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:39AM (#6046248)
There isn't a 'single' status quo, but if you question and/or debate the existence or definition of certain articles of feminist faith such as 'patriarchy' or 'rape culture' or various statistics about the relative status of women versus men, watch out.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by king_jester on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:56AM (#6046359)
> debate the existence or definition of certain articles of feminist faith such as 'patriarchy' or 'rape culture'

This is not a debate in good faith. If you come to the table with no previous knowledge about anything and demand to be heard, why should people waste time with bringing you up to speed? The vast majority of the times this happens it ends up in moving the goal posts.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by theorique on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:26PM (#6046561)
I'm certainly not suggesting that a person go in completely uninformed, nor that he use misguided or misogynist arguments. But it's completely suitable to refute statistics or conclusions if one has done the appropriate reading - both feminist texts and texts criticizing feminism - and come to different conclusions.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by king_jester on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:40PM (#6046686)
I totally agree. However trying to argue that patriarchy or rape culture doesn't exist would imply that someone doesn't have a even a basic understanding of written feminist works as they go over this in various criticism very often.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by __--__ on Monday July 15, 2013 @04:11PM (#6048259)
Why is this debate not in good faith? Because they disagree with you? Assuming they have no previous knowledge about anything solely because they disagree with you is arrogant and lazy. Don't engage in an exchange of ideas, just paint them as stupid and ignorant and move on, firm in your unchallenged convictions.

This point of view you harbor is WHY there can be no debate in good faith.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by epsylon on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:44AM (#6050615)
I'm not debating the existence of extreme opinions among people who label themselves as feminists.

I'm just saying that feminists come in all shapes and colors, and, lo and behold, there are a wide range of opinions among them, and (unsurprisingly) many of these opinions are contradictory, just like in any other group of people sharing some basic ideas.

I'm also saying that you should not base your opinion of social movement around the views of a kernel of extremists. Specifically, if you think that, as soon as someone introduces herself as a feminist, you think that she will stand by extreme opinions and that your differences are irreconcilable, and therefore is not worth talking to, then perhaps you should try to review your judgements.

And I'm also saying that there is a problem with gender equality in our modern societies. Even if you disagree with the methods and propaganda of extremist groups, you should recognize that there is a big problem. And the easiest way to eradicate those extreme opinions is to eradicate the problem that gives a voice to these groups.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by zem on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:24PM (#6046548)
that's like going to a scientific conference and "debating" climate change. there are lots of things that sound questionable and/or debatable simply because you don't know enough about them.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by gizmo686 on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:20AM (#6046100)
Kind of. The feminist movement is a movement, and like all movement it has developed a continually evolving culture, in the same was the US has a different culture than Canada, and Google has a different culture than Microsoft. Seeing how pervasive a culture is almost impossible to do without comparing it to others. It is entirely possible that the feminist movement has developed a culture relatively closed to dissenting opinions.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by icebraining on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:24AM (#6045688)
I can't believe I had to self sensor, just to hit the post button.

What do you mean?

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by 3pt14159 on Monday July 15, 2013 @01:04PM (#6046875)
I had a fourth point, but there is no reason to kick the hornets nest in life.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by smtddr on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:19AM (#6045662)
With this kind of thinking, how will women(or any less-represented group) be able to reach you?
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by overgard on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:26AM (#6045703)
He didn't say he wasn't willing to listen, he expressed that he wanted a forum for equal discussion instead of a one way message.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by jasonlotito on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:52AM (#6045896)
Seeing that he doesn't attend "women in tech" presentations, how does he know they are all one-way messages?

On a side note: considering he's frustrated at self-sensoring himself from saying something he knew was wrong to say in some manner, I'd contend that in an environment where you do not have a chance to review what you say before saying it out loud, he's at least partially responsible for reactions he receives.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by overgard on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:58AM (#6045943)
Well he didn't say he never attended one, only that he chooses not to now. Anything else is editorializing. I don't know the guy so I can't say anything about his opinions, but I'm amused at how many assumptions people are making about this guy.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by jasonlotito on Monday July 15, 2013 @08:02PM (#6049295)
> Well he didn't say he never attended one, only that he chooses not to now

I didn't suggest he never attend one. In fact, I was careful to avoid suggesting that at all.

My question has nothing to do with what happened in the past, but rather, his assumption that everything he doesn't attend is a certain way.

> I'm amused at how many assumptions people are making about this guy.

Casting stones, pots and kettles, and all that jazz.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmrfrmrf on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:25AM (#6045693)
I'm sorry to hear that; that must be awful.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by arrrg on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:16PM (#6047925)
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by 3pt14159 on Monday July 15, 2013 @07:25PM (#6049166)
Yeah see this is exactly what I'm talking about.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by jusben1369 on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:27AM (#6045709)
Good Lord you do sound like you have a lot of issues with women btw.

Edit: My fault for not explaining further: Pasted just below: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6045814

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by beachstartup on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:53AM (#6045904)
this is standard anti-male shaming language. it ALWAYS shows up in gender discussions because it's a great way to instantly discredit anyone without actually using an argument.

notice how there isn't any actual content in the rebuttal and how it is completely infalsifiable and indefensible. it's the equivalent of dropping the c-word in an argument against a woman.

shaming language against males:

  * grow up, be a man, man up  
  * you're a virgin / inexperienced  
  * "issues with women"   
  * you're bitter   
  * you're scary   
  * you're a rapist  
  * you must be gay (not sure why people use this one) 
  * you hate women  
  * you have psychological issues
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:03AM (#6045989)
you must be gay (not sure why people use this one)

People use that because they think a man acting like a woman (by having sex with men, by being the receptive partner in sex, by being penetrated, etc.) is a terrible thing for a man to do. Some homophobia is a form of misogyny, hating men who act woman-like.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by sp332 on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:15AM (#6046073)
I think a more relevant interpretation would be that the man has "issues" with women, or hates women etc. and therefore only has relations with men.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by ebfe on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:14PM (#6046474)
Would you agree that shaming lesbians is a form of misandry, hating women who act man-like?
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:22PM (#6046528)
Or it could be seen as hating women who don't act feminine?

"misandry" as an institutualised hatred against men for being men and hatred and degeration of masculine things and activity doesn't really exist in the same was people view feminine as weak & not as good exists.

There is also a lot of gender roles that people break, which feminism is attempting to break down.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by hacker789 on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:13PM (#6046465)
I've seen feminists publicly accuse men of being closeted gays to explain "an otherwise inexplicable hatred of women".
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by wonderzombie on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:25PM (#6047550)
I've seen men publicly accuse feminists of being lesbians to explain "an otherwise inexplicable hatred of men."

You're not going to get very far towards any kind of understanding by taking the least worthwhile arguments made by a group of people and projecting that belief on everyone else. That dog won't hunt and it just looks silly.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by hacker789 on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:06PM (#6047842)
What's the purpose of this comment? I obviously don't think all feminists walk around saying that. I was simply explaining why that particular shaming tactic was included in the list above.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by rmc on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @10:35AM (#6052116)
Really? Got a citation? That sort of homophobia is very uncommon and very unacceptable in many feminist and social justice circles.

(e.g. the large reddit subcommunity dedicated to feminism & social justice "ShitRedditSay"/"SRS"/"the Fempire" has a large discussion (SRSDiscussion) with Rule #1 being: "SRSD is a progressive, feminist, antiracist, GSRM-positive, antiableist community", GSRM = gender, sexual & relationship minorities, i.e. anyone not a cis straight monoagomous person. Homophobic language would fall afoul of that)

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by Wintamute on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:29AM (#6045731)
When someone says they believe in equality, why do you then say they have an issue with women?
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by jusben1369 on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:41AM (#6045814)
Sentence 1) I'm a victim. I'm oppressed by women who won't allow me to express my opinion because it differs from theirs. I believe in equality so I guess I'm implying they don't. Sentence 2) I'm uncomfortable talking about this so I'll try and say let's not talk about it at all and just focus on some abstract technology discussion. 3) We're doomed. You can't solve the problem. It's just the way it is so leave it the way it is. (I kind of like the status quo even though I was just objecting to a status quo mentality)
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by overgard on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:49AM (#6045871)
He didn't say he was a victim, he said he wasn't willing to converse on terms that he didn't like.

That's simply exercising a choice in what sort of conversation is worth your time.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by gizmo686 on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:32AM (#6046192)
Sentence 1 speaks only about the "women in tech" movement. The fact that "women in tech" self selects a mostly women population does not mean that commenting on it is commenting on women.

Sentence 2 is again speaking specifically about "women in tech" event, not about talking about the subject.

Sentence 3, is admittedly a defeatist attitude. However if there is nothing we can do about it, then why should we waste our time talking about it. In this case it is more of, if the people who are heavilly invested in this have not come up with something we can do about it yet, why should I waste my time unless I want to be a major activist. And, based on point 1, the movement is already hostile to what I have to say, so forget about it.

Admitadly, I am probably projecting my own thoughts on sentence 3.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by 3pt14159 on Monday July 15, 2013 @01:06PM (#6046888)
Your projections are completely accurate. The only thing I would add is that my own fiancee is a woman in tech (she's a frontend developer), so it isn't like I'm hostile to women in tech or anything.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by fosap on Monday July 15, 2013 @01:37PM (#6047145)
Sentence 1: If you disagree with something you get nothing but ridicule and insults. You just proved that point. Sorry, some people are just not worth arguing with, for example people with that discussion style, like you and most feminist. Or most fans of homeopathy. Or most jehovah's witnesses. Or other esoteric world views, preferably with a very strong in-group/out-group mentality. Case closed.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by arrrg on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:35AM (#6045778)
I'm just guessing, but I would say maybe completely bonkers bullshit like "feminist status quo"?!
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by overgard on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:45AM (#6045849)
If we accept that there's such a thing as feminism, it would make sense that it would have a current status quo. The argument would be if you agree with their definition of the status quo or not.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by king_jester on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:00PM (#6046377)
> If we accept that there's such a thing as feminism, it would make sense that it would have a current status quo.

This doesn't make sense. Most movements that are composed of many different groups with different interests never reach a status quo. Mass movements are rare and usually are not as mass as they are made out to be. Acting like feminism is a monolith and that all feminists act or think a certain way is one of the most common stereotype out there.

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by hnal943 on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:28PM (#6046584)
You're confusing "status quo" with "consensus".
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by shadowfox on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:23AM (#6046124)
I think the parent is also implying that there is perhaps no particular status quo with respect to the entire feminist movement(s)
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by hacker789 on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:09PM (#6046439)
Modern western feminism certainly has widely accepted dogma, but there are exist bitter battles between competing factions.

That being said, the largest factions don't exactly cover all sides of an issue, to put it mildly, so the existence of factions doesn't make anything better.

For example, the argument over transsexuals (mentioned by @rmc) has two main factions within modern western feminism:

1. "Transsexual women aren't real women; they're just men who are co-opting the brutal oppression real western women face, drowning out real women's voices."

2. "If you feel that you are a woman, then you are a woman. You do not need to present yourself as a woman, you do not need to be a woman every day, and you do not need to chose between being a man and being a woman at any given moment—you can be both. Anyone who questions your womanhood is a misogynist, because they are oppressively forcing their definition of womanhood onto a woman."

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by bilbo0s on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:53AM (#6045905)
Guys...

Would it be ok if we could discuss this without the profanity?

Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by Wintamute on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @05:02AM (#6050664)
Absolutely not. People are totally free to write and talk however they want to. Your conceptions about profanity are subjective and personal, don't try and impose them on others. If people are using hate speech, or being discriminatory, that's different, but colourful language harms no-one except those intent on being offended for no good reason. A more rewarding path would be to respond to the content of what is written, rather than the tone.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by tokenrove on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:54AM (#6045911)
It's a typical stance taken by people ignorant of the grievances of a minority or oppressed group. It's like saying, "I believe all the problems here are simple and solved except for trivial exceptions". "I believe in equality" is an easy stance to take without doing any research.
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by overgard on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:55AM (#6045916)
Fantastic. Why engage someone's points when you can play the white knight and simultaneously make an ad hominem attack instead?
Re:Why I won't speak at women-only events by nawitus on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:34AM (#6045765)
Nice way (or attempt) to kill a discussion.