Do you think the government would jail someone of Steve Ballmer's stature if he talked openly about what the government has asked of Microsoft. Because of his position he is much more protected from criminal action than almost anyone else. The reason he doesn't reject government requests is more likely that it would be bad for business not that he would suffer legal consequences.
... I think the proper place to direct your anger is at the laws that require them to cooperate.
I see the law as allowing them to cooperate. It gives them cover for not protecting the privacy of individual citizens.
Absolutely, but even if they didn't, if you were Steve Ballmer, would you take that risk? They certainly could prosecute you for leaking secret information.
That's even assuming that Ballmer knew about it. It could have been that they approached people who were in some position of power on the particular products they were interested in and served them with the order. Some random middle manager at Microsoft certainly has considerably less political pull than Ballmer and would likely go to jail if he/she came out about this, but could still be in the position to direct their team to build whatever features the government demanded.
I see the law as allowing them to cooperate. It gives them cover for not protecting the privacy of individual citizens.
If it came via a court order, it's definitely a demand. This isn't a marketing gimmick -- if you're served a lawful court order, you either obey it or risk the consequences, up to and including time in jail.
They don't seem to mind taking risks when it comes to questionable tax deductions.
They certainly could prosecute you for
But they wouldn't. The type of activity the government is engaged in only works when people are passive.
if you're served a lawful court order, you either obey it or risk the consequences, up to and including time in jail.
When was the last time anyone of stature went to jail for defending the public against the government?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nacchio
They don't even have to prosecute you for not obeying a secret order, they can easily use some other law to put you away, especially given they have legal access to any communication about, from and to you. I choose to believe him rather than the NSA on the reasons for that prosecution.
I imagine that case had a sobering effect on anyone high up in these companies who was inclined to stand up to the NSA.
I don't think that's taking a risk. From all accounts, the tax deductions they're taking are perfectly legal. Leaking government secrets? Not so legal…
There's an obvious reward for taking "questionable" tax deductions: lower taxes. What does Ballmer, specifically, gain from releasing classified information?
And really? You want to compare questionable tax practices that aren't actually questionable legally to something that can be construed as espionage?
But they wouldn't. The type of activity the government is engaged in only works when people are passive.
Those two statements don't follow. The government may cease these practices if people find out and come out against them, but that doesn't stop them from prosecuting the person that brought them to light.
When was the last time anyone of stature went to jail for defending the public against the government?
When was the last time anyone of stature defended the public from the government via illegal means?
It's a risk. Full-stop. You can get prosecuted for releasing classified information. And let's not even take it all the way to going to jail. The government can make your life a living hell just by prosecuting you for a crime, even if they're unsuccessful in getting a conviction.
Which leads me back to my first question, why would Ballmer take that risk?
... you challenge it, pulling out from campaign contributions, and making noise in the press. Microsoft (and Google, and Yahoo, and and and) have billions of dollars they could use to resist pretty much any law they wanted to.
Every day we complain that modern democracies are captive to moneyed commercial interests, and now we should believe that actually, they're completely powerless, oppressed by Big Bad Government? I don't think so.
Granted, Microsoft et. al could attempt to lobby politicians to get these sorts of laws reversed, but that's not the position I was arguing against. Specifically, the GP said, "Do you think the government would jail someone of Steve Ballmer's stature if he talked openly about what the government has asked of Microsoft." That's an argument that Ballmer clearly could've talked about these programs because they wouldn't arrest him, but that assumes two things: a) Ballmer knew about this, and b) Ballmer was willing to take the risk that he wouldn't go to prison if he talking about that. Neither of those are a given.
Talking about lobbying is attacking an argument I didn't make, but I'll address it anyway.
From the standpoint of the big companies, lobbying only makes sense before the law is passed if you have no interest in following it. Alternatively, you follow it while lobbying to get it changed. You now have companies attempting to get the government to allow them to talk more openly about what they do with regards to PRISM and so forth. To put it in perspective, if SOPA had've passed, do you think Google et. al would've just ignored it?
The standard some have applied to Snowden should also apply to corporate executives: companies should oppose the orders publicly, and "face the music." Ballmer might be arrested, or his family harassed, but he would go from dancing developer monkey to public hero overnight.
(In the US, corruption is hidden by punishing whistleblowers.)
Perhaps... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_for_NSA_spying
In the US, my understanding is that companies lobby for things they want politicians to do. If any of these tech giants wanted less surveillance, wouldn't that be how they'd facilitate it?
Replace "in the US" with "in Nazi Germany" or "in Soviet Russia" and you'll see how chilling that sentence is. They're just following orders. It's the utter banality of evil.
"Are major companies based or operating in the US allowed to provide secure email and/or data storage without options for lawful surveillance from law enforcement?"
Compare 47 USC §1002(b)(3):
A telecommunications carrier shall not be responsible for decrypting, or ensuring the government’s ability to decrypt, any communication encrypted by a subscriber or customer, unless the encryption was provided by the carrier and the carrier possesses the information necessary to decrypt the communication.
Also, (b)(1):
This subchapter does not authorize any law enforcement agency or officer—
(A) to require any specific design of equipment, facilities, services, features, or system configurations to be adopted by any provider of a wire or electronic communication service, any manufacturer of telecommunications equipment, or any provider of telecommunications support services; or
(B) to prohibit the adoption of any equipment, facility, service, or feature by any provider of a wire or electronic communication service, any manufacturer of telecommunications equipment, or any provider of telecommunications support services.
Finally, (b)(2):
The [interception capability] requirements of [...] this section do not apply to [...] information services [...]
http://paranoia.dubfire.net/2010/09/calea-and-encryption.htm...
Note "unless the encryption was provided by the carrier." Skype is the one that provides encryption here (a carrier) as far as I understand. No user can influence it. You are right that they are allowed to make the systems where users would provide keys themselves and that then the carrier wouldn't be required to assist in the decryption.
Any "crypto" which doesn't do secure keygen on the client for "at rest" data storage is now significantly more suspect than before these revaluations. You can explain away whatever you like in terms of "usability" or "most users don't care", but now manyof us are going to read any excuses as "Yeah, the US government has got to our CEO… And he's not gonna be the next Qwest guy…"
"Secret laws" are not laws, they are tyrannical pseudo-rules that belong in the Middle Ages.
Still, I've no doubt that french secret services practice all kind of immoral if not illegal stuffs (at the widest scale they can afford), and they have "interesting" theories about what allows them to do that (or maybe they they are just crazy enough to don't care at all, like the recent declaration about the law not applying at all to those programs seems to says...)
You start by demanding that this process, this subversion of democracy, be made illegal.
This is the root of the problem: secrecy. Secrecy corrupts as much as power, and absolute secrecy corrupts absolutely.
Take $5B out of the cash pile. Lobby to dismantle the laws or severely weaken it.
That is, you don't need to quit your only mildly, indirectly enabling job right this instance, throwing your family into financial difficulties. But, you do need to work towards untangling yourself as much as your conscious demands.
Note that when the EU data retention directive (which is often used here under the header "see, others are doing it to", even though it doesn't even come close to what the NSA does) was initiated, that's exactly what many telecom providers and ISP's did, before and after this came into affect. It didn't stop it, but it least it has brought it out into the open, making it an (still ongoing) public issue.
The remarkable part of what's happening in the US is the utterly quiet and extremely forthcoming complicity of major companies who otherwise don't seem to have any problem throwing a lot of resources at manipulating governments foreign and domestic.
And in the case of Microsoft, in it's monopolists heydays, even up to the point of structurally breaking the law.
Also, it's not like they are only quiet about it because the law tells them so: they actively deny it, hell, they even advertise with pure lies about the privacy of their services.
These companies aren't victims anymore. They are complicit.
Lastly, it should be quiet obvious that with absolutely no restriction in the wiretapping of foreign nationals, they are breaking the law in every country they do business in. Those foreigners, like myself, have no voice in US legislation.
From my perspective as a non-American, Microsoft is complicit in a full frontal attack on our civil liberties. We can't stop the US government, but we can certainly stop Microsoft e.a. from doing business here.
I'll let you know how that goes from here in Sydney, Australia.
Yeah,I'm not a US citizen. None of the "with a valid court order" weasel-words apply to me.
CALEA applies to telecommunications providers, which is a label that would seem to clearly apply to Skype. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calea
Are major companies based or operating in the US allowed to provide secure email and/or data storage without options for lawful surveillance from law enforcement?
If people do not like these policies and the cooperation from the companies operating them, I think the proper place to direct your anger is at the laws that require them to cooperate.