That is what an evanescent wave is. There is light that decays exponentially "bleeding" off the reflective surface[1]. The snell's law solution is sort of a hack, what is really going on has to do with the quantum wavefunction of the photon ensembles, but the result is the same.
Biologists use evanescent waves to do microscopy - you can illuminate an area of low density underneath your coverslip, and effectively a very very thin layer of flourescence is illuminated right above the coverslip.
It would seem reasonable that the NSA would use exactly this technology to tap fiber optic cables without splicing them, and it should be nearly undetectable. There will be a nonzero loss of photons if you tap it, but it should be relatively negligible.
[1]note - the photonic energy is just 'there' as in the wavefunction has nonzero amplitude in that spatial region. It's 'bleeding' into the space outside of the fiber optic channel, but it's not actually bleeding energy, there is no energy loss from this 'spatial bleeding', unless there is something in that zone that is capable of absorbing that photonic energy.
http://www.goochandhousego.com/products/passive-fiber-optic-...
This is not a term used in fiber comm. The wave traveling down the fiber has a "mode", and part of it extends beyond the core. Yes, that part is evanescent, but it is part of the mode solution from Maxwell's equations.
All you've done is restated OP's explanation of how a fiber tap works.
It is also detectable: Long haul folks sometimes pull up the cable to service it for various reasons. So they pull it up and see a zillion fiber taps? WTF?
And where does that cable tap go?
To your bigger point: Yes, this article has zero explanation of how it is done. The salient sentences are:
However, light signals can not be read in another way. Therefore you have so far to expose and turn that a small part of the light waves emerging from the fiber, the individual glass fibers. If you immediately reinforce these waves again and transported via another cable, it has diverted the data.
To anyone in fiber comm, this language is pretty much gobbledegook. Any chance the pastebin is a translation? It vaguely sounds like someone is describing a fiber tap, but in such confused language as to make it sound like a bad spy novel.
Edit: I should have read through the thread. It is a translation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5982681
Further, there are a ton of options for collecting data from a fiber connection at the endpoints that don't involve splicing the fibers at all. There's no reason to cut a fiber when you can detach the end and attach something between the end and the connector. Another possibility is a "software tap" where they could install packet sniffers in the relay firmware.
I'm not trying to say that I know how the NSA tap technology works, and I certainly can't rule out using a submarine to splice into wires at the bottom of the ocean, but I'm pretty sure there are smarter ways to achieve the desired result.
two: when you're a gov't agency you want to justify having a big budget and a shiny new toy, plus the overhead can be used for other stuff.
Maybe that's the old way ...
Yes, the other countries' subs patrol, but with submarines it's all about stealth and avoiding the patrol.
Blind Man's Bluff is a great read on the subject. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blind_Man%27s_Bluff:_The_Untold...
Make breaks A and B near the endpoints. Make a third break X, between A and B, and install splitter at X.
Please reference an example of a 99/1 splitter existing and usable on an optical line system. You can't get a usable signal from 1% of the light. The levels you would need to split off would be entirely noticeable.
> So how do you turn a piece of fiber into a beam-splitter without cutting and splicing? Well, that's surprisingly easy. One way to create a fiber beam splitter is to take two fibers and fusion-combine them.
This is not possible to do on a live system without it being service affecting.
http://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage9.cfm?objectgroup_id=171...
>You can't get a usable signal from 1% of the light. The levels you would need to split off would be entirely noticeable.
http://www.perkinelmer.com/CMSResources/Images/44-12462DTS_S...
Obviously, you'd need something faster. However, 1% of a microwatt is more than detectors like this need to get damned good signal. In fact, it might be enough to burn it out. If you have good control over the fusing process, splitting off much less than 1% would probably be preferable.
>This is not possible to do on a live system without it being service affecting.
Why not? The only impact on the fiber being tapped would be a brief period of heating and a temporary change in refractive index over, perhaps, a couple cm of fiber.
Nah, get the best split/splice you can without affecting the target fiber (without causing detection). You could use a power meter to determine the resultant signal strength, but if you've planned/done this more than a couple of times, you know what it is going to say. You could use an attenuator if needed to protect the detector, but since the detector current is dependent upon the gain of its amplifier, it would be simpler to simply adjust the gain. In fact using an auto-gain-circuit (AGC) here would be preferred, since it will automatically compensate for any differences in splice quality (within range). Also, it would be clumsy to design an amp that could easily burn out your detector, but sometimes you do crazy things when pushing performance to the limits.
IMO you couldn't use a silicon detector like the one from Perkin Elmer. It is fairly large (170um x 170um), and therefore has a large Capacitance, and therefore is as you say, slow. However, such detectors exist. They would probably use InGaAs if they used off the shelf stuff. Here is an example http://www.thorlabs.com/Thorcat/10700/APD310-Manual.pdf There are almost certainly better choices than InGaAs if they forget about cost and don't need to produce enough to supply the whole world. Given that NSA has its own chip-fab capabilities (it does), this seems like a possibility. Being on the ocean floor here is great because it is cool and dark, and therefore low-thermal-noise (also not a lot of RF, I bet).
>>This is not possible to do on a live system without it being service affecting.
>Why not? The only impact on the fiber being tapped would be a brief period of heating and a temporary change in refractive index over, perhaps, a couple cm of fiber.
I also see no reason that this or some other method could not be employed on a live cable, and go unnoticed.
My question is how the NSA gets the data back to where they want it. They have to lay cables of their own, probably have remote stations to reject some of the data; or maybe NSA has a secret undersea fiber network that rivals the normal one. They certainly have the money, I just never considered it.
There's no way you're getting through that without it being service affecting. Even once you get through the layers of protective sheathing, and around the copper power lines that provide power to the undersea amps, you're suggesting that they fully remove the reflective sheathing to bend the fiber and tap off light? That is absolutely ludicrous. The process would introduce much more span attenuation than splicing in a 50/50 fiber tap (which is 3db).
Are you doing this to every fiber in the bundle, you'll need at least two tapped to get bi-directional communication. It's simply unfeasible.
The NSA loves when people think this thought.
At some point the signal must
a) be converted from electrical to optical
b) be boosted down the wire
c) be converted from optical to electrical
Easiest solution? Tap in at A, B or C.
Who's going to notice that your repeater at the bottom of the ocean actually has a NSA listener plugged into its debug socket?
If you want to tap a classical signal traveling down a fiber, you want to turn that fiber into a beam splitter. A beam splitter probabilistically reroutes photons from the data stream down a different fiber. Since a single bit traveling down a fiber optic cable is represented by millions of photons in an identical optical state and fiber-optic lines are lossy, a few won't be missed. A 99/1 splitter (i.e. 99% one way, 1% the other) would be pretty hard to detect in a fiber optic line that is subject to fluctuating loss caused by bending, temperature change, etc..
The trick, according to this article, is to avoid cutting the fiber and splicing in a beam splitter. This is because, immediately after the fiber goes dark, the company running it will want to know where the fault is and hook up an OTDR to the line. In the simplest terms possible, this is a device that sends light down the fiber and looks at what gets reflected back. Any break in the fiber will reflect light back the way it came. Time how long the round-trip takes and you can pinpoint where the break is and send out a repair crew. If the operators are fast this can take mere seconds to do. Naturally, the NSA doesn't want repair crews finding their tap-in points!
So how do you turn a piece of fiber into a beam-splitter without cutting and splicing? Well, that's surprisingly easy. One way to create a fiber beam splitter is to take two fibers and fusion-combine them. Basically, you put them right next to each other and heat them up so that they melt together just a little bit. If you did this to a line in service it would never have to be cut. This is dead easy to do... to one fiber... in a lab. Doing it to a bundle of fibers in the deep sea is challenging! However, it's certainly feasible. Given that the NSA's budget dwarfs the entire scientific research budget of many nations, it's reasonable to expect they could get pretty good at it given a couple of decades.
They probably aren't doing this. I've done a little in free-space optics, but fiber really isn't in my bailiwick. There are probably other, much easier ways. However, based on a few minutes of thought I'm convinced the claims of the article are beyond merely feasible. I'd be shocked if the NSA, and every other nation out there with subs, doesn't have the same capability.
The real trick, of course, is getting the data back home (and processing it). The article suggests that the Jimmy Carter has the ability to lay fiber lines, presumably to take their purloined bits back to the nearest NSA processing center. The amplifiers spoken of are unlikely to be used to boost the signal that continues on the original fiber back to the people being spied upon, simply because a good method of tapping in should be indistinguishable from fiber loss, plus components like amplifiers spliced into the line are detectable! No, those amplifiers are likely there to boost the signal going down the NSA's pirate lines. What I don't understand is how the NSA keeps their lines from being detected. Wouldn't, for example, Russia patrol it's fiber back-bones (while tapping other nations fiber) and cut the NSA's lines? There may very well be an underwater struggle going on day-to-day that we're entirely unaware of!