News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by jcampbell1 on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:05PM (#5971976)
The auction model for ads basically ruins internet searches in transactional categories. If you want to win at the "italian restaurant" search game, you have to bid the highest for the ad, which means you must have the highest margin. The best way to win is to open a restaurant with ridiculously high margins (over priced wine and cheap ingredients).

Want the "cheapest car insurance"? Google is zero help. It sends you to Geico or a bunch of lead-gen sites, and no matter what, you will end up at an insurance company that makes the biggest margins.

If you really want the cheapest car insurance, you need to find a company that doesn't advertise, and is non-profit, that way your premium is spent buying insurance, not TV ads and Berkshire Hathaway's stock appreciation.

Whenever I see a SERP full of ads, I search for something different. When there is nothing but ads, Google is sending you to high-margin crap.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by notatoad on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:58PM (#5973512)
Internet searches in many categories have always been useless. Searching for a restaurant or car insurance has never ever returned anything useful on any search engine, ever. it's not as though google used to have incredibly relevant results for a search term like "cheapest car insurance" and now it's been replaced by ads. The only thing a search like that has ever gotten you is the websites of the insurance companies who are well established brands.

The categories where google is pushing a lot of ads or supplementary features like knowledge graph are the categories where organic results are not a good experience. 9 times out of 10, when i search for something on google i get a traditional SERP with little to no advertising. If you're searching for something that doesn't necessarily lend itself to a web search, google should be trying to find some way to make that useful to somebody, whether that is a feature that gives you better results or an admission that their organic results for that query are useless, so here have some ads instead.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by hobs on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:41PM (#5973760)
In regards to your first paragraph, you are completely right because the product has always not been the consumer of the search.

I dont if it would be possible for a subscription based search service to exist, but as long as they are selling to advertisers and not to the people there is very little incentive for this to change imo.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by netcan on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:29PM (#5972180)
It's not quite like that.

What advertisers can afford to pay is margin X conversion rate. If people search for cheap socks and you have high margin socks, your conversion rate will be lower. In super competitive markets, the conversion rate is usually what makes one win. For something like insurance quotes, that probably means the one with a known brand, supporting advertising in tv & radio, etc.

The quality of the sites and the margins will probably be pretty similar among most players.

Where the dynamic you're describing happens is between product categories where you have a high margin per unit in one product category. Eg. If you want to sell a 'diy divorce kit with a $5 margin' you will have to outbid divorce lawyers who expect to earn thousands per client. The lawyers will drown everyone else out.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by AJ007 on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:15PM (#5972546)
I don't know about the sock market, but there are lots of categories where the arms race for user revenue-maximization has either not yet started, or everyone is using very old techniques.

A better example would be someone selling "cheap" socks but with expensive shipping. Or, aggressively upselling additional sock products in the checkout, possibly with FTC-unfriendly opt-in vs opt-out methods. Or, hammering their users with advertising after the sale by email and phone.

When a particular vertical market gets aggressive, the item being advertised usually brings little, no, or negative revenue to the advertiser, and all of the money is made on the back.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by jcampbell1 on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:42PM (#5972302)
> The lawyers will drown everyone else out.

The worst lawyers will drown everyone else out, including the good lawyers. The lawyer that has a high conversion rate by promising it will cost $5000, but ends up costing $30k drowns out the lawyer who legitimately quotes $10k.

I agree, for certain searches, the ads are helpful, but I stand by the notion of avoiding SERPs with tons of high value ads. The person paying for those ads will likely be you.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by ericd on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:31PM (#5974820)
Yeah, from what I've seen fraudulent advertising, bait and switch, and various other shady tricks are dominant strategies in adwords advertising within some categories, and I haven't seen any obvious effort by Google to curb it. If there was some way for Google to act as a reliable Better Business Bureau replacement, that rating would be a great addition to their ranking algo.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by md224 on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:30PM (#5972189)
I've been doing a lot of thinking about this topic recently, so it's nice to see a discussion on HN.

AdWords ad placement is determined by a mix of quality score and bid size. It's good that they're using quality of links to influence ad ranking, but here's what troubles me:

We're allowing money to influence information salience.

You could say this is how the world works, and I can't deny it. Money = power = eyeballs. But is this a good thing? Is this a dynamic we should be actively supporting? I honestly don't know.

Possible counterargument (because I can't help but play Devil's Advocate against myself):

Maybe the auction model is about determining the true "market price" of an ad position, in which case maybe this is a good thing?

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by notahacker on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:03PM (#5972462)
Is there any hypothetical search model in which money doesn't influence information salience? High performers for competitive searches in organic search have usually invested heavily in SEO and/or brand-building too. Open reviews can be astroturfed and social likes can be astroturfed or incentivised. At least with "sponsored results" it's blatant, and declared.

Ironically, considering the original article starts off by complaining about its effect on search results, the most-free-from-financial-influence way of ranking information salience is probably the Zagat review model (selling aggregated secret shopper info)

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by md224 on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:37PM (#5972666)
I don't claim that advertising is the only vector of influence, and I realize it is possibly the least worst version (because of labeling), but that hardly seems like a reason to consider it a Good Thing.

Your argument seems to be that if we get rid of sponsored search results, this will push advertisers to invest more heavily in less visible forms of opinion manipulation. This is actually a very interesting viewpoint and possibly a valid argument, but it also feels like coercion in some way ("give us ad space or we'll reach you via less ethical methods").

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by RivieraKid on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:16PM (#5972550)
I've been thinking about this too. IMHO, the only reason to advertise that is beneficial for both the consumer and the advertiser, is to provide information. Ie.: our product is objectively better than the competition for certain consumers, but the problem is, they don't know about us. So we create a ad campaign, that will be beneficial for both the consumers and our company.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by md224 on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:41PM (#5972707)
The goal of connecting people with value-providing businesses is a noble one, but the problem is the difficulty in using advertisements as reliable indicators of a product's merit. Economists have written about the prominence of advertisements as signaling mechanisms, but the bottom line is that I would rather rely on customer reviews than ad placement when it comes to determining if I want to buy a product.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by RivieraKid on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:02PM (#5972844)
I absolutely agree, most of the time ads don't help consumers make better market decisions.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by nowarninglabel on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:15PM (#5972056)
I think your hypothesis is quite far off. Can you give an example of an auto insurance company that is a non-profit? I couldn't find any. Perhaps you mean a mutual insurance company? Furthermore, when I bought car insurance last month, Geico gave me the most coverage for the least amount of money (after quite a bit of research), so I also don't agree with your assertation that Google is no help in that regard.

While I agree with the concept, as I work for a non-profit and belong to a credit union instead of a bank, I don't think your hypothesis holds without some data to back it up.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by austenallred on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:34PM (#5972230)
As someone who sells car insurance leads for a living, this is an interesting discussion.

First, Geicko isn't ranked number 1, affiliates who mask themselves as Geicko are. In high rewards markets like insurance (where 30% of the overall price of insurance goes to affiliates) it's actually about which affiliates convert the best and have the best payout. Those SERPs are dominated by black hat SEO. None of that is organic.

The larger issue (percentage of the page dedicated to SERPs vs ads aside) is that Google's formula worked best in a world where people weren't trying to game it. In the end it breaks down to relevance and links.

Relevance is based on tags and keywords, which everyone can get a perfect score on. So in the end it comes down to links.

Is a link there because someone just loves the site, or because some SEO schmuck built it? There are correlations, but there's really no way of knowing. The key to spam is mimicking a human process closely enough that a computer (or algorithm) can't tell the difference, then making that scale.

Google does manually review the SERPs for the highest grossing terms basically daily to try and find foul play, but those can be beat, too.

So why doesn't Google just manually find and serve up the best pages of content? Because you just described Yahoo.

So it's a very complex game that evolves every day as both parties advance and become more sophisticated, often in response to each other. If you think you can do better you either have to out-engineer Google or find a way to rank sites based on something other than links.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by webjprgm on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:48PM (#5972750)
Could Google Analytics data be used as "something other than links"? They can track traffic, bounce rates, how long people stay, how often the same people return. Would that provide a better indicator of quality pages? It would only apply to sites that opt-in by using Google Analytics, but if it made them rank higher than everyone would do it. (How many don't already?)
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by austenallred on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:45PM (#5973112)
Just because blackhat SEO ranked it doesn't mean it's not a page people will use or stay on. That would also require every site to have Google analytical installed. Google is a big company for sure, but not quite that ubiquitous.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by dennisgorelik on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:28PM (#5973365)
Why use Google Analytics, when there is Google Chrome browser?
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by josephlord on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:42PM (#5973098)
No Google already know too much about all of us.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by michaelhoffman on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:25PM (#5972130)
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by ActVen on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:50PM (#5972355)
This is hands down the best company with which I have ever done business. Their technology is amazingly far ahead of others in the banking and insurance space. I was taking a photo of a check with my smartphone to deposit it years before it became mainstream.

It is a great example of how constraints build value. By constraints I mean, they have had to deal with military customers stationed in far flung places for years. This built their capability to conduct business virtually.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by thecoffman on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:46PM (#5972735)
I will second pretty much everything you just said. I have renter's and auto insurance, checking, savings and a credit card all through USAA and they are fantastic. Many banks are just beginning to catch up with their technology and none can match their customer service.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by chii on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:48AM (#5976371)
i like the business model of USAA, where it isn't a corporation, but that everyone who becomes a member gets some sort of benefit. its almost like voluntary communism. I wonder if this model would work for other sorts of institutions.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by Terretta on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:48PM (#5972340)
> Can you give an example of an auto insurance company that is a non-profit?

Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange (PURE) is not "non-profit" but theoretically "policy holder owned" with surpluses to the benefit of subscribers.

To your point about credit unions, insurance 'unions' are interesting:

Overview: http://www.pureinsurance.com/about/index

That said, there is a marketing arm that extracts value as fees for marketing and management, and a financial stakeholder umbrella seeking return on capital. It's an interesting structure:

Structure: http://www.pureinsurance.com/about/pure_group

In any case, my experience with PURE has been superior to my experience with other insurers (except Met-Life who was excellent but unable to competitively insure my property), and my costs have been 30% less than the most competitively priced usual players.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by jrochkind1 on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:13PM (#5974363)
> Can you give an example of an auto insurance company that is a non-profit? I couldn't find any. Perhaps you mean a mutual insurance company?

Aren't mutual's non-profit? They aren't trying to extract a profit for investors or other owners, but just need to charge enough to pay business expenses (including salaries, as well as the main expense of an insurance company, paying out claims and funding reserves to pay out claims, etc.)

USAA mentioned in some other followups is... even weirder than a mutual insurance company, but it's legal structure is effectively the same as a mutual insurance company.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by leephillips on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:20AM (#5978357)
"Aren't mutual's non-profit?"

No, they distribute the profit to policyholders, who are effectively shareholders of the corporation. I belong to one, for auto and home. I get a dividend each year of 20 - 25% of the yearly premium, which is competitive even without considering the dividend. It's not open to the public.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by rogerbinns on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:16PM (#5973295)
> Can you give an example of an auto insurance company that is a non-profit?

AAA who do my insurance: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Automobile_Association

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by narrator on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:14PM (#5973280)
What's funny is how different using Consumer Reports online experience is. What? There's no free content? I have to pay a monthly fee to read content and it's not trivial. Best investment I ever made. Especially when buying new appliances. Ha.. It's kind of pathetic that I flinched at spending a few bucks a month for good content.

If you're getting information for free your information likely has a cost you're just paying for it in an obfuscated way in the form of higher margins when you shop at a place that advertises heavily.

If you ever look at Hulbert's Financial digest, which tracks the total return of investment letters you'll see that the ones that do well are $120/year. Oh yeah, you have to pay for the digest which will tell you which newsletter performs the best and that isn't cheap either.

Of course free investment advice is available everywhere online and usually makes a good contra-indicator. If I see a hype filled story show up in the freebie investment news it usually means the stock is about to take a short term down turn.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by corresation on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:25PM (#5974000)
Best investment I ever made. Especially when buying new appliances. Ha.. It's kind of pathetic that I flinched at spending a few bucks a month for good content.

I have an entirely different perspective of Consumer Reports (the online variant which has external site ads on it).

Understand that they are entirely biased (as we all are): They take home the lucre by keeping you thinking that you need them, and that they're doing an important service. Hence why the big noise about things like not recommending the iPhone -- all just noise to keep the subscription dollars coming and to create a sense of utility. They're also prone to taking complex products and then trying to distill it into easily quantified values that they can put in a chart and categorize, leading to a detachment from real-world value and "need to fill this issue". I was a subscriber for several years and eventually came to realize that their top picks were usually not really top picks, and they were often in areas where they were entirely out of their depth (I discovered that particularly after buying a set of their top pick speakers).

After that print subscription ended, years later I was looking at getting a new furnace and saw that the online site listed furnace reviews, though they were hidden behind a paywall. Okay, bought a subscription to find that there were no reviews at all, but some useless summary about basic efficiency levels. Well that's useless. Oh well, a year subscription wasted. A year later I discovered that they auto-renewed (never signed up for that, but whatever), and put it on my todo list to jump through hoops to cancel at some point, wasting my time (as they give NO clear way to cancel, despite subscribing being a trivial painless step). The next year they sent me notice that my credit card had expired -- awesome, easy way to finally unsubscribe from an auto-renew that I didn't opt into without sitting on hold for half an hour! Imagine how funny I thought it was when they guessed my next expiry and just used that, continuing the subscription.

I have an extremely poor opinion of CU, and I think the belief that they're more pure or their opinion more useful is a bit naive.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by pitchups on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:31PM (#5974459)
>> Imagine how funny I thought it was when they guessed my next expiry and just used that, continuing the subscription.

They are not guessing the expiry date - I believe it is a service provided by some credit card companies, possibly to large merchants. It happened to me for several years with my Yahoo Email account - that would renew for $20 / year even though my card expired twice during that time. It stopped after I reported my card as lost/stolen - and got a replacement card, so the actual card number changed. Fastest - albeit a bit drastic - way to get out of a recurring billing if you are having trouble cancelling.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:45PM (#5974556)
It's relatively easy to update the expiry date, since the month doesn't usually change. You just add two years, try the charge, and if it doesn't go through, wait a day and try it again with the next year. This is pretty standard for services with a recurring subscription model, and they don't really need to pay an outside provider for that info (although it would be trivial for any credit agency to provide.)

That said, I'm not sure he can complain that a recurring subscription continued to, well, recur.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by pbhjpbhj on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:10PM (#5975010)
Isn't that fraud though.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:27PM (#5975085)
I'm not a lawyer (nor an expert on payments) but generally it doesn't seem to have any element of fraud - it's collecting payment for services fairly rendered via the credit card account provided by the customer. Fraud would involve some kind of intentional deception.

If their was fraud, you could get a chargeback, and I don't see that happening very often.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by pbhjpbhj on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:35PM (#5975664)
You provide payment using the card. The card expires and can't - supposedly - be used beyond the expiry date to make a payment. There is no expectation of continued payment beyond the expiry date.

Guessing the new expiry date in order to exact a payment is taking an unauthorised payment. It can't be authorised because the card-holder can't authorise payments beyond the expiry date.

Taking a payment that isn't authorised by the card-holder by guessing some of the details of a card against the expectations of the card-holder appears to be fraudulent to me.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:26AM (#5975821)
No, you provided initial payment using the credit card account, but you signed up for the service until you cancel it, not until your method of payment expires.

Even if you cancelled the card outright, you're generally technically (and legally) still on the hook for a subscription if you don't go and cancel. Read the ToS for just about any recurring subscription. It's your obligation to cancel, not their obligation to guess when you want to cancel. Honestly, I'm not sure how that's unfair; it's not a service provider's business to interpret your payment methods and how they might map to your desire to cancel or retain a service.

The only reason most services don't bother to pursue payment for expired cards is because it's not economic to do so. So when a card expires, they eventually mark the account as overdue and disable it. That's not the same as a clean cancellation; technically you still owe them for the services rendered between the last invoice and the final cancellation.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @06:28PM (#5981147)
>you signed up for the service until you cancel it //

Maybe, that would depend on the legal terms under which you signed up. Mostly you sign up and pay for a fixed term. So contractually the expectation is that you don't continue payment.

If legally the payment is due, then that's still doesn't mean you can have authorised it on a card beyond the expiry date. Moreover you haven't authorised the payment with the new card (in the circumstances we're considering).

So the payment may be due, but it's been fraudulently acquired. There are procedures for collecting overdue amounts. Of course the companies don't want to follow those procedures and air their unfair [attempted] retention practices in court.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Monday July 08, 2013 @05:48PM (#6009562)
Hardly anyone offers a subscription service without an automatic renewal of some type. It's counter to the entire business model, which is that you spend once to acquire a customer but then earn back multiple subscription cycles from them (as the first cycle almost never pays back the cost of acquisition.)

Look at the Amazon Prime TOS, in all-caps: "UNLESS YOU NOTIFY US BEFORE A CHARGE THAT YOU WANT TO CANCEL OR DO NOT WANT TO AUTO RENEW, YOU UNDERSTAND YOUR PRIME MEMBERSHIP WILL AUTOMATICALLY CONTINUE AND YOU AUTHORIZE US (WITHOUT NOTICE TO YOU, UNLESS REQUIRED BY APPLICABLE LAW) TO COLLECT THE THEN-APPLICABLE MEMBERSHIP FEE AND ANY TAXES, USING ANY CREDIT CARD WE HAVE ON RECORD FOR YOU."

I'm guessing that their definition of "CREDIT CARD" is wide enough that they can roll the expiration date; when your card expiresd at Amazon you can just update the date without entering a "new card" - they consider the new physical card to be the same "payment method."

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by chii on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:41AM (#5976355)
interesting - so there is a business opportunity to collect these overdue amounts in large numbers, and exact the payment along with a "fine"…
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by corresation on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:52AM (#5977734)
It's your obligation to cancel, not their obligation to guess when you want to cancel.

You have a remarkably apologetic attitude towards a scumbag industry.

Just to be clear, here's the modus operendi for the retention industry-

1) Trick or outright scam people into recurring subscriptions. I never told Consumer Reports I wanted my subscription to recur, and it provides absolutely zero value to me that they did so. If they hid text somewhere for this, it is a clear and obvious example that the industry desperately needs onerous rules and restrictions prohibiting this, such as a customer yearly opt in and double-positive recurrence opt-in (rather than some hidden subtext that oh by the way we have your credit card so have fun cancelling sucker).

2) Hide methods of cancelling said subscription behind as many layers as possibly: It is shocking how easy it is to sign up for many things versus what is needed to cancel the same (as if charges on my credit card are less of an issue for me than the possibility that online access might be temporarily delayed). In Consumer Reports case, you could not email or fill out an online form -- the single and only option was a limited hours telephone number that required lengthy wait times. They know that many people will avoid the time sucking tax. Xbox Live had a particularly hilarious system where not only did you have to phone a call center and sit on hold, your cancellation had to be immediate (despite the fact that all payments were for future services, when you disabled recurrence they immediately downgraded your account) which of course is meant to delay people from jumping through the hoops until the last day when they might forget or give up and boom, another month.

While much noise was raised about Apple shaking down the subscription industry on the iOS platform, they will have to simply eat that cost because people like me have absolutely zero trust in the industry, and I greatly respect how Apple not only constantly reminds me of subscriptions, they make cancelling any of them the easiest thing in the world, so those services that want subscribers need to actually work

Recurrence is a tax on the world. It is inefficient and obnoxious companies that turn their business model towards unsavoury tactics rather than actually providing value that keeps people from wanting to be their customer.

1) By reading this post you agree to subscribe to future posts at the economical cost of $14.49 per month, billed bi-annually.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:54AM (#5978672)
What you're describing is the MO for dishonest subscription services. But there's lots of subscription services that aren't dishonest and have very happy customers.

To your points:

1. While there are dishonest sites, I'm sure you also have numerous recurring subscriptions with a whole bunch of services where that's exactly what you agreed to, and what you want. Your internet provider, your mobile phone provider, your cable company, etc. I realize you may have had an issue with one company, but that doesn't mean the subscription model can't be used in an honest, customer-focused way. I have subscriptions with utilities, online content services (Spotify), and even a podcast network and for 90% of situations, it works fine and there's no trick or scam.

2. I totally agree that companies should make it easy to cancel, and it's despicable if they don't. It's also generally bad business practice because it hurts your relationship with them. But again, there's lots of companies with recurring subscription models that handle this right: just look at Netflix. Not only will they cancel easily, they'll also put your account on hold if you're going on vacation, etc.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by leephillips on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:07AM (#5978260)
"only option was a limited hours telephone number that required lengthy wait times."

You don't need to play their game. Send them a letter cancelling and revoking the authorization to charge your credit card. When they charge you anyway, send a letter to your bank informing them of the unauthorized charge. You'll get the chargeback. Send another letter to the AG of your state, too, complaining about the credit card fraud.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by corresation on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:55PM (#5975241)
An important point is that it isn't for services rendered -- it's for services to be rendered in the future on receipt of payment. At the point of billing I owed them $0, and had received no service from them. A credit card number is the compound of the number and expiry day, and they essentially fabricated a new expiry date.

There are whole industries built around billing people for services they don't actually want, and this is just an example of it. I completely understand that it is normal across the industry, but it is incredibly scummy and puts deception and evasion ahead of providing actual value.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:28AM (#5975825)
This depends a lot on the particulars of the individual subscription agreement. But in most cases, you owe for the services once the new subscription period starts, not when payment is received. (In most cases, your card company actually pays long after the services are rendered (30-60 days), anyway.)

You're saying this is a service you don't want, but it's unclear how the provider is supposed to guess that. You signed up for it, you haven't cancelled it, and now they're going to provide it and then seek payment for it. The failure to cancel is on you, not the provider. Even if you cancelled the card outright, in most good ToS, they'd still have a right to bill you directly for the service if you don't cancel.

Let's say I run a gym and you're a signed up member. If a new month starts, and you've got an active account, even if your card expires I'm still going to bill you for the month unless you come and tell me you want to cancel your membership. The two things are unrelated.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by corresation on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:43PM (#5974883)
That said, I'm not sure he can complain that a recurring subscription continued to, well, recur.

Yes, I will complain. Intrinsic in the notion that I'm not bothering to update billing information after numerous updates telling me that it will cancel if I don't is the conclusion that the service, and billings, will cease. Credit cards have expiry dates for a reason, and ultimately it is fraud that they effectively manufactured my info for me.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by tomkarlo on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:17PM (#5975035)
I'd check the wording of those updates. It's usually that your service may be interrupted if you fail to update your credit card when it expires. And usually, the terms of the site say that you're on the hook for the recurring charge even if your card fails to clear.

You're hoping that the natural expiration cycle of your physical card - not the account - will impact a transaction that doesn't actually involve that physical implement. I can see where you're coming from, but I don't know that you really have a right to expect the expiration of your physical card to impact an existing business relationship with a third party that involves recurring charges (that you have likely agreed to pay regardless of your card's validity, or credit limit.)

I've worked on these kinds of renewal systems for large sites and generally, users don't mind them because the reverse case - where 4% of the users lose access each month because their physical card expired - sucks for both the site and the end users who don't expect access to be cut off.

If you want to use credit card changes as a shortcut for properly cancelling your subscription, you probably need to actually change the card number.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by krichman on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:09PM (#5982229)
Since you tried to cancel and it was difficult to find how, can't you issue a chargeback at that point?
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by npsimons on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:42PM (#5973443)
If I see a hype filled story show up in the freebie investment news it usually means the stock is about to take a short term down turn.

Good time to short it.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by bobsil1 on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:04PM (#5980030)
This will be solved using big data, and it will be free not subscription. Working on it right now.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by AJ007 on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:08PM (#5972495)
I am happy to see other people finally pointing this one out.

I will refine your hypothesis a little.

a) It isn't companies with the highest margin who win, but the ones which are able and willing to devote the greatest percentage of revenue to performance driven advertising. If the company has a slim margin to begin with, they will never even be able to start in the "race."

b) Education is a better example than car insurance. While there are geographic variances to what ads are shown, nearly all of the ads will be for for-profit schools (many of whom spend more on acquiring a single enrollment than on educating them.) Additionally, the organic results will either be for performance marketers driving leads right back to these schools, or it will be objective journalism plastered with banner ads and contextual text ads for for-profit schools (Forbes, Washington Post (who owns and receives half of their revenue from Kaplan but thats another story..))

c) Some markets get so abusive Google puts very heavy handed and aggressive rules in place. For example, if you read the FTC's news releases regularly a common scam is someone operating as a payday loan operator simply emptying bank accounts (not sure why this isn't an FBI/DOJ issue.) Its easy to bid high when your end result is the entire content's of your customer bank account. If you are operating in a market and your competitors start doing this stuff -- your fucked. Google can take years to catch up.

d) The "quality score" means little. It largely has to do with how a site looks, not what it actually does. Misleading ads tend promise more and thus get better click through rate which means they are even more likely to show up higher, not less. At the end of the day, Google will let low quality site run, they just charge them a little more.

e) The most disturbing thing to me is how Google is trying to wash away organic altogether. The original article points this out. Aaron Wall (SEOBook) has been pointing this out for year. Ben Edelman has been doing an excellent job of busting Google's bullshit PR (even though he may be paid by Microsoft for consulting its academic level work of the highest quality.) Google wants to keep serving that organic content to users, but block them from flowing through to the original source. Google Images' recent changes reflect this exactly.

f) All of this makes me think Google's original business model is in serious crisis. Ironically, Google is doing the same revenue escalation to their own users as their advertisers are forced to employ. If desktop revenue is dropping fast, Google has to crank up the "aggressive" meter to milk out more revenue from a diminishing ad clicker user base.

g) This is great news for the next search companies. Google is dependent on their ad revenue to fuel their behemoth enterprise. They are sacrificing their own product in an escalating fashion. (If you use AdBlockPlus you probably never even noticed..)

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by jcampbell1 on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:35PM (#5973405)
It is worth pointing out that Google is internally very aware of this situation. They have attempted to do what is best for users on several high value searches such as "Mortgage Refinance". At one point they had a fixed fee comparison widget, that would actually suggest banks with the lowest rates.

Unfortunately all these attempts were killed, because it is so much more valuable to sell an ad to a shady comparison site, than to run a transparent one.

I also don't think their business model is in any sort of crisis. Google gives people great search results consistently. It takes crazy logic to see good Google search results consistently everyday, and then not trust Google's results for a high value query.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by AJ007 on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:08PM (#5973899)
My assumption & opinion is they know exactly what they are doing. I assume every decision has firm logic & metrics to back it up. However, the very nature of the marketplace is for advertisers to squeeze as much value out of the customer as possible in order to purchase higher visibility. I don't see it as a mistake or a flaw, it is just the end reality of a set of circumstances.

What makes Google's marketplace uniquely challenging is the following: In the physical world, you can go to a store and make a pretty good judgement that the product being sold is real, it is high quality, the cashiers are happy, the (real) customers tell you they have shopped there for years.

Online, everything becomes about human perception of data. It is easier to represent quality when there is none. It is easier to sell a customer one thing and extract a great deal of additional value from them. When that happens, the winner is the one with the most visibility (I think Americans can greatly relate this to US elections.)

Are user reviews and testimonials the solution? Amazon is loaded with fake ones. Many companies exist already to help small business owners "tweak" Yelp reviews. Even when you put a real face behind a review, it can be gamed. A static review will always be quite different than judging something with all of your senses in person.

Load your own site or app up with ads and see what happens to user retention. Prediction based on my own experience: it tanks.

Google is in crises because their behavior tells me their revenue would drop immensely if the result pages had as many ads on them as they did 6 years ago. Google is in crises because the ad revenue is their life blood. They have a massive organization which must have this revenue stream to remain in business.

There is a segment of the market that will click on and respond to bad ads over and over and over again. There is another segment that is more perceptive. There is a whole other segment that doesn't even know any of this has happened because they have used ad blockers for years!

Google might be really good at avoiding the tipping point. I assume that right now they are balancing the flight to mobile with the drop in user retention from "too many ads." Or perhaps I am overestimating the impact of ads, and the real game for Google is making customers think they are just clicking on content.

Some verticals pillage their customers. Many verticals do not, the arms race has not happened for them yet. That is a good thing for Google, and an even better thing for Google's users.

Google can control what they do, however with every step they take in the "show more ads" direction, the opportunity for someone else gets that much bigger.

As pointed out in the original article, in some result pages 90% of above the fold is ads. Would you watch Game of Thrones if it was 54 minutes of ads and 6 minutes of content? I wouldn't.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by boomzilla on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:39PM (#5974516)
I wonder when (if at all) the pendulum swings back and users actively avoid clicking on the ads so much that makes Google scales back the number of ads shown. It's essentially a race to bottom and no matter how big a margins the current winners can make, it's gotta get thinner and thinner everyday.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by peanutz454 on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @04:11AM (#5976436)
I've read in certain places that most users are not aware that the top few links are ads.

With the new trend of usage of laptops increasing, a little shift of certain LCD screen on laptops changes the contrast of the advert background (very light pink) so much that it is impossible to determine that the first few links are ads.

I think people will continue clicking on ad links without realizing that they are doing so.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by diminish on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:09PM (#5973568)
for some keywords search ads, are also a free service to users if you make a Copernican turn in your perception. the problem for end users for ads is the auction mechanism. it may seem that from quarter to quarter GOOG has to report better earnings and more ad placements seem to be an easy way to achieve increased revenue, albeit jeopardizing their main organic search experience.

at my zombie startup, "Vadlue" (http://www.vadlue.com/node/en/contact), we tried to strip ads out of search results and them searchable, browseable etc. maybe future lies in not making ads look more annoying by mixing them inside content, but making 'some content' behave like ads.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by bigiain on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:56AM (#5976091)
" … maybe future lies in not making ads look more annoying by mixing them inside content, but making 'some content' behave like ads."

And so online advertising re-invents traditional media's "product placement".

To paraphrase a comment upthread "Would you watch Game of Thrones, if The Freys had used Smith & Wesson branded crossbows to massacre the Starks? Or if The Lanisters only used AT&T brand carrier pigeons?"

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by helloworld99 on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:55PM (#5974939)
Google is in crisis because they need 2-3 times more ads than before to keep earnings growth. At some point everything will be ads, even page 2.

Also many users do not know they are seeing ads, imagine if FTC cracked down on shady labeling? People do not like seeing that many ads and Google's revenue and reputation would go down the drain.

>> It takes crazy logic to see good Google search results consistently everyday, and then not trust Google's results for a high value query.

Why, maybe Google manipulates only the high earning keywords? There is no money on "Snowden leaks"

Business owners should band and push another search engine. Google has some guy name Mat Cutts offering "do this and that and your ranking will improve from [update a-z]" but apparently these are lies by Google, Google is actively taking away traffic to send it to ads. Some site that paid $50 for a click, will have to get that money back, and you, the user, will pay for it.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by SteveGerencser on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:43PM (#5975182)
They are cracking down. Just a week or two ago a new statement from the FTC came out with new ad guidelines specifficly targeting search engines.

http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2013/06/searchengine.shtm

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by Alex3917 on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:39PM (#5972694)
"many [for-profit colleges] spend more on acquiring a single enrollment than on educating them."

According to the DoE, 4-year for-profit colleges spend 2.9x more on administrative expenses (albeit including student services and academic support) than instruction. Unfortunately I can't find a better breakdown of this category, but I'd assume this is mostly leadgen.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by mkopinsky on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:51PM (#5974210)
Do you have a comparable number for non-profit colleges? While I doubt it's 2.9, I'm sure it's still high.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by Alex3917 on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:24PM (#5975634)
Non-profit 4-year colleges actually spend more on instruction than on those other categories, by 1.1x.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by i_need_sources on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @05:32AM (#5983375)
yeah, I'm going to have to ask you for a citation there.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by Alex3917 on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:57AM (#5985391)
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by saumil07 on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:55AM (#5975915)
It's interesting to note that across 165 comments, only 2-3 have even touched upon Quality Score let alone attempted to discuss it in detail.

Based upon personal experience (worked at a company that spent 8 digits on Google Ads on an annualized basis, profitably and successfully over a long period of time) I can assure you that Quality Score does NOT mean very little.

It is also a falsehood to state that Quality Score is entirely about "how a site looks". Google actually even measures how quickly users come back to Google after clicking on an Ad - and if users come back too often in too short a period of time (signal for poor quality ad landing page), the advertiser's Quality Score can be penalized (to what extent, exactly, is of course unclear).

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by milesskorpen on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:51PM (#5973822)
"g) This is great news for the next search companies. Google is dependent on their ad revenue to fuel their behemoth enterprise. They are sacrificing their own product in an escalating fashion. (If you use AdBlockPlus you probably never even noticed..)"

This. I sometimes feel like I'm using a different internet than most users.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by pitchups on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:10PM (#5974332)
True that car insurance ads deliver little or no value - as in the end you always end up at one of the major carriers - and the price is no lower than if you had gone to them directly. The restaurant example assumes that you can continue to fool your customers with overpriced wine and low quality food. If you could stay in business long enough with that strategy you don't really need to run PPC ads! But these two examples completely distort the way Google's Ads are used by the vast majority of businesses - to whom they can and do deliver real customers and value. This includes the vast majority of cases - the long tail of search traffic that converts well for niche products and services that have little or no other way to directly market or get customers. When used correctly, Google Adwords is a godsend for such businesses. This could be a maker of high-end custom furniture cabinets in a little town in the middle of nowhere, or a small software company in a small town in India that has produced a killer app to learn Yoga, or a software developer in New Zealand, that has developed the perfect SaaS app for monitoring your server, and so on. These are the businesses that Google empowers - by giving them access to a potential worldwide market for their products.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by vacri on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:50PM (#5973817)
find a company that doesn't advertise, and is non-profit, that way your premium is spent buying insurance

Does economy of scale not apply to insurance?

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by dendory on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:47AM (#5976071)
I've long ago taken this approach to all ads myself. Whenever I'm forced to see an ad (because I block or skip ads as much as I possibly can) then I make a mental note not to buy from that company. Whenever I go to buy something, I always go for a brand I've never seen in an ad. I find that this on average saves me money.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by npsimons on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:38PM (#5973422)
A thousand times this; when I tell people I prefer buying from companies who aren't blowing my money on superbowl ads, they just don't get it. The ads aren't for you, the existing customer - they're to get new customers. There's a reason I like Vanguard and USAA.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by ohashi on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @05:05PM (#5980733)
So this comment really resonated with me because I am competing in a space like this. I have a better product but a better product means making substantially less money.

Do you have any ideas on how to better compete without the same type of margins?

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by dano415 on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:38PM (#5972260)
You are 100% correct! I've thought this for years, but gave up trying to convince friends. It seems like people like paying more for cute advertising?
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by corresation on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:14PM (#5973928)
The best way to win is to open a restaurant with ridiculously high margins (over priced wine and cheap ingredients).

That's a rather terrible example: a restaurant that had over priced wine and cheap ingredients would fail miserably in short order, regardless of how many Google ad auctions they won.

If you really want the cheapest car insurance, you need to find a company that doesn't advertise, and is non-profit

I doubt those two traits have any measurable correlation with providing the cheapest car insurance, or any other service or business, just as it's possible that a company with rampant ads on every medium and high margins provides the best value.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by chii on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:51AM (#5976384)
> a restaurant that had over priced wine and cheap ingredients would fail miserably in short order, regardless of how many Google ad auctions they won.

unless if there's so many restraurants, and the quality of wine is so subjective that most customers cannot really differentiate it. Then exposure is really the only thing a (time poor) customer can rely on, and thus, by massively spending on advertising, and not on ingredients, they can convert more paying customers than the small, but quality restaurant who nobody knows exists.

I want some way to have word of mouth recommendations work over the net, without it being game-able. perhaps a system where you must pay (a very small token amount) to review?

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by lmm on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @08:29AM (#5977325)
>I want some way to have word of mouth recommendations work over the net, without it being game-able. perhaps a system where you must pay (a very small token amount) to review?

That would make it even more of a money arms race. Ultimately you want something like personal recommendations where people attach their own reputations to their recommendations; google is trying to push something on these lines with google+.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by chii on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:33PM (#5982089)
but a person's reputation on the net is inherently non-existant, unless they're forced to use their real name, and is somewhat known/famous.

Being able to create fake reviews and fake recommendations is the same problem as spam in email (cept spam is easier to filter out). If sending email costs the sender some token amount (say, 1cent per 1000 email), it would probably stop majority of spam, because it just became cost-ineffective. That was why i was suggesting paying token amount for writing reviews - tho i have no doubts there are flaws with that idea….

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by acdha on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:56PM (#5982179)
> That's a rather terrible example: a restaurant that had over priced wine and cheap ingredients would fail miserably in short order

Have you ever travelled? There are restaurants like that surrounding every airport, convention center, etc. because they know people will value convenience, speed of service, ability to handle large parties, etc. more than great food. The situation is similar near large office parks — it may be mediocre but it's the closest choice! — areas with lots of tourists or transient populations (how many college town date-night restaurants are great?), etc.

Actually, it's even simpler: Applebee's does not appear to be disappearing.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by camus on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:13PM (#5972042)
there is no such things as "internet searches". Because all search engines behave differently and nobody can tell for sure how panda works , except people working on panda. So the rules are decides by whoever develops the search engine. Like there is no such thing as SEO , Google has a monopoly and the rule is pay to play.