News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by apsec112 on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:47PM (#6035073)
"The worst thing to post or upvote is something that's intensely but shallowly interesting. Gossip about famous people, funny or cute pictures or videos, partisan political articles, etc. If you let that sort of thing onto a news site, it will push aside the deeply interesting stuff, which tends to be quieter." - http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

I'm pretty sure that personal experiences of discrimination qualify as "intensely but shallowly interesting" content. It's "intense" because racial/sexual/etc. discrimination is a very charged topic that people get passionate about. (Not that this is bad, it's just the current state of things.)

It's "shallowly interesting" because it doesn't teach us anything except "some companies are racist sometimes", which everyone already knows. If companies in field X are especially racist, that might be interesting. If specific company Y was really racist, that might be interesting. If people were more or less racist under circumstance Z, that might be interesting, etc. But since this kind of content doesn't name specifics, all we can take away is "some employers are racist sometimes under some circumstances" (according to one person, whose account might or might not be completely accurate). That hasn't been new information since, well, ever. Even if you went back to 1900, everyone would already know this, it's just that most people would agree with it, instead of objecting like modern-day people would.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by coldtea on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:55PM (#6035137)
>It's "shallowly interesting" because it doesn't teach us anything except "some companies are racist sometimes", which everyone already knows.

I think you got it wrong. It doesn't have to teach you anything new. It's not here to amuse you. It's here to enrage you and get you to do something about it.

Now, if you are white, you might not find it amusing or interesting at all. But if you are black, you can see into it something that fucks you chances, and that's not funny at all, even if it's not novel or "everyone already knows".

>That hasn't been new information since, well, ever. Even if you went back to 1900, everyone would already know this, it's just that most people would agree with it, instead of objecting like modern-day people would.

Yes, and in 2050 they might say:

"Even if you went back to 2013, everyone would already know this, it's just that most people would not care, because it was not novel or interesting, instead of getting enraged and trying to fix this as a modern-day people would."

I mean, to me it's not very unlike reading about lynchings in 1910, and saying: "Well, OK, this is not news, such things happen for two centuries. Next news item please".

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by apsec112 on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:59PM (#6035164)
Sure, but the purpose of HN is specifically to teach people things, and not to create rage. The site guidelines make that pretty clear.

Also, is our problem really that people don't get outraged enough about race? We've had a number of days-long, city-wide street riots about race. That's an awful lot of rage we have already.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by wpietri on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:06PM (#6035208)
I would find this position more credible if people were downvoting and admonishing all the tech, business, privacy, and government rage.

I didn't notice anybody saying, "Hey, let's not get ragey about [the NSA|Apple|patent trolls|Facebook|Google|Congress], we're here to learn, not get upset."

You may personally be sincere, and if you have been equally assiduous on all upsetting topics, I commend you. But more generally, I think the sudden tone-policing that appears on race and gender discrimination topics has much more to do with the topic than the tone.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by smtddr on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:16PM (#6035263)
I agree with you...SO MUCH... you don't even know. Has anyone on HN checked out Google+?. Particularly, anytime the official Google account "LifeAtGoogle" posts anything about promoting/highlighting african-americans? It turns into a crazy 100+ comments thread of arguments..every..single..time. I don't see this kind of thing when someone posts about Chinese new-year, or just about any other event about any other group of people. I made the mistake of getting involved in one of those G+ threads and getting myself[1] all heated. Now I don't bother trying to debate. I'm just sad that anytime anything attempting to highlight positive things, or problems, for african-americans turns into a storm of comments almost completely drowning out the original article/story.

1.myself=blackmale

EDIT: And now this story has disappeared from the front page superfast(less than 45mins), while the the one about a lady adding "Mr." to her resume remains on front page(For at least 3 hrs now)......

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by DanBC on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:40PM (#6035381)
> I didn't notice anybody saying, "Hey, let's not get ragey about [the NSA|Apple|patent trolls|Facebook|Google|Congress], we're here to learn, not get upset."

People were saying that. People were flagging those stories. Some people lost their flagging rights because they flagged too much.

I still flag some of the [the NSA|Apple|patent trolls|Facebook|Google|Congress] flamebait stories.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by apsec112 on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:28PM (#6035320)
For what it's worth, I'm indeed annoyed at how much front page content has been about the NSA recently, but that issue will eventually blow over. We've been fighting about racism ever since the Three-Fifths Clause was included in the Constitution, over two hundred years ago.
Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by codygman on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:33PM (#6036193)
As a white male with a black girlfriend: No we don't get outraged enough about racism.

The amount of people who don't get what white privilege is or why saying the N-word isn't okay is astounding.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by lotharbot on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:00PM (#6035172)
> "It's here to enrage you"

HN submissions are supposed to "gratif[y] one's intellectual curiosity".

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by coldtea on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:31PM (#6035982)
If your "intellectual curiosity" can stand idle when black people are denied access to jobs and opportunies, then it's not worth much in the first place. I'd go as far as to call it dead.

"Intellectual curiosity" is not IDLE curiosity. It either is curiosity about building and changing things (including society) or it's no better than stamp collecting.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by lotharbot on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:56PM (#6036076)
> ""Intellectual curiosity" is not IDLE curiosity."

I agree.

"Intellectual curiosity" is also not mere rage, nor mere social activism [0]. Those things are not what the Hacker News frontpage is for. Intellectual curiosity does require something to be either novel material, or presented in a novel way; this is neither.

[0] Want to build and change society? Come join us at http://www.teachindenver.com/teachindenver/denver-fellows-pr... . As a bonus, it will gratify your intellectual curiosity.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by mynewwork on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:05PM (#6035196)
I found the article interesting, but upon reading apsec112's comment, it's probably true that this doesn't really belong on HN. That you say "It's here to enrage you and get you to do something about it." furthers my view that this is an article more appropriate for Reddit than HN. Of course as reddit becomes more exclusively memes and funny pictures, it's not surprising that many people are using HN for the type of content that would have been found on reddit 5 years ago.

I guess my point is, I read apsec112's comment as purely about whether the article belongs on HN, not whether the article was good or interesting (which it was).

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by chc on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:06PM (#6035204)
Nobody said it's "not news." They just said it doesn't suit this particular special-interest news site's standards. Similarly, if Apple were to buy out Facebook tomorrow, that would definitely be news, but it would probably be inappropriate for a My Little Pony news site.
Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by coldtea on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:37PM (#6036010)
IMHO, the world would be infinitely better if people did not compartmentalize issues. Especially important issues.
Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by wpietri on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:55PM (#6035134)
I strongly disagree. Not everybody knows that racism exists, and not everybody agrees that it is a significant barrier to hiring.

Further, it is not a solved problem, so it is well worth talking about it so we can solve it. Even if you don't believe that it should be solved as a societal problem (I do), this is a sign to hiring managers that they can do especially well by looking for the sorts of people that many companies tend to miss.

Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by lotso on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:03PM (#6035185)
Not sure why this user gets downvoted, while the parent comment gets upvoted. Maybe this related to the belief of meritocracy that many have in Silicon Valley.
Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by anon808 on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:48PM (#6035083)
Agreed. Let's just ignore this. Next article please.
Re:Unemployed Black Woman Pretends to be White, Job Offers S... by codygman on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:11PM (#6036534)
This attitude reeks of white privilege, although I used to have an opinion similar to it. I recommend spending some time here:

http://racismschool.tumblr.com/post/16976192868/white-privil...