It may just be a gag order thing, sure. But with the level of access required for stuff like this, I don't think they could shut the whole team up. How many people worked on this Microsoft back door? It can't have been less than a couple dozen at least. And none of them raised the issue or let someone know, a journalist for instance, or publicly raised the question?
It makes me wonder about the true extent of the programs we're freaking out about. I mean, of course they exist and they're big and threatening, but I don't buy that they could combine complete access with complete secrecy. They need the cooperation of the companies, and the companies, by NSA standards, just aren't trustworthy enough. In fact, they're full of wild cards like Snowden, denizens of newsgroups, IRC, 4chan, etc, who would LOVE to be the one to blow up an NSA attempt to write a back door into Skype.
Maybe they did, and it all faded away. But it just seems strange to me that so little has been said about the elephant that must surely have been in everyone's room for the last few years.
self-driving cars, balloon network testing in NZ, google fiber, and more mundane things like Golang and angular.
I don't give them a pass, its just that in the bad column they're the same as all the other actors in this drama, on the good column they're a damn cool tech company that can realistically change the world in fundamental and positive ways.
EDIT: also for the most part their interests are selfishly aligned with ours. They want a fast easy open internet. That contrasts pretty sharply with FB/MS/APPLE - who are more about hardware/walled gardens. Though all these lines seem to getting blurred.
http://blumenthals.com/blog/2012/01/31/is-google-intentional...
They recently got rapped by the FTC for it.
http://wallstcheatsheet.com/stocks/ftc-googles-ad-practice-i...
The difference is that the negative Microsoft news tends to float on top of sites like HN more than positive news, and the reverse is true for Google so this alters perceptions of people.
These were reissued rules that clarified and enhanced the rules issued by the FTC in 2002 to make advertising clear. It likely came out of Danny Sullivan's letter to the FTC[2] showing how the competitors accusing Google Shopping of not disclosing paid inclusion well enough had no intention of themselves following the FTC's rules.
> The difference is that the negative Microsoft news tends to float on top of sites like HN more than positive news, and the reverse is true for Google so this alters perceptions of people.
You clearly visit a different HN than I do. While there is plenty of positive Google news here, the negative news in the top 10 is almost daily (Reader, account closing, PRISM, etc). Considering your account is 6 hours old (with 196 karma!), maybe stick around for a while before making pseudo-hypotheses about story dynamics?
[1] http://searchengineland.com/ftc-search-engine-disclosure-164...
[2] http://searchengineland.com/a-letter-to-the-ftc-regarding-se...
Ok I've been around for awhile and can vouch that what he's claiming happens regularly. Some links from the last time I bothered to comment on it can be found in the following:
So sure, you could blame some perceived Google bias on Google shills flagging Microsoft articles. You could also blame some perceived Anti-Microsoft bias on Microsoft shills being abrasive and causing comment sections to become toxic (for example, by filling the comment sections with comments complaining about HN rank compared to Google articles).
I see little to no evidence for either, I am not in a position to inspect the complete data to determine what is causing any perceived phenomenon (nor are you, I suspect).
With hnrankings.info I believe you could establish a trend (so far I have only seen specific handpicked examples, not a trend. A trend is probably there, but nobody that I have seen has bothered to do the legwork to uncover it.), but there is not enough there to say that (as many have claimed) there are non-organic rings of flaggers targetting pro-Microsoft articles.
But here's a simple experiment that can be done in a few minutes: search for daringfireball.net links on HN, click on the ones with a decent number of points, put those into hnrankings.info and you'll see a clear pattern of flagging for pretty much every single one.
Now maybe Gruber articles are just terrible (ymmv) but I can say that every other article I've seen flagged down (fairly easy to tell from rank/points/time) falls into the same categories. And I don't see how it's a big conspiracy theory to apply occam's razor to the observation that "hey all these anti-google or pro-apple or pro-ms links have a graph that makes it look like they were flagged off the first page". The same mentality that would abuse this is not hard to find in the comment sections of many tech sites so I'm not sure why anyone would be surprised or think HN is immune.
And again if HN mods want to produce a list of flagged articles I'm confident it would back the assertions that I and others have made.
Oh, btw, I know many people over here in Europe who never use any Google service other than search out of general mistrust towards the company. Might not help them much, as the search history combined with the IP-address logs of all the G+ buttons is already a pretty encompassing profile, but nonetheless they exist and constitute a non-negligible fraction of the populace over here.
Google/Apple are not going to get shut down over this. They can afford lawsuits and penalties. So why not take a stand? Are they really that timid? Or is what they would reveal actually so grim they just sit by and hope they're somehow going to escape this?
This is the time to put cost/benefit analysis aside and take a stand. Show the world what kind of company you are. So far, its all whimps and pushovers.
"Google Lawsuit Challenges N.S.A. Domestic-Spying Apparatus"
the first hit on google for "google nsa lawsuit"
We know where you are. We know where you’ve been.
We can more or less know what you’re thinking about
Just remember when you post something, the computers
remember forever
[1] http://www.stateofsearch.com/top-15-of-eric-schmidts-remarka...[emphasis mine]
...and for you!
[filter bubble anyone?!]
http://www.bing.com/search?q=google+nsa+lawsuit
1) Maryland Attorney Mike Slocumb Comments on Google Privacy Class Action Lawsuit and NSA Surveillance Case (negative)
2) Google surveillance far surpasses the NSA, author says - CBS News (negative)
3) EPIC files FOIA request over reported Google, NSA partnership ... (negative)
4) ACLU sues Obama administration over NSA surveillance (neutral - not even really about Google, just prism)
5) Lawsuit Could Find Out If Google Working For NSA? For a long… (negative)
6) Conservative activist files lawsuit over NSA surveillance | PCWorld (neutral)
7) Maryland Attorney Mike Slocumb Comments on Google Privacy… (negative)
8) Lawsuit filed over NSA phone spying program - Computerworld (neutral - not even really about Google, just prism)
Everything is a filter bubble.
Developers only need to build some APIs - those APIs can be multi-purpose. They don't need to know that one such purpose is NSA spying - you can come up with dozens of other reasons for wanting a "back door".
The actual interface that's used for responding to legally binding orders or subpoenas and that uses the APIs in question can be built by people on NSA's payroll.
Besides executives, the only people slightly aware of what's going on will be some people from the legal department. And they'll get presented with an interface in which they have to double-check (in bulk) the validity of received orders.
A service provider is the middleman in this case and encryption only serves the purpose of you making sure that communications are with this service provider and not with another middleman.
"Breaking the encryption" is not accurate. They don't need to break anything as your data is in plain text on their servers.
While this is true, I don't think it was his point. His point, I believe, was that the software should protect the data, and the engineer should not install or create APIs that allow someone to circumvent the security and privacy of the user — for any reason. He was replying to someone saying that higher ups could lie about the reason or need for such an API; his reply was saying that even the lie should be so obviously privacy-breaking as to be unacceptable. (Hence, he asked for examples.)
That said: legitimate law enforcement requests, i.e., warrants, would be an acceptable reason to me to implement such an API. That said, it should be auditable, so that you can verify it isn't being abused.
This provides full PRISM access and allows for deniability of direct access.
Oh what's that? There is an NSA module most big companies run on their servers? Right, it's called SE Linux. The question that remains how do you build a backdoor that cannot easily be spotted in the source code. Maybe a weakness in a random number generator used for encryption. Oh what's that? The NSA does that too?
On Backdoor in encryption standard: http://www.wired.com/politics/security/commentary/securityma...
On SE Linux: http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-07-03/security-enh...
This speaks about the lowest level of ethics. Many things are more important than the shareholders Once I was working for the tax agency of my country and they wanted to hide tax information for specific politicians (that obviously were involved in corruption cases). I loudly spoke against the project and was ready to speak about it to the press. The project was cancelled at the end.
Oh how times change.
A little bird told me that Microsoft was the most "helpful" out of all the big tech companies. If this new article is accurate, I hope that statement also was. I'm rather pro-US/NSA. But, even I find this new leak very disturbing if it's accurate and true.
Being realistic, I bet all the other big American tech companies are doing similar things. For example, my thinking is still that FB gives law enforcement a "god view" of all information and communications (even if it is in a round about way, like Microsoft allegedly does).
This document just says that surveillance was broken for chats when they did the outlook.com upgrade, but that has since been fixed.
This also provides some answers to http://www.skypeopenletter.com/.
"We provide customer data only when we receive a legally binding order or subpoena to do so, and never on a voluntary basis. In addition we only ever comply with orders for requests about specific accounts or identifiers. If the government has a broader voluntary national security program to gather customer data we don’t participate in it."
One down, several to go. If I were Google/Facebook/Yahoo executives I would be very worried right now as to what soon-to-be-released revelations say about their NSA cooperation. Sure, they may have only done that which was compelled by FISC order, but that won't preclude them from being perceived as culpable.