Put another way, our failure of due process has led to a severe security breach. What made him flee was not convictions—he fled because Bradley Manning is in solitary.
Daniel Ellsberg, the Pentagon Papers leaker, argued well that Snowden made the right call to flee.[0]
Forcing down his plane, or any number of molestations, would only exacerbate this baffling strategy of abusing people to the extreme.
If the government didn't do that bullshit, like Ellsberg said, he'd come home and have his day in court.
[0] http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/daniel-ellsberg-nsa-l...
Snowden is running away from having to take responsibility for his actions. It's not complicated. He knows full-well the penalties of revealing classified information, and acknowledged on multiple documents (going into his job) that he knew the procedures if he leaked any information. He leaked information. He doesn't want to go through that process, so he finds it easier to run to someone else in hopes that he won't face punishment.
This makes about as much sense as the same argument from Airplane!: "They bought their tickets, they knew what they were getting in to. I say, let 'em crash!"
It's not complicated. If a system is corrupt, any punishments that system may mete out for bringing that corruption to light are also corrupt, by default, and should rationally be opposed.
Keep in mind, we have the Manning example to look at. "Facing punishment" in this case equates to "being tortured".
I don't think you're seriously suggesting that he should just turn himself in to be tortured - that gains everyone nothing. So what is your angle?
Sure there seem to be extenuating circumstances, but ultimately he did knowingly break a law. Regardless of whether you think it's just or unjust, a law is a law. Devout Christians seem to think that paying taxes that ultimately support abortion is immoral. If they don't pay their taxes, they're guilty of tax evasion regardless of how moral they feel it is. This is probably a bad example, but I'm just trying to illustrate a point here.
Anyways, I was trying to say that the government isn't simply torturing Manning, there's a good reason for keeping him isolated. In a sense, he knew what he was doing, releasing troves of information that he had no legal right to release. He's going through the painful legal stuff now, but in a lot of ways I think he's better off isolated, rather than murdered by fellow inmates.
Can I rephrase? A law is only a law. Followed by none, it has no power, revered religiously, it becomes an instrument of great pain and suffering.
Opinion follows: Unjust laws should not be followed, or given any heed beyond condescension towards both the law and those who passed it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_Unite...
So what?
The entire point I was trying to make was that I don't think the average HN reader, whatever their level of dedication to rule of law (some more, some less), wants to see a guy tortured because he broke a law, less so when the law is being abused by a corrupt system in furtherance of its corruption.
Not making this argument basically means that you're outsourcing your moral compass to a third party, a third party who often makes tenuous and outright backwards connections between moral principles and laws.
All judgements aside, the normative argument is the only thing there's any kind of discussion or disagreement on. Making the descriptive one apropos of nothing carries the connotation that you value the rule of law above all else.
I voted you up for whatever that's worth, but I wish you'd expand on what you mean. Oftentimes it seems you and I misunderstand each other.
It's not that being misunderstood is a great injustice, but rather that it makes it very difficult to make descriptive points on HN, since the forum is unnecessarily tilted towards normative judgements that is is frankly not well qualified to make.
Moreover, descriptive comments often include "hard facts" data about the way things work, and are the product of some amount of research and analysis, which is valuable no matter what the commenter might believe. Normative comments very rarely have that value.
Put simply: a comment describing the way things work isn't a strong indicator that the author of the comment wants things to work that way.
Show of hands. Who here legitimately thinks that Manning and Snowden didn't break the law as written?
With that in mind, I can only assume that someone posting something like this (especially comments like "the law is the law" - a tautology in any other context) has a different objective in mind, since most posters here don't post obvious facts to waste everyone's time.
Have you, personally, ever heard someone use the words "the law is the law" to have any other meaning other than the veneration of rule of law above some other concern? I have not.
Why should I suffer for revealing the unlawful acts of my government?
To be honest, I am outraged that more people do not write, email, or reach out to the White House and demand that this guy is pardoned or at least guaranteed a fair trial.
You keep on thinking Snowden is going to get a fair trial though.
Manning's trial is ongoing as we speak. Am I the only one paying attention to it?
> Manning was held from July 2010 in the Marine Corps Brig, Quantico, Virginia, under Prevention of Injury status, which entailed de facto solitary confinement and other restrictions that caused international concern. In April 2011 he was transferred to Fort Leavenworth, where he could interact with other detainees.[3] He pleaded guilty in February 2013 to 10 of the 22 charges, which could carry a sentence of up to 20 years.[4] The trial on the remaining charges, including aiding the enemy, began on June 3, 2013.[5]
So, from indictment to trial was about 3 years, no?
This is a decent Slate article on the topic:
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...
Complicating things in Manning's case:
* The trial took place under UCMJ rules, which are different from civilian rules
* Manning's supposed mental health issues delayed his arraignment while it was determined whether he was fit to stand trial.
We also don't know (do we? sources welcome) whether Manning's defense wanted to hasten the trial. Trial delays often work to the advantage of defendants.
What I think we do at this point know is that Manning's treatment from July 2010 through April 2011, as a maximum security POI inmate at Quantico, was inhumane. It's worth mentioning that similar inhumanity is inflicted on civilian criminal inmates; it doesn't make the practice any more morally acceptable, but suggests that Manning's experience wasn't (unfortunately) unprecedented.
Regardless, my original comment meant only to speak to the issue of whether Manning was "held without trial". I don't think he was.
No, quite the opposite. The government is, however.
[1] http://usmilitary.about.com/library/weekly/aa102200a.htm
I am a reservist, I have been mobilised at short notice and served overseas, and amazingly I would have no problem whatsoever not murdering Manning or someone like him, and indeed, were he in my custody, I would have a problem with and would even try to stop some wandering psychopath who did try to murder him. Crazy days.
Most of my peers would take a _much_ different approach to that situation, I'm sure.
As to your personal question; I would stand against any unlawful actions taken against a detainee, and anything requiring unnecessary personal harm or danger. I don't like treating anyone inhumanely.
Umm, "intelligently sidestepping a justice system known for its egregious disregard for due process in cases similar to his, as amply demonstrated by the Manning precedent" would be a better overall characterization of his actions.
I think the flaw in your argument is that you're acquiescing to the supposed authority, legality and rightness of the USG and its military/intelligence agents.
Snowden is in absolutely no way running away "from having to take responsibility for his actions" -- he is running from a USG that has shown and proven they will torture and kill those who get in their way.
You think Manning is just "sitting in solitary" -- given his open homosexuality -- I am sure between waterboardings he is being forcefully sodomized and otherwise tortured.
You are under the delusion that the NSA/USG is "the good guys" -- they are agents of the CIA's psychopathy.
Do you really believe Manning is being waterboarded and sodomized? Do they just squeeze those sessions in between his trial appearances or something?
What do you think they do in sites where people are renditioned to?
Is that all it takes, a lot of time served and then the guards get bored and sodomize you?
> What do you think they do in sites where people are renditioned to?
I have no clue. As best as I can tell waterboarding was finally taken off the menu around 2008 or so. But Manning wasn't 'renditioned' so I'm not sure what that has to do with my question anyways.
This is a reasonable question, but not sure the word 'regime' is warranted. If you're talking about Venezuela then that's a democratically elected government.
As such, Snowden has to worry about many scenarios. Will his "host" country use him to extract concessions out of the United States in exchange for his extradition? When the regime changes in the country he ends up in, will he wear out his welcome? Can the country he ends up in even protect him from extraordinary rendition? Even if the country fully intends on assisting Snowden, would it be able to weather whatever sanctions were levied on it by the United States in the form of trade restrictions? Ecuador didn't seem to think so.
Then there is the question of whether he can even get to the country he is going to. France and Spain (indirectly) forced down the jet of the president of Bolivia on the rumor that Snowden was on the plane. There is no reason to expect that they and other European countries won't do so again. Routes from Russia to Cuba (assuming he has to use Havana as a stop) also typically fly over the United States. The United States is free to, if not directly force the plane down in the United States, not grant it permission to fly in U.S. airspace, effectively forcing it to land in a U.S. friendly country (Canada). And Cuba might simply hand him over to improve U.S. relations. My understanding is that small private jets simply do not have the range to go directly from Moscow to any of the countries listed (perhaps Venezuela would be just within reach).
At this point, though, I don't really see what option Snowden has but to take Venezuela's asylum offer and hope for the best. He is on a small boat on the ocean in a raging storm. His fate is not in his own hands.